Chris Graziul retweeted
My colleague and friend Dr. Rizk Abu Shaaira was killed yesterday at work when Israel, backed by the US as always, bombed the surgical recovery room at Nasser Medical Complex. Two of his colleagues were badly injured, and many patients were hurt and killed. Dr. Rizk is featured on the original poster for the documentary American Doctor, standing to my right as we did a redo laparotomy on a disaster abdomen.
Dr. Rizk was one of those surgeons we describe as "super enthusiastic". On rounds he would jump at the opportunity to change a dressing, clean a wound, or pull a drain. He always had an answer to any question anyone asked. He embodied the surgical wisdom that "a chance to cut is a chance to cure."
Dr. Rizk's shocking murder is yet another reminder of why we must get control of our country. Our government has no right to force us to subsidize the mass murder of doctors and children, not in Palestine and not anywhere.
Chris Graziul retweeted
I hope he’s waking up in some other area of the universe, his entire life here a dream injected by an alien probe
Chris Graziul retweeted
AI doomers have little to no understanding how other engineering disciplines operate, and how both safety and security engineering have invested in system (including operator) resilience for years. The mass hysteria on this platform is unbelievable.
Chris Graziul retweeted
Announcing Project Protostar, the next initiative from the our open science efforts at @huggingface.
huggingface.co/project-proto…
Chris Graziul retweeted
We are hiring for many positions in EECS at Berkeley - join us!!
Importantly, this includes a search in AI, Inequality, and Society - more details here - aprecruit.berkeley.edu/JPF05…!
We 'll be hiring very actively at Berkeley!
Assistant/ Associate/ Full Professor – Electrical Engineering & Computer Sciences (Deadline: Dec. 7, 2026 at 11:59 pm Pacific Time). Apply here: aprecruit.berkeley.edu/JPF05…
Assistant Professor – AI for Biology – Electrical Engineering & Computer Sciences and Center for Computational Biology (Deadline: Nov. 9, 2026 at 11:59 pm Pacific Time) Apply here: aprecruit.berkeley.edu/JPF05…
Assistant Professor – Intersection of Statistics and CS – Departments of Electrical Engineering & Computer Sciences and Statistics (Deadline: Nov. 10, 2026 at 11:59 pm Pacific Time). Apply here: aprecruit.berkeley.edu/JPF05…
Assistant/ Associate/ Full Professor – Computational Biomedicine - Center for Computational Biology (Deadline: Nov. 18 2026 at 11:59 pm Pacific Time). Apply here: aprecruit.berkeley.edu/JPF05…
Assistant / Associate Professor – Electronic, Functional, and Quantum Materials – Electrical Engineering & Computer Sciences and Materials Science & Engineering (Deadline: Dec. 7, 2026 at 11:59 pm Pacific Time). Apply here: aprecruit.berkeley.edu/JPF05…
Coming Soon! Assistant/ Associate/ Full Professor - AI and the Physical Sciences -Bakar Institute of Digital Materials for the Planet (BIDMaP) and home department(s) to be determined. (Deadline: Dec. 7, 2026 at 11:59 pm Pacific Time) Apply here: aprecruit.berkeley.edu/JPF05…
Coming Soon! Assistant/ Associate/ Full Professor-in-Residence - Gladstone Institute of Data Science and Biotechnology and home department(s) to be (Deadline: TBD at 11:59 pm Pacific Time) Apply here: aprecruit.berkeley.edu/JPF05…
Chris Graziul retweeted
“normal technology” isn’t a metaphor; it’s default-state statement.
in anthropology, there is a saying (via Eric Wolf) that ‘there are no people without history’. this emerged in direct opposition to claims that certain (‘civilized’) people have History, and everyone else exists in a state of ahistorical, permanent primitivity. which is, of course, false, but served a very specific political and economic purpose.
‘AI is normal technology’ follows in a similar milieu. there were a set of people within the industry who attempted to claim their fancy new technology exists outside history, and therefore could not be subject to historical analysis, contextualization, or critique. this was a political statement first-and-foremost, and an attempt by a group to seize power by asserting their claims were above scrutiny. “normal technology” is a direct rebuke of this claim, grounding the new innovation in a long history of technological revolutions that were also radically transformative. to be a “normal technology” is to exist within the history of technology and be subject to known patterns of human behaviour around new technology. it is normative. it is also directly challenging to a common rhetorical strategy of the AI hype community, where they claim extraordinary outcomes are normative (or the ‘null hypothesis’), and normative claims are the extraordinary claims that must be proven with great difficulty.
