Jeremy Reis (@JeremyReis) header
Jeremy Reis (@JeremyReis) profile picture

Husband, Father, Nonprofit Strategist. Raise more money to help more people. President of @servingorphans

Westerville, OH
Joined December 2009
A receipt isn't a thank-you. When I make small gifts, the experience often ends with a transactional receipt. Sometimes from large organizations that should know better. Hearing a real person say thanks is surprisingly rare. Be the rare one.
16
A growth percentage isn't a plan. Twice, at two different organizations, I've seen ten-year plans where someone applied a percentage increase to every year and called it a fundraising projection. Neither plan said where the extra money would come from. No channels. No new investments. A number that went up every year. One of them made it worse. It budgeted from the long-range projection instead of from actual results. Every year it missed the goal, and every year the next target went higher anyway. My preference: an organizational strategy of three years at most, paired with a detailed 12-month fundraising plan. Past that, the economy, channel performance, staffing and donor behavior can change too much. Every growth target should answer one question: why will we grow? 1. Are we adding major gift capacity? How many gift officers, starting when? 2. Are we investing in monthly donor acquisition? How much, and in which channels? 3. Are we building a new digital source? What will it cost before it pays? If nobody can answer, the percentage is a wish. What's the growth target in your plan built on?
19
I once told my boss a young writer might struggle to write for our older donors. His answer: That's their job. Their job is to put themselves in the donor's shoes. Let them do it. He was right.
32
I once approved a $10,000 test I was sure would fail. My team wanted to try Spotify ads to find new child sponsors. I didn't believe in it. I said yes anyway. Here's why, and what happened. The idea made sense on paper. The organization did a lot of work in Christian music, including sponsoring tours where artists invited concert crowds to sponsor children. The team's hypothesis: target listeners of similar artists with sponsorship ads, and maybe recreate some of that concert success. The full test would cost about $10,000, a big share of our testing budget. I had a reason to say yes. My own bosses had let me take chances, and taking chances is how you find new wins. If a team never gets permission to fail, it keeps doing what it has always done. So we ran it. We spent about $10,000 and got very little. Maybe one or two donors. What we learned: what happens at a live concert doesn't necessarily carry over to a streaming app. What I relearned: sometimes a leader has to fund an idea he doesn't believe in so the team can test its assumptions. What's a test you approved even though you doubted it?
1
2
51
AI wasn't wrong. It was harsh. Here's how I use AI for strategy work. I give it the principles, what we're trying to accomplish, and the numbers. It assembles a strategy document. Then I review and edit it. Used that way, I can't think of a time it was confidently wrong about the information I gave it. Where it overreached was tone. In consulting work, it could be more negative about a client's strategy than the situation called for. The observation underneath was often useful. The conclusion needed to be softened and said with more grace. Correct analysis can still be badly calibrated. That's why I keep a human at the start and a human at the end. The middle is where AI helps most. Have you had to soften something AI wrote about a real person or organization?
1
36
Two nonprofits. Two money crunches. Very different endings. At the first, where I worked, the leadership team was open about the financial situation and the steps to fix it. Not every step was easy. But we were grateful to be trusted, and when things got hard, the staff pulled together. At the second, a friend of mine ran HR and constantly had to push the executive director to share information with staff. Most employees didn't know how the organization was doing until the annual report came out. One year it was losing money, and leadership said nothing until it was too late. Ten percent of the staff were laid off on a Friday afternoon. The rest panicked, and several key people left on their own. When leaders don't share good and bad news, staff fill in the gaps with their own assumptions. Share more with your team than feels comfortable. How much does your staff know about your organization's finances right now?
18
We wrote about how great our programs were. Donors didn't care. Shortly after I started at one organization, we brought email fundraising in-house. Our agency's emails weren't raising much, and they cost a lot to produce. Easy decision. Our costs dropped. Our revenue barely moved. The team was a writer with a journalism background and me, an inexperienced fundraiser. So we did what inexperienced fundraisers do. We wrote about our excellent programs and our efficient organization. Clean water, child sponsorship, and more. Success after success. It didn't work. Read your appeal the way a donor would. If it sounds like you already have the answer, why would she give? Success stories aren't the problem. They're in the wrong place. Put them in thank-you notes, newsletters, and follow-up emails, after she gives. In the appeal, show her the need she can meet. Is your last appeal asking for help, or announcing that you don't need any?
1
41
A blogger sold thousands of goats for us. Every Christmas, one place I worked put out a gift catalog. Donors could give chickens, goats, school uniforms, and more. One year we partnered with a popular blogger. He promoted goats from the catalog in his own voice, in a way that fit his personality and his readers. Thousands of goat gifts came in. Many of the people who gave knew very little about us. They gave because they trusted him. Three lessons I took from it: The messenger can matter as much as the message. Trust can transfer from a person to an organization people don't know yet. Let partners talk the way they talk. The campaign worked because it sounded like him. Who outside your organization already has the trust of the people you want to reach?
27
Put a reply envelope in everything you mail. Even the pieces with no ask. Some people will give anyway. Code each envelope so you know which mailings bring in the surprise gifts. At one place I worked, it was great income for the cost of an envelope.
