
Selling ERW steel tubes - again! Following The Red Devils - the English ones as well as the mercenary bunch! #Remain.
Shropshire, UK
Joined August 2009
- Tweets2.7K
- Following446
- Followers303
- Likes406
Brian Stanley retweeted
Dearlove Is Shocked. He Should Be. But He Is Looking At The Wrong People.
Sir Richard Dearlove, the former head of MI6, said yesterday he was shocked to learn that a senior Foreign Office civil servant had discussed Britain's nuclear deterrent in closed-door meetings with an organisation he describes as a front for China's main foreign spy agency. He called for parliamentary scrutiny of Stephen Lillie's meetings with the Grandview Institution during a four-day trip to Beijing last October.
Dearlove is right to be shocked. He is looking at the wrong level.
Lillie's meeting did not happen in isolation. It happened during what the Telegraph describes as a flurry of trips to Beijing by top British officials amid Starmer's deliberate thawing of relations with China. Sir Olly Robbins, subsequently sacked, lunched with Grandview experts the week before Lillie's visit. Jonathan Powell, now the Prime Minister's National Security Adviser, met Grandview before his appointment. Since becoming National Security Adviser in December 2024, Powell has met Wang Yi, the Politburo member directing Chinese foreign affairs, four times. His vetting arrangements have never been publicly confirmed. Every parliamentary question about those arrangements has been blocked.
A civil servant discussing nuclear deterrent protocols with a Chinese spy agency front is alarming. The Prime Minister's National Security Adviser maintaining undisclosed relationships with PLA-connected officials through his private consultancy, while his vetting status remains secret, demands scrutiny of an entirely different order.
The government's defence of Lillie's meetings is that no sensitive information was discussed. That formulation covers every difficult question this government has faced on China. The spy trial that collapsed because the government refused to name China as a national security threat in court. The super embassy approved despite a concealed underground chamber positioned within a metre of the cables carrying the City of London's financial data. The Mandelson appointment despite a due diligence report flagging China and Russia concerns. The same language. The same outcome.
Dearlove warned yesterday that Chinese intelligence operates on an industrial scale, approaches every engagement with aggressive intentions, and exploits any relationship it can access. He said British officials should have been briefed in detail about the threat before attending these meetings. He said he has serious concerns about the national security adviser's previous contacts with China.
Those concerns are warranted. The question Dearlove has raised about Lillie is a question about process and judgment. The question Powell's undisclosed vetting raises, alongside the spy trial collapse, the super embassy, the Indo-Pacific withdrawal, and Chinese components being embedded throughout Britain's energy grid against explicit American intelligence warnings, goes considerably further.
A pattern of decisions this consistent, each retreating from Britain's interests and advancing Beijing's, each defended with the language of pragmatism and engagement, does not emerge from poor judgment alone. Poor judgment produces occasional errors. Sequential decisions, each pointing in the same direction, over two years, by a Prime Minister warned repeatedly who proceeded regardless, produces a different and more troubling question.
Dearlove wants the ISC to scrutinise Lillie's paperwork. The ISC is already reviewing thousands of pages on Mandelson. Parliament has been blocked from scrutinising Powell.
Scrutinise the civil servant by all means. Then ask who sent him, who knew, and why the pattern of engagement with an organisation accused of fronting for Chinese intelligence runs from the bottom of the Foreign Office all the way to the office of the Prime Minister's National Security Adviser.
Sir Richard "has serious concerns about the national security adviser's previous contacts with China."
Brian Stanley retweeted
The Manifesto Was the Alibi
The Labour manifesto of 2024 was explicit. Britain would not rejoin the customs union. It would not rejoin the single market. There would be no return to freedom of movement. Voters were told this clearly, repeatedly, and in writing. They voted accordingly. That was the promise.
Eighteen months later, Cabinet ministers are publicly calling for exactly that. David Lammy has pointed to the benefits of customs union arrangements. Wes Streeting has called for a deeper trading relationship with the EU. Peter Kyle, the Business Secretary, has said it would be crazy not to engage with the prospect of a customs union. These are not backbenchers freelancing. These are senior ministers, at the Cabinet table, arguing openly for the reversal of a commitment their party stood on at a general election. Ask yourself what that tells you about how seriously the commitment was made.
Downing Street's response is instructive. Sources close to Keir Starmer did not say the ministers were wrong about the destination. They said they had not thought it through. The objection was tactical: move too fast, trigger freedom of movement, and the politics become unmanageable. The direction of travel was not disputed. Only the pace.
That is the admission. Buried in a briefing designed to look like a rebuke is a concession: the government accepts the logic of deeper integration. It simply wants to manage the sequencing before the public understands what is being decided. This is not a debate about Europe. It's a question about whether the people who voted in 2024 were told the truth.
The agrifood deal now being finalised illustrates the method. Ministers present it as a modest technical arrangement, a matter of reducing friction for exporters. What it actually involves is Britain operating under EU law, enforced by the European Commission and the European Court of Justice, with British taxpayers funding the privilege and British ministers having no vote on the rules they are required to follow. That is not alignment. It's accession by another name. And if you doubt that the same logic will be applied sector by sector until the architecture is complete, consider that no one in government has yet explained where it stops.
