Pinned Tweet
change.org/LGFA-ReviewTransg…
Gaels For Fair Play has launched a petition urging the LGFA to review its transgender policy that lets trans-identifying males from the age of 12 upwards to play Ladies Gaelic Football. Please sign if you believe in fairness and safety for women and girls.
The reason so many Irish politicians look like rabbits trapped in the headlights when asked about single-sex provisions for women is because there is so little guidance and clarity around Ireland's self-ID laws that even those who passed the legislation are unsure of its application.
The LGFA brought in a policy of male inclusion in 2023 and said it was a legal obligation prompted by the Gender Recognition Act 2015.
Yet Irish Rugby and Swim Ireland dont't let males participate in the female category.
Leo Varadkar, in a Sunday Times article last year, said "the law as it stands does not prevent sporting bodies from creating female-only categories where female athletes — biological women — would otherwise be at a significant disadvantage."
In the middle of all this confusion, women and girls who play @ladiesfootball are being denied safe and fair sport.
All we ask of our elected representatives - those in government and those seeking to govern - is that they stop equivocating and acknowledge we have an issue that needs to be meaningfully addressed and resolved.
@FineGael
@fiannafailparty
@sinnfeinireland
@AontuIE
@labour
.@davidcullinane acknowleges that a woman is an 'adult female' but adds: "There are also trans women who can legally transition in this State and live their lives as women, and I don’t see where the controversy is."
The women who were injured by male players in a @LadiesFootball match can see where the controversy is.
The teenage girls who played against an adolescent male with an obvious competitive advantage can see where the controversy is.
The LGFA's unsafe and unfair policy is a direct result of legislation that David says he sees no issues with.
He is not the only elected representative who doesn't have a grasp of this situation.
It's small wonder there is so much uncertainty and apprehension in Gaelic Games around eligibility policies when even our legislators cannot provide clarity on this issue.
PS - women and girls deserve 'compassion' and 'respect' too.
They will lose on sport as well. ALL female athletes, regardless of age or ability should be allowed to participate in fair and safe sport.
On the matter of trans participation in sport, @sinnfeinireland says it should be left to the governing bodies but that community level should be 'as inclusive as possible'.
Women and girls, AT ALL LEVELS, deserve safe and fair sport. No female player, whether she is elite level or not, should be forced to sacrifice fairness and safety as the price of male inclusion.
Gaelic Games can be 100 percent inclusive by ensuring all players, irrespective of how they identify or present, are made to feel safe, welcome and included playing in the correct sex category.
GaelsForFairPlay retweeted
In what would appear to be a reversal of policy
Sinn Féin agree that a woman is an adult female; no self-ID for 16- and 17-year-olds; & males with serious violent or sexual convictions to be barred from women’s prisons.
On sport they want to leave it to the governing bodies — but say community level should be “as inclusive as possible.”
Fairness and physical safety for women and girls must come first at every level, not just elite level. Prisons should be segregated based on biological sex, not the level of crime.
Will they follow through on these policies?
Sinn Féin instructs its TDs and senators on how to answer the question 'What is a woman?' - and now we can reveal just what it is they are being told to say trib.al/BNGZtc6
On the matter of trans participation in sport, @sinnfeinireland says it should be left to the governing bodies but that community level should be 'as inclusive as possible'.
Women and girls, AT ALL LEVELS, deserve safe and fair sport. No female player, whether she is elite level or not, should be forced to sacrifice fairness and safety as the price of male inclusion.
Gaelic Games can be 100 percent inclusive by ensuring all players, irrespective of how they identify or present, are made to feel safe, welcome and included playing in the correct sex category.
Sinn Féin instructs its TDs and senators on how to answer the question 'What is a woman?' - and now we can reveal just what it is they are being told to say trib.al/BNGZtc6
.@LadiesFootball a really good way to improve the retention rate among teenage girls would be to stop coercing them to play against and undress in front of adolescent males.
Closing today! ⚠️
Apply now for our 2027 #Gaelic4Teens programme!
Gaelic4 Teens is aimed at improving the retention rate of teenage girls aged 13-17 years!
Full details and how to apply➡️ bit.ly/4jfDD91
#LGFA
GaelsForFairPlay retweeted
No one needs to be excluded.
Fairness & safety is important for women & girls in sport and must be given priority in female categories.
Anyone who identifies as transgender can still play sport in their appropriate sex category.
Being able to participate in sports is important for all young people, but #transgender and #nonbinary youth are often excluded. Let everyone play - #trans and gender-diverse youth included!🏳️⚧️
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Trans and non binary people are not excluded from sport. They can play in the category of their biological sex, the same as everyone else.
olympics.com/ioc/athletes/m…
Indeed, including males in the female category can result in self-exclusion by girls.
seeninsport.org/the-law
GaelsForFairPlay retweeted
Replying to @KirstiMiller30
It is a reliable measure except in the rare cases that Anne has highlighted. What we can say is that the absence of the SRY gene means that the athlete is female unless they have de la Chapelle syndrome. In these cases testosterone is typically at the low end of the male scale but nothing like as low as females. That level of T would trigger WADA concerns and further questions would be asked if at an elite level. If those with the SRY gene believe that they have perhaps CAIS or Swyer syndrome then they may wish to pursue this further. Those with these conditions are likely to have detailed medical records. The overwhelming majority of female athletes will not have the SRY gene so you are talking about a tiny minority of people where further medical evidence may be needed. The answer if you are male like you to step away. This utterly disingenuous scaremongering is unhelpful.
