I'm Dan. LA-based futures trader, founder of Stacked Edge, building Blackwell Capital.
What you'll get here:
- Prop-firm rules, broken down plainly
- Risk, sizing and execution: the stuff that decides whether an account survives
- Honest questions traders actually argue about
Follow if you trade futures or funded accounts.
1
1
134
Made big money shorting today? Check your consistency rule before you request anything.
NQ went from ~28,279 to ~27,235 since Sunday night. Days like that create one huge green day, and that's exactly what a consistency rule is built to catch.
The math with a 30% rule:
$3,000 best day → you need $10,000 total profit before payout.
With a 40% rule → $7,500.
The big day doesn't get you paid faster. It raises the bar for every day after it.
Save this before the next trend day.
Do you keep trading normal size to dilute it, or slow down and grind small green days? Can we have a discussion?
16
Fewer than 1,000 traders affected, and they still announced it publicly before anyone found out at payout time.
That should be the bar for every prop firm. Which firm surprised you at payout instead?
This week, we’ll be restricting access in a handful of countries. This will impact less than 1,000 current Topstep Traders but we want to be transparent with you all about why.
Protecting the integrity of our program and the security of our community is our responsibility. Lately we’ve seen a rise in coordinated activity from certain regions, including attempts to bypass ID verification and payment safeguards, and coordinated trading across accounts.
We’ve been shutting down the accounts involved, but the activity keeps returning through new profiles and new tactics. Topstep exists to help traders grow and prepare for live markets, and we’ve avoided country-level restrictions wherever possible.
Given the recent surge in fraud rings, we’re taking a harder step. Watch our socials for more details about which countries will be impacted and next steps.
42
My AI discretionary trading bot took one trade on NQ today (Mon Nov 16). It lost, and the day finished at -$365.50.
Quick context: the old challenge experiment is over, but the learning continues. The bot still makes its own calls and takes real paper trades every day. There's no profit target and no loss number it has to hit. I'm just tracking how it does over time, in P&L and in wins and losses.
What the market did (times PT):
• The 6:30 open flushed through the overnight low (~27,612), swept down to 27,485, then ripped back up to 27,717. It whipsawed around VWAP with the 5m ATR near 2x normal.
• By 8:00 it had printed a 27,338.25 low. It bounced, then ground lower for most of the day. The RTH low broke at 10:30, and at 12:55 price was around 27,276, about -2.7% on the day. ES and RTY were also down, and VIX was up ~24%.
The trade:
• Short 2 MNQ @ 27,520 at 8:16 (the limit was 27,515, filled 5 pts worse). The bot's reasons: a failed bounce under the London low, a lower high, and a 5m close back below VWAP, with Daily/4H/1H all pointing down. It graded the setup B+. Stop 27,603, targets 27,383 / 27,340.
• Exit: stopped at 27,603 around 8:22. A fast rip took back VWAP and flipped the 1m gaps against the short. The bot's re-grade rule said to take half off, but the stop hit first.
• Then a bug in how my bot handles orders: its "take half off" buy went in after the position had already closed, so it opened a 1-lot long @ 27,606.75 by mistake. That was flattened by ~8:25 for about -$33.50.
• Result: -$365.50 in total, -1.10R.
Besides that trade, the bot set five resting short limits during the session (27,520, 27,450, 27,485, 27,340, 27,336). None of them filled. The 7:31 one missed by 1.25 pts, and the rest were pulled under their cancel rules. It read the direction right but never got filled on the pullbacks.
Running total since Sep 28 (one combined record; some early trades were counted as shadow fills while paper order placement was being fixed):
• Total P&L: +$1,738.00
• 24 trades, 13 wins: 54.2% win rate
• Profit factor: 1.39
• Current drawdown: -$642.50 from peak
• Max drawdown: -$1,335.50
The lesson: getting the direction right isn't enough. With the 5m ATR around 75, a short at VWAP had about one ATR of room, and one rip was enough to stop it out. Also, any order meant to reduce a position has to check that the position still exists before it's sent. That fix is on the bot's list.
