Joe Benjamin (@JoeBenjamin_) header
Joe Benjamin (@JoeBenjamin_) profile picture

Founder | RevPilots - B2B Sales Recruiting We connect companies w/vetted full time sales talent

Brooklyn, NY
Joined January 2010
A recognizable company on a resume does not mean a salesperson can build pipeline from scratch. When evaluating candidates, surface level filters often cause teams to miss great talent or hire the wrong person. A career gap or lack of direct industry experience is worth looking past if the candidate has a strong record selling to your exact buyers. Pay attention to how they engage during the process, like whether they ask to see a product demo or can honestly break down a lost deal. On the other hand, skip candidates who claim huge revenue numbers without explaining their personal contribution. And always pass on anyone willing to share confidential customer lists from a previous employer, because they will eventually do the same to you. True evaluation comes down to verifying how a rep actually sells rather than relying on resume shortcuts. What is your biggest green flag or instant dealbreaker when interviewing