Peter Petrov retweeted
Today's launch isn't about Robinhood adding support for crypto, the asset; that's old news.
it's about Robinhood choosing Arbitrum and using crypto, the technology, to support and grow its core business.
Last week on CNBC, @vladtenev laid this out quite elegantly:
Peter Petrov retweeted
The hypocrisy is staggering.
Video 1: Trump slams the U.S. administration for taking money from Qatar.
Video 2: Trump praises Qatar for giving money to the U.S.
You can’t make this up.
Peter Petrov retweeted
here is a explainer thread on zk
for normal people who use the internet and want it to respect them
↓
Peter Petrov retweeted
Latest Russian joke:
Trump, in the afterlife, gets permission to go back and visit Earth for one hour. He goes into a bar in NYC and asks the bartender how things are going for America. The amazed man says, "Wow, sir, we have the most incredible empire thanks to you! Greenland, Panama, and Canada!" "That's great," says Trump, "What about Europe?" "Oh yes," says the bartender, "They also couldn't resist us!" "That's so beautiful," says Trump. "Well, I have to go back now, how much do I owe you?" "One ruble and fifty kopeks," replies the bartender.
Peter Petrov retweeted
5/ These claims come from Alnur Mussayev, former KGB officer and ex-head of Kazakhstan’s intelligence service, as well as ex-KGB agents Yuri Shvets and Sergei Zhyrno, who now reside in the U.S. and France, respectively.
Peter Petrov retweeted
Taka, така... Да ви запозная с #клетотокопеле с чудното име Балтазар Ебанг Енгонга - шеф на финансовото разузнаване на прекрасната държава Екваториална Гвинея. Господин Ебанг Енгонга ще остане в историята с... Ами, нема как иначе да се каже - с е*ане ще остане... /1
Peter Petrov retweeted
There'll be one global backbone - Ethereum
Ethereum is the backbone of the new global financial system of L2s and L1 apps. No other chain will come close.
Mert suggested that Sol can pivot to being the backbone. But Solana will never be the backbone. Here's 5 reasons why.
Four years ago, Ethereum pivoted to focus on being the backbone of the new global financial system of L2s and L1 apps. Eth's backbone strategy is being increasingly recognized as an apex L1 strategy and genius move - it's still early, but the signs are there if you look closely, such as imitation being the most sincere form of flattery, and L2s dominating.
Solana has done very well this season in degen/meme growth and SOL price. Yet, imo Sol leadership are starting to see the writing on the wall in terms of L2s being on track to eat alt L1 market share. Now, they seem to be suggesting that Solana could pivot to become a backbone like Ethereum, too.
But Solana is fundamentally unsuited to be a backbone for L2s or even world-scale L1 activity. I'll explain why in detail.
As a preface, let's explore how Solana leaders seem to have have gradually admitted that Ethereum's L2 backbone strategy is excellent and that Solana might pivot to pursue being a backbone.
At first, Solana sold the idea that they were going to be so fast and so cheap that the entire world was going to use the single Solana chain. This was their "monolithic" era, a term they championed before it became a liability (because in reality, no one monolith can serve the whole world). They pivoted their marketing to use the term "integrated".
Then, mid this year, Solana acknowledged that L2s are the right approach. A few things led up to this. Solana leaders noticed that some of their flagship apps began building custom L2 appchains on Sol - this was for the usual reasons that customers love L2s (ie. control and customization, while being part of a greater whole and not having to run your own consensus). And earlier this year, a prominent Sol community member wrote a spicy thread on Sol's need to adopt L2s - the Sol community lit that mfer on fire because this was before their leadership admitted that L2s are ~inevitable. Plus, a major Sol dev team pivoted/expanded to building a SVM L2 on Ethereum (from Sol L1 app to Eth L2). The net result was that Solana leadership started leaning into L2s.
