
Professor @APCSS, former Post-doc Fellow @Harvard @Kennedy_School. Evolutionary Realist. Sometimes I paint portraits, sometimes caricatures.
Honolulu, HI
Joined July 2013
- Tweets11.2K
- Following847
- Followers4.4K
- Likes1.9K
Pinned Tweet
Want to understand what soft power is, where it comes from, how it works? Read this paper: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.…
Alex Vuving retweeted
The right analogy for AI is not nuclear weapons but biological ones.
We’re effectively doing gain-of-function research in labs (“sandboxes”) that are full of holes. We don’t understand how it all works, yet we keep pushing the limit.
The US and China need to jointly establish boundaries on this type of cyber experimentation and testing.
Today we published WeWorm, our zero-click worm that spreads across iOS and Android.
All it takes is one phone call. You don't have to answer. Seconds later, your WeChat account is compromised, calling your friends and spreading the attack.
We reported the bug to Tencent, and it's now mitigated for all users.
We hope this sets an example. The US and China disagree on plenty, but keeping billions of people safe online shouldn't be one of them.
AI gives us a chance to find and fix these bugs faster than ever. We should work together to make the world safer for everyone.
Our story and demos: calif.io/research/weworm
Karen Hao just said the quiet part out loud.
The biggest names in AI are not predicting the future. They are building a story designed to make the future comply.
Hao: “We don’t predict the future, we make it.”
She called these statements acts of speech. Designed to persuade the world to hand over power and resources to the people making the claims.
She is not accusing them of being wrong. She is saying accuracy is beside the point.
When a CEO announces superintelligence is five years away, that is not a forecast. That is a capital acquisition strategy dressed as a timeline.
It pulls money. It pulls talent. It pulls government attention. It restructures where billions flow before a single technical milestone is reached.
The prediction does not describe the future. It funds it.
Hao: “They are purposely trying to create this feeling within the public. Because it is a crucial part of their power.”
Most people stop here. That is exactly what they are counting on.
The doom narrative is not a warning. It is positioning.
Convince the world that what you are building is the most dangerous thing in human history, and you have simultaneously convinced the world that you are the most important person in the room.
Fear and inevitability do the same work. Both concentrate resources around whoever controls the frame.
Then Hao reached for the analogy that ties the whole thing shut.
Hao: “The AI world is like Dune.”
In Frank Herbert’s universe, myths are pre-seeded on planets generations before anyone arrives. When Paul Atreides lands on Arrakis, he does not invent the messianic narrative. He steps into one that was planted long before him.
Hao: “He steps into the role of the messiah and leans into this idea in order to better control the people and rally them behind him.”
He knows the myth is engineered. But he inhabits it long enough that the line between strategy and belief dissolves.
Hao: “It kind of starts to blur in his mind whether this is really a myth or whether he’s really the messiah.”
That is the condition of the men building this industry.
They started by telling a story they knew would move markets. Then they told it so many times they started believing it themselves. The line between strategy and conviction dissolved somewhere in the repetition.
That is the part nobody talks about.
It is easy to call it manipulation. It is harder to accept that the person doing it may no longer know where the performance ends and the belief begins.
Hao is not saying these people are lying. She is saying something worse.
They have fused with the narrative so completely that the question of truth no longer applies.
The prediction is the product.
The fear is the funding mechanism.
The myth is the moat.
If you are consuming their timelines as neutral information, you are not tracking the future.
You are being recruited into someone else’s.
Alex Vuving retweeted
"Godfather of AI" Geoffrey Hinton on the odds that AI will try to take over from us, and why nobody can honestly put a number on them:
Hinton is asked what the chances are that AI will try to take over from humanity.
He begins by admitting there's no historical precedent to work from: "We've never been here before."
Then he lays out where people land:
"Very few people think there's no chance. Some people say 99%. Those are the real alarmists. Some people say 0%. Those are the deniers."
He calls out one of the people in the zero camp, Nvidia's Jensen, and questions his motives:
"Jensen has good reason for saying it's not dangerous because he wants to sell more Nvidia chips. I don't have any particular good reason for saying it's dangerous."
