David Jones (@DavidJonesPhil) header
David Jones (@DavidJonesPhil) profile picture

PhD student @UniofNottingham : Ancient Philosophy, Plato, Aristotle, Logic. Parmenides dialogue interpretation.

University of Nottingham
Joined June 2024
The reductio ad absurdum argument (nominally attributed to Zeno as its earliest practitioner) and can rightly be called thematic for Plato’s Parmenides. Yet a reductio need not serve just as a means of proof. It has three levels of complexity in its use:-
1
40
who also employs a re-examination of the first Deduction in the style of iii) a puzzle reductio. He rightly notes that, after the target is revised, the Deduction need not only yield negative results (as it does before the revision)....
1
11
We can find however points not discovered by Miller. An important positive result (that is not ruled out) is that ‘the one’ may be a part (in some sense) of other things while not itself having parts.
6
Should Logic be a neutral language within which we clarify what is 'rational' in different contexts, or should logic have built into it a normative sense of 'rationality'? The pre Frege and Russell has the former idea whereas Frege thought that you set up logic to mimic...
1
62
....the scientific method, deemed the only rational method. So now Logic can never be that neutral language to discuss rationality and science and whether it is the only way...
41
Logic is meant to formalize the way we reason, using various terms like identity ,negation, ever, some, here exists, always, never etc. And this logic has done. but it has missed whole/part reasoning. there is no logic of these terms - there is classical mereology which...
1
45
..fools philosophers into believing whole/part is covered. But it isn't! Classical mereology was intended, not to be the logic of whole/part, but replace set theory as the foundation of mathematics. so we muddle on talking completely intuitively about 'constitutive theories...
1
2
27
...of X' without an formalism. Simons (2000) Koslicki (2008) pointing the way to a ordinary mereology though!
9
It is interesting the difference between the 'servants of god' model in Plato of the normative relation between humankind and the gods, the 'shepherd and flock' and 'children of God' metaphor of the religious perspective both pagan and Christian. Plato's is more empowering...
1
1
68
...ironically (since we are meant to slaves or servants), because a servant is actually useful to god aim of bringing good into the world. Whereas consider the Lords prayer - 'thy will be done' - it does not say 'thy will be done *through me*' ...
1
45
Plato's god(s) are not all powerful and so need to work through us, not merely for their own benefit (as some saw gods wanting sacrifices) but to bring good into the world.
1
36
The other 'Third Man'. It is a fairly well known infinite regress argument that Aristotle called the Third Man. If Socrates participates in the form of Man, then if we set this Man alongside Socrates we can ask what they have in common? The answer is a further Third Man..
1
1
2
169
...But there is a less well known Third Man argument that was apparently well known around the time and a favorite of Sophist's displays. This one is not an infinite regress argument, but points to the difference between intensional and extensional definitions...
1
2
93
It goes: There is one Man Socrates and a Second Man is the form of Man - a property Socrates has. Then there is a Third Man - the generic 'Man' as when we say "Man walks". This third man is an indefinite Man from the extensional class of 'Man'!
2
63
In order to move forward peacefully, “let the left say, ‘We were wrong. It is legitimate to vote for Donald Trump. It is legitimate to be pro-life. It is legitimate to believe that there are only two genders. And we were wrong to suggest that that is not the case. We were wrong to say that that is hateful.’ When they say that, I am waiting with open arms to take down the temperature.” Please listen to the whole thing. She nails perfectly what I’m thinking. What so many of us are thinking and feeling.
964
2,828
287
14,646
1,228,142
How are forms participated in by other forms and particular things/people? (Socrates participates in the form of justice and justice participates in the form of virtue) This has never been resolved in Platonic studies but we are getting closer to a solution ....
3
1
162
1. Physical Share (S. Rickless) 2. Paradigm-Copy (Timaeus) 3. Likeness (Parmenides) 4. Having (Aristotle) 5. Two kinds of Predication (C. Meinwald) 6. Limit (M. H. Miller) 7. Being (M. L. Gill) 8. 'Global' whole/part relation, which is based on P. Simons work on global mereology
1
2
84
...There is not yet been a comparative study bringing all these together which I think would be fruitful.
2
51