The economics do not justify it. Independent analysis from the Growth Commission and the Prosperity Institute reaches the same conclusion: rejoining costs more than it returns. The case being made in Cabinet, that integration means growth, is not supported by the modelling. It's an article of faith presented as an economic argument, and the public is being asked to pay for it without being told so.
And the damage extends further still. Rejoining the customs union would require Britain to abandon its trade deal with India, exit the CPTPP, and unwind agreements with Australia and New Zealand. Those arrangements took years to negotiate and represent the most tangible gains from leaving. They would be surrendered not for a gain but for a loss, in exchange for re-entering a regulatory framework in which Britain has no seat, no vote, and no means of redress. That is the deal. It should be stated plainly, because the government will not state it at all.
The Downing Street briefing made one thing plain. The complaint against Lammy, Kyle and Streeting was not that they were wrong. It was that they were saying openly what the government is doing quietly. The objection was to the candour, not the content. The manifesto said one thing. The negotiations are producing another. That is not a government managing a difficult policy. It's a government that made a promise it never intended to keep, and is now hoping the public will not notice until it's too late to matter.
"David Lammy has pointed to the benefits of customs union arrangements. Wes Streeting has called for a deeper trading relationship with the EU"
Brian Stanley retweeted
There is a new belief taking hold among Britain's institutions, and it is as dangerous as it is dishonest. The countryside, we are told, is "too white." Not green. Not rural. Not historic. White. And therefore a problem to be fixed.
This is not satire. It is official policy. Government-commissioned reports now describe England's hills, fields, pubs and footpaths as a "white environment" that risks becoming "irrelevant" unless it is reshaped to reflect a "multicultural nation." Rural authorities are instructed to attract specific ethnic groups, redesign access, rewrite interpretation, adjust behaviour, and rebrand culture itself. All paid for by the taxpayer.
This is not about access to nature. No one is barred from walking in the countryside. There are no gates marked by race. What is being objected to is not exclusion, but presence. The wrong people, in the wrong numbers, in the wrong place. Solitude is suspect. Pubs are "problematic." Dogs are a "barrier." Englishness itself is quietly reframed as a form of hostility.
Once again, the pattern is familiar. First the language. Then the targets. Then the money. Culture is recast as a flaw. Continuity becomes "dominance." History is reduced to optics. And the group that built, sustained and preserved these places is told ā politely, bureaucratically ā that it must adapt or move aside.
What makes this moment different is that the countryside was never in crisis. Cities were transformed by pressure, density, and policy failure. The countryside was stable. Rooted. That stability is precisely why it is now being targeted. It stands as a rebuke to the idea that constant demographic churn is inevitable or desirable. So it must be corrected.
This is demographic engineering, not conservation. The state has decided that England's national landscape reflects the wrong story, and that story must be rewritten. Marketing is altered to show the "right" faces. Outreach is targeted at the "right" groups. Behaviour norms are revised. The land remains, but the meaning is changed.
We are told this is because "we all pay for it." But that argument collapses on contact with reality. If something truly belongs to everyone, you do not single out one group as a problem and instruct it to change. You do not racialise shared space. You do not treat existing culture as a barrier to be dismantled. That is not inclusion. It is displacement by policy.
The same logic now runs through housing, planning and migration. New towns dropped onto villages. Farmland sacrificed. Infrastructure ignored. Numbers driving everything, consent nowhere. The countryside is no longer a living inheritance but a blank surface onto which officials project social outcomes.
And notice the asymmetry. One group must always adapt. One culture must always soften, explain itself, dilute itself. The others are affirmed, accommodated, reassured. That alone tells you this is not about fairness. It is about power.
Once you accept that England itself is a racial problem, nothing is safe. Not villages. Not landscapes. Not history. What survives only does so until the next report declares it "unrepresentative."
The countryside does not need re-education. It does not need racial quotas, rewritten customs, or academic lectures about who belongs. It needs defending because when the state decides a country's heartland is "too white," it has already decided the country itself must change. And once continuity is broken, it does not return.
"The wrong people, in the wrong numbers, in the wrong place. Solitude is suspect. Pubs are "problematic." Dogs are a "barrier." Englishness itself is quietly reframed as a form of hostility."
Brian Stanley retweeted
Replying to @chrislittlewoo8
Software has bugs ā remember the Post Office scandal. Systems get hacked, phones stolen, companies abuse rules and profit from data. The fallout always lands on us, while government shirks responsibility. Digital ID will be no different ā only the consequences worse. Say NO!
Brian Stanley retweeted
Digital ID for every adult is not progress. It is the end of a free society dressed up as convenience.
I am a cyber security specialist. This is my take.
They are selling it as a fix for illegal migration. That is bollocks.
We spend hundreds of billions a year on cyber security and yet the volume of breaches is breaking records. The threat is growing faster than the spend.