(Note that Solana didn't admit that Ethereum was right about L2s all along, instead they said their L2s are not L2s, but are in fact "Network Extensions". This is pretty huge marketing spin. It's is similar to Sol's recent new concept of "True tps" which they had to invent because, over the years, they pervasively misrepresented Sol's tps on many info sites by including the 80% (!!) consensus overhead in reported tps. Many sites still say Sol's tps is 3k but really it's ~750tps. Their new "True tps" was invented by them to counteract their longstanding practice of reporting "False tps". My point is that serious people doing serious diligence for serious onchain investment should be sure to look closely at Solana's claims - many do not hold up under scrutiny.)
Fast forward to this month, and now Solana leadership is starting to talk about how they can simply pivot to Ethereum's backbone strategy (but they can't for the reasons below).
Why is Solana starting to favor Eth's backbone strategy? Why now?
It's because it's finally becoming obvious to everybody that the world needs many, many new chains (thousands, then tens of thousands), and L2s are generally a much better deal than alt L1s (that's why Coinbase, Kraken, Sony, EVE Online, etc. chose L2), so being the backbone for L2s is an apex strategy.
So can Solana just pivot to being a backbone? No, this strategy is unavailable to Solana (for the reasons below).
In reality, Solana is in deep trouble in terms of their technical and economic strategy.
What trouble is Solana in specifically?
Solana will not be fast or cheap enough to serve even a fraction of the whole world's coming demand.
Solana is not decentralized enough to attract true giga whale capital.
Solana can't be a competitive global backbone for L2s.
Solana bundles consensus and execution, which is slower and costlier than doing only execution. That's why the most scalable L2s - who only need to do execution and not consensus, while also benefiting from being part of the overall trustless composability network effect across all L2s - will soon be faster and cheaper than Solana. See MegaETH.
To say the previous point again because it's crucial: not only will Solana not be the backbone, but soon, it won't even be the fastest or cheapest chain.
Right now to some people (including many investors), Solana might seem like the best at everything - a better version of Eth. But this couldn't be further from the truth. Soon, Solana will be the best at nothing - on a technical/economic level.
So far this season, ETH may have lost the ratio battle against BTC and SOL (season's not over), but Ethereum has been playing chess, not checkers. Ethereum is on track to win the "war" of capturing the vast majority of onchain growing to global ubiquity because Ethereum scales the way the world actually works - via an L1 backbone and marketplace of L2s.
In short, Ethereum was right all along that being the backbone is by far the best L1 strategy. Yet, while Solana leadership may suggest they can become a backbone, they can't.
~~~
5 reasons why Solana will never be suitable as a global backbone
1) Solana has no real client diversity and probably won't ever have it on a meaningful timeline.
Client diversity means that your chain is run by several independent programs in parallel. This greatly helps to prevent both attacks (multiple independent dev teams and programming languages) and accidents (multiple codebases, as bugs are usually local to a single codebase).
Client diversity is mandatory for a global backbone.
To achieve client diversity, no single program can run a majority of your validator stake. This requires at least three independent chain clients and balanced stake between them. It also requires a PDF protocol spec and research community that's upstream of your chain clients. The protocol spec determines the "definition" of the chain, as well as the correctness/reliability of this definition. This ensures all the clients are working towards the same rigorously specified goal.
Today, Sol has only one production client (agave rust). Sol is trying to build a second client (firedancer), but it's proving to be extremely difficult and delayed because they have no real protocol spec or research community, and because the agave rust client is highly optimized and strongly leverages underlying hardware, making it even harder to extract the low level design into a PDF protocol spec to then reimplement in new clients.
Firedancer is not close to being ready to run 50% of stake in production with its entire own codebase. imo years, not months.
Even once Solana has firedancer in production, they won't yet have achieved client diversity. To do so, they'll need at least a third production client (so that no client has more than 50% stake, impossible with 2 clients), and a balanced stake between them, and for all three clients to be 100% original codebases with no code overlap, no dev team overlap, no code dependency/library overlap, and written in all different programming languages.
Ethereum has four production chain clients that meet these criteria, and has for years.
2) The second reason that Sol will never be a global backbone is because their chain requires very high bandwidth (they recommend 10Gbps upload). This adds very significant real-world centralization and risk.
The entire point of a global backbone is to minimize risk in all its forms, so burdening with extremely high bandwidth requirements is a non-starter.