So where does Hinton stand?
"I just believe there's a significant chance that we'll develop AIs that we don't want to share the planet with unless we do much more work on the other aspects of those beings."
What's striking is that Hinton won't defend any specific figure, including the ones often linked to him.
He says the popular estimates are signals, not measurements:
"Nobody can get a good number. There's no way to justify 10% or 20%. You use those numbers to indicate to people it's a significant chance. It's not some very minor chance."
He goes further:
"Nobody knows what the right number is. There is no way to estimate that number, but it's certainly not zero. And Jensen knows better than to say the probability of anything is zero."
So if the number can't be known, what is it for?
Pamela Brown brings up an analogy Hinton has used before: if there were a 10% or 20% chance the plane you were boarding would crash, you probably wouldn't get on.
Hinton agrees:
"Exactly. Exactly. That's the point of saying 10 to 20% to tell people it's a significant chance. It's not inevitable."
And @geoffreyhinton spells out what follows from that:
"That means that saying there's an 80% chance it won't happen, but it's a significant chance and therefore you should put resources into trying to make sure it doesn't happen."
Alex Vuving retweeted
Chinese local governments as shopping malls is such a brilliant analogy.
You want to attract anchor tenants or firms for their spillover benefits.
Originally coined by Chinese economist Steven Cheung and referenced in Lan Xiaohuan’s book How China Works: pekingnology.com/p/chinas-la…
Alex Vuving retweeted
NYT editorial board: “The nuclear analogy is useful because it reminds us of something our cynical age can forget: Human society can restrain a dangerous innovation once it decides to.”
nytimes.com/2026/09/18/opini…
Alex Vuving retweeted
Had @Ada_Palmer back on – this time to talk about Machiavelli, perhaps the most misunderstood thinker of all time.
Machiavelli cut his teeth as a high-level diplomat for Florence, a position from which he got to closely observe the most important rulers in Europe at the time, including the ones who were on the path to destroying his dearly beloved Florence.
In 1513 the Medici retook control of Florence and, wrongly suspecting Machiavelli of participating in a coup attempt, fired, tortured, and exiled him.
Machiavelli could have fled his exile and worked for any number of different principalities that would have been eager to make use of his talents.
Instead, he decided to rot in the countryside and compile his career's lessons about power, politics, and human nature into a book he dedicated to the very man whose new regime had tortured and exiled him, Lorenzo di Piero de' Medici.
But at least the Medici were in a position to use his insights to defend Florence. Machiavelli the patriot did not want any other hands to touch this book, because those hands, armed with these lessons, might pose an existential danger to Florence.
The closest modern analogy, at least as Machiavelli would have seen it, would be Szilard's letter warning FDR about the possibility of a nuclear fission bomb.
What were those insights? And how were they inspired by Machiavelli's dangerous diplomatic missions all across Europe, and his extensive reading of antiquity? Watch this episode with Ada Palmer to find out!
00:00:00 – How Florence bargained with Cesare Borgia for survival
00:15:08 – Machiavelli’s analytical innovations
00:23:58 – Why popes became warlords
00:36:13 – Why the common people demanded nepotism
00:47:57 – Cesare Borgia brought terror to rulers and justice to the people
00:57:55 – Art as a proxy for war
01:06:41 – Florence, a city famous in hell
01:15:57 – The Prince was a job application to Machiavelli’s torturers
01:41:39 – During the Renaissance, original ideas had to be couched in antiquity
01:50:44 – Why copyright began with the Inquisition
02:02:12 – Machiavelli wasn’t Machiavellian
Look up Dwarkesh Podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, etc.
Alex Vuving retweeted
In thinking about the right historical analogy for AI, I've become very interested in the early history of electricity in the early 1900s.
