The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet) header
The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet) profile picture

Seaside Community Newspaper and Aggregator of Western Cape news.

Cape Town
Joined April 2015
Photo by The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet)Photo by The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet)Photo by The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet)Photo by The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet)Photo by The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet)Photo by The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet)Photo by The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet)Photo by The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet)Photo by The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet)Photo by The Cape Navigator (@CPTzaNet)
The Cape Navigator retweeted
Only white persons are excluded. Everyone else is privileged.
There are no race laws in South Africa.
16
109
1
396
6,145
The Cape Navigator retweeted
I come back to this thread often, it eviscerates the 'history' curriculum of South Africa.
The 1976 Soweto student uprising is mythologized as an early noble skirmish in the fight against Apartheid. But the commencing act of violence was a student stabbing a female teacher with a screwdriver because he didn't want to learn Afrikaans.
16
94
3
376
15,000
The Cape Navigator retweeted
There are no race laws in South Africa.
86
337
27
1,141
40,490
The Cape Navigator retweeted
Mzanele Manyi (@MzwaneleManyi) and I had an hour-long, very lively debate yesterday about his push to remove section 235 (the self-determination clause) from the South African Constitution. - I accused him of not understanding international law. - He called me a racist for thinking self-determination is a good thing. - I asked him why he's so obsessed with attacking Afrikaners. - He asked me why I'm so obsessed with being / remaining an Afrikaner. - I pointed out that giving more power to the state (evidently his primary objective) makes things worse. - He responded to my concerns about the failure of the state by discussing coal capacity and wind power, but denied that he was changing the topic, because those are policy issues. - I confronted him about his obsession with race laws. - He passionately denied that there are race laws in South Africa, and then immediately defended the continued existence of race laws in South Africa. - I pointed out that these laws (which he defends as passionately as he denies) are objectively destructive. - He said that those laws are good, because the intentions are good. - I said that you cannot judge a law by its intentions, but by the outcome. - He accused me of wanting to bring apartheid back because I oppose race laws (😂) - I pointed out that he was unknowingly quoting Hendrik Verwoerd. - He said that if that's true, then perhaps Verwoerd was right. - I said that his attack on section 235 will create a Streisand effect, strengthening the case for self-determination, as opposed to weakening it. - He accused me of wanting to promote enclaves. - He said that I'm filled with hatred. - He encouraged me to lie awake at night and contemplate my racism. - I accused him of speaking like a man who lost an argument. My honest conclusions: 1. Mr Manyi has very strong opinions about why self-determination particularly for Afrikaners is bad, but he evidently doesn't know what it means. 2. He didn't show any comprehension of the fact that there are different forms of self-determination - internal vs external, territorial vs functional etc. He creates the impression that he thinks self-determination is simply a synonym for secession. 3. I got the impression that he doesn't understand that there is a difference between "states" (Afrikaans: state) and "peoples" (Afrikaans: volke). When international law recognises self-determination for peoples, he reads that as self-determination for states. 4. He doesn't understand the difference between self-determination and cultural participation. He argues that having the right to participate in your culture renders the right to self-determination redundant. 5. He doesn't understand the difference between individual and collective rights. I explained to him that the individual right to participate in your culture becomes moot when your cultural institutions are destroyed, and that individual rights alone do not cover the rights of communities for the continued existence of their institutions. That's why self-determination is important. From his response, I got the impression that he had no idea what I was talking about. 6. I asked if he thinks that his party leader, Jacob Zuma was wrong to agree that Section 235 had to be included in the South African Constitution, in response to which he was particularly vague. I'm sure that he would have dramatically different conclusions from the discussion and I'd be keen to read it. But when all is said and done, we'll leave it to the viewers to decide for themselves. We will publish the discussion on my YouTube channel on Thursday.
138
200
14
860
41,404
The Cape Navigator retweeted
“Hoërskool Erasmus Learner Switches to Homeschooling After Years of Alleged Bullying BRONKHORSTSPRUIT - A 16-year-old learner from Hoërskool Erasmus has withdrawn from the school and turned to homeschooling after alleging she was bullied and assaulted multiple times since 2024.”