Digital ID will not stop boats. It will not stop trafficking gangs. It will not fix a broken border.
āØCriminals will work around it.
Honest citizens will pay the price.
It builds giant data banks that track where you go, what you buy, what you read and who you speak to.
āØIt links your identity to every checkpoint in daily life.
āØOne breach and your life is exposed.
Look at Jaguar Land Rover and the airports in recent weeks. Now imagine that at national scale on an ID system tied to everything you need to live your daily life.
Here is the risk that ministers will not admit.
āØRansomware seeded through a supplier or an insider:
āØIt lies quiet for months.āØIt rolls through the backups.āØOn trigger day the register and the recovery sets are both encrypted.
āØPayments fail. Health and benefits stall. Borders slow. Citizens are frozen out until a ransom is paid or the state rebuilds from scratch.
āØCentralise identity and you centralise failure.
Do not fall for the pitch.
Function creep is certain.āØIt starts as login.
āØIt becomes access to money, travel, speech and public services.
āØIt turns rights into permissions controlled by the state and its contractors.
āØIt creates a single point of failure for criminals, insiders and hostile states to target.
āØIt will punish the elderly, the poor and anyone who is not always online.
āØIt will centralise risk and outsource blame.
āØIt will not stop fraud.
āØIt will not stop illegal migration.
āØIt will build the machinery for a social credit system by stealth.
If ministers cared about the border, they would enforce current laws, resource patrols and processing, close loopholes and remove those with no right to stay.
āØYou do not need a national ID to do any of that.
We scrapped ID cards in 2010 for a reason.
āØBritain does not need a central register to prove age or status.
āØYes to privacy first proofs. No to a database state.
Brian Stanley retweeted
Believe it or not, I had an old school friend on todayās marches in London. He sent me some photos from the crowd.
We went to middle school together and grew up on the same Eastern District council estate in Northampton.
I asked him why he was there. He gave me two answers:
1.āThe government doesnāt listen to us.ā
2.āI want to feel proud of my country again.ā
He wore a Union Jack, not a St Georgeās Cross as he said that one had been hijacked by racists.
He wasnāt there for Hopkins, Musk, or any of the professional āgriftersā as he put it. He was there to feel part of something bigger, though he admitted there were a lot of, in his words, āassholesā there.
Heās an electrician. Heās smart. Heās not racist, but heās not āPCā either. Heās not a fan of Keir Starmer but he also believes Farage would be a disaster.
Oh yes, heās a bundle of contradictions! But arenāt we all?
I donāt know what āboxā we put him or the millions like him in. And I think pretending theyāre all racists or fascists would be a massive mistake.
Some were. But not all.
This is about something bigger than immigration slogans or GDP numbers. For decades weāve hollowed out our national life, underfunding and undermining the very institutions that once brought us together.
Karl Polanyi, writing in The Great Transformation, argued that when markets are ādisembodiedā from society, when land, labour, and life itself are treated as commodities
society pushes back. He called this the ādouble movementā: people seeking to protect themselves, to reclaim dignity and meaning when everything solid seems to melt into air.
Thatās what I saw in my friendās photos. Not just anger, but a demand for belonging.
Weāve replaced collective experience with atomisation. Without getting too nostalgic, programmes like the BBCās Generation Game once pulled in millions every Saturday night, giving us something we could all talk about on Monday morning. Now we watch Netflix, Disney+, Prime, or Paramount, alone, in algorithmic silos.
Football used to be affordable and rooted in community; now itās millionaires playing for the profitability of billionaires. The NHS, the post office, the railways - all chipped away, run down, sold off or centralised, leaving people feeling powerless and disconnected.
And donāt get me wrong: some kind of āHovis Labourā nostalgia for the 1950s isnāt the answer. The country back then was often intolerant, grey, and deeply unequal. But what weāve built since is a society that gives people little to hold in common, no collective story about who we are or what weāre for.
I reckon thatās partly why my mate marched. Not because he wants to turn back the clock. But because he wants to feel pride again. Pride in a country that is inclusive, fair, and offers a role for everyone. Pride in a nation that has a respected place in the world, tackles grotesque inequality, and gives people something real to believe in.
Polanyi warned that when democracies fail to provide a humane alternative, the backlash can turn authoritarian. This is how fascism grew in the 1930s, not because everyone became a true believer, but because millions felt abandoned and looked for strength, identity, and meaning wherever they could find it.
If Labour and progressives donāt offer that story of renewal, if we donāt rebuild our national institutions, restore collective pride, and re-embed markets within society, the far right will do it for us, in their own image.
And by then, it will be too late.
Brian Stanley retweeted
Wes Streeting says cutting 50 calories a day will solve obesity and save the NHS. Thatās bad politics and bad science. In this video, I take apart his arguments and ask whether heās naive or deliberately complicit in weakening our NHS.
youtu.be/UuWhX2ma1yY?si=6iosā¦
Brian Stanley retweeted
Dismayed to see you sharing such a misleading & potentially deeply frightening video, Kim.
