Boston Tom retweeted
Judge Doolin’s May 19, 2025 Order denying @DoctorTurtleboy Aidan Kearney's initial motion to dismiss found that the Massachusetts witness intimidation statute wasn’t an impermissible overreach under the First Amendment, either generally or as specifically applied to Kearney.
This morning, Kearney’s attorneys asked Judge Belezos certify a question for appeal requiring the Judge to instruct jurors that the witness intimidation law nevertheless must be viewed in light of the overarching protections of the First Amendment. In turn, Special Prosecutor Robert Cosgrove argued that Judge Doolin’s prior order precludes any Freedom of Speech discussion before jurors. Full stop.
Judge Belezos declined to certify the question for appeal but recognized that not all the speech jurors will hear about falls within the prohibitions of the witness intimidation statute. Without being specific as to any given remark, The Court signaled that jury likely will be instructed about the First Amendment in some fashion.
This is huge. It means Kearney’s attorneys probably will be able explain to jurors during argument about the influence the First Amendment ought to have on their determinations. It also means Kearney probably can introduce testimony about the sphere of his protected speech activities. And it means Kearney’s attorneys might also be permitted to argue during opening arguments how the entire trial ought to viewed through a First Amendment lens.
This is a huge win for @DoctorTurtleboy.
Boston Tom retweeted
Norfolk County District Attorney Michael Morrissey and Massachusetts Speaker of the House Ronald Mariano never expected this letter to see the light of day and it was only obtained through a public records request.
#karenread
Boston Tom retweeted
BREAKING:
Turtleboy remains free.
Motion by Meatball's hack prosecutor to jail Aidan Kearney before trial is DENIED in Suffolk Superior Court.
Judge says he will issue new release conditions so no impounded records can be used by anyone, no matter how they got into public domain.
Boston Tom retweeted
This one is a real gem
Lizzie Proctor going guano crazy and calling people’s employers because they stated Michael Proctor bad.
Hey Lizzie - Which law enforcement officer’s wife should be embarrassed? Which LEO is a disgraced officer?
Hmmmm.
Canton Cover-Up Part 308: Elizabeth Proctor Writes Email To Western Mass Superintendent Demanding That School Committee Member Be Fired For Posting Negatively About Husband Michael Proctor
Fake victim Elizabeth Proctor *
tbdailynews.com/2024/03/19/c…
Boston Tom retweeted
BREAKING: Aidan Kearney’s trial is pushed back to February of 2027…
Meaning 2/27. The jokes write themselves
Boston Tom retweeted
Supporting an independent journalist by going to court or donating to a legal fund is NOT on the level of JIM JONES.
But the judge kind of alluded that it is?!?
This isn’t Jonestown, Your Honor 🤦🏻♀️
Even Google knows what up:
Boston Tom retweeted
Aidan Kearney – Full Pre-Trial Hearing Recap
Today’s hearing addressed the Commonwealth’s motion to revoke bail plus a large set of motions in limine filed by both sides ahead of trial.
Bail & Scheduling
Bail revocation DENIED.
Special prosecutor Robert Cosgrove sought to revoke Kearney’s release under G.L. c. 276, § 58B, alleging he violated conditions by reading/discussing discovery materials (including content from Jennifer McCabe’s phone extraction) on livestreams despite prior warnings and protective orders.
The defense argued the material was already in the public domain and protected by the First Amendment.
Judge Belezos denied revocation.
Kearney remains free.
New conditions imposed: “Any material which is impounded or protected by this court is not to be broadcast, rebroadcast, published, [or] addressed in any public forum by Mr. Kearney.”
The judge emphasized “no mistakes.”
Trial continued.
Originally scheduled for early December 2026, the trial was postponed to February 1, 2027 because of a conflict with another trial the judge is handling. (Some courtroom observers referenced a possible February 27 date.)
The Commonwealth filed at least 14 motions in limine.
The defense also filed an omnibus motion for certain findings and rulings in limine.
Here’s what was addressed and the reported outcomes:
MIL #1 – Preclude reference to alleged “bad character” and prior misconduct of victims/witnessesBad character / prior misconduct evidence will require case-by-case approval by the judge.
Judge made clear the defense will not be forced to fully disclose its trial strategy in advance. Relevant topic areas must be identified so the court can rule without requiring a complete preview of the defense case.
MIL #2 – Advanced notice of bias cross-examinationDefense had no objection, provided it receives advance notice of the individual and what that person is expected to say.
Witness sequestration (Commonwealth MIL #7 / Defense omnibus request)Granted.
All trial witnesses will be sequestered so they cannot discuss testimony with one another.
MIL #3: Voir dire of any witness to be asked for opinion or character of the defendant or any witness
MIL #4: Admit defendant’s out-of-court statements as statements of a party opponent
MIL #5: Ongoing order to impound all sidebar conferences + impoundment of juror names
MIL #6: Visual presentations / “chalks”
MIL #8: Opening statements and notice of any visual aids the defense intends to use
MIL #9: Attorney-conducted and individual voir dire of potential jurors
MIL #10: Intent to obtain CORI records of potential jurors
MIL #11: Preclude the defendant from arguing that the prosecutor or DA’s office has a conflict of interest
MIL #12: Allow in-court identification
MIL #13: Admit evidence of other acts between the defendant, alleged victims, and certain third parties related to the Karen Read case
MIL #14: Preclude reference to any missing witnesses
The defense’s omnibus motion sought, among other things:
Witness sequestration (granted)
Exclusion of opinion-based terms such as “victim” or “suspect”
Exclusion of unnoticed “other bad acts” evidence
Exclusion of prejudicial references (e.g., “known to us,” “fled,” “harassed,” “threatened,” “cult”) and attribution of followers’ actions to Kearney
Updated CORI records for Commonwealth civilian witnesses
Adherence to the Bill of Particulars
Reservation of the right to call persons named in police reports
Exclusion of a late-noticed digital forensics expert (Nicholas Guarino)
Media were banned from using electronic devices inside the courtroom.