172
223
42
579
81,952
The Cape Navigator retweeted
The office of the Public Protector (PP) has warned against "insults" directed at the institution, saying individuals who do so could be fined up to R40,000 or face imprisonment for up to 12 months. brnw.ch/21x2p6z
2,155
618
528
1,864
402,704
The Cape Navigator retweeted
A Cape Town woman’s formal complaint about treatment at Victoria Hospital’s emergency department has drawn attention after she shared the account of her partner’s final hours before his death: capetownetc.com/featured/wom…
1
2
653
The Cape Navigator retweeted
Western Cape - #Flooding
Meiringspoort: unlikely to reopen this evening - NOTE: Swartberg pass is also closed
37
354
22
866
148,561
The Cape Navigator retweeted
Cape Town’s water situation has never been worse. No maintenance no new infrastructure no plan B for drought, just more sewage pumped into the sea.
LIVE | The strategy for JHB is to get the basics working, starting with water and electricity - Zille brnw.ch/21x0Upz
32
432
2
988
21,953
The Cape Navigator retweeted
This is in Cape Town, how for the love of me has this been allowed??? The @Our_DA and @geordinhl are definitely destroying CT.. kids with fake guns during a Palestine March yesterday!! Shame!! 😳
109
174
23
428
13,723
We are hiring!!! Apply now and be part of our dynamic team, Click the link for more information erajobs.state.gov/dos-era/va…
2
3
186
We are hiring!!! Apply now and be part of our dynamic team, Click the link for more information erajobs.state.gov/dos-era/va…
1
2
112
The Cape Navigator retweeted
Interesting flight pattern above Cape Town
50
92
20
666
103,475
The Cape Navigator retweeted
If the residents of Cape Town were only responsible for funding themselves, their taxes would be 96% lower. Yes, 96% lower... making them the most affordable place to live in the country. But alas... we choose socialism ...
Supporters for the @Our_DA melting on X over my posts. This blind loyalty truly is something to behold. We send more than R230B to the central government, which they distribute to prop up ANC patronage in other provinces. We get back R5B of that money to run our own affairs. @geordinhl has explained that Cape Town faces a R4.2bn shortfall if new fixed tariffs are overturned. Does the issue of R1.6B in tender fraud, in a province where we are made to pay more taxes due to a supposed shortfall, make any sense? There's clearly money to steal and if not to steal, then simply hand over to the ANC. Why not claw that money back. If we're raking in R230B, why should we only get back R5B if there's a R4 shortfall? Cape Town doesn't have a revenue problem. We have an oversight problem.
19
36
4
139
7,028
The Cape Navigator retweeted
Durban vs Cape Town with Anton Taylor
1
2
479
The Cape Navigator retweeted
Dismissal of Deputy Minister Whitfield Offers Legal and Political Options The dismissal of Deputy Minister of Trade, Industry, and Competition, Andrew Whitfield, by President Cyril Ramaphosa has once again raised questions about the president’s constitutional prerogative to appoint or dismiss cabinet members and deputy ministers. In 2017, then-President Jacob Zuma removed Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan and his deputy, Mcebisi Jonas, from their posts. The Democratic Alliance (DA) took the matter to the High Court for judicial review. Rule 53 of the court rules allows a party requesting judicial review to access the record of decision-making to evaluate the decision. Zuma’s legal team refused to provide the record and also declined to disclose an alleged intelligence report that underpinned Zuma’s decision. The DA launched an interlocutory application to compel the state to release the decision-making record. Judge Vally, in the Gauteng High Court, Pretoria, ruled in favor of the DA, determining that Rule 53 could apply to executive decisions such as cabinet reshuffles. He accepted the argument that disclosing the decision-making record is necessary to ensure transparency and accountability in executive actions. Zuma was ordered to provide the record, prompting him to appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeal. The appeal ruling was a victory for the DA, but unfortunately, the appeal court did not address the merits of Judge Vally’s decision, dismissing the appeal solely on the grounds that the matter had become moot. This was due to three reasons: First, Zuma had resigned from the presidency; second, President Ramaphosa had conducted a new