Replying to @homo_sapian_2_0 @ygzgzot
Also, don't ask how Lenin himself described the USSR during the Eleventh Congress of the Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks).
1
4
102
Can't really complain that people are criticizing the Kautsky was right piece without reading it, when the piece is under paywall.
35
Even in the marxological account, that he doesn't focus on the TRFP in itself, but on the terms through which it is expressed is not that strong of argument that it doesn't explain anything.
1
19
In the conclusion to Marx's Theory of Crisis he doesn't privilege disproportionality (or underconsumption) as more explanatory and serios than the TRFP.
1
1
17
If the TRFP doesn't explain anything according to Clarke, then neither do his descriptions of the dynamics of the formation of surplus populations or circuits of circulation and accumulation from Vol. 2
1
26
Clarke criticized the "trfp _theory of crisis_" and claims derived from Engels' commentary that it's the most important teoretic achievement of Marx. From that, to claim that it doesn't explain anything is to bend the stick too far. It has its place in Marx's analysis.
1
24
Replying to @Darren_Mooney
There are moments even early on. There's a one page gut punch in Flex Mentallo where the main character goes "Why didn't the superheroes stop the bomb? Why didn't they mum and dad from fighting". Can't really go back to full-poptimism after that.
3
170










