Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @Robkearney1981
This is literally Thucydides' antilogy between the pessimistic Spartans and optimistic Athenians, the only difference being that Athenians don't crack when experiencing misfortune, the pessimitic Spartans do. The psychology is wrong, people being used to good fortune are stronger
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @MAOrthofer
Nobody reads Marx because he's a fossil. No thinking man can believe in the end of history, or that man can be made better by science, or that materialism can become a science predicting the future, or in his division of labor. All these are refuted by Plato.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @verseweave
Thucydides said it better: for the weak (Melos) hope as a future help from gods and friends can be a ruinous relief from danger. For the strong (Athenians) hope as a present force of a large army, technology and money can be a comforter in action. Hope loves power.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @sentantiq
Cf Aristotle - a man who refuses politics is either a god or a beast. Calypso is a woman who can make you a superman, godlike, Circe makes you subhuman, a pig. Homer shows us the best of women, Calypso, and the worst, Circe. Odysseus refuses Calypso because he's a political man.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @HomerPavlos
There are 2 types of history: 1) Marxist, an impotent, slave moralistic outrage due to looking back at humiliation, weakness, trying to repair in the present the evil of the past. 2) Thucydidean, the past as a lesson and a light to understand the present and predict the future.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @MinCorpPixel @sentantiq
Lethe (oblivion) and mnemosyne (memory) are two sources that can produce in the soul either forgetfulness or the revelation of the past as a truth for the present, and a foresight for the future (Thucydides). Helen is virtually a form of Platonic wisdom, unchangeable.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @romanhelmetguy
The best part of that dialogue is the masked intervention of Xenophon himself who says that they only have arms and virtue, and they're ready to fight the Persians at once, but without arms virtue is useless. Aristotle would later say that virtue without armament is nil.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @Utahdesert @sentantiq
Not through senses, but through intellect. Thucydides believes that the historian's hindsight can be the politician's foresight - to polish his xynesis. Thucydides is more actual now than ever before - interpret the world through insight, intuition and tested experience.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @athenaeumbc
Depends on the book, not all the old books are useful. Cf Thucydides: investigating the past is useful to determine the present evil, to find a way to predict the future (by eliminating evil). The past as a light to shine on the present in order to predict the future.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @CLT_Exam
Courage is best defined by Thucydides and Plato, although Plato gives a Thucydidean definition of the virtue, both in the Laches and the Republic - the union between the Spartan and the Athenian character. Thus, courage is both moral (Spartan) and scientific (Athenian). Rep 430B.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @LisaBritton
This is what Antiphon says. If you bury a wooden bed, after some time the 'physis' of the wood would manifest itself, and it will give birth not to a bed, but to another wood/tree. What this means is that physis (human nature) is stronger than nomos (education or 'lion taming').
Alex Leone retweeted
Lots of words, no substance. A hero for Plato is a philosopher in the higher sense (that goes through a katabasis) and in front of pleasure, fear, desire or pain has the power to stay steadfast and obedient to law of what to fear and what to not.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @the_culturist_
That piety leads to good fortune is so ridiculzed by Thucydides with Nicias's catastrophe. Cf Plato's Laches. Here you have the difference between a great thinker, Thucydides, and a guy who writes for children. Piety can lead to ruin more than anything else, it gives false hopes.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @suzania @trottskyathome
Not at all. The sophists believed in virtue as art, man made better by the science of man, philosophy. Socrates believed in the same thing, and Plato has him being refuted by Thrasymachus, art in the hands of an expert crook leads to injustice. Philosophy for Plato is a katabasis
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @wylfcen
Stupid criminals get caught, smart criminals transform their crime into law, or, they protect their crime through it. This is how Thrasymachus refutes Socrates in the Republic - the criminal in high places is a very intelligent artist.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @EveKeneinan
The good and law (thus god) are different things. The communists in murdering did so in the name of the good. Xenophon brilliantly proves that the good is not the law in the coat argument in Cyropedia. The woke also believe in the good (as fairness or fitting) as law.
Alex Leone retweeted
Replying to @HarrisonGarlic1
Plato himself denies that the philosopher is a craftsman - or that virtue is a craft. Socrates believed in virtue as craft and Plato has him being refuted by Thrasymachus. You name ''Platonic'' something Plato refuted and waged war against - because it is a sophist invention.