cabinet reshuffle; and third, the DA had withdrawn its original review application. Nevertheless, it is significant that the appeal ruling did not overturn Judge Vally’s finding that Rule 53 can apply to executive decisions. Since the appeal court did not address the merits of Vally’s ruling, his decision technically remains unchallenged and thus binding law. No subsequent ruling has explicitly confirmed or expanded on Vally’s finding, creating some legal uncertainty. The appeal ruling referenced other cases where Rule 53 was applied in similar contexts, indicating that Vally’s approach was not entirely without precedent. However, the court emphasized that the Rules Board of the High Courts is the appropriate body to define the scope of Rule 53, suggesting that future amendments to the rule may be necessary to clarify this issue. In the context of Andrew Whitfield’s dismissal, it is possible that Vally’s ruling could apply, particularly if the DA or another party launches a review application and demands the disclosure of the president’s decision-making record. The dismissals of Whitfield in 2025 and Gordhan and Jonas in 2017 share certain similarities. All the individuals involved were prominent figures in their respective portfolios, and their removals sparked political controversy. In both cases, the DA was a key player, criticizing the president’s actions and considering possible legal steps. The constitutional authority or prerogative of the president to dismiss cabinet members is central to both cases, though the political contexts differ. The 2017 events were part of a broader political struggle within the ANC, while Whitfield’s dismissal is more related to tensions within the Government of National Unity (GNU). A key difference lies in public perception and the nature of the allegations. In 2017, there was widespread concern about the alleged “intelligence report” and possible improper motives behind Zuma’s decision. In Whitfield’s case, the reasons are less clear. The president claims that Whitfield committed insubordination by not seeking approval for an overseas trip. Whitfield contends that he requested permission but received no response. Furthermore, in 2017, the DA quickly responded with a review application, whereas, in 2025, it has not yet taken formal steps. The DA is in a delicate position: President Ramaphosa and the ANC are clearly frustrated with the DA’s presence in the government. They would likely prefer to govern without the DA’s support. At the moment, the actions of the two largest parties in the GNU resemble a couple aware that their marriage is on the rocks, but each waiting for the other to initiate the divorce. The recent celebration of the GNU’s first anniversary was a lackluster event. Policy-wise, South Africa has continued on the policy path carved out by the ANC over the past 31 years, entrenched through draconian legislation, regulations, and relentless cadre deployment. It is unlikely that the DA will risk a review application at this stage, but in the coming weeks, when parliament votes on individual ministerial budgets, some portfolios’ budgets may face challenges. Budgets of ministers suspected of corruption but tolerated and protected by Ramaphosa could be particularly vulnerable. So, we can prepare the popcorn for intriguing developments in this new, exciting era of coalition politics. *Column written by Willie Spies for Nuusweek, 4 July 2025*
2
19
2
74
1,867
Top academics at Unisa, including vice-chancellor Puleng LenkaBula, splashed out more than R500,000 of the university’s money on an ANC anniversary jamboree held in Cape Town in January. timeslive.co.za/sunday-times…
41
160
13
304
11,099
Welcome to the United States Minister #Steenhuisen. May you have all the success you deserve when you meet President #Trump. Memories like an elephant...
225
459
46
1,828
47,141
The Cape Navigator retweeted
Dear @AmericanExpress and @EuropAssist_SA, please respond to Mr @DawieScholtz, no one should have to struggle with something so elementary after enduring such a horrific ordeal. Reference: File number: E25M0124150 Claim number: E25T1085596 He has also sent emails on 3 May, 6 May, 7 May, 8 May, 12 May or 15 May.
1/ Unbelievably horrible thread. Sorry to everyone to take this public, I hate to put personal stuff on here, but this is an absolute last resort. Five weeks ago, my sister was in a terrible car crash. She was severely injured, her husband unfortunately died on impact.
5
70
3
173
8,686