Respect for naming that. Most traders won’t.
A rule that only exists in your head gets renegotiated in the moment, and usually by the most activated part of you.
Trading for a living makes this harder. When the PnL has to pay the bills, a red day feels like a threat. A threatened nervous system will trade to get out of discomfort before it will sit still.
The DLL is guarding your income, even on the days it feels like it’s in the way.
This quoted post is unavailable.
THE REAL REASON YOU NEED RULES:
Position sizing and daily loss limits aren’t just risk management tools.
They’re self-boundaries. And when you break them, it’s rarely just about “poor discipline.”
It’s a psychological rebellion against feeling small, constrained, or powerless. And most traders don’t realize this.
They think they’re simply breaking a trading rule. But what’s really happening is an emotional protest.
You take on oversized risk because somewhere deep inside, you’re tired of feeling limited... by markets, by rules, by yourself.
What's really happening in a deeper level:
👉It’s the unconscious urge to prove your significance.
👉To make something happen now.
👉To not feel small.
But every time you violate your own limits, you reinforce the very thing you’re fighting.
The deeper reasons why do we need rules:
➡They protect energy.
➡They create structure.
➡They make consistency possible
When you respect them, you’re not playing small, you’re creating space for sustainable growth.
That’s not constriction. (the ego thinks it is)
More accurately, it's containment, the kind that allows power to build, not leak.
If you’ve ever said “I know my rules, I just don’t follow them,” pause and ask yourself:
What part of me is rebelling?
What emotion am I trying to avoid by taking more risk than I should?
What am I trying to prove... and to whom?
Trading boundaries aren’t about control. They’re about self-trust.
Because real freedom in trading ... and in life... comes after you’ve learned to honor your own limits.
If this resonates, follow, like, re-post it and BOOKMARK this post.
#tradermindset #tradingpsychology $ES_F $NQ_F
$SPY $QQQ
Yes.
And I'll add there is a wide range of quality of people in the 'trading psychology space.
Same is true in trading education in general.
It's why I said yes when Brian @alphatrends asked me to do some work for him.
Replying to @JazOnChain @Andrew_Menaker
trading is a psychological game, first and foremost. Need more guests like Andrew, tbh.
2
8
1,016
🙏
hopefully, more people will see these videos.
My coaching clients often say it's a 'crime' that I don't have as many followers as your average trading educator.
Most pple just want the fantasy/hope, not the reality.
Replying to @KrutzkyTrades @Andrew_Menaker
I'm like halfway through this interview and wow, the amount of psychological concepts and aspects of trading he has covered are amazing.
So much to learn from these interviews
This needs to be said, and it means more coming from someone who spent many years on the floor.
I’d add one distinction. I work with traders at traditional prop firms like Gelber Group, Merus Global, First N.Y., Schonenfeld, etc (and large HFs) and the culture there has very little in common with the online funding programs. Those firms invest in a trader over years. There’s real capital, real risk oversight, and people around you who’ve done it.
The online funding model is built differently. It’s a very profitable business, and much of the money comes from evaluations people don’t pass.
I’ve heard from a lot of traders who’ve spent thousands on fees. Some got a few payouts. For most, the math hasn’t worked.
My bigger concern is what it does to development. The rules push people toward overtrading, because drawdown limits and payout targets put the nervous system under constant time pressure. And traders spend years shaping themselves around rules instead of finding out what kind of trader they actually are.
That second part is the skill you’re describing, the one nobody can take away. It’s hard to build it inside a box someone else designed.
There’s a warning sign in the future of day trading, and it starts with the mindset of today’s traders.
Somewhere along the way, the conversation shifted from building careers to chasing payouts. We rarely talk about what it takes to grind through the difficult years, develop real skills, and make a living in the markets.
I was a blue collar trader with no money or college education. I spent 23 years as a CME member, never the richest or the best, but I built a career and developed a skill nobody can take away from me.
Today, traders have opportunities I never had. I believe prop firms may be the greatest stepping stone aspiring traders have ever had. But only if they’re used correctly.
If the goal is simply to pass evaluations, collect payouts, and repeat the cycle, we’re missing the bigger opportunity.
Prop should be a stepping stone to independence, not a permanent destination.
We need to shift the mindset from chasing payouts to building sustainable careers. Otherwise, we risk creating a generation of traders who learn how to get funded but never learn how to survive on their own.
The greatest thing trading gave me wasn’t money. It was a skill, discipline, and confidence that will last a lifetime.
That’s what the next generation of traders should be building toward.
