Hasan Hasmani (@HasmaniHasan) profile picture

Founder of Underdog Games | In 2023, we bought 200,000 families together for game night. Learning & sharing about creativity, marketing, and building products

New York, NY
Joined January 2020
Trump’s tariffs will decimate small toy/game businesses. We’re being forced to front $400K in tariffs—before we can even sell during the holidays. We fund new products + marketing in the first 9 months. The holidays are our payoff. Most won’t survive the year
Another 50% tariff on this order would add $90k in tariffs on it, bringing the new total to $191,000 in tariffs Which pretty much means it’d be worth abandoning this shipment and shutting down the physical product side of our business. And for anyone who cares, we are the highest quality brand for products for kids with special needs.
41
95
12
422
58,222
An important thing I've learned about tabletop game design in the last few years, thanks to more intense blind playtesting: A great rulebook will not only make the first play experience better, it will lead some players to feel the game is better overall, than they otherwise would. Here's my current theory about why: a good game has emergent qualities, that usually requires experience to understand and internalize. Players usually experience a game as better when they realize those emergent qualities are there, and understand them. A key point: many players will never get to this point. If they judge a game (and rate it online) before getting there, they will give it a lower rating than they would have otherwise. A great rulebook shortens the time and effort required to get there, so more players DO get there, so more players experience the game as excellent. However, there may be a double-edged sword here: I've noticed some players seem to judge a game as "not for them" based on how simple and streamlined the rules are. If the rules are simple, they'll conclude the gameplay must be shallow, and judge the game before they understand it. This bothers me. The folks who do this tend to be heavy gamers who should know better, and who (I assume for ego reasons) portray themselves as understanding games better than they actually do. It's a very "judge a book by its cover" way of relating to games, and it's categorically untrue that games with simple rules must have shallow gameplay. Some of the deepest games ever created have very simple rules.
9
9
3
46
5,210
You generate sales through marketing. You build the foundation for a board game company with word-of-mouth. My last post was about how hard it is to generate awareness for board games. But, the one sustainable free acquisition channel is customers sharing your product with others. There's an equation to profitably acquire new customers with marketing, it goes: Profit = Revenue - Cost of Goods - Shipping - Cost per Acquisition The cost per acquisition is by far the most variable here and for most companies, the most expensive. For games, that includes: Facebook Ads Kickstarter Fees Amazon PPC Google PPC Retailer Margin Indirectly, it includes: Youtubers Influencers All of these can be hard to sustain. Board games are often a one-time purchase. We don't have lifetime customer value like supplements, perishables, foods, etc. It's extremely hard to have margins that support high spending on Facebook Ads with a low order value and no return customers. That leaves 2 avenues for game companies to build a sustainable company without blowing their budget on marketing because there's a $0 CPA. E-Mailing Current Customers Word-Of-Mouth What influences word of mouth? 1. How fun the game is: The more enjoyable the game is, the more it'll spread. Doesn't even necessarily have to be a great game, just has to have people enjoy it enough to share with others. 2. Type of Game: Party games or drinking games tend to be easier to share with others as they're faster and more accessible and used at large gatherings. 3. Their experience with you: Did you have good customer service, fast shipping, and lived up to your promises? There's 100 other factors that can go into whether someone actually shares your game. The key is to remember that it's only step 1 to figure out profitable acquisition. The end goal is to create something so great that others will spread it for you for free.
1
2
2
8
1,766
Great advice. Increase the opportunity for people to find you by writing content that's relevant. Also allows potential employers to pre-vet your thinking. Writing is thinking. Seeing someone else's thinking on page is powerful It's how I found @Nick__Bentley and hired him
I got my last 2 jobs without applying for them. I work in the board game industry, where the supply of applicants exceeds the supply of jobs even more than in most industries. (the reason is games are fun and enthusiasts dream of going pro) How did I do it? When I want a job, I write content for a tiny audience: folks who own board game companies. I write articles about how to work through their problems. I got my last two jobs when the owners of companies contacted me after reading an article I wrote. Think about that. Both jobs rolled up to my doorstep. Now that I've worked in the field for a decade I have the advantage of deeper knowledge, so I should be able to do it ever better next time. This practice compounds. It has felt like a cheat code and and I've loved having it mostly to myself. I'm forcing myself to post this despite that, because I'm trying to practice the twin values of transparency and usefulness. Hard for me to think of a more useful thing I know. Caveats: ⚠️ You have to be a good researcher, thinker, and writer to make this approach work. "Good thinker" is especially hard. I've spent my life trying to be a good thinker and I still regularly discover major bonehead thinking patterns. ⚠️ This only works if you want to work in small companies. It won't work if you try to write for owners of big companies. They already have too many people advising them. If you can deal with the two caveats above, it's a general method that should work for many industries. It's also much more fun because you end up learning a lot and bettering yourself in the process.
