Docbate SW London (@DocbateSWL) header
Docbate SW London (@DocbateSWL) profile picture

Cash, care and coercion - Doctors really do know best. Our exciting debate topic to be discussed on 28th April, 6pm in Lecture theatre F, St George's Hospital.

Joined March 2015
Docbate SW London retweeted
Pls RT if you think Theresa May should also be held to account for systematically underfunding the NHS, allowing staff to be treated appallingly, and keeping Jeremy Hunt in both a job and a luxury bathroom theguardian.com/society/2017…
55
2,178
68
1,116
Docbate SW London retweeted
'Junior doctors are being treated so badly that we may be forced to strike' ind.pn/1QmUlfB
2
69
22
Docbate SW London retweeted
Check out our write up in @TheBMA future docs! communities.bma.org.uk/commu…
Docbate SW London retweeted
Mental health spending cuts forecast bbc.in/1KdNphW
2
46
12
Final vote - Opposition wins by 13 to 5 with some remaining undecided! #docbate2015
Doctors are best placed to hear the whole MDT plus the patients perspectives, does this make us the best qualified decision makers #docbate
Final arguments before the final vote!#docbate2015
Would a wealthy person accept financial incentives to have a monthly depot? Unlikely. An interesting moral argument #docbate2015
Dr O'Brien suggests the Drs certainly know best about some aspects of care but given prior mistakes this is by no means full proof #docbate
Catherine Hawkins argues each stakeholder will have different priorities. Is a more commercial approach required?#docbate2015
Dr burns suggests as doctors are not living with the conditions we can not know better and they're involvement in care is key #docbate2015
1
Dr Ed Burns expands the question to "do doctors know better than managers and patients?" #docbate2015
Are doctors terrible at noticing when they are being influenced? The drug lunches? Free pens?#docbate2015
1
1
Mid Staf managerial staff largely consisted of non clinical staff. Would the events have happened with clinicians in charge?#docbate2015
1
Nav using the example of mid Staffordshire, with targets being met consistently but with an appalling low standard of care #docbate
Nav argues financial incentives can be a short term fix. Would smokers be paid lifelong to stay away from cigarettes? #docbate2015
Patients on depot injections increased there adherence with a £10 per injection incentive #docbate2015
80% of people surveyed felt effective financial incentives for smoking cessation would be a worthwhile investment #docbate2015
Adam argues everyone has unhealthy habits and when then is a financial incentive appropriate #docbate2015