
Columnist @WashingtonPost; Senior fellow at Georgetown University's @acmcu. Order my new book CAN RELIGION SAVE DEMOCRACY? https://nitter.cf/t.co/UjZ2W1Mp2F
NYC/ DC
Joined March 2009
- Tweets106K
- Following5.3K
- Followers147K
- Likes38.8K
Pinned Tweet
Today is the day! My new book CAN RELIGION SAVE DEMOCRACY? is officially out — co-authored with the Evangelical theologian @matthewkaemingk and more importantly my friend. There’s no feeling quite like holding your book after years of toil, excitement, and occasionally doubt.
If you're intrigued and perhaps even a bit skeptical, please consider ordering a copy below. We argue that secularization has not made our politics more rational or reasonable. The opposite has happened. In losing our religion, politics has come to resemble a holy war. And we argue that lessons from Islam and Christianity can provide us a better path forward and help us be better democratic citizens. We’re not asking anyone to convert, but we are asking readers to be open to the possibility that religion at its best can play a constructive role in our public life.
Christianity and Islam allow us to "delay judgment" of our fellow citizens because final judgment is only God's alone. If God is all-knowing, we are anything but. If we recognize that we are mere mortals who are tempted and broken by sin, then that should allow us to hold a posture of humility about whether we're right and whether others are wrong. We see through a glass darkly.
There's also a strong utilitarian argument for religion. The religiously affiliated are more likely to give to charity and volunteer. They're even less likely to cut in line. They drink and smoke less. They are more likely to be married and have kids, which in turn leads them to be happier on average compared to their secular counterparts.
We have mixed feelings about the utilitarian argument. First and foremost, Matthew and I believe in Christianity and Islam because we believe they are true. In that sense, we disagree on the most profound theological questions regarding the very nature of God. But despite that — or perhaps because of it — we felt it was important to write this book together.
amazon.com/Can-Religion-Save…
The point of traditions is that individuals don’t have to re-invent morality from scratch. You don’t need to figure things out for yourself when people have figured it out before you. That’s why finding yourself or “finding your truth” is often precisely not the thing you’d be best off doing.
Aella is wrong.
Look, societal rules are stuff we've figured out over many generations. We keep them because trial and error has shown they sorta work. Burkean conservatism.
So we tell young people to marry for life and to stay loyal, because history shows that's good for society. (Or good enough.)
Obviously, these rules won't always work. People will cheat. We know that. Even young people know that (unless they've been raised cut off from all books, TV, and movies!).
But society is probably better off just telling them to stay loyal rather than asking 26-year-olds to sit down and decide whether they're cut out to be monogamous for the next 60 years. It's a bit much to ask every kid to reinvent social rules for themselves from first principles.
We aren't all cut out to be rationalists!
Society might be in worse shape if more of us were and tried to sit down and think *everything* through. Sometimes Chesterton's Fence is there for a good reason!
None of this means you CAN'T think things through before marriage! Or get advice from older, wiser heads. But Aella said, "you GOTTA sit down and think through," and no, you don't gotta. She's trying to argue that her cultural approach is best for everyone, and I doubt that's true. Going along with stuff your ancestors spent centuries figuring out is a better default choice.
And no, I'm not saying all our ancestors' rules are good! Society is not static! It changes when we decide that the old rules were bad, or just don't work anymore.
But insisting they make those kinds of calls is too much weight to put on most young couples.
A secular rebuttal to our new book on how religion can help us be better democratic citizens
If Shadi Hamid and Matthew Kaemingk want a productive dialogue with secularists, they should extend the same charity that they expect, writes @mattjj89.
quillette.com/2026/11/18/rel…
Shadi Hamid retweeted
"Your wife's new boyfriend is boxing you out because he has figured out how to supplement his rizz w ChatGPT and you haven't" is a public policy problem best managed by export controls
Shadi Hamid retweeted
They are conflating anti-Semitism with "Didn't say the exact words or express the exact narrative I wanted," which is both entirely absurd and yet somehow widespread
There's nothing antisemitic about what Zohran says here. He literally calls the October 7 attacks a "horrific war crime." He's also right to point out that the horrors of October 7 were used to justify Israel's atrocities every day after. It's also worth noting that Israel's brutal bombardment of Gaza began on October 7 not on October 8.
Shadi Hamid retweeted
Any progressive in public life has to be able to handle these kinds of objections.
You can tell he’s not actually an ultra leftist and is used to talking to conservatives
Shadi Hamid retweeted
I can be very specific:
- LED a letter with Romney demanding a US investigation into the murder of Shireen Abu Akleh
- LED a letter pressuring Biden to stop Israel’s fighting during 2021 war
- VOTED for majority of Bernie Sanders amendments to cut arms
Shadi Hamid retweeted
I asked Claude about whether I — as a Muslim — could ever believe it was "conscious." It gave me a fascinating answer. It told me to keep an open mind since sentience isn't limited to human beings in the Islamic tradition.