#NQ #futures #daytrading #AItrading
64
Last week Blackwell made $1,363.25. Today we gave back $832.90 of it. 📉
Not exactly how I wanted to start the week, but this is what building and running an automated trading desk actually looks like.
Blackwell Capital | November 16
🔴 Net P&L: −$832.90
📊 4 trades | 1 win, 3 losses
🎯 Win rate: 25%
Today’s breakdown:
🔴 EMA Trend (MNQ): −$386.10
🟢 EMA Trend (MNQ): +$606.40
🔴 Williams %R (MGC): −$509.60
🔴 Morning Flush (MES): −$543.60
Interestingly, EMA Trend actually finished positive at +$220.30 net.
The losses came from our gold and Morning Flush strategies.
But the P&L isn’t the only thing that caught my attention.
We found discrepancies between the alert prices and actual broker fills, particularly on the gold and MES exits.
That doesn’t automatically mean slippage. Some exit payloads contain questionable reference prices, including one reporting a quantity of zero even though the broker correctly closed all five contracts.
That’s something we need to investigate before drawing conclusions about execution quality.
On the positive side, all eight received alerts were processed, all four positions were closed, and no failed exits were recorded.
Execution confirmations also remained fairly consistent, with exits locally confirmed in roughly 1.1–1.2 seconds. Exact broker latency still needs proper clock synchronization.
Our regime detector is now at 48 usable signal annotations across 9 strategy labels, but remains shadow-only while we work on validating its usefulness.
We’re still in drawdown, and today certainly didn’t help.
Last week’s profits weren’t proof we’d turned the corner, and today’s losses don’t automatically mean the strategies are broken.
What matters now is investigating the discrepancies, protecting the remaining drawdown cushion, and making decisions based on evidence rather than reacting emotionally to one session.
A red day, but the system completed its trades and finished flat.
Building Blackwell in public means showing days like this too. 🏗️
$MNQ $MES $MGC
27
Down 2% the day before Nvidia reports isn't a signal. It's a range warning.
NQ's overnight range alone was about 725 points. That's $14,500 on one mini. $1,450 on one micro.
If your stop was built for a quiet week, it's sized for a market that isn't here.
The fix: set the stop for today's range first, then cut contracts until the dollar risk matches a normal day.
Tomorrow: normal size, half size, or flat until after the print?
18
Your daily loss limit isn't a dollar number. It's a points number.
$1,000 daily loss on NQ:
1 mini = 50 points
2 minis = 25 points
5 micros = 100 points
10 micros = 50 points
Now put your normal stop next to it. A 20-point stop on 2 minis is $800. One loss and you've got $200 left for the day.
Quick check: daily limit ÷ your stop in dollars. If it's under 3, you're sized for one bad trade, not a day.
Save this. What's your number?
22
njoii.eth retweeted
OK, now that the market is closed, can we have a discussion?
🛑Stop full porting the U.S. market open.
It's a bad strategy. And odds are that it's not going to work out for you.
This week, we ended our funding relationship with 61 mostly new traders who got into PRO accounts and then decided to full port (e.g., trade large size) at the 9:30 AM ET open. This is a very small fraction of traders, but they're always consistently there. And I don't understand why.
Best case: they make a few thousand dollars. Worse case: they blow their PRO accounts. But either way, it ruins their chances with trading one of the best live-market prop firm programs out there.
The goal of prop firms is to turn good trading into good traders. In other words, to give you the experience and enforce discipline that will help you turn those stretches of good trading into a consistently profitable approach.
From a risk management perspective, trading full size at highly volatile times is not a strategy that will work out. If you do this, you have a 100% chance of ruin. So, it's not the key to a long-term relationship where we can win alongside of you.
First, I should be very clear: trading at the open isn't against our rules. Most traders do this responsibly inside their account and never hear from the risk team. A few do this irresponsibly. For them, we don't claw back profits (if they are lucky enough to make them). We simply identify the behavior, and notify traders that they're not a fit for our program moving forward. They're allowed to withdraw any profits they made, finish out their path in a PRO+ Development account, and then, we part ways.
