Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher) header
Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher) profile picture

Author "The Farthest Reaches" Ambassador for Conjecture Institute Board Member of National Progress Alliance Host of ToKCast Guest of The Naval Podcast Optimist

Sydney, Australia
Joined December 2009
Photo by Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher)Photo by Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher)Photo by Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher)Photo by Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher)Photo by Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher)Photo by Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher)Photo by Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher)Photo by Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher)Photo by Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher)Photo by Brett Hall (@ToKTeacher)
High praise. When one gains the respect of (or criticism from) those whose opinion one has deep respect for, what else matters on social media? nitter.cf/naval/status/187889210…
Replying to @aaryan_kakad
Same as I recommend to everyone. Read like a textbook, slowly, making sure that you understand each point. Less a book and more a school of philosophy. The Sovereign Child is an offshoot. Accompany with @ToKTeacher podcasts. The Beginning of Infinity a.co/d/aVrmpfE
19
10
1
323
126,458
Trigger warning: this is, apparently, very upsetting to those committed to the doctrine that genes - and not *ideas people create in their minds* - explain human behaviour.
At The Thinkable Review, we've just published a rather provocative piece by @ToKTeacher on why the central assumption of evolutionary psychology is wrong. Link in next tweet.
7
365
At The Thinkable Review, we've just published a rather provocative piece by @ToKTeacher on why the central assumption of evolutionary psychology is wrong. Link in next tweet.
5
1
3
16
5,518
Brett Hall retweeted
YES. There are no experts on the future. There are no experts on the future. There are no experts on the future.
Marc Andreessen explained why the people who invented AI are the worst people to ask about its future, using a mistake Thomas Edison made in 1877... Geoffrey Hinton won a Nobel Prize in 2024 for the work behind modern AI. When people ask Hinton where AI is going, he believes "rampant unemployment" and UBI for everybody. "People think, because he's one of the inventors of AI, that he must be the guy who knows." Andreessen's answer is Thomas Edison. Edison invented the phonograph in 1877. To him, Andreessen says, the use was obvious. Every family would buy a record player and a library of discs with sermons from the great preachers of the time. Then the machine went on sale. "Immediately, of course, it's music. It's ragtime, and swing, then it's jazz. And Edison's just completely horrified." "If Edison didn't know what the phonograph was going to get used for, the idea that Joe AI entrepreneur is going to be able to forecast the economic implications... No. That's not going to happen." Inventors, he says, are "too buried in the specifics of the here and now." He includes himself. "I don't know if there's anybody that can predict big cultural, or economic or social trends, but it's certainly not somebody who's been in the lab for 20 years, including myself."
38
101
8
1,072
103,896
🛡️Defend the West Conference🛡️ When: 1/13/27 Where: online (free) Speaker spotlight: @ToKTeacher Talk title: The Eternal West: A Timeless Approach to Principles as Conjectured Explanations Brett Hall is an Australian educator, science communicator and technical advisor. He hosts ToKCast, a podcast promoting optimism, unbounded progress and creative critical thinking using the best-known explanations from fundamental physics and philosophy.
1
6
16
709
My guess is it wasn’t *her* goal “from day 1”. The “how dare you?!” tears were genuine. But since then she has *learned* and come to genuinely support the full leftist memeplex. And that memeplex “from day 1” has used “the climate”, and much else, to displace rationality.
Greta Thunberg admits their goal "from day 1" was "overthrow capitalism" It wasn't about "the climate" after all WE TOLD YOU SO
7
10
3
120
4,294
Many environmentalists think some version of “the world is being destroyed by humans” is true, and are largely ignorant of economics, politics, liberty and so on. But their minds are being cleverly utilised by socialism through the vehicle of “compassion” for “the natural”.
1
1
16
606
That they also are often as vocally anti-Israel as they are vocally opposed to capitalism, industry, energy and progress almost to a person is explained by the fact every evil idea eventually merges with The Pattern. Much of their thinking becomes corrupted by it.
3
15
514
Every word is wrong. Britain did not organise the slave trade. Its wealth does not derive from slavery. It was British industrial capitalism that made emancipation feasible. Compensation is a tendentious word: we force-purchased slaves so as to free them: an unambiguous good.
68
537
11
3,772
55,634
🧵“Free will does not exist” has become a proxy for “people aren’t that special”.
42
66
11
528
177,072
Optimistic on solar, pessimistic on our discovering new and better forms of energy. In either case, prophecy…
The amount of energy we harness for civilization from the Sun will obviously ultimately round up to 100% of all energy. That math is obvious and trivial.
2
1
40
2,644
“If your conception of rationality conflicts with a mathematical theorem…then your conception of rationality is irrational.” - @DavidDeutschOxf “Perfect” alignment of AGI is not merely not possible…it’s not desirable either. Most people and ~all doomers don’t get this.