A high bandwidth requirement is difficult to work around. You can buy a big computer and transport it anywhere, but you can't get 10Gbps upload in many areas, especially not outside of capturable corporate data centers or over VPNs.
The backbone must be able to run practically anywhere. The credible threat of running the backbone anywhere - even totally avoiding data centers entirely if needed in the future - is a key part of risk minimization.
10Gbps is Sol's recommended upload today, but it'll increase over time. For Solana, the bandwidth problem doesn't get better over time.
3) Solana has a high risk of a future outage. Solana's halted lots before and lacks Eth's protocol-level fallback to continue producing blocks even if "finalization" can't occur.
When there are 200 countries with 100 trillion in assets trusted to a global backbone, it's pretty important that the backbone always does what it says it will do, including never going offline.
4) Sol lacks economic decentralization. ~2% of SOL TGE/ICO was sold publicly. That's a ~98% (!!) insider allocation.
ETH sold 80% publicly, and then PoW with high inflation for seven years had the upside of distributing ETH very widely because miners must dump almost all their ETH to pay for mining costs.
On an economic and operational basis, Solana is relatively very centralized. This adds significant risk and detracts from suitability as a global backbone.
5) zk proof aggregation for L2 settlement means that the L1 global backbone has no reason whatsoever to sacrifice even a tiny amount of decentralization for extra scalability.
Although the Eth L1 is intentionally not focused on execution scaling, every L2/L3 in the world, even 100,000s of chains, will be able to settle on Ethereum because of zk aggregation.
Solana specializes in L1 execution scaling, which is a liability for the global backbone's requirement to maximize decentralization and credible neutrality.
~~~
For these reasons, Solana will never be the backbone of the new global financial system.
imo, Solana won't even be "a" backbone in the sense that Solana's year-over-year market share will continue to decline vs all of Ethereum (L1+L2) across key hard-to-game metrics like non-native app capital or major corp integrations. This is because the world is generally much better off onchain on Eth L2 or L1 vs. on Solana or any other chain. Don't trust me - ask Coinbase, Kraken, Sony, Visa, the City of Buenos Aires, and many more existing and upcoming corps and govts.
Anybody doing serious diligence to come onchain will uncover the points I made above, including corps and govts seeking to invest or build - which will soon be all of corps and govts across the world.
Ethereum is the backbone of the new global financial system. No other chain will come close, Solana included. L2s are destroying alt L1 market share and distributing ETH as money. Significant value accrual to ETH will follow.
Peter Petrov retweeted
Реших да чекна няколко от топ-коментиращите ентусиазирани "фенове" на Шиши🐷
1/n
Peter Petrov retweeted
An amazing wrap-up to an engaging @ETHSofiaBG with the most passionate crew: @0nestone , @mariakirovaa , @DeFinanceGeorge .
Huge thanks to @hackenclub for the endorsement 🙌
Sofia 🇧🇬 ✈️ never fails to impress! ☀️
Peter Petrov retweeted
the defi protocol gigathread, covering 47 protocols.
uniswap, maker, aave, frax, liquity, chainlink, uma, balancer, lido, eigenlayer, rocketpool, pendle, curve, convex, morpho, tornado cash, karak, spark, renzo, reflexer, gearbox...
one post each, basic summary. let's go. 1/49
Peter Petrov retweeted
Against choosing your political allegiances based on who is "pro-crypto"
vitalik.eth.limo/general/202…
Peter Petrov retweeted
I've noticed almost every post unfavorable to Viktor Orban gets bombarded by comments praising his "excellent governance" and the "great things he's done for Hungary" (usually coming from subject matter experts that can't actually point Hungary on a map).
So I figure we should take a lot at the great things he's done for Hungary, and in the spirit of me trying to get as many insults as possible from pro-Orban Hungarian ultra-nationalists, I'll do it by comparing Hungary to quite possible their favorite neighbor and a country often traditionally seen as having one of EU's most corrupt and incompetent political elites (a point I do not dispute): Romania.
Peter Petrov retweeted
Rocket Pool is an amazing protocol. rETH is the best LST, it has added thousands of nodes to Ethereum, and it has the most vibrant community in all of crypto. Sadly, it's fundamentally broken in some ways. The community is fixing it, though. Here's how we're doing it.