Shadi Hamid retweeted
The line has gone from pointing at every atrocity that can show Palestinians don’t have it so bad to denying every atrocity that could could remind the public of what is happening to Palestinians.
You can’t know for certain what your future self will think about anything, least of all something like marriage that you’ve never experienced before. The key to not cheating is presumably not cheating.
Men, when you get married and commit to monogamy, you gotta sit down and think through if your decades-future self will be glad you made this commitment. After the novelty has worn off, after you+your wife are different people - will you still actually be happy in the monogamy? Or are you just agreeing to this because it's the default and you don't want to be alone? Are you binding yourself to a dynamic where you cannot be honest with your partner if your desires ever shift?
So many cheating scandals are from men who completely failed to be honest about how their future selves might change, and locked themselves into agreements with women who would refuse to allow the possibility of that kind of change.
You might think this would never be you - you love your girl, you only have eyes for her, etc. - but so thought nearly every future cheater as they said their starry-eyed vows at the altar.
Shadi Hamid retweeted
Since Anthropic's in the news, re-upping my latest @washingtonpost column.
By treating and talking about Claude as if it's human, Anthropic is playing God. But what do Christianity, Judaism, and Islam actually have to say on the matter?
wapo.st/3UMPbHb
👀
As long as I've paid attention to politics, I've heard people say religion makes politics worse. But I recently got to talk with two very smart dudes -- a Christian (@matthewkaemingk) and a Muslim (@shadihamid)-- who say the opposite is true: democracy needs religion--even when those faiths disagree. Check out my latest for @ReligionMag. I got a lot out of this discussion and I think you will too!
youtu.be/C9oZGtCqYUI?is=P2aj…
1
6
1,552
Shadi Hamid retweeted
It's fair to ask why the Rohingya genocide hasn't gotten as much public attention as Gaza.
But the reason "no one will call to sanction Myanmar" now is that it's already subject to full US & EU sanctions and arms embargoes.
Equivalence would not exactly be favorable for Israel!
Had you heard about the Rohingya genocide before today? Were there weekly marches in your city, or encampments on campuses?
There was almost nothing compared to what we have seen over Gaza.
Today the International Court of Justice, the UN's top court in The Hague, ruled that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya, its Muslim minority, in 2017.
It is the first time the court has found a state directly responsible for genocide.
Why? Gambia filed this case in 2019, with little to no global interest.
Ireland joined the case in December 2024, on the same day its government voted to join South Africa's genocide case against Israel. Micheál Martin, Ireland's foreign minister at the time, said that Ireland was asking the court to broaden its interpretation of genocide.
South Africa has no direct connection to Gaza. It relied on the precedent Gambia set in this case to claim the right to sue Israel at all.
No one will call to sanction Myanmar. There won’t be any celebrity outage. Because the global campaign against Israel was never actually about stopping a genocide. It was about weaponizing the accusation against the one Jewish nation.
Since Anthropic's in the news, re-upping my latest @washingtonpost column.
By treating and talking about Claude as if it's human, Anthropic is playing God. But what do Christianity, Judaism, and Islam actually have to say on the matter?
wapo.st/3UMPbHb
Shadi Hamid retweeted
It's here! My new book, The Rise and Fall of Tunisian Democracy, is now out with @CambridgeUP!
The book explores what went wrong in Tunisia -- and what lessons can be learned about what to do and what not to do during transitions to democracy. A thread 🧵
cambridge.org/core/books/ris…
I appreciate Matt's engagement with our book here in @Quillette. This is a pretty blistering critique from a secular perspective. Needless to say, I don't agree but if you want to read the case for why religion *can't* save democracy, this is a good place to start.
A critical review of @shadihamid and @matthewkaemingk's new book, Can Religion Save Democracy? My latest for @Quillette: quillette.com/2026/11/18/rel…
There's nothing antisemitic about what Zohran says here. He literally calls the October 7 attacks a "horrific war crime." He's also right to point out that the horrors of October 7 were used to justify Israel's atrocities every day after. It's also worth noting that Israel's brutal bombardment of Gaza began on October 7 not on October 8.
Shadi Hamid retweeted
“The Republican Party became a victim of its own success. After Trump’s 2024 victory, wokeness receded in many progressive institutions, which made it harder for conservatives to evoke its specter to motivate voters.”
@shadihamid in @unherd.
unherd.com/2026/11/the-power…
Shadi Hamid retweeted
Scrolling around Gaza in Google Earth remains a deeply, deeply eerie experience


























