joeyshoe retweeted
What Abstract’s Shutdown Leaves Behind for Pudgy Penguins
I have supported @pudgypenguins since 2021. I loved the characters, felt a sense of belonging in the community, and believed in the future this team was building. I took part in that future through Abstract too, using the ecosystem and accumulating more than 11 million XP.
When the shutdown was announced, what I felt most was a sense of loss. What felt lost was the meaning of the time and effort behind those numbers, and part of the trust I had placed in this team. Even now, thinking about it brings back anger and a feeling of betrayal.
@AbstractChain is scheduled to shut down on December 15, 2026. Users must move their assets before then. Igloo has said it will focus its resources on Pudgy Penguins, the NFTs, and PENGU.
@LucaNetz said @IglooInc had funded Abstract for roughly 18 months and had absorbed losses in the tens of millions of dollars. The team cited stalled growth, thin liquidity, a limited DeFi ecosystem, and weak institutional adoption. These are the reasons management has given for its decision.
There are limits to funding a business without a credible path to sustainability. Launching a token without confidence in the demand behind it also carries a cost. I accept that shutting Abstract down may have been a financially rational decision for Igloo.
A question still remains: how will the time and contributions of the people who helped build it be acknowledged as it ends?
What concerns me most is Pudgy Penguins losing the trust of the people who might otherwise join its next venture.
Pudgy Penguins grew through its characters, products, and distribution, alongside the work of its community. People tried products early, created content, brought in new users, and made the brand part of their identity.
Running local communities, helping users, and explaining and supporting a project during difficult periods do not all show up in trading volume or revenue. Yet those activities help people understand and trust a brand.
When those contributors leave, their recommendations, explanations, and goodwill can leave with them. Quiet departures are especially hard to detect. People who stop reading announcements, buying products, or recommending the brand may not return simply because prices rise.
The XP system made this relationship more complicated. The official documentation described XP as a system for rewarding users and creators, connecting it to app usage, streaming, development, and community contributions. Badges and multipliers were also part of the participation structure.
That alone does not establish a guaranteed token allocation or cash payment. I accepted uncertainty, and I take responsibility for my spending and investment decisions.
The expectations and behavior encouraged by the system also deserve examination. When a team spends a long period measuring activity and assigning different levels of recognition to contributions, it should explain how those records and expectations will be handled when the project ends.
Hoping for a reward and caring about a project can coexist. Treating disappointed participants as people who only wanted a payout risks dismissing the relationships and contributions they built along the way.
How this shutdown is handled will shape the basis on which people trust this team in the future.
Good products and business results demonstrate a team’s ability to execute. Treating participants responsibly under difficult circumstances demonstrates whether it can also be trusted when things go wrong. Future users and developers will ask about a new venture’s prospects, and about what happens to their assets, time, and work if it fails.
Some people, including me, joined Abstract because they trusted Pudgy Penguins. If the brand’s reputation and leadership helped bring us in, that connection remains when we assess what happened afterward.
For those participants, the announcement that the company will refocus on Pudgy Penguins can be difficult to hear. For the business, it may reduce costs and allow the team to focus. For someone deeply involved in Abstract, it can feel like a declaration that the team is closing something they helped build and moving on. Explaining the benefits to the company does not resolve that sense of loss.
I do not believe this means Pudgy Penguins has no future. Its characters, products, and distribution business may still attract new customers and support growth.
But the company’s growth, the value of its NFTs and $PENGU, and the trust of existing supporters need to be assessed separately. A brand can grow while its digital assets struggle. Prices can recover without restoring relationships with people who left. Later success does not undo the experience of someone who already realized a loss and walked away.
For some, this may be a permanent departure. Even if the brand succeeds later, they have no obligation to return.
There are still things the team can do now.
First, explain the process that led to the shutdown. When did sustainability become a serious concern? What alternatives were considered? What changed the final decision? A meaningful account of the timeline, cost ranges, and causes of failure would help users evaluate that decision more accurately.
Second, support users and ecosystem projects through the transition. Address migration cases that general instructions do not resolve, and provide clear updates on outstanding issues. Preserving XP, roles, badges, and other activity records also has value. Commemorative SBTs or preserved records, however, do not resolve financial losses.
Third, I ask the team to reconsider a reasonable goodwill allocation for long-term contributors. I am not asking for every investment loss to be reimbursed. I am asking the team to assess what resources it can responsibly set aside to recognize sustained participation and contribution. If it decides against such support, it should explain what alternatives it considered and why it ruled them out.