If someone is in 'unspeakable pain' at the end of life, they should see a palliative care doctor like me - & I can promise you there is always something I can do for your pain. (1/n)
Great to hear from @PrueLeith who knows all too well how the current status quo restricting choice at the end of life fails so many.
Brian Stanley retweeted
The national debt has just fallen by Ā£1.5 trillion taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2024⦠According to the governmentās own accounts to March 223, which have just been published, the national debt of the UK fell by Ā£1.5 trillion during that year - and is now much lower than the government claims, even when including all future sums owing to pensioners. They claim these accounts are true and fair - so why is it that the government is not shouting about this and saying that the debt obsession is over and that austerity can be consigned to history?
Brian Stanley retweeted
Why doesnāt the Bank of England tell the truth? youtu.be/ZkC9Y3rmGqk?si=04y4⦠The Bank of England knows that all money is created by lending. It has published papers that confirm that fact. They must as a result also know that government spending has to take place before any tax can be paid. But they never say that. They take part in a conspiracy of silence on that issue to deny the public the truth. Why is that?
Brian Stanley retweeted
Half of all people employed in the UK work for small businesses which are run by working people. So, an increase in employers' national insurance will increase taxes on all those working people. Rachel Reeves either does not know this or is denying the truth. Neither is good.
Brian Stanley retweeted
There seems to be significant faux outrage from Tory leadership candidates Cleverly and Tugendhat about the Starmer governmentās transfer of the Chagos islands to Mauritius.
Official sources tell me the transfer would have happened in materially the same
way at roughly the same time if Sunak had somehow won the election.
The point is that the transfer was being negotiated on the recent Tory governmentās watch - including by Cleverly as foreign secretary and then by Cameron - and the deadline was in effect set by Washington.
I am told that President Biden wanted the deal done before the 5 November presidential election. Biden wanted certainty about the future of the US military base on the Chagossian island of Diego Garcia, just in case Donald Trump were to win the election.
For confirmation that the deal was clinched on a timetable and in a style to suit the US administration, see Bidenās statement that āit is a clear demonstration that through diplomacy and partnership, countries can overcome longstanding historical challenges to reach peaceful and mutually beneficial outcomesā.
Biden pointed out that the agreement between the UK and Mauritius meant the US had secured āthe effective operation of the joint [military] facility on Diego Garcia into the next century.ā
It is therefore curious Tugendhat should describe the transfer as āleaving our alliesā exposed when the UKās most important ally, America, has welcomed it.
And Cleverlyās denigration of Starmer as āweak, weak, weakā for formalising it seems eccentric when the negotiations with Mauritius were in full swing when he was in the cabinet.
As for Liz Trussās assertion that Boris Johnson is to blame, I am told that Johnson was the last PM to wholly oppose giving up sovereignty over Chagos, and that the talks did not start properly till she was PM.
If anyone in the Tory party wants to know the nitty gritty of all this, possibly they could ask for an introduction from the former minister Lord Frost - because his spouse Harriet Matthews has been the lead official negotiator for the foreign office on the Chagos treaty with Mauritius.
Brian Stanley retweeted
Imagine the amount of good that football could do with Ā£50m? For the same amount that it reportedly spent on lawyers last year the Premier League could fund 100 3G pitches, five in the vicinity of each of its 20 clubs. Imagine the impact on local residentsā physical and mental health, possibly even on talent ID?
Imagine what good football could do with £50m in making ticket prices more reasonable, especially for particular age-groups like 18-24s who generate much of the atmosphere (and TV rewards clubs handsomely for atmosphere). Fans, many struggling with rising prices during a cost-of-living crisis, would feel better about the Premier League and feel less a cash machine to be plundered at will by the elite. Imagine loyalty being rewarded. Imagine if even £5m was earmarked for subsidised away travel.
Imagine what £50m, which is paid out of the central PL pool, would do if invested judiciously throughout the football pyramid, especially in EFL academies which nurture those who go on to star for Premier League clubs like Raheem Sterling (QPR), Jadon Sancho (Watford) and John Stones (Barnsley).
The Premier League spent Ā£15m more on lawyers in 23/24 than its admirable Charitable Fund distributed the previous season to 90+ club community organisations from National League to Premier League. The Fundās a fantastic initiative, one of the biggest sporting charities in the world, and the Premier League is rightly proud of its impact, including supporting a workforce of 6,200 people ādedicated to improving the lives of people in their local areaā. Imagine how many more lives they could improve if legal disputes were handled more swiftly and without battalions of barristers. If only brief meant brief.
The Premier League could be spending the same amount on lawyers in an 18-month period as it has invested in the life-changing Kicks projects over the past 18 years. Kicks tackles crime levels and youth disenchantment. More than half a million kids across 4,900 venues have benefited to date. That helps the country more than pouring millions into legal disputes. That also helps the country by providing a platform, and free coaching sessions, for those who end up playing for their country like Sterling,Ā Marcus Rashford and Declan Rice.