This paper from 1950 proves that AI alignment is mathematically impossible. It’s based on a legendary proof by Nobel laureate Kenneth Arrow. Arrow asked a simple question: Can we design a perfectly fair voting system? If a group of people have different preferences, can we create a mathematically perfect algorithm to rank what the group actually wants? He laid out three basic, undeniable rules for fairness: 1. If everyone prefers A over B, A must win. 2. Introducing a random option C shouldn’t change whether A beats B. 3. There is no dictator. Then he ran the math. And the result broke decision theory forever. Arrow proved it is mathematically impossible for any system to meet these basic criteria when there are three or more options. Every single ranking algorithm, voting system, and consensus mechanism is mathematically guaranteed to be unfair, manipulable, or illogical. Every. Single. One. Why does this matter right now? Because Silicon Valley is spending billions trying to solve "AI Alignment." We are training AI models using RLHF (Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback). We are building autonomous agent swarms that vote on outcomes. We are trying to mathematically encode "collective human values" into a superintelligence. But Arrow’s theorem delivers a brutal reality check. There is no such thing as a mathematically perfect "collective preference." If you ask an AI to perfectly satisfy the desires of a group, the math dictates it will eventually have to violate basic logic. And if you force the AI to follow perfect logic, it will eventually have to act like a dictator.
3
7
52
4,084
Brett Hall retweeted
America didn’t invent DEI. We went through this shit 80 years ago. This is a real Czechoslovak communist document from 1948: Circular The local organization of the Communist Party of Czechoslovakia, Org. No. 2 in Stará Ves, hereby calls a meeting on 10 December 1948 at exactly 7 p.m. in Starý Výbor. Agenda: 1Those who wish to serve as judges, professors, etc. should come forward. 2Members who would apply as career officers. 3Members who would apply as members of the SNB [National Security Corps]. Only workers or small farmers may apply, and they may have only elementary school education. Secretary: Krael Heitel
[stamp: Local organization of the KSČ, Stará Ves II]
Vice-chairman: Raimund Koutný
16
46
6
252
13,342
Those who endorse climate catastrophism and who think mobile phones will damage your heart or your (quote) “dick” share an interesting quirk of rarely having any *fundamental* understanding of the science they insist those who disagree with them are ignoring.
Anthony Albanese and co-president of COP31, Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen, have been caught in a highly embarrassing on-air exchange, talking about the dangers of phone radiation to their penises. Read more: bit.ly/4jcBiLA
1
30
2,119
Sam is right about Iran. Konstantin over and again said he was disagreeing with Sam, but I couldn’t hear *exactly* what the former was trying to say other than to repeat some version of “No, my argument is…” or “My point is…” or “No you’re not representing my point…” etc. 🤷
The Midterm Win Could Make the Democrats Worse - Sam Harris Watch the full episode right here on X.
9
4
74
14,948
He *seems* to disagree America or “The West” can achieve regime change. Rightly reminded about Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan, he ignores the salience of the point. At 1:30:38 literally saying “No one has explained how changing the regime changes the regime…” 🤨 His argument that follows is that if one Ayatollah is replaced, you’ll just get another. Which is of course a straw-man of what “regime change” means. Konstantin is broadly a very clear defender of The Enlightenment and sees the bright line between good and evil, truth and falsity - especially on Russia and Ukraine. Why the difference here? I think in *this case* there are loud echos of The Pattern. It corrupts critical thinking such that lines which are clear in *any other situation* are blurred in people’s minds.
1
1
20
1,135
Brett Hall retweeted
Pretty crazy people demand the IDF care about the lives of Palestinian civilians but don’t make any such demands about Hamas.
5
49
2
485
8,737
Important work. Check out @BjornLomborg ‘s feed to find your country and what effect it going “Net Zero” would have, coupled with what it will cost.
Australia runs the negotiations at the UN Climate Summit #COP31, and has promised net zero by 2050 Cost to Australia: A$1.7 trillion ($1.2 trillion) The world gets 0.00909°C less warming in 2100 Each dollar buys 19¢ of climate benefit NetZeroCostBenefit.com/Austr…
1
5
23
1,547
Yes, the question is what effect would there be if *all* nations went “net zero”? Which is, ostensibly the reason for any single nation doing it. But the fact is they simply will not. It’s a complete fantasy. China, India, South America, Africa and the rest of Asia aren’t going to go net zero unless fusion power becomes a thing or something else completely unexpected happens (but that same argument applies to their using even more coal than at present). Especially developing nations. They simply *must* transition through coal and oil/gas before they can afford industrialising through the use of uranium solar and batteries. Nevermind wind which in many places is simply not an option.
2
541