Pretending that we cannot have a workable system which will with a very high accuracy identify males when the combined incidence of Swyer, CAIS and de la Chappell is around 0.01% of the population is desperately clutching at straws.
As to being male, it has been recognised for decades that testosterone provides significant athletic benefits. It is why it is a banned substance. Give it up Kirsti, no women want you in their sports.
GaelsForFairPlay retweeted
The best way to ensure everyone is included in sport, is to have everyone participate in the category of sports that corresponds to their own sex. For sport to be truly inclusive it must guarantee the safety, equality and dignity of all those engaged in playing, including women and girls (i.e. females)
Being able to participate in sports is important for all young people, but #transgender and #nonbinary youth are often excluded. Let everyone play - #trans and gender-diverse youth included!🏳️⚧️
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Trans and non binary people are not excluded from sport. They can play in the category of their biological sex, the same as everyone else.
olympics.com/ioc/athletes/m…
Indeed, including males in the female category can result in self-exclusion by girls.
seeninsport.org/the-law
GaelsForFairPlay retweeted
Playing in the correct sex category is the model of inclusion Gaelic Games chiefs must adopt.
It will take courage to go against a powerful movement that says males should play LGFA & camogie and which ignores the impact on women & girls.
But find courage they must.
The best way to ensure everyone is included in sport, is to have everyone participate in the category of sports that corresponds to their own sex. For sport to be truly inclusive it must guarantee the safety, equality and dignity of all those engaged in playing, including women and girls (i.e. females)
We agree everyone should play - but in the correct sex category so that females are not denied fairness & safety.
@officialgaa can strive to make men's Gaelic football & hurling an inclusive & safe enviroment for ALL males, no matter how they identify.
That's real inclusion.
Being able to participate in sports is important for all young people, but #transgender and #nonbinary youth are often excluded. Let everyone play - #trans and gender-diverse youth included!🏳️⚧️
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Trans and non binary people are not excluded from sport. They can play in the category of their biological sex, the same as everyone else.
olympics.com/ioc/athletes/m…
Indeed, including males in the female category can result in self-exclusion by girls.
seeninsport.org/the-law
GaelsForFairPlay retweeted
And I've check my correspondence. @Sportandrights claim
"Our invitees represent a diverse range of stakeholders and perspectives, and our sessions are not framed around support or otherwise for any particular motion or policy."
To use a technical term, this is codswallop.
This is my post to @LinkedIn, if any of you are over there. I hope, though doubt, that @SportandRights will pay some attention. It's pretty shameless, and devalues any contribution that they might want to make in other areas where rights are infringed or violated in sport.
GaelsForFairPlay retweeted
I've written to Sport Ireland requesting an investigation into the LGFA's transgender policy as a serious child safeguarding risk.
Email: [email protected]
This is an opportunity for @sportireland to conduct a thorough review of the child safeguarding gaps in @LadiesFootball policy of male inclusion, and to ask:
1. Why has the LGFA not reviewed its policy despite its commitment to do so within 3 years of its introduction?
2. What guidance has been issued to clubs regarding adolescent males being present in changing rooms with teenage girls?
3. Why does the policy remain in place despite overwhelming scientific and medical evidence that it exposes girls to increased risk of injury?
The LGFA is in breach of its own safeguarding code. Sport Ireland can, and should, hold this governing body to account.
Sport Ireland has ordered a review of child protection practices across all national governing bodies of sport after the emergence of safeguarding and vetting gaps at the FAI rte.ie/news/2026/1111/159877…
GaelsForFairPlay retweeted
Replying to @cruickshank
Please stop attempting to undermine women's and girls' rights to equality in sport.
Stop pretending female sport categories are an invention of the political right.
Female athletes fought for their own sport categories.
Stop handing an open goal to the political right.
GaelsForFairPlay retweeted
Replying to @nycpa
Stop gifting the political right a wide open goal.
Stop virtue signalling by euphemism.
You are advocating for males with trans identities to play in female sport.
This undermines the female sport category that female athletes fought for.
Women's & girls rights matters.
GaelsForFairPlay retweeted
Replying to @transscribe
This is completely untrue. All studies using matched cohorts show retained advantage in males with trans identities following testosterone suppression.
See:
Sex, Gender Identity and Sport | Cathy Devine | Taylor & Francis eBook share.google/T7SYvKnUDSwhKCA…
The US democrats who support fair and safe sport for women and girls have been backed by voters at the polls.
We urge Ireland's elected representatives to take note. @simonharris was vocal about the fact that women and girls should not be forced to wear the camogie skort yet was silent when we wrote to him to draw his attention to a policy where women and girls who play Gaelic football are being coerced to play against, and undress in front of, males.
The @LadiesFootball policy of male inclusion remains in place despite the fact it denies females fair and safe sport. It has not reviewed the policy despite its commitment that it would do so after three years.
@finegael oversees the department that allocates public money to the LGFA for the purpose of empowering women in sport and increasing their participation.
Women and girls being exposed to physical harm and denied fair completion is as far from 'empowering' as you can get.
#SaveWomensSports
The LGFA's policy of male inclusion requires that applicants over the age of 16 reduce their testosterone to a specified level.
But scientific evidence demonstrates unequivocally that testosterone suppression does not negate male advantage.
Across sport globally, the overwhelming majority of governing bodies have followed the science and updated their policies to prioritise fairness and safety for female athletes.
Yet the LGFA will not review its policy despite acknowledging the situation has evolved significantly since 2023.
This raised serious governance questions.