There's a new version of this post
1
3
868
Designing a great board game is hard. Generating awareness for that board game is even harder. You spend years ideating, testing, and refining a game to get to a level that is (hopefully) good. The issue is that you need that game to reach people's tables at home. And the distribution/marketing part of the value chain will be more expensive than the manufacturing for most companies. To break it down, these are the major channels and how to think about them. Word-of-Mouth: This is every publisher's dream. Create a game that is so fun that everyone who plays it wants to tell others about it. Note: Absurdly hard. Also, need the first 5,000 customers to get the ball rolling. Mass-Market: Distribute it to major-market retailers and they generate awareness for you, through foot traffic. Usually requires a prior relationship. With mass-market, you're paying the retailer half the revenue, by selling it to them at 50% off, as the cost of reach/traffic. Independent Retailers: Small but powerful community-driven channel, that can help market your games locally and spread awareness. Meta Ads: Push awareness by spending on FB and Instagram. The key here is your unit contribution margin. So essentially: Unit Contribution Margin: Revenue - Cost of Goods - Cost per Acquisition (Your Meta cost to get a purchase) - Shipping to Customer If you can get this to work, one of the most scalable, just keep adding more money to generate more sales until it stops working. Hard to make this work under $40, which can make games very challenging. Amazon: You can put it up on the platform, but have to rank for bigger keywords as it's a keyword search driven platform. Extremely difficult and can be very expensive. Only a few major keywords, and tens of thousands of games competing for those broad keywords. If your product is already a hit due to other awareness methods, you'll see a ton of sales here. But likely not generating awareness in and of itself. Organic Social/Tik-Tok: Instagram/FB is hard to get reach these days. TikTok is where all the buzz is for good reason. Can get tons of viral visibility with the right product/right video. Hard to replicate on any other platform. Free to generate sales, expensive to make videos. High cost/high overhead on the video side with a ton of risk. But if you hit virality, you're not paying a per unit cost so scales very well. Note: Celebrity/Influencer Partnerships also work here. But it has to be a good product-market fit. Your own email list: If you had a pre-existing hit game, getting more sales from your own customers by creating consistently great games is always the best/most affordable way of marketing a new game. Create amazing relationships with your fans. Kickstarter: Generates organic sales via discovery, people like to search and see what's new. Also a public platform, so easier to share than your own website for example, more fun and collaborative. Kickstarter will also push successful products through their own marketing. The goal is always virality through word-of-mouth but you still need those first 1,000 -5,000 customers to even get there so it's important to think through all of these, and realize that making the game is only the first step. Now, I'm just patiently waiting on @Nick__Bentley to hurry up and make me another hit game. He keeps telling me that my 2-week deadlines for new games are "insane."
5
7
2
31
2,856
Easily one of the hardest parts about making a new game is trying to figure out if you're actually going in the right direction at all times. Having a group of advisors who help eliminate internal bias and get out of infinite loops in decision-making make that process slightly less agonizing. @Nick__Bentley can't go to sleep until he's agonized over every potential issue with Trekking the World 2nd Edition. Because of his psychosis, we’ve done 374 playtests of the 2nd edition of Trekking the World on Tabletop Simulator. Through sheer willpower, I think we’ve made a great game, and even then I’m still not sure. This is the future of game design in our view and product creation overall. As you’re designing and innovating, get consistent feedback from the end user. Here’s 4 things our advisors have helped us nail down: 1. Game Mechanics 2. Title 3. Cover 4. Marketing creative and copywriting
2
2
5
502
I tell @Nick__Bentley that making a hit board game is easy. All we need is a game that is: 🥳Extremely fun 🧠Super Strategic ➕Mathematically sound 🎨Has Beautiful Art 📏Rules teachable in 5 minutes to someone while they’re texting Why is a 2-week turnaround "difficult"
1
1
5
451