But these traders aren't entirely irrational, are they? They have a 50/50 chance of winning a few thousand dollars, right?
The data suggests otherwise. Here are the stats from this week:
Monday: 3 of 11 traders made money
Tuesday: 3 of 13 traders made money
Wednesday: 4 of 8 traders made money
Thursday: 2 of 14 traders made money
Friday: 8 of 15 traders made money
In total, 20 of 61 traders made money. 33%.
Why is it so low? The issue with placing huge sized bets at a volatile time is that NQ might go up 15 points and then down 30 points in a few seconds. You can be wrong betting both ways if you try to get too much out of the trade.
But I'm sure you're much more disciplined than the traders above, and you put a bracket trade down so that you either hit it or don't: 15 NQ points – to match the 15 points of drawdown you have at max size. That's truly a 50/50 chance. OK, I'll agree. Now, let's say now that you guess right and hit your profit target.
Great, you just made $4,500 across five accounts. $22,500, right? What's the math behind that now?
You're still inside the buffer, so after the profit split, you just made $2,250 x 5 = $11,250 you can withdraw today. Not bad for 20 seconds of work. Don't forget to save for taxes (e.g., -25%). And you probably paid some to get into the accounts in the first place. So let's call it profits of $7,500… or $1,500 per account. Maybe that's worth it. But when you consider you just burned an opportunity to be a funding partner with a top firm in the space, what's it really costing you?
Or, instead of withdrawing, you now get to move into live with 5x PRO+ Development accounts. You either make these accounts work or go looking for a new funding partner. That's some pressure.
Look, I get it: the allure of full porting is real. Futures trading presents you with an opportunity to make thousands in seconds. But before you do that, do the math as to the real costs and benefits. Even if it works out, I'm not sure it pays.
The most dangerous trade next week is the first one on a fresh account.
A lot of evals and funded accounts got blown this week. Monday, the reset feels like a clean slate.
It isn't. The drawdown is at its tightest, and you're trying to win back the fee.
Day one on a new eval or funded: normal size, half size until there's a buffer, or skip the first day?
23
My AI discretionary trading bot: Fri Nov 13 recap (NQ / MNQ, TradingView paper, times PT)
Quick context: the old challenge experiment is stopped, but the learning keeps going with real paper trades every day. No P&L goal either way, just tracking how the bot does over time, P&L-wise and win/loss-wise.
Today: 1 trade, 1 win, +$108.00 (+0.37R).
What the market did:
• The open flushed hard. From the 28,399.25 high, NQ sold through the overnight low and printed a 27,690.5 low in the 8:20 bar.
• My bot sat that drop out. A buggy 1.5x ATR stop check combined with spiking volatility pushed risk over the bot's $400 cap even at 2 micros, so those shorts stayed watch-only. One short it marked near 6:45 ran ~160 pts, but the pre-news blackout ahead of UMich kept it out.
• After the low, NQ chopped in a range with 27,951 as the lid.
The trade:
• SHORT 3 MNQ. At 9:44 the bot rested a sell limit at 27,908 after the third rejection under 27,951. It filled at 27,920.75 during the 9:45-9:47 sweep to 27,954, 12.75 pts better than the limit. Stop 27,970, 1R = 49.25 pts.
• Why: range day, third failed push at the lid, price under VWAP.
• By 10:09 it was up about +0.75R. At 10:11 the bot moved the stop to 27,896 to lock +0.5R. It stopped out in the 10:15 bar at ~27,902.75 (6.75 pts of slippage). Result: +$108.00.
At 10:35 NQ closed above 27,951 for the first time and broke out to 28,049.5 by 11:05. The midday rule (A- or better from 10:00 to 11:30) kept the bot out of the breakout long. It was flat by the 12:50 cutoff, with NQ near 28,027.75 at 12:58.