The criteria should be transparent. Alongside XP and tiers, offchain contributions should also be considered. Fairness in the selection process matters as much as the size of the support.
I do not expect these steps to satisfy everyone or restore all the trust that has been lost. They could still demonstrate, through action, what the community’s past contributions mean to the team.
I can no longer join this team’s next venture on unconditional belief alone. Future trust will need clearer terms, closer scrutiny, and a record of promises being kept.
As someone who has supported Pudgy Penguins since 2021, I want to see actions that make that relationship possible again: acknowledging past contributions, handling the shutdown responsibly, and backing future claims with results.
Pudgy Penguins still has a future after Abstract.
Whether people like me want to be part of that future again will depend on how the people who stayed until the end are treated now.
Feels like Xmas day❤️💙 #throwtheballup
1
45
I also believed in Abstract because I believed in Pudgy💔
From Belonging to Heartbreak: Can We Huddle Again?
I joined @pudgypenguins in 2021. What began as a chance discovery of NFTs eventually became something much more than an investment.
After Luca acquired Pudgy, I watched him and the community build its success together. Whenever a crisis came, whales and passionate supporters stepped up. People promoted the brand, bought its products, and supported Pudgy as if it were their own business.
That united community was Pudgy’s greatest strength.
Luca emphasized that too. The community had made its success possible, and that success would be shared with the people who helped create it. At least, that was the Pudgy I believed in.
Walmart and Target launches. Major partnerships. A brand growing beyond anything many of us had imagined.
We watched it happen together. Luca became known as one of Web3’s most successful leaders, and simply wearing a Penguin PFP became a source of pride.
Then came the $PENGU airdrop.
To me, it meant more than receiving tokens. It felt like recognition of the years we had spent believing, contributing, and standing together.
I was happy. I felt that my faith had been justified.
That experience was why I believed in the next vision: @AbstractChain. I expected another chapter in which we would build something together and share in the value it created.
I wanted to give back to the team that had rewarded my faith. So I kept a substantial amount of $PENGU, held on to my Pudgy Penguins and @LilPudgys NFTs, and reinvested a significant amount of my assets into the Abstract ecosystem.
Of course, past rewards do not guarantee future rewards. But those expectations did not appear out of nowhere. They grew from Pudgy’s history and the messages the team had repeatedly communicated.
Many people who had watched PENGU’s success wanted to be part of that next journey too.
Some bought Penguins and changed their PFPs. They purchased merchandise, created content, used Abstract’s apps, promoted its ecosystem, and brought new people in.
Starting before launch, I spent nearly two years putting my time, money, and energy into that journey.
Yes, I hoped for rewards. But hoping to benefit from something you help build does not make your support or contributions insincere.
So what is left now for those who believed and stayed?
For me, there is still no clear answer as to whether my contributions will be recognized at all. Alongside the financial loss, there is the pain of realizing that a relationship I thought we were building together could end this way.
Some of the people who once supported Pudgy most passionately are now expressing the deepest anger.
Where did things go wrong?
On Inner Igloo, Luca spoke about feeling betrayed by people he trusted, and about the criticism directed at him whenever NFT and token prices fell.
I tried to understand his pain. The pressure of leading a community cannot have been easy to carry.
I understood the message to mean that genuine supporters, rather than farmers, would be recognized. I believed it.
We told ourselves:
“We are not farmers. We actually believe in this.”
Looking back, I think we accepted that distinction too easily. We believed that even if others left, staying until the end would show the sincerity of our support.
But staying until the end did not protect us.
Some of those who believed longer and participated more deeply were left with greater losses and deeper wounds.
I do not know whether the team saw all of us as farmers. I know that the distinction we trusted has brought us little comfort in the outcome.
Luca explained that winding down Abstract was an unavoidable decision to save Pudgy.
Perhaps that decision was necessary for the business. I understand that not every project can succeed.
But deciding to close a business and deciding how to treat the people who believed in it are two separate responsibilities.
If this was done to save Pudgy, why do people who followed Pudgy into Abstract now feel left outside the community they believed they belonged to?
Recently, Adam Weitsman’s (@AdamWeitsman) personal NFT purchases attracted attention. I understand how that news could help the market and give holders some encouragement.
But positive headlines do not resolve the hurt left by Abstract.
Pudgy’s next success and a respectful conclusion for Abstract’s supporters are both needed. Without that conclusion, some people will find it difficult to celebrate as they once would have.
I am one of them.