The Premier League, of course, needs legal representation which doesnāt come cheap. Ditto the clubs. Increasingly some of the legal battles involve Magic Circle law-firms. Big club owners want big-name lawyers. The Premier League has to follow suit. The level of legal expertise is impressive, and some of the finest minds in the country are involved, but everyone seems to have forgotten that it should be a sport. That's not naivety. That's frustration that the game is being taken away from fans and communities.
English football has badly lost its way. It's worth all involved in the myriad disputes remembering that football should be about those striding out of the dressing-room, not those heading into the courtroom.
Heaven knows what the Manchester City case will cost in legal representation. On both sides. When the dust finally settles on this lengthy case, and ongoing expensive PSR disputes elsewhere, the Premier League and its constituent clubs have to agree some form of truce on legal battles, especially on time involved which inevitably adds to the lawyersā bill.
The 20 clubs and the executive are stronger together. All the in-fighting within the Premier League comes at a price, to unity, to the authority and credibility of the league and to funds which could be more constructively spent elsewhere. The Premier League is a magnificent sporting competition, and the community departments do transformative work, but bad blood between members, and some with the executive, damages it. Just stop it.
The astonishing amount spent on lawyers provides another reason why there is widespread support for a regulator to bring sanity to proceedings. And that will be led by a top legal mind, too. Lawyers are increasingly taking over English football when the game should be about players and supporters, and when £50m could do so much good for the game and the community. #EPL #EFL
Brian Stanley retweeted
Rachel Reeves is planning on repeating all the mistakes Gordon Brown made taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2024⦠I was told by many before the election, when I warned of the danger that Reeves represented, that I was being overly harsh and even unfair. In office, I was assured, she would show her true colours. Now I can report that she is doing that, and those colours are at least as bad, or even worse than I imagined they might be.
Brian Stanley retweeted
So it turns out Rishi Sunak originally refused to go to the D-Day commemorations *at all* and only agreed to go for part of it, in a "compromise" with the French.
reaction.life/d-day-tory-furā¦
Brian Stanley retweeted
This is importantā¦.
The Spectator has just ran the figures for the Tories' published tax plans.
On Sunak's maths, it works out as £3,000 tax rise per household.
Details: spectator.co.uk/article/on-sā¦
Brian Stanley retweeted
Summer Window Update 1# by SwedishRumble
I will provide my takes on the summer window activity in regular š§µ, and this is the first. It will be opinionated, speculative, wordy (can't help it), and include reviews on our financial position. Turn on the notification to not miss anything!
ā½ļø...'it's complicated'... [sic]
Analyzing MUFC's summer transfer window on 19 May 2024 is complicated, at the same time, it is not (!). Here is why.
We don't know who the manager will be, we don't know who will make the decisions, we don't know if we will play in Europe -- and so forth.
At the same time, the above is what it is and gives us allot of leads as to where we are in negotiations in relation to current and potential transfer targets, who we are looking at, which parameters we will consider when picking a manager for next season and so forth.
ā½ļøETH -- will he stay or will he go?
I think Jim Ratcliffe and Blanc knows, but have decided to keep their decision secret, including not informing ETH about it (they could very well have indicated where they are coming from to ETH though). There is too much uncertainty for it to be known by a wider circle, though.
There are pros and cons with this approach, yes it creates uncertainty. At the same time, if the decision is to not keep ETH, that can really negatively impact the squad, and if it is to keep him, the faith of the future of several players on the squad could be sealed, players we still could be dependent on.
A lot of ex-players made a U-turn after G.Nev's ETH interview. Have they been told something? I think they have, but not what people think, i.e. I doubt they have been told ETH will be kept. I think Neville and ETH had a talk before the interview, and that ETH simply gave GN his defense speech, with everything that couldn't be said in the interview. And that defense speech will have been long. But at this point, it is anybody's guess.
And there will have been issues going on behind the scene, that aren't known and possibly might not become known.
ā½ļøBut isn't this a disaster for our summer transfer window? Most work should have been done by know? What if a new manager is to come in and want different type of players?
Theoretically, it definitely could be a disaster. But we know this, (1) we are not a ship without a rodder and/or captain. Jean-Claude Blanc has been involved on the Ineos side from Day 1 and as a CEO now. (2) The fact that we are not forcing things, getting in Ashworth, making clear who the manager will be and so forth -- clearly indicates that Blanc and co knows things we don't, and are comfortable that it won't be a disaster.
So what could they know, that we don't? A few things:
(1) Even if ETH is not kept, "ETH type of players" are also RDZ players, Arteta type of players, Klopp type of players -- and so forth. Just a few examples of managers buying players first developed/acquired by ETH:
Mazraoui -- Tuchel at Bayern
DvB -- Ole at United
Frenkie De Jong -- Valverde (?) at Barca
De Ligt -- Sarri at Juventus
Ziyech -- Lampard at Chelsea
SergiƱo Dest -- Xavi at Barca
Lassina TraorƩ -- Robert De Zerbi at Shaktar
Andre Onana -- Simone Inzaghi at Inter
Sebastian Haller -- Edin TerziÄ at Dortmund
Gravenberch -- Klopp at Liverpool (via Nagelsman at Bayern)
Jurrien Timber -- Arteta at Arsenal
Edson Alvarez -- Moyes at WH
(2) One report that have come out is that we won't look at a manager playing with 3 at the back.
