Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered) header
Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered) profile picture

Separating the Hall of Fame from the Hall of Very Good. Making the case for and against sports most debated resumes.

Joined December 2020
Photo by Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered)Photo by Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered)Photo by Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered)Photo by Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered)Photo by Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered)Photo by Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered)Photo by Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered)Photo by Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered)Photo by Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered)Photo by Hall Things Considered (@HallConsidered)
Some players have Hall of Fame careers. Others have Hall of Fame moments. Eli Manning has two of the greatest moments in NFL history. But does that make him one of the greatest quarterbacks ever? We’re making the case that Eli belongs in the Hall of Very Good. Let’s consider it. 🧵
🤖 Made with AI
1
136
Eli deserves credit for both winning drives. But two Super Bowl rings have never guaranteed a spot in Canton. Jim Plunkett won two with the Raiders, including Super Bowl XV MVP honors. He even threw 3 TDs in that Super Bowl victory. More than 40 years later, Plunkett is still waiting. youtube.com/watch?v=OlyBEJ60…
1
19
Even Giants legend Phil Simms remains outside Canton. He won Super Bowl XXI MVP after completing 22 of 25 passes and earned a second ring in 1990, although injury kept him out of that postseason. Eli’s place in NFL history is secure. His place in Canton shouldn’t be. VERDICT: HALL OF VERY GOOD.
14
Curt Schilling won 216 games, never captured a Cy Young Award and has one of the most controversial reputations in baseball. He also struck out more than 3,000 batters, dominated an era built for hitters and authored some of October's greatest performances. Lets Consider his HOF Case 🧵:
🤖 Made with AI
9
2
4
24,872
If we're evaluating what happened between the lines, Schilling's case is exceptionally strong. Voters are entitled to consider character, and his controversies were real. But the baseball argument is different as @dpshow explains here...
1
1
263
Three World Series championships. More than 3,000 strikeouts. Elite control. Approximately 80 pitching WAR. One of the greatest postseason records in baseball history. Curt Schilling doesn't need his personality defended to have his pitching career recognized.
🤖 Made with AI
2
1
235