Before I begin, this tweet is a summary of the latest tokenomics rework coming out of the Rocket Pool community. This is the work of numerous community members. All credit goes to them. You can read the tokenomics explainers here rpips.rocketpool.net/tokenom…
As you all know, Rocket Pool the protocol has stagnated in growth, and the price of RPL the token has suffered massively because of it. Since November, the community has been working incredibly hard to fix the problems with the current design of the protocol, unleash its true potential as the best liquid staking protocol, and get the protocol growing again.
After 8 months of hard work, the community has arrived at the (almost) final form of it's tokenomics rework. The work is presented in five parts, and I'll summarize them for you all here.
Part 1 - Why rework the tokenomics?
This section starts by explaining how the ideas for linking RPL and ETH to stake were found - back to the Rocket Pool whitepaper and ICO in 2017. The Rocket Pool Investment Thesis really boosted the idea of RPL and staking being intertwined and drove massive attention to Rocket Pool. Then, Fire Eyes designed the tokenomics and put this relationship at the heart of the protocol. The illusion of these being amazing tokenomics started to shatter when growth stalled post Atlas. Since then, growth of Rocket Pool has stalled, and it has started shrinking.
The original idea was RPL would be used as an entry ticket to outsized eth rewards, the RPL rewards would be attractive enough people would stay above the 10% collateral amount, and that the RPL price should head towards 10% of rETH TVL.
In reality, this did not work. First, RPL price fluctuates too much and how successful your validators are are too strongly linked to the price of RPL. If RPL goes up, you massively beat solo staking. Conversely, if RPL goes down, you suffer greatly. In addition, the RPL rewards are not enough for people to maintain the minimum collateral amount. Nearly 70% of node operators (NO) are currently under collateralized on their nodes. There are two ways to get back into good standing, 1) top up with more RPL to get above 10% and 2) reduce how much ETH you have staked to improve your collateral ratio. Sadly, more and more people choose the second option. This is not what the protocol should be forcing to happen. Finally, because not enough people top up their collateral, the relationship between the rETH TVL and RPL breaks down. This has consequences on how much rETH the protocol can provide based on eth deposits from NO.
The current system is brittle, and having RPL as a bond along with ETH has shown to be hugely flawed. So, what are we going to do about it? This brings us to Part 2.
Part 2 - Tokenomics rework
Under the new system speculation in RPL and being a node operator are separated. You will not need RPL to stake your ETH with Rocket Pool. On top of that, holding RPL will become a desirable action due to its standalone investment properties. If you choose to stake RPL alongside your ETH, you get higher ETH yield! You can speculate all you want, but it will not be forced on you from the protocol. Also, there will be no lower 10% cliff to punish smaller amounts of collateral.
The new tokenomics will allow smaller ETH bonds. This is fundamental to changing how the protocol generates revenue - income from ETH staking rewards. Charging a 3.5% commission on borrowed eth gives the following boosted rewards compared to solo staking: 8 ETH bond is a 10.5% boost, 4 ETH bond is a 24.5% boost, and 1.5 ETH bond is a 71.2% boost! These bonds will be safe to use because of node level penalties and forced validator exits. RPL inflation will be reduced from 5% to 1.5% as rewards to NO from inflation will not be required. There will be some other changes too such as gas optimizations, forced delegate upgrades, etc.
Part 3 - Foundation of the rework
In this section is where the real explanations start to happen. First, we get an explanation of how the protocol will generate revue and what will happen with that income. The protocol will still charge rETH holders 14%. Currently, this 14% goes to NOs. However, paying NO 14% of 30.5 ETH of rETH is too much especially at lower bond amounts. The revenue can be more effectively used elsewhere. So, where will the revenue go? There will still be a NO commission share, we will have a new RPL voter share, and there will be a "surplus" share. NOs will get eth similarly to how they get it now but there will be no rpl requirement. Those who stake RPL alongside their ETH will get the voter share. The surplus amount will be used to buy back and burn RPL (this is one area that is currently undecided - other value capture methods are still being considered).
