The best solution to me at this point in time seems relatively obvious. Put him up there in the booth side by side with Pettine. They could have them effectively call plays together and no one would be the wiser from an optics standpoint. Similar to how NY calls offense with both Roman and Nagy. Sucks to say it, but what CP needs most right now is training wheels on how to play call in the NFL throughout a game.
Jerry recalling with us on @1053thefan that Sean Payton had play-calling taken away and restored over the course of his career.
Just my read: Sounds like they're greasing the wheels for some sort of defensive play-calling change.
Interesting trend with CP’s defense since he announced changes to help Dallas start faster.
He changed the practice structure, meetings and walkthroughs, while emphasizing a different play style to jumpstart games.
The results: 1H points allowed dropped from 15.5 (weeks 6-7) to 9 points (weeks 8-10). But 2H points allowed skyrocketed from 6.5 to 24.
The changes appear to have addressed the slow starts, but the defense is now struggling to sustain that level of play. Are opposing offenses adjusting at halftime, or is execution breaking down as games wear on?
Either way, fixing the first 30 minutes means little if you can’t finish the last 30.
The Cowboys have given up touchdowns on the first drive of their last four games and in five of seven games overall. Coordinator Christian Parker on what needs to change:
“I was actually studying that last night, the cut up for the first drive of each game and the first drive of the second half of each game. I think there's a couple different ways to look at it. I changed some things this week with how we practiced, how we met, how we walked through to try to jumpstart that process, going to try something different with our mock walkthrough on Saturday, just to make sure that we have that on the forefront of our mind, just with the execution and awareness to get those things done. And also with me just jumpstarting the group, if you will, with certain play style and how we're going to start the game.”
Do they fire him this week? I don’t think so, that seems like something they’d do during the bye if it continues to look this way. This week I would however expect him to be side by side with Pettine in the booth. Probably calling the plays together, like how Nagy and Roman do in NY. If he’s stubborn with being on the sidelines, then maybe they do fire him this week but I believe they try to get him going with training wheels the rest of the way
When asked about his confidence in Christian Parker; Brian Schottenheimer said he is "taking a deep dive, and looking at everything." Is this the beginning of the end for Parker's time with the Cowboys?
Is Christian Parker On The Way Out?
When asked about his confidence in Christian Parker; Brian Schottenheimer said he is "taking a deep dive, and looking at everything." Is this the beginning of the end for Parker?
Just a thought, but I’d like to see CP sprinkle in more situational 4-3 fronts.
The current 3-4 packages have done a better job stopping downhill/power runs, but outside zone and B-gap runs have been a weakness. Against a 5-down front, offenses can exploit the numbers on perimeter runs and effectively take two backside defenders out of the play.
A 4-3 can give your LBs better angles to scrape, flow laterally and funnel those runs back inside. With Barham’s versatility alongside Marist, you can even stem between 4-3 and 3-4 looks pre-snap to keep offenses guessing.
James, Winters, Overshown and Barham are all playing at a similar level right now. More 4-3 looks could help get all four involved while putting them in positions to succeed.
I’m not saying it needs to become the defense’s identity. But when an elite play-caller like Shanahan spends an entire second half spamming outside runs to exploit your base structure, having that package as an adjustment in your plan is critical.
Regardless of how this season ends, I think Jerry and the Jones family may have learned a lesson about hiring inexperienced coaches.
If you’re a middle-of-the-pack team, you can afford to let young coaches grow with the roster, learn from mistakes, and build toward future contention.
But when you declare an “all-in” window, going into the season with a HC in year 2, a OC in year 2 who’s never called plays, and a first-time DC is a recipe for disaster.
I think they keep Shotty, but the smart move is surrounding him with proven play-callers. Bring in an experienced OC like Kingsbury or Gruden and a DC with a track record of calling plays, like McDermott or Quinn.
If you’re going all-in on the roster, you can’t afford to have inexperience cost you at the coaching level.
Dan Quinn had Jayron Kearse and Donovan Wilson playing ridiculous as his secondary chess pieces and we’re 10 weeks into the season and still can’t find out how to utilize Caleb Down’s strengths…. 😔
I think this speaks to the formula for building a true contender in today’s NFL. Having elite talent on both sides of the ball just isn’t feasible or sustainable.
You can still have a highly productive unit with an average play caller when you have the talent to support it. But on the side of the ball where you’re lacking talent, you NEED an elite coordinator who can maximize what he has and consistently do more with less.
If you look at the best teams in the league the weaker side of the ball talent wise is often led by an elite tier coordinator. That’s how you compensate for roster deficiencies and build a team that can win consistently. The issue with the cowboys is CP is not in that class….
I’ll never understand why we’re still running Cover 0 by blitzing BOTH LBs from depth. Even if they get a free lane, they have 10 yards to cover before reaching the QB.
Let Von rush off the edge, send ONE LB, and keep the other in position to cover CMC from depth.
Game on the line and we’re getting cute with “disguises” when everyone in the building knows SF is trying to milk the clock. Make it make sense.
DeMarvion Overshown played just 5 defensive snaps today…. With the way the cowboys struggled tackling in space and defending sideline to sideline I’m having a real hard time trying to understand why he wasn’t on the field more…..
And this is the biggest issue with the scheme. The way they match formation/personnel allows for offenses to come up with ways to dictate and exploit matchups. The more tape that gets shown, the more you see other teams find players to attack who are already in a bad spot with the scheme. They thought they went out and hired one of the brightest defensive coordinators in the league who just so happened to be from a scheme that the NFL has fully figured out this year.
The cowboys may have played the most man today they have all year, and it def looked a little better at times. But I wonder what the blitz rate numbers will look like. Because if you’re just playing man and blitzing 4 it would explain why they lack the numbers to finish some of these off schedule plays by Purdy.
5
681
Didn’t see Overshown on the field at all on that first defensive drive, despite being out there on the kickoff team…. Possible consequences of that penalty from last week?
1
1
408
Despite only getting three on the opening drive I liked the mindset from the cowboys offensively. Forced the 49ers to cover every blade of grass on that possession. And I’d imagine if they keep the approach for 4 quarters the refs are going to have to call PI at some point….
4
289