With a back 4, as long as we don't go for a Mourinho/Simeone type -- there isn't any major risk that we will be buying player TYPES under ETH that a new manager will have no use for.
ā½ļøBut we might miss out on targets now?
This is definitely a concern. But for the core positions; i.e. one (1) CB, one (1) LB and one (1) striker; it is perfectly possible that our position wouldn't be any different.
At CB, I wouldn't at all be surprised if we have Jean-Clare Todibo more or less locked up. He fits what we need really well. This would be one major signing locked down immediately.
For those who haven't seen much of JCT -- it is hard to not wonder why he still is at OGC Nice (even after first getting bought by Barca, and sold back to France where he recovered his career) at the age of 24. He is quality through and through. Strong, fast and very skilled. Hard nosed, focused, very consistent.
We could of course target others than Todibo. But why would we?
At LB, we will have a list including guys like Milos Kerkez, Luca Netz, Miguel Gutierrez and Melvin Bard as well as other promising young LBs, and we will of course keep track of a bit more experienced LBs like Ferland Mendy, Alphonso Davies, Robinson from Fulham and the likes.
But I wouldn't be surprised if we already have a younger target we really like there, perhaps being Milos Kerkez. This is probably the position a new manager could impact the most, but there will probably be multiple teams pushing for all of the younger LBs, most of these guys are really well rounded, can be molded.
Then at striker, the market is what it is. We, Chelsea and Arsenal are all after a striker. And so is Real and close to every other team in Europe.
This is the striker market -- if any club today decided that they want to have Sesko ink'ed within 7 days, it could surely be done, but it would cost a fortune and agent fees, wages, bonuses etc. If any club today decided that they wanted Ivan Toney signed within 7 days, Brentford would probably want 85m.
Arsenal and others will be courting Benjamin Sesko really hard. What type of deal is Sesko's agent looking for? The release clause is one thing, Haaland also had one, but still costs City 70m a year. Brentford must finance building it's squad with player sales, and haven't sold anyone in a while. I am sure that they don't want to lose Ivan Toney for free. But on the other hand, if two rich teams bids for him -- the price could be 75m. If there is only one team involved in the bidding and Brenford wants to sell early to finance new signings, the price could be 30-40m.
I think we need to sign a really strong and capable striker. But unless we really manage to bait someone like Sesko or really like a veteran striker that can be had cheap for a pure back-up position (like a Carlton Morris), it is going to a take a while, and some pieces must fall into place.
One player that shouldn't be forgotten is Randal Kolo Muani. Ramos has played as much as him for PSG, and RKM only has 9 goals for the season. And if PSG get Victor Oshimen, PSG got one striker too many. LāĆquipe reported a few days ago that Dortmund was targetting RKM, but only were willing to pay 50m EUR.
RKM is a player I am sure would be really helpful for us. More Darwin Nunez than Rasmus Hojlund so to speak.
I also wouldn't rule out that we could see a bit of a shocker when it comes to the striker position. First of all, I just don't see an issue with having two top strikers. Rasmus will probably be injured about 4 weeks in a season, could be a lot more if we are unlucky. It is the most subbed position. There are just enough games to go around. And to put it like this, I would be surprised if we didn't make signing this summer more in the mold of a statement signing. The competition will be so tough for a top 4 spot next season. All our rivals will spend big. This year, top 4 would have been obtainable. But the number of easy games are getting harder, and our rivals are getting better (while Liverpool is a bit of an uncertainty).
Victor Osimhen is a striker we have been after for a long time. From my POV, the £110m price tag doesn't scare me. But "400k" a week plus 500k for every goal he scores does. I don't think striker is the most important position for the best teams today. I rather pay through the nose for a CM or CB or wing. But Osimehn wins you a few games alone over a season.
šSo in summary, for the core positions where we have players leaving already or have a hole, i.e. 1 striker, 1 LB and 1 CB -- I think we are on track. 1/3 could basically already be in place in JCT. We can have done all the leg-work in relation to a LB, just waiting to launching the negotiations and the striker position is what it is and we probably have to be a bit patient there.
I don't think our work, priorities, execution and so forth would change massively if Ashworth was in place or we knew who the manager was going to be, in relation to the above.
ā½ļøOn the topic of It takes two to tango -- Who will be sold?
I think the process of selling players will be a grueling process, and that -- as a starting point -- expectations cannot be too low.
If it was down to me, I would besides Greenwood, Sancho and Casemiro sell at least one of Maguire/Lindelof, McTominay, AWB and I would sit down with Rashford to listen in on if he really wants to be here. But in reality -- it won't be easy to get deals done, it never is.