Let's work out the numbers. The 14% of commission will be divided as follows: 3.5% will go to the node operator, 5% will go to RPL stakers, and 5.5% will go to the surplus. Here the same person could get rewarded in one way as a node operator (NO share), one way as an RPL holder (RPL burn), or all three ways for a person who stakes ETH and RPL. While, the minimum stake is the primary, and indirect, value capture for RPL in the current system, there will now be two direct value capture methods. This is how there is no need for RPL inflation to go to NOs. This new mechanism will open up possibilities for many different kinds of node operators such as those who want to stake ETH only, how much RPL they want and feel comfortable with, and RPL holders get direct protocol revenue too.
For a NO, while it might seem like commission going down from 14% to 3.5% sounds bad. The reality is that you'll be getting 3.5% on a much bigger amount of ETH than you currently do. Currently, an 8 ETH validator needs 8 ETH and 2.4 ETH of RPL. That person can earn 1.14x solo staking. However, this amount becomes 1.01x solo staking at RP maturity. If the RPL ratio goes down, however, that person would earn 0.82x solo staking. Under the new system, an 8eth validator would get 1.11x solo staking with no other dependancies.
Once we look at lower bonds, the numbers are mind blowing. The amount of rewards dramatically outperform solo staking. As mentioned above, a 1.5 ETH validator will be earning 1.71x solo staking rewards. Smaller bonds are much better at capital efficiency. There are, however, limits to just how small the bonds can get. This is because of protections needed for rETH holders such as slashing insurance etc. In the first set of Saturn upgrades, it's likely we'll require a 4 ETH bond per validator. In Saturn 2, we'll have some new tools to allow the 1.5 ETH bonded validators, but the first 2 will 4 ETH validators. That is because we will get forced exits which will provide a huge security boost.
Rocket Pool will introduce Universal Adjustable Revenue Split (UARS) to balance between the different groups in the community. NO share, voter share, and surplus share will all be adjustable through the UARS. If we are running low on NOs, we can increase the commission to them to make staking more attractive. We can incentive more staked RPL to make sure governance attacks are less likely. Altering the surplus share can help balance rETH demand by making that more or less attractive. This will mean the pDAO needs to be more responsive to the changing dynamics within the protocol.
There are three main value capture mechanisms for RPL being explored using the surplus share. These are buy and burn (use eth income to buy RPL and burn it), buy and provide liquidity (use eth to add buy side liquidity to a RPL/rETH pool), and a greater voter share (to make RPL stakers get more of a share of the commission ETH). This is one of the areas where community discussion is still taking place.
Part 4 - Supporting components
This section of the tokenomics rework explains all the different components needed to support the changes. I'll briefly mention them here. 1) Anti-sock puppet effects - this will make having multiple nodes for one person unattractive. 2) Megapools - this is a Rocket Pool level upgrade that will lead to massive gas efficiencies as well as allow access to 1.5 ETH validators. 3) Forced exits - this is an Ethereum level upgrade that will allow Rocket Pool to kick out malicious actors or remove NO who have been offline for a certain period of time. 4) Node level penalties - this allows access to lower ETH bonds as the collateral on the whole node can be punished in the case of MEV theft. 5) Forced upgrades - this will remove long term technical debt. Finally, 6) express queue - this will be a system to help small operators move from legacy validators to validators on the new system.
Part 5 - Glossary of terms
This section explains some of the jargon that is being introduced in the new tokenomics. These include terms like megapools, cliff, etc.
The tokenomics rework has now been published to the Rocket Pool DAO forum. This is the next step in the Rocket Pool governance process. Here, the community will discuss ideas and perspectives. Within the next few weeks, a community sentiment poll will be added to that thread. If the sentiment is positive, it will go to vote for the whole of the DAO where we will all decide on whether to adopt this or not. I strongly expect this proposal to pass every stage of governance and be voted in within the next couple of months.
If you want to help, you can do it in one of three ways. The first is proving meta feedback on the explainers. The second is providing specification feedback. Finally, you can provide general content feedback.




























