A liberal anti-Zionist Jew is only anti-Zionist so long as that anti-Zionism remains symbolic, rhetorical, and ultimately harmless to the continued existence of Israel. The minute they realize you’re 100% serious about dismantling that order, reversing Palestinian dispossession, and refusing to accept a century of colonization as an irreversible fact that Palestinians simply have to make peace with, they tap out. My great-grandfather fought against Allenby. His younger brother participated in the 1936 rebellion. My grandfather fought in 1948. My uncles fought against Israel and died during the Second Intifada. Generation after generation of my family did not sacrifice, fight, bleed, and die so that I could arrive at this moment and start bargaining away Palestinian rights because somebody who discovered anti-Zionism yesterday suddenly gets nervous about where its logic actually leads. The trolley of liberation is moving. So let the liberal “anti-Zionist Jewish ally” who tied himself to the tracks because he thought his own comfort would determine how far it was permitted to go understand one thing: we were never asking his permission in the first place, and when we spot him on the horizon, the only change he’ll notice is that the trolley is moving faster.