Benchlight (@Benchlight) header
Benchlight (@Benchlight) profile picture

Tracking the work of the federal appellate bench and the status of federal appellate nominations and vacancies.

United States
Joined August 2026
OPINION — SUPREME COURT National Park Service, et al. v. National Trust for Historic Preservation in the United States. Per curiam. Dissent, by The Chief Justice, joined by Justice Sotomayor, Justice Kagan, and Justice Jackson. benchlight.org/opinions/7029…
1
169
An appeals court sided with the parents of New Hampshire students who accused school officials of banning them from events after they wore wristbands to protest a transgender player's participation in a girls' soccer game in 2024, finding the display "fell short of harassment and disruption."
The First Circuit sides with parents punished for wearing pink “XX” wristbands to their daughters’ soccer game to protest transgender athletes’ participation in girls’ sports. It was a silent protest. There was no evidence of disruption or harassment of any player. As the court recognized, school officials sought to suppress a viewpoint on a contested issue. But “administrators cannot favor one side of a debate involving parental speech on an issue of prominent public concern, and which, in those parents’ views, concerned the safety of their children.” That violates the First Amendment. Great win by @InstFreeSpeech.
1
119