With early 20th century electricity, you had:
- famously feuding private inventors creating/scaling the early technology (Edison, Tesla, Westinghouse)
- a set of de facto monopolies who insisted that their technology was different in kind from other products and required special levels of corporate concentration
- a period of sluggish growth, followed by a surge in commercial demand that prevented the boom from falling into the classic definition of an infrastructure "bubble"
- a financial mania around electricity—e.g., the holding companies of the early 1900s, many of which did blow up after the 1929 crash
- an inevitable showdown with the federal government about regulation in the 1930s, which ultimately resulted in a lot of regulated monopolies
If you think that the AI buildout might result in some companies crashing and burning, without the entire thing becoming a classic Carlota Perez-style capital bubble, and furthermore believe that we are on an inevitable path toward a new regulatory regime that treats the frontier labs as regulated monopolies, I think you should definitely get curious about the 100-year-old history of electricity.
derekthompson.org/p/the-ai-v…
Alex Vuving retweeted
Kazakhstan has a good chance of becoming "the next Singapore", if this analogy even makes sense. It's exciting to see @balajis making waves, and it's further proof that political will is what makes (and unmakes) countries. If I had to bet, this is how things will evolve:
Alex Vuving retweeted
This is an interesting question. My take: I do not quite accept the notion that China did not seek to "weaponize" rare earths and instead stumbled into a position of advantage. For at least 16 years, and likely more, the purpose has been an economic weapon. This is not like, say, solar or EVs, where excess capacity is sort of an accident.
Here, for example, is a semi-authoritative book cited by @JohnF_Sullivan on rare earth strategy written in 2011 for the state China Economic Publishing House the year after the Japan situation:
"What magical quality do rare earths possess that makes the usually arrogant and domineering Americans so furious? What magical quality do rare earths posses that leaves the usually wealthy and arrogant Japanese grief-stricken? China is the only country in the world capable of supplying all 17 rare earth elements, particularly holding a larger share of heavy rare earths that have prominent uses in military applications. To change China’s international position in the rare earth industry, since 2009, the Chinese government has launched a vigorous rare earth defense war, adopting a series of rectification measures including suspending approval of mining rights, controlling total mining volume, reducing export quotas, raising export tariffs and and severely cracking down on rare earth smuggling."
A key purpose of these post-2009 steps, which PRECEDE China's weaponization against Japan in 2010, was to hone a better coercive instrument.
Then there is some empirical evidence suggesting PRC action in this sector was about leverage.
First, most obviously, China used this as a coercive instrument in 2010. That shows, for at least 16 years, they have understood it as a critical leverage point.
Second, China's government has for decades manipulated the price of rare earths to prevent anyone else from achieving scale - dropping the price to kill foreign investment. Why did they do this when they already had 90% market dominance? The logic is toward control, not profit, and it is not the result of disaggregated independent Chinese market actors (which do not exist in this sector).
Third, related to that point, if this industry operated on economic logic, we would probably see more fragmentation. Indeed, for a brief time, we did see that before 2010. But then the PRC sharply consolidated the rare earths industry into state-backed companies. They shut down, arrested, harassed, and outright expropriated private actors. This was partly to ensure greater state control over external flows - the better to maintain leverage. The quote above refers to that effort.
Fourth, I do not think China's controls on rare earth minerals were modeled off U.S. controls. For example, the October controls went far beyond any U.S. controls. China's idea was any product, anywhere in the world, with .1% value coming from Chinese produced rare earths, required a license to be sold to anyone else in the world. The closest analogy -- and Chinese scholars have said this directly -- is to U.S. financial sanctions, not export controls.
Fifth, this is not a case where "there are many different actors, and they often overperform in search of particular targets." The industry has for a long time just been a few actors, tied to the state, acting at the state's direction. China's cultivation of leadership in this sector dates back to the 1960s, accelerating in the 1980s, with direct involvement of Deng's family in the 1990s and Premier Wen in the 2000s.
The empirical evidence seems to indicate a conscious desire to dominate this sector. One can debate whether or not such an intention was justifiable given U.S. control over chokepoints like finance.
But I think it is hard to advance the claim this was just the independent action of market participants that happened to accidentally create a position of extreme concentration and dominance.