16
Two checks on the desk: $500,000 and $250,000. A friend of mine was asking a well-known local business leader for a six-figure gift. The man listened to the pitch, then said: "I have two checks here: $500,000 and $250,000. I don't want to be the largest donor to the campaign, so whichever check you pick up, you need to go find someone who will give the same amount. Otherwise, you'll need to return it." My friend picked up the $250,000 check. He knew he could find a match at that level. And he did. That donor wanted to give. He also wanted to know others believed in the campaign too. Most donors feel some version of that. It's why stories from other donors matter so much. Why did they give? What did it feel like? Why do they keep giving? You probably have plenty of stories from the people you serve. How many do you have from your donors?
1
30
At one place I worked, we didn't call it our mission, vision, and values. We called it our Heartbeat. It was printed on postcard-size cards. Every employee had one. It sat in the middle of conference room tables and hung on posters around the building. That part isn't unusual. Lots of organizations print their values. What mattered was that we used it. When a decision had to be made, we ran it through the Heartbeat first. A values statement only matters if it changes what you decide. Try this at your next leadership meeting. Before you vote on anything, read your values out loud and ask which one this decision serves. If nobody can answer, that's worth knowing.
12
Good design in fundraising has one test: does the donor read it and respond? Reversed text, fancy fonts, and faded photos can win compliments in the office. Readability beats sophistication every time.
16
Why would anyone move money away from finding monthly donors? Here's the math we use where I serve now. We review every fundraising tactic monthly. Each one has a goal for every quarter, an actual for every quarter, and a year-to-date total. Each quarter, we make bigger changes, sometimes to the goals themselves. Sometimes a monthly donor source starts drying up, and the cost to acquire one climbs past what we're willing to pay. When that happens, we can move the money into finding single-gift donors. Each one is worth less up front. But about 30% of them give a second gift. And when they cost roughly eight times less to acquire than a monthly donor, the trade can make sense. Judge a channel by what donors do after the first gift, not just by the first transaction. Your plan is a set of bets. Check them monthly. Change them when the economics change. How often do you move money between tactics during the year?
17
A failed credit card is not a donor saying goodbye. When a monthly donor's card expires or the number changes, the gift stops. Often the donor didn't decide anything. At two places I worked, we had a save process for child sponsors whose payments failed. It ran about 60 days: An email with a link to a page where they could update their card. No response? A phone call. Still nothing? A letter. Then a postcard. The moment a sponsor updated the payment, everything stopped. Many sponsors fixed it after the first email. If you have a monthly program and no process like this, you're losing donors who never meant to leave. What happens at your organization the day a monthly gift fails?
2
1
29
Want fewer emails from a nonprofit? Give them $1,000. It's an old joke in development circles. It's funny because it's true. "Protecting" bigger donors too often means going silent. Move them to a better communication stream, not to no stream at all.
1
27
He didn't have a giving goal in dollars. He had one in people: one million people with clean water in his lifetime. First, we had to earn back his trust. He'd had about three donor reps in three years. When we had yet another staff change, he asked a fair question: why can't you keep people, and why should I trust you? Rebuilding that trust took conversations and visits to the work. Along the way, we learned how he thought about giving. He was counting people, not dollars. He had brought his grown children and his company into the goal. So we changed how we reported to him. Instead of leading with what he had given, we tracked the estimated number of people who had clean water through the projects he funded. Report on the scorecard your donor is keeping. Your database may be keeping a different one. Three questions worth asking your top donors: What would you love your giving to accomplish in your lifetime? How will you know it's working? Who else in your family is part of this?
20
Someone once offered to name a beer after our work and donate the proceeds to us. It would have brought in money. We said no. The organization was part of a larger Christian ministry, and promoting alcohol didn't fit who we were. Every gift acceptance decision is really two questions. Will it raise money? Does it fit? A yes to the first doesn't answer the second. Values only mean something when they cost you something.
39
Our first year-end email fell flat. We could have kept sending the plan as written. Instead, we stopped and asked what was missing. Our best guess was a matching gift. So we found a small match and tested it in the next email. Response was significantly better. Then we went to board members and other key supporters and asked them to build a bigger year-end matching fund. That match carried us through the rest of the campaign. A campaign plan is a starting point. Once the campaign begins, it shouldn't become a prison. If your first email underperforms this December: Test one change in the next send. If it works, scale it. Ask your board to help solve the problem, not just to make their usual gifts. What's your plan if the first email misses?
12
One organization I worked with set a goal of a million new email leads in a year. It also resisted removing long-inactive names, because the board would see the list shrink. A big list and a valuable list are different things.
1
1
55
Our email platform reported 99% deliverability. Our year-end results said something was very wrong. One year at a place I worked, year-end giving came in well below expectations. The content was similar to the year before. Something was off. We worked through the usual suspects: timing, the giving climate, the creative. A few days into January, after the final numbers came in, I was convinced we had a deliverability problem. Our tech team investigated and couldn't find anything wrong. The platform said deliverability was around 99%. We tested a different platform anyway. It took time to set up, so the real answer came the following year-end. The new platform performed much better. "Delivered" meant the email had been accepted. It didn't mean the email landed where a donor would see it. Some of it may have been filtered into promotions folders or otherwise lost. That lesson cost us a lot of money. If your dashboard says everything is fine and your results say otherwise: 1. Believe the results first. 2. Check inbox placement, not just delivery. Send to a few test addresses at the major email providers and see where your emails land. 3. Compare opens and clicks by email provider. A drop concentrated in one provider is a clue. 4. If the pattern holds, test a different platform. Delivered and seen are two different numbers.
27