This is one of my favorite conversations about trading. @KrutzkyTrades asks me great Qs.
Definitely worth a watch. We went deep.
#tradingpsychology
Much of this conversation with @Andrew_Menaker centered around relief.
Many of my trading mistakes boil down to relieving uncomfortable feelings associated with NOT being in a trade.
The takeaway: Get comfortable with simply doing nothing: nitter.cf/thirdmetax/status/2121…
Your worst trades were probably a search for relief.
@KrutzkyTrades and I went deep on that, and on why crypto hits the nervous system in its own way. One of my favorite conversations.
youtube.com/watch?v=Z2iypdnR…
#tradingpsychology
TWO LESSONS EVERY TRADER KNOWS - BUT ONLY A FEW HAVE ABSORBED & INTEGRATED:
Two lessons separate the traders who make it from the ones who keep starting over. Almost everyone can recite both. But very few have truly integrated them into their identity as a trader.
And the space between knowing something and integrating it into oneself is where a lot of trading careers quietly stall.
LESSON ONE:
A good decision can cost you.
Sometimes a good decision means watching a move happen without you. Your setup wasn’t there, so you passed, and the market ripped anyway.
Sometimes it means taking the loss at your predefined stop. Clean execution, exactly as planned, and you’re still down money.
You know both of these are correct. Every trading book says so.
But nodding along to that is very different from sitting flat at 10:42am while NQ runs 120 points without you.
Your nervous system didn’t read the book. It registers exclusion, it registers loss, and it files both under threat.
So the lesson isn’t actually learned - integrated into who you are - until you can miss a move or take a controlled loss and your body stays relatively quiet. Until the regret stops leaking into your next trade.
LESSON TWO:
A bad decision can feel great.
This one is harder to see, and I think it does more damage.
You take a trade on impulse. No setup, no defined risk, just a pull in your gut that said now. And you make money.
It feels like a relief, or can even feel fantastic, which is exactly why it’s dangerous.
Underneath the P&L, you just paid yourself for breaking your own rules. You rewarded the behavior you are trying to eliminate.
A couple of things follow from that.
The ego gets fed. The win becomes proof that you “saw it,” that your instincts are special, that maybe the rules are for other people.
In trading, your ego is not your amigo.
It cares much more about being right than about being successful over time, and a lucky impulse win hands it exactly what it’s been asking for.
And the brain/nervous system learns.
Dopamine has less to do with pleasure than most people assume.
What it tracks most reliably is the gap between what you expected and what you got.
An impulsive trade that pays off is, almost by definition, unexpected, so the dopamine response tends to run hotter than it does for a boring planned winner.
That surge tags the behavior as worth repeating.
Because impulse trades only pay some of the time, you end up on an intermittent reward schedule, which is about as sticky as conditioning gets.
Anyone who has watched someone at a slot machine understands this intuitively.
Bad habits get wired in while you’re making money.
You won’t notice them forming. Your account will notice later.
So which one is the real threat?
Many (not all) traders are far more afraid of missing out than of their own impulses.
FOMO feels urgent and painful. And the impulse win feels like a gift. In my experience they have it backwards.
A missed move costs you one trade. A rewarded impulse can cost you years, because it trains the very pattern that eventually hurts an account badly, and it does it while making you feel skilled.
Getting this to land, not just intellectually but in the nervous system, is a big part of what good coaching actually does.
Someone has to look at the winning trade you’re proud of and ask how you got into it. Someone has to help you stay with a missed move long enough for your system to register that nothing bad happened.
Left alone, your Inner Market will keep treating the missed move as the emergency and the impulsive win as the victory. Most traders never stop long enough to question which one is truly costing them.
This often becomes a focal point in my 1:1 coaching. They may 'know' it already, but they haven't come to terms with it.
You can read and study all the psychology in the world, read a great psychology book, have a nice self-mgt. app to help keep you focused, etc. but the real work will always come down to how you respond in the heat of the moment.
Do you act out the emotion - hit the button for temporary emotional relief?
And automating your trading seems like the solution.
I have worked wth traders who have automated, and what I see is they either tinker with the system at the wrong time, or they get too rigid and let the system run even though the market enters a regime the system was not designed for and they take a huge drawdown.
The real work always has been and always will be... in how you address that.
#tradermindset #tradingpsychology $ES_F $NQ_F
$SPY $QQQ
we should start a guidebook....
proposed title:
"Nothing Where It’s Supposed To Be"
1
7
925