I still hold my Pudgy assets. I still do not want this relationship to end this way, or today’s anger to harden into permanent hostility.
Luca has shared his perspective on Inner Igloo. What I hope to see now is that explanation communicated clearly to the wider community, recognition of the people who contributed, and concrete action that gives that recognition meaning.
The weight of saying “community is everything” becomes clear not only when we celebrate success together, but also when we face failure together.
I believed in Abstract because I believed in Pudgy.
Now, the way Abstract has ended is shaking my belief in Pudgy too.
Can we huddle again? 🐧
I still hope we can.
But @LucaNetz and @IglooInc now need to give us that answer through their actions.
3
37
joeyshoe retweeted
It’s not the decision to shut down @AbstractChain that broke trust. Projects end, building is hard.
It’s how it was handled, and a pattern at @IglooInc beyond Abstract: big announcements, community commitment, then silence when things fall apart.
I still think it’s repairable 🧵👇
joeyshoe retweeted
Believers will say: We believe!
Haters will say: We hate it!
Marketers will say: Genius!
Id rather have 1 real friend on Abstract than 2 friends on Robinhood
Because at this point people still here basically monks. They survived silence, frustration, the “Abstract is dead” posts and months without the dopamine everyone in crypto is addicted to
No instant gratification. No constant announcements. No shiny new narrative every week. Somehow they’re still here - using the product, talking about it, believing in what’s being built and the people building it
People like that can go very far and that’s what makes the silence around Abstract interesting to me
Look at what some brands have done:
1. Snickers put Bounty bars inside Snickers wrappers. People started asking what the hell was going on. #SnickersGate exploded. Then Snickers revealed it was all a marketing stunt
2. BlackBerry once staged what looked like a real protest against Apple. People saw it, talked about it, built theories around it - then BlackBerry revealed they were behind it
3. Mr. Clean even “retired” after 68 years. People thought they were losing an icon. Then came the reveal: another marketing stunt
Different brands. Same mechanism:
Create uncertainty > let people talk > let them build their own theories > reveal the story
Now look at Abstract
Silence. Frustration. People leaving. People saying it’s dead. Everyone building their own theory about what’s happening
But one piece of news can turn months of silence into an atomic bomb of attention
And if that happens people who stayed through the silence will be the first ones there
Believers will say: We told you!
Haters will say: I knew it!
Marketers will say: Genius!
Read books - study brands and you won’t have to cry
I still believe ✳️💚
Any interaction with this post will confirm that you believe in @AbstractChain ✳️
3
44
joeyshoe retweeted
Moody just airdropped 170M Black Diamonds
to ALL Vault S1 players on Abstract.
The Vault S2 launches Mon 14th:
→ bigger starting prize pool
→ Daily Mission Rewards + Streak Rewards
→ 3X Black Diamonds in the shop
Check your balance 👇
RT @gucci_gcc: 🎁 OCH RINGBEARER GIVEAWAY 💍
Giving away 1 floor OCH Ringbearer, current floor: 0.64 ETH / $1,500 💰
👀 Rumored to grant WL f…
This quoted post is unavailable.
joeyshoe retweeted
The biggest platforms all own distribution.
Apple has the App Store.
Amazon has its marketplace.
Abstract has the Portal.
A place for users to discover everything being built within the ecosystem.
joeyshoe retweeted
🚨 TOMORROW · THE VAULT SEASON 01 FINALE
⚔️ New attacks close 3PM UTC
🏦 Season ends 4PM UTC
✅️ Moody Drops stays fully operational — keep stacking BD, parts & resources for S2.
🔔 Notifications ON for the Closing Ceremony.
Rewards. Surprises. Alpha.
joeyshoe retweeted
Abstract Portal is your gateway to everything happening on Abstract.
AGW users have driven 254M+ of Abstract’s 334M+ total transactions, accounting for more than 75% of all activity onchain.
How do you explore Abstract? 👇
joeyshoe retweeted
Reminder:
Pudgy Penguins is in continuous talks with the SEC, House of Representatives, Senators, and White House members to help shape the future of crypto in the USA. 🐧
It was great meeting with Commisioner @HesterPeirce and other members of the @SECGov today.
Very optimistic about the future of crypto.
joeyshoe retweeted
Consumer crypto is one of our industry’s greatest opportunities.
At Abstract, we’re building toward a future where apps, financial services, and digital assets bring the global economy onchain, for everyone, everywhere.



