The Zoom remote feed was disrupted when a participant unmuted and used an expletive. The judge later shut off the remote video for the remainder of the hearing.
Live coverage came primarily from the live zoom and observers present in court or monitoring the Zoom (notably @GrantSmithEllis and others).
#AidanKearney #Turtleboy #KarenRead #MotionsInLimine
Boston Tom retweeted
Here is the pages they are on in Karen’s filing , the are not under a protective order
Boston Tom retweeted
Karen Read’s latest federal filing, citing Jessica Hyde’s report, reveals two texts sent from Jen McCabe’s iPhone at 2:25 a.m. on January 29, 2022.
Put alongside the phone activity that night, the timing is hard to ignore:
• 2:22:35 — Brian Albert calls Brian Higgins (1 second)
• 2:22:52 — Brian Higgins calls Brian Albert (22 seconds)
• 2:23:31 — Jen McCabe’s iPhone is unlocked
• 2:25:11 — Jen texts Michelle Gallery and Matt McCabe:
“I am disgusted!!! Can’t stop thinking about it!!! Ur girls should say are we trying to win games or !?!?”
• 2:25:56 — Jen texts Denise, Coco and Shelly:
“I called dad as well but polly was there”
• 2:26:37 — Two screenshots are deleted from the phone
• 2:27:40 — A search is made: “hos long to die in cold”
• 2:31:07 — The phone locks again
These Jen McCabe texts became public through two separate channels: FOIA records and Karen Read’s federal filing.
Funny that she called the DA office beginning of November and the night before his pre trial hearing Cosgrove tries to take Aidan freedom away for publically accessible discovery
Boston Tom retweeted
The phone extraction Jen McCabe reportedly called DA office about, was released through a FOIA request back in May. Now, months later, Cosgrove is trying to revoke Aidan’s bail over it?
The timeline matters. This information was already out there. What changed and why is this being raised now?
Boston Tom retweeted
My biggest flex, is that even when I had every reason to rash out and take people straight to hell on this app, I never did - Ive always tried to keep it cordial and lift people up when I can. Never will I ever let anyone turn me into someone my momma wouldn’t be proud of 💯
HOMAN v. BRANDY BARREL PUB GRILL INC (2020)Appeals Court of Massachusetts.
Patricia HOMAN v. BRANDY BARREL PUB & GRILL, INC., & others.1
19-P-1355
Decided: August 11, 2020
By the Court (Singh, Wendlandt & McDonough,2 JJ.3
"Plaintiffs often rely on direct evidence of drunken behavior such as loud or boisterous conduct to meet their burden. See, e.g., Cimino, 385 Mass. at 325 (testimony that patron became “loud, and vulgar,” and “obnoxious”); Gottlin v. Graves, 40 Mass. App. Ct. 155, 158 (1996) (testimony that patron appeared drunk and that his “whole manner changes when he drinks”); Hopping v. Whirlaway, Inc., 37 Mass. App. Ct. 121, 123 (1994) (testimony that patron “look[ed] like he had a few” and “seemed to ‘be feeling pretty good’ ”). The plaintiff here has no such evidence. Indeed, witnesses who were at the bar on the evening of the plaintiff's accident testified that she showed no signs of intoxication at any time before she fell. To survive summary judgment, the plaintiff thus needed to come forward with sufficient circumstantial evidence to allow a jury to infer that she must have displayed signs of intoxication prior to being served her last drink. See Douillard, 433 Mass. at 165.
Here, the only evidence that the plaintiff has to support an inference that she was visibly intoxicated at the time of last service is expert testimony opining that, in order to have had the BAC she did when admitted to MGH, she must have been served the equivalent of ten shots of vodka."
" The direct evidence was that the plaintiff did not appear visibly intoxicated. Moreover, the plaintiff failed to supply any additional circumstantial evidence of visible intoxication. The plaintiff did not, for example, have her expert calculate what her BAC would have been at the time she was served her last drink. Instead, he only calculated the plaintiff's BAC at the time of the accident -- some thirty minutes and two and one-half units of alcohol consumption later. The plaintiff also did not testify regarding the number of drinks required before she became intoxicated or obtain testimony from friends or acquaintances who had seen her intoxicated and could describe her appearance and behavior when intoxicated. Compare Douillard, 433 Mass. at 164-168 (reversing summary judgment in favor of defendant bar and finding triable issue as to visible intoxication based upon evidence that bar patron had elevated BAC after his arrest, testimony that patron usually became drunk after seven drinks, testimony describing how patron behaved when drunk, and expert testimony calculating what patron's BAC would have been at time of last service). In short, while the plaintiff has offered evidence that would allow a jury to infer that she appeared visibly intoxicated after she fell, her evidence does not support an inference that she appeared visibly intoxicated at the time she was served her last drink. The plaintiff therefore does not have evidence sufficient to demonstrate that the defendant was negligent, much less willful, wanton, or reckless. The Superior Court judge properly granted summary judgment."
Accordingly, we conclude that a jury could not find that the defendant engaged in willful, wanton, or reckless conduct based upon the record in this case
3
183






