When China spent decades building dominance in rare earths supply chains, what was it really trying to do? Build an economic weapon? Or something else?
I asked @jessicacweiss on The Economics Show with Soumaya Keynes podcast this week...
ft.com/content/34a8939c-ba23…
Alex Vuving retweeted
Fields Medalist Timothy Gowers raises a troubling possibility: AI could become so powerful at mathematics that future generations may lose the motivation to study the subject deeply enough to understand its discoveries.
The paradox is striking. Machines might eventually solve problems far beyond human capabilities, while fewer mathematicians possess the expertise needed to interpret their results.
For Gowers, the deeper concern extends beyond the future of mathematical careers. It is about preserving the curiosity, intellectual discipline, and satisfaction of discovery that have sustained mathematics for centuries.
He also envisions a possible transformation of the mathematician’s role, from discovering new theorems to interpreting, connecting, and explaining mathematical knowledge generated by AI.
Reflecting on the approaching social consequences, Gowers offers a vivid analogy:
“We’re still on the beach, we can see the tsunami, but it hasn’t quite reached us yet.”
Importantly, he is not calling for mathematics departments to close or for universities to stop admitting PhD students. His remarks are cautious predictions about a possible future, rather than descriptions of changes that have already taken place.
Alex Vuving retweeted
Hannah Arendt delivered this lecture, "Thinking and Moral Considerations," in 1971, several years after she had covered Adolf Eichmann's trial in Jerusalem. That trial left her with a nagging question: how could someone commit such horrific acts without being a monster or fanatic? She concluded Eichmann's defining trait was simply an inability to think — he relied on clichés and fell apart when none applied. This lecture is her attempt to work out whether moral judgment depends on this capacity to think.
To explore this, she turns to Socrates as her model of real thinking. He described himself three ways: a gadfly who wakes people up, a midwife who helps others examine their own ideas without ever supplying answers, and an electric ray that paralyzes others by first being paralyzed itself. Genuine thinking, in her view, doesn't produce fixed rules — it unsettles things, which is both its value and its risk, since that same unsettling can tip into nihilism if people mistake uncertainty for permission.
Her central insight is that thinking is really an inner conversation — a "two-in-one" dialogue with yourself. Conscience, she argues, isn't some built-in moral sense; it's just what happens when you're forced to face yourself in that inner dialogue. People who never pause for this conversation have nothing stopping them from doing terrible things, because there's no inner witness there to object.
She ends by linking thinking to judgment — our everyday ability to say "this is wrong" without consulting a rulebook. Thinking itself is quiet and produces no visible results, but in moments when society's norms collapse, people who've practiced this habit of inner questioning are more likely to recognize wrongdoing and refuse to go along with it.
cooperative-individualism.or…
Alex Vuving retweeted
“Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature.”
— Hubert Reeves
Alex Vuving retweeted
“Courage is resistance to fear, mastery of fear — not absence of fear.”
— Mark Twain
Alex Vuving retweeted
"All governments suffer a recurring problem: Power attracts pathological personalities. It is not that power corrupts but that it is magnetic to the corruptible."
— Frank Herbert
Alex Vuving retweeted
“We've arranged a global civilization in which most crucial elements profoundly depend on science and technology. We have also arranged things so that almost no one understands science and technology. This is a prescription for disaster. We might get away with it for a while, but sooner or later this combustible mixture of ignorance and power is going to blow up in our faces.”
― Carl Sagan
Alex Vuving retweeted
Here is an article from 2019,
Very funny to look at hindsight but also a reminder that despite it being true Zelenskyy was relatively soft on Russia compared to Poroshenko,
Putin still decided to invade nevertheless
Alex Vuving retweeted
While researching Greek and Roman battles, I had the idea that the origin of the languages of the Greeks and Romans, the end of their states, and the beginning of Greek freedom in the modern age are all strangely attracted to this Black Sea region. A coincidence worthy of note!