Running total since the desk started Sep 28 (one combined record; some early trades were counted as shadow fills while paper order placement was being fixed):
• Total P&L: +$2,103.50
• 23 trades, 56.5% win rate
• Profit factor: 1.51
• Current drawdown: -$277 from peak
• Max drawdown: -$1,335.50
Lesson: the early profit lock paid for itself today. The range lid broke 20 minutes after the bot moved its stop. With the stop still at 27,970, this short would have been a full -1R loss. The +0.5R lock made it a small win instead. The trade-off was the morning: the big trend move came while volatility was too high for the bot's size rules, so it watched. That was the bot's call. Sitting out beats taking an oversized trade.
#NQ #futures #daytrading #AItrading
1
115
+$850.15 today. +$1,363.25 on the week. Still in drawdown, but Blackwell is fighting its way back. 📈
Blackwell Capital | November 13
One trade today. One winner.
🟢 Weak/Strong Close — Long 5 MES
📍 Entry: 7,544.00
📍 Exit: 7,578.25
💰 Gross: +$856.25
✅ Net: +$850.15
The trade ran from 8 AM to 1 PM Pacific, capturing 34.25 ES points.
Morning Flush also generated a long signal, but Blackwell correctly blocked it because another strategy already occupied the position slot. Its later exit was rejected because it didn’t own the trade.
Exactly the kind of protection a multi-strategy trading system needs.
Execution timing was encouraging as well:
• Entry locally accepted in 1.33 seconds
• Exit locally confirmed closed in 1.12 seconds
Clock synchronization still needs fixing, so these aren’t verified end-to-end broker latencies.
Now for the weekly numbers. 📊
November 9–13
💰 Net P&L: +$1,363.25
🎯 Win Rate: 60%
📈 5 trades: 3 wins, 2 losses
💵 Gross: +$1,393.75
💸 Fees: $30.50
Daily breakdown:
🔴 Monday: −$78.60
🟢 Tuesday: +$215.30
🟢 Wednesday: +$376.40
⚪ Thursday: $0 (no trades)
🟢 Friday: +$850.15
Five trades across an entire week with 10 live strategies.
No need to force trades just because we’re trying to recover from drawdown.
A green day is a good day. A no-trade day that preserves capital can be just as important.
On the development side, our market regime detector now has 40 usable signal annotations across 9 strategy labels.
It’s collecting market conditions across MNQ, MES, and MGC, but remains shadow-only while we evaluate whether those conditions actually improve strategy performance.
We’re not out of drawdown yet, but this week was a solid step forward.
Profitable week. Controlled activity. Strategy ownership safeguards working as intended. System flat heading into the weekend.
Now the goal is to keep stacking weeks like this without compromising execution or risk management.
Building Blackwell in public. 🏗️
$MES $MNQ $ES $NQ
2
48
NQ was green before the open on a cooler PPI. By late morning it was down about 2%.
Same print. Different tape. Nvidia's CEO exit and the chip selloff did the rest.
Overnight high to the flush low was roughly 890 points. That's about $1,780 per micro.
On a day like this, the real decision isn't direction. It's whether you're still trading at all.
Friday afternoon after a flush: short the bounce, take one small shot, or done for the week?
26
A cooler print doesn't make the open safer. It just makes it feel safer.
PPI came in under forecast this morning and Nasdaq futures were green before the bell. That's exactly when people skip the part of the plan that says wait for the first range.
The print already happened. The open is still its own event.
Do you trade the first 15 minutes after a news-day open, wait for the range, or sit the open out?
23
Most scale-outs aren't risk management. They're a way to never be fully wrong.
NQ printed 28,652 today and closed near 28,388. Whoever took half at the first target felt smart. Whoever held the runner gave a lot of it back.
But the trades that pay for all your losers are the ones that run. Scaling out every time quietly caps those.
Full exit at target, scale out, or trail the whole position?
44
My AI discretionary trading bot took one NQ trade today and lost it. Here's the full, honest breakdown.
Quick context: the old challenge is over, but the learning isn't. My bot still takes real paper trades every day. There's no P&L target, just tracking how it performs over time, in dollars and wins/losses.
The trade (MNQ Dec, PT times):
Long 2 MNQ. The bot's call was a resting buy limit at the rising 5m 9 EMA plus a 1m bullish gap, after a strong morning push on what it graded a trend-up day. Filled about 8:31 at 28,534.25, stop 28,440, target 28,772.50. It never got going. The best it saw was +17 pts. Stopped in the 9:20 bar at 28,438 for -$385 (-1.02R).
