Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball) header
Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball) profile picture

Law Graduate @Villanova_Law | Former Baseball Strategy & Pro Scouting in MLB Front Office | 2025 TIBAC Champion | [email protected] | Opinions My Own

Joined September 2014
Photo by Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball)Photo by Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball)Photo by Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball)Photo by Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball)Photo by Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball)Photo by Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball)Photo by Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball)Photo by Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball)Photo by Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball)Photo by Zach Cioffi (@CioffiBaseball)
Had an amazing time on MLB Network’s Hot Stove this morning with my law school classmates after winning the 18th Annual Tulane International Baseball Arbitration Competition this past weekend. Huge thanks to @Feinsand for organizing! mlb.com/video/tulane-interna…
4
35
2,577
Axiel Plaz is a very interesting decision. Has not played above High-A, there may not even be a Rule 5 Draft this season, and players on the 40-man cannot play in the minors during a lockout… That being said, Catchers have managed to stick on rosters at a high rate (Susac, Hicks, etc.)
Pirates Select Mitch Jebb, Axiel Paz mlbtraderumors.com/2026/11/p…
There's a new version of this post
124
Teams have until 6:00 PM EST to protect players from the Rule 5 Draft. Here is how I would approach today's deadline from the shoes of each organization:
1
1
7
4,668
Toronto Blue Jays — Rule 5 / 40-Man Roster Analysis Current 40-man Roster: 37 Rule 5 Additions (2): Gage Stanifer, Josh Stephan Corresponding Moves: None required. Notable Rule 5 Omissions: Chay Yeager, lack of upper-minors experience makes him unlikely to stick on an MLB roster. Rule 5 Analysis: With three open roster spots entering the deadline, Toronto can protect Stanifer and Stephan without needing any corresponding moves. Roster Outlook: The Blue Jays move to 39/40, leaving one open spot. They may need to trade from the bottom of their 40-man roster or be more selective with future additions to preserve room for potential free-agent signings.
2
532
Reposting my Jeffers QO thoughts from earlier this week on why accepting the QO was the correct move by Boras Corp. and Jeffers:
I disagree with this decision by Jeffers. Not a ton of demand out there for a full-time Catcher The teams that pop out with a need at Catcher are: 1. Small-market teams (ex: CIN, MIA) who won’t give up a pick + commit multiple years to a below-average defensive Catcher 2. Low payroll flexibility (ex: TEX) I don’t see teams like NYY or BAL spending big to platoon/part-time at C or DH MIN is only team that makes sense in my mind (due to no QO penalty), but with a loaded Catching prospect group (Lackey, Tait, Diaw, etc.) there’s no reason for them to offer more than 2 years and they should have a ton of negotiation leverage I would’ve recommended Jeffers accepting the QO and then joining a loaded FA class next year (Adley, Contreras) where there will be much more demand and no QO attached I ultimately expect him to return to Minnesota on a 2+1 (Club) at an AAV below his QO value
1
336
San Francisco Giants — Rule 5 / 40-Man Roster Analysis Current 40-man Roster: 39 Rule 5 Additions (2): Joe Whitman, Henry Lalane Corresponding Moves: One roster spot needs to be cleared. I would DFA Trevor McDonald. Notable Rule 5 Omissions: Reggie Crawford, contact-skill issues make him unlikely to stick on an MLB roster. Rule 5 Analysis: Although Lalane has not pitched above High-A, his injury history makes him an interesting Rule 5 candidate. An oft-injured player can be easier for another organization to stash on the injured list, reducing the practical burden of carrying him under the Rule 5 restrictions. The Giants’ weak farm system cannot afford to risk losing Lalane that way. Roster Outlook: Protecting Whitman and Lalane would take San Francisco from 39 to 41 players. DFA’ing McDonald would return the club to 40/40, with no open spots remaining for additional acquisitions.
255