First out, I think many assumes that Casemiro is gone. But I would be very hesitant to offer all that high odds on Casemiro staying. Saudi could reportedly cut spending . Even if SPL will have a lot of money available, we don't know if any of the rich team wants to sign Casemiro. They have a cap on foreign players, and a lot of stars signed already. Then thirdly, even if the SPL clubs will spend big again, and even if they want Casemiro -- Casemiro must want to go there. Casemiro was a questionable signing given his price tag for sure, and he is expensive on a per year basis, no doubt. And he got two years left (reportedly, I wouldn't be surprised if it is 3+1). If we can get a good return for him, you must take it. But...
We have done what we can with Sancho and Greenwood. Now, its time to sit by the phone and wait. I am hopeful, but it is far from a given that we will get any meaningful money -- say more than 20-30m -- for either. Why? We will want to sell both. We are almost in a 'we have to take the highest bid' situation. Sancho and Greenwood themselves decides where they want to go. To get more than 30m for either, there probably must be a bidding war. Sancho is also on 300k a week, which is at least 5-10m per year over what other teams will be willing to give him.
Dejan Kulusevski has been really good for Tottenham this season. He is the same age as Greenwood and Sancho basically. Tottenham bought him for 20m last summer from Juve. We would be furious if we had Kulusevski and only got 20m for him. But he told Juventus that he either were returning or signing with Tottenham, Juve needed to raise money and had to take what Levy offered them. We are in a similar situation with Sancho and Greenwood. Let's say Atheltico Madrid wants Greenwood, and Mason tells us that he only is signing with them or returning to Manchester. What can we do if we get a 30m offer and AM won't offer a penny over it? Maybe we can get it up to 35. Never 45-50 (I think).
Will AWB be sold? I don't know. I think he is the most likely to go besides Greenwood and Sancho. Only 1 year left on his deal, but it depends on what the market will be and if we can get Jeremie Frimpong.
Because that is an upgrade, offensively, I would love to do. But remember, we won't be the only team gunning for Frimpong with that ā¬40m release clause. If not Frimpong, then who? Vanderson at Monaco? Dumfries? If we can get 30m for AWB and buy Frimpong for Ā£32m (ā¬40m), its a no brainer. But what if it is 15m for AWB and 50m for Dumfries?
And it is perhaps not super easy to find a taker for AWB. It is tricky with 1 year left on a deal. A big big payday could be awaiting AWB if he gets to free agency. If a team that AWB really wants to go to, are interested -- sure, count him gone. But back to Crystal is unlikely now with Glasner in charge, using wing backs. Inter? West Ham? Wolves? It is anybody's guess.
I fear that both Maguire and Lindelof will be here next season. We wanted to sell Maguire last summer, he was coming off a decent World Cup for England, and the best offer we could get was 30m if we were willing to pay 5m of Maguire's wages for 2 seasons. That was from Moyes. He is not the type of CBs teams are looking for. Who would buy him now?
Hopefully we can find a taker for Lindelof, but it is of course not a given.
McTominay? I would definitely sell him. I think he does more than score goals, he takes a lot of runs offensively that are good, and help the team that way by opening space for others. He is also great on defensive set pieces. But -- if he doesn't score a goal one game, he is not a sufficiently valuable player for us. When we have a healthy squad ready to compete -- he won't play much. His value is too high for a mid table club, to sit on the bench for us. But to sell him, I think we must force him out. And I doubt they are prepared to go there. And I have much more sympathy for us keeping an academy player than someone like Maguire or Lindelof who just haven't delivered and aren't home grown. McT could definitely be earning more if he was playing elsewhere. That count for something.
Antony? I wouldn't rule it out, that he is sold.
But can we even sell Antony given how much we paid for him? Isn't it a FFP nightmare? Nah, not quite. We have amortized 2/5 of his contract. App. 49m is still on the books. If we keep him, he cost us 16.4m in amortization charge in 24/25 and 10.4m in wages, so the total accounting cost is 26.8m. If we sell him for 20m, we make a loss of 49m (his book value) - 20m (the tranfer fee) = 29m on trading with players, but save 26.8m by not amortizing his contract nor paying his wage, so it is just basically a 2.2m loss to sell him for 20m.
ā½ļøBut I think the above is the reality in terms of outgoings, unless we are ruthless and let players know that they are getting sold, meaning that we also have to take the highest offer that we get for them, regardless how low it is. Are we willing to go there?
If not, it seems like we will have the same approach as previous years. We will "listen to offers". In parallell to which, we will try to keep potential replacement's warm. But unless and not before we get a player sold, will we sign the replacement.
This puts the business off until the later part of the window.
AWB/RB could be one exception. Antony/RW could be another exception. Casemiro/CDM can definitely also be an exception. I.e. where we either force a move, even a loan potentially (Antony), or are prepared to take whatever offered (AWB) or know that the player will agree to go to like the MLS in worst case, if he isn't 'wanted'.
ā½ļø But wait a minute, how about Olise? Isn't he a done deal?
When Fabrizio is announcing that we are negotiating with Olise, we basically seem to be now where we were with Mount last season.
But with that said, if we can't find a taker for Antony, be it on loan in Europe or the SPL, speaking for myself, I wouldn't get a RW after the emergence of Diallo. Does this mean MUFC wouldn't? Of course not, but by the sound of it, KMJ was basically a done deal this time last season. You never know.
I think we are signing Olise and I think it means that Antony is loaned out to Europe or sold to SPL. But it is by a narrow margin, I think that is probable.
ā½ļø Who are we getting, if others can be sold? Aren't we getting any midfielders?
In a way, Mainoo has replaced Eriksen, but CM is of course a massive hole in many ways even when Mount is back.
I think we are getting a CM, we need more depth. If Casemiro is sold, it's a given.
Again, I think Ineos will want one statement signing. The talks about Joao Neves have been persistent. Can we get him? If so, I think we will. But the question is if he won't go to City instead.
Isn't Rabiot "free"? Last time, Rabiot was "free" he wanted ā¬10m as a sign-on bonus and ā¬10m net per year in salary (app. 307k week) his annual cost would have been Ā£18.7m. The annual cost for 63m signing Lissandro Martinez is 18.8m.
FDJ? I would 100% sign him, doubt he will leave Barca though.
Ederson from Atalanta, Hjulmand from Sporting and the Brazilian from Wolves, João Gomes (my favorite of the 3) -- are strong options. But will we go out and get one early in the window? Remains to be seen.
Over and out!
#MUFC #transfers #summerwindow
Brian Stanley retweeted
There is one reason and one reason only why this case is not settled yet. When the PL launched the procedure for the 115 charges, City made sure that it got stuck in the courts for almost 3 years challenging every technical aspect it could to delay it.
A summary:
November-December 2018: The Premier League write to City requesting certain information and documents in relation to potential breaches of their rules ā known as the information claim. City object to the request ā after what has been published by Der Spiegel/the Football Leaks.
21 August 2019: The PL issue a complaint against City, since it has still not received the documents and information it has the right to receive under the Premier League Rules and which City refuse to give the PL access to. City responds by challenging the PL's disciplinary system, challenging a technicality (only highly regarded barristers could be elected for the commission).
22 October 2019: With the documents and information not forthcoming, the PL begin arbitration against the club seeking a declaration that they are contractually obliged to provide them. The club try to stop the arbitration by arguing to the tribunal involved that the PL had no power to start it. They also claim that the tribunal does not appear impartial.
26 June 2020: City issue an application in the Commercial Court repeating their argument that the tribunal lacks jurisdiction on the information claim and is tainted with ābiasā.
2 November 2020: Cityās claim that it has no obligation to to pass on the requested information and documents to the PL ā is rejected. Itās clearly stated in the rules that they must do so. The order to provide them is however postponed pending the outcome of the Commercial Court case.
17 March 2021: In the Commercial Court, Mrs Justice Moulder more or less summarily dismisses the club's challenge to the jurisdiction and impartiality of the tribunal, dismantling the Cityās lawyers arguments clearly hinting that it was felt that it had abused the public court system. She refuses permission to appeal her judgment.
24 March 2021: Mrs Justice Moulder said her judgment should be published, in order to reveal the lengths to which City had attempted to resist passing on information to the PL. City successfully seeked permission to appeal the decision to make the information public in the Court of Appeal. So we get another delay (I think you are starting to get the drift by now, itās an appeal of an appeal of an appeal about a pure nonsense technicality. On a side
30 June 2021: The Court of Appeal opens its hearing into the club's appeal against publication. The Court of Appeal handed down its decision dismissing the appeal.
So it took the PL almost three years to just have it sorted out that it has the right to receive the information the Premier League Rules clearly states that City must submit to the PL. After this, we know that City made another challenge of the impartiality of an experienced barrister in no way connected to the Premier League, in KC Murray Rosen. How much delay this caused is unknown.
During this time, City was also sentenced by UEFA for failing to produce requested information and delaying procedures.
I am sure we all come across City PR people, at twitter, during Cityās PCs, and so forth, telling us that the reason no decision have been made against City is because it is quote ācomplicatedā. Decide for yourself!
Brian Stanley retweeted
Darren Jones MP, Labour's shadow Chief Secretary to the Treasury, has just said on ITX that the government has "maxed out the government's credit card". The crass stupidity of doing so when the government has no credit card, no credit limit, and can always create the money required to pay its bills is really quite staggering.
Brian Stanley retweeted
There is no āotherā taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2024⦠It is my suggestion that we must both share our well-being with others whilst simultaneously celebrating the fact that they are not us precisely because that fact enhances the essential truth that we too (subject to inevitable constraints requiring that we do not abuse others) can be accepted despite all our own peculiarities and differences. There is no āotherā in that case. There is, instead, an acceptance that reflects our right to be who we are, and its existence is what frees us to live as we wish.

