Chris Graziul retweeted
This highlights a much higher level issue: When we anthropomorphise systems, we assume they have a human-like ability to understand our intent, and a predictability similar to what we've experienced from people. We overtrust, aligned with our human expectations. This is part of why all the subtle (and not so subtle) anthropomorphisational language about AI agents can be so toxic: It literally makes us more likely to catalyze AI security failures. /end
Use of polysemic language to refer to both technical and non-technical concepts destroys the meaning of both. It seems to happen again and again in AI research and it creates needless suspicion around perfectly fine ideas.
Replying to @TaliaRinger
I think this has the effect of people saying "we are close to RSI" referring to the concrete work which actually seems pretty neat, and then misusing that association to raise alarms about the theoretical/sci-fi fears
Chris Graziul retweeted
I think this has the effect of people saying "we are close to RSI" referring to the concrete work which actually seems pretty neat, and then misusing that association to raise alarms about the theoretical/sci-fi fears
Chris Graziul retweeted
Just watched the @netflix Instadocs about the @OpenAI cyberattack on @huggingface. Super disappointing, as they went for maximum anthropomorphism of the technology and full doomer mode.
I spent more than two hours with them trying to correct all their mistakes and ground this in reality, explaining that agents are technological systems, not aliens. But it looks like the drive to scare people for maximum views was too strong.
Also, they didn’t mention the lack of containment and monitoring of the agents, how closed-model safeguards blocked our defensive work, or how we defended ourselves with AI using an open model. And that we still lack a lot of information and transparency, including full agent traces and that companies need to remain accountable for what their agents do.
It ends up being a fun sci-fi movie though!
Chris Graziul retweeted
Students from North Carolina A&T can be seen marching back to their HBCU after voting on the first day of early voting in the state.
The Guilford County Board of Elections voted to remove the school’s on-campus polling site. (video via @tmsimmons) greensboro.com/news/local/go…
Ok, about 2,000 words on this and it's holding up decently enough. If I can finish it then get it closer to my 1,500 word goal then maybe I have something...
New hypothesis: Big Tech consists of unintentional communities that became religious via the company town mentality.
Separate workers, provide for their needs, and the isolation creates de facto religious communes.
2
57
So here's an impossible problem we should probably talk about for safety purposes:
There are lots of LLM-based tools integrated into government systems that were never audited.
Now they need auditing, but who is going to advertise they have unaudited LLM-based systems in use?
1
2
51
Yes, and movements from mid 19th to early 20th century formed around utopian values realizable through intentional communities.
This is when you see things like the Oneida Community (yes, now a silverware manufacturer) practicing eugenics before Galton had even coined the term.
listen i’m as critical of the atlantic as they come, but @ibogost’s piece is not wrong
end times and millenarian cults are two sides of the same coin that perennially emerge during any time of (real or prospective) social transformation, and are additionally a fundamental part of american culture — including (if not especially) american tech culture, from y2k to grey goo to social media to AI, since the sector’s very foundation is the radical transformation of society (and itself) through innovation
the extensive anthropological literature on these ‘great transformation’ movements ubiquitously captures a certain ‘joy of dread’ of people who adhere to these beliefs, not least because it imbues one’s life with a sense of meaning and historical centrality (a literature *especially* relevant if you want to understand Safety as a social movement)
“YOU are SPECIAL, part of a WORLD HISTORIC IN-GROUP, with UNIQUE POWER AND KNOWLEDGE that will CHANGE THE WORLD. YOU MATTER.” — it’s a very seductive narrative. and it is foundational to how many in the community see themselves and affirm their identities.
2
1
91
Chris Graziul retweeted
Side note. The idea that current models are conscious is absurd and downright offensive. Do not confuse competent information processing and sentience, they are wholly unrelated.
You can be entirely incompetent at everything yet fully conscious, like a toddler, or extraordinarily competent in one or more domains with absolutely zero consciousness, like a calculator, a chess engine, a self-driving car, or an AI chatbot.
Possessing the "circuits" for competent information processing in a given domain, whether through training or hardcoding, does not produce qualia, subjective experience, emotions, or suffering. Calculators do not "feel" arithmetic and they don't get tired or annoyed when you give them larger numbers to process. To argue otherwise is ontologically absurd. Current AI models are effectively calculators scaled to a very large number of competence circuits across many domains, etched via gradient descent.
Have not kept up with the lit, either, but my working hypothesis:
Atomized social relations destroy the solidarity necessary. Work culture in tech is designed to atomize, and stigma exists around unions being a blue collar status indicator. High income masks real vulnerability.
Replying to @hecubian_devil
I’m not sure about this. Didnt work that well in 2020-2022 for workers at previous tech incumbents, and only a few people in the companies are actually irreplaceable. I don’t know the literature, but this doesn’t seem like an industry where unionisation is going to be the solution. Happy to see counter arguments though
1
50
























