
Privacy advocate, Executive Director @EPICprivacy in Washington, DC. Interested in: tech + privacy law. @AlanInDC@infosec.exchange
Washington, DC
Joined June 2009
- Tweets4.7K
- Following1.5K
- Followers1.7K
- Likes1.5K
Replying to @joejerome
Yeah but see that was about a *theoretical* opt-out that no one would actually use. This is way too close to useable
1
1
36
Panel at #CPDP2022 starting now featuring @EPICprivacy ‘a @Iwillleavenow discussing privacy in exceptional circumstances with @k_irion, @MalJayaram, @rafa_zanatta, and @patrickpenninck
Curious what folx with programming backgrounds think about this definition. See the ultimate paragraph and the example in FN 7. Opinion here: supremecourt.gov/opinions/20…
Looking forward to discussing Surveillance and Privacy in the Pandemic at the @AmULRev symposium tonight @ 5:15pm ET w/ @tiffanycli @ariezrawaldman and @ProfFerguson. See you there! youtu.be/6WjBlSdizho
Today we lost a true champion of freedom and an absolute legend. Rest in power RBG. May your dying statement be honored even by those who have no honor.
The result? SCCs are valid, but controllers and DPAs in EU must review transfers / laws in third countries to ensure adequate protection or else block transfers. Privacy Shield decision invalidated; US transfers subject to GDPR. Fin.
What does this mean for the US? Well neither Section 702 of FISA, nor EO 12333, nor PPD-28 provide the necessary minimum safeguards. Those authorities are not limited to what is strictly necessary. They are overbroad. They also don't provide any effective remedies.
1
1
These limitations must be proportional and apply only so far as is strictly necessary. The law that interferes with Charter rights "must lay down in clear and precise rules" the scope and application and must impose "minimum safeguards" to protect against abuse.
1
1
This is groundbreaking and worth breaking down in more detail. The Charter of Fundamental Rights provides that any limitations on the freedoms it recognizes must "be provided for by law and respect the essence of those rights." Scope of the limitation must be clearly defined.
1
1
Fourth (?s #7, 11), are the European Commission's decisions approving the standard contractual clauses valid? The answer? YES. Because the SCCs themselves require that processors provide an adequate level of protection or else stop the transfers.
1
1
Third (?#8), is a data protection authority required under GDPR to suspend data transfers under the SCCs if they find that adequate protection cannot be provided as to specific transfers? The answer? YES
1
1
Second (?s 2, 3, and 6), what factors need to be considered when evaluating the level of protection for personal data transferred under the SCCs? The answer? Data subjects must be afforded level of protection "essentially equivalent" to what is guaranteed by GDPR + the Charter.
1
1
First, does EU Law (GDPR) apply to transfers of personal data by a business w/r/t potential data processing by a law enforcement or government intelligence agency (FBI/NSA)? Even though GDPR does not apply to transfers by EU member states for such purposes. The answer? YES
1
1














