Pinned Tweet
It would be nice if this account didn't have to be anonymous but considering GISAID's history of legal threats and retribution in response to reasonable public criticism there is sadly no alternative at this point in time.
For a start, read this article:
science.org/content/article/…
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
Skip if you’re sick of reading about @GISAID - but here are a few thoughts about the big new story that @PaulNuki published yesterday. telegraph.co.uk/global-healt…
Here is some evidence that Peter Bogner is a felon: he was convicted by the court of first instance.
"The court found ... Peter Bogner ... guilty of Count I ... Count II."
The screenshots are from Bogner's very own appeal!
Replying to @PaulNuki
But here's the thing, it's not our choice.
Bogner created GISAID. He got the world sharing data data where the suits in charge failed.
And nor can I find any evidence of him being felon, a fraud or even a spy - as some have suggested.
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
Replying to @PaulNuki
Where did you get the Joni Mitchell picture from?
It's conspicuously similar to the 2020 version of this Wikimedia picture (if you look at the color levels).
You seem to be using it also in the article, but no attribution.
commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/F…
Has anyone seen a single MERS sequence in GISAID? I haven't.
Replying to @PaulNuki
On this, all agree. It's the “go-to” repository for the code of most new nasties. H5N1, MERS, Covid... they're all there. It houses 15m sequences of SarsCov2 alone.
As @DrRHatchett puts it, it does not just spot sharks but tracks them once the dorsal fin dips beneath the water
99
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
Replying to @PaulNuki
Oh finally, a real journalist, who is willing to accept that Steven is real! And has simply been misspelling his own name all these years, and is just super private. It's totally appropriate for such a fine person to decide who gets to look at virus genomes.
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
In a @VanityFair story, @KatherineEban oddly misrepresented an investigation into @GISAID and Peter Bogner by @sciencecohen and me; suggested our story was a volley in the lab leak debate; and let Bogner dismiss it as a "hit piece." Here's our response. science.org/do/10.1126/scien…
The article is available here: ft.com/content/4597ede8-f698…
The article was written by @donatopmancini and @ @mroliverbarnes. I have a question for you: what's your evidence for the truthfulness of this quote other than Peter Bogner's word?
145
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
To outsiders, the name GISAID means little. But inside science this small non-profit organisation is a mighty force in the storage and sharing of genetic data about pathogens econ.st/3K9Mbeu
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
🧨💣🧨 This goes to several issues mentioned about @GISAID in recent weeks. Interesting biographical details on the mysterious Steven Meyers, mention of the "first" sequence, inferences to draw about the author, etc.
Obtained under Louisiana FOIA. This is a public record.
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
GISAID, a leading genetic database for pathogens sharing, has come in for criticism by scientists and its funders. This will raise question marks over its future.
economist.com/science-and-te… A critical genetic database is under fire from TheEconomist
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
Replying to @alexselby1770 @wanderer_jasnah
I'm slightly baffled as to why GISAID has chosen this hill to die on. I mean I get the desire to empire-build, but the Empire-Building User Manual (Basic Edition) clearly states: "Don't make a claim that can easily be disproved because then you will look very silly."
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
Scientists don’t go to papers for dates. Dates aren’t “peer reviewed” you can stack up shitty however you would like but no one believes the story GISAID has put out. – at Chilly, France
Not many may know that Peter Bogner, @GISAID's founder and president, once produced a video called "Peter Bogner's Skiing Techniques: Free Skiing and Recreational Racing"
On the cover, he claims to have been a "former World Cup Skier" - but I couldn't find any records thereof.
I found a list of all world cup skiers.
These are the Bogners. There is no Peter among them. Hmm.
Is this another lie?
fis-ski.com/DB/alpine-skiing…
2
1
155
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
15/ For now, I hope Mr. Bogner will issue a sincere apology for his mistakes & dishonest actions and then step down. GISAID is a gem. The world is much safer with GISAID than without it. Let's do the hard work to fix this mess then put it behind us & move forward to rebuild trust
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
13/ For example, GISAID should provide an option to data submitters to click a box to choose whether they eventually want their data to be deposited in the Public Domain, e.g., (a) 3 months, (b) 6 months, (c) 1-year, (d) 2-years, (e) 3-years, (d) 5-years, (e) 10-years, (f) Never
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
11/ In essence, GISAID is a fantastic data sharing community in dire need of a new leader & a package of serious reforms. It needs clear mechanisms for accountability, transparency on all funding sources, and a clearly defined transparent process for adjudication of disputes, etc
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
12/ If GISAID really wants to grow and thrive, it also needs to stop picking fights with the Public Domain sharing mechanisms and their funding agencies.
Anonymous GISAID User retweeted
8/ The context is that––among many other problems & lies–– Mr. Bogner has long allowed himself to play Kingmaker in disputes over who gets to publish a story, going so far as to having GISAID lawyers send emails to universities to compel a team of scientists not to publish..





