What the market did: the morning run topped out near 28,652, then faded. The post-breakout 1m bullish gaps flipped bearish at 8:42. A 9:15 flush flipped the last support gap at 9:17, and the bot re-graded the day from trend-up to range. The afternoon chopped between 28,311 and 28,412, with four failed breaks of the low. No setup offered 1.5R+, so the bot stood aside and was flat by 12:50.
Day: -$385 (1 trade, 1 loss)
Combined since Sep 28: +$1,995.50 over 22 trades
Win rate 54.5% | Profit factor 1.49
Current drawdown -$385 | Max drawdown -$1,335.50
(A few early trades were counted as shadow fills while paper order placement was being fixed. They're all in one record.)
The lesson: my bot re-graded the day to range twice while still holding a long it took because the day was trending. When the reason for the trade is gone, waiting for the full stop just gives back the rest of the R. Cutting or trimming at the re-grade is the next thing to test. The loss stayed at about 1R, and the bot didn't force anything in the chop afterward.
#NQ #futures #daytrading #AItrading
5
1
161
10 strategies running. Zero trades today. Still in drawdown. And honestly, a day like this might be exactly what we need.
Blackwell Capital | November 12 📊
After two consecutive green days, Blackwell stayed on the sidelines today.
💰 Net P&L: $0
📊 Trades: 0
✅ No recorded execution failures
✅ All 10 strategies live and enabled
✅ System healthy, flat, and monitoring
No alerts were received, so there were no trades to execute.
We’re still working our way out of drawdown, and obviously I’d love to see more green days.
But recovering from drawdown doesn’t mean we need to trade every day.
Sometimes a no-trade day is exactly what an account needs.
No unnecessary exposure. No forcing setups. No giving back profits just because we want to recover faster.
That’s one of the biggest advantages I’m trying to build into Blackwell: allowing the system to operate without the emotional pressure of needing to make money every single session.
On the development side, our market regime detector continues running smoothly across MNQ, MES, and MGC.
We’re holding at 36 usable signal annotations across 8 strategy labels. Still shadow-only while we work toward evaluating actual trade outcomes.
No new execution timing data today, but the infrastructure remains healthy. All 10 strategies are enabled, public routing is operational, and the runner is idle with zero open positions or working orders.
We’re not out of drawdown yet.
But after two green days, a flat session with no trading and no recorded system issues is perfectly fine with me.
A green day is a good day. A no-trade day that preserves capital and keeps us ready for the next opportunity can be just as valuable.
Sometimes progress isn’t about making more money.
Sometimes it’s about knowing when to do nothing.
Building Blackwell in public. 🏗️
$MNQ $MES $MGC
37
The gap fill is not a second chance to size like normal.
NQ opened about 1.3% lower and has spent the morning clawing a large chunk of it back. That's repair, not a new trend day.
On a funded account, the daily you still have left was set at the open. Getting green into lunch doesn't reset it.
Do you keep morning size, cut it once you're green, or flatten into tomorrow's print?
19
Same setup, yes. Same size only if the red trade didn't already move your floor.
On a trailing drawdown, a loser can shrink the room you have left, so repeating the same size is how a second scratch becomes a rule breach.
Do you cut size after a red trade, or only after the room actually changes?
Execution makes the money
Emotion gives it back
Repetition keeps it
Your funded account does not care how smart the plan was
It cares whether you followed it after a red trade
Same setup
Same size
Same exit
That is how payouts stack
1
1
69
Bonds are open again. NQ still opened about 1.3% lower.
Yesterday's rally happened with Treasuries shut. This morning the rates market is back, claims came in a bit soft, and there's a string of Fed speakers still ahead.
So the gap isn't a verdict on yesterday. It's the first real vote on a move that didn't get one.
Do you fade the giveback, wait for the first speaker, or stand aside until the calendar thins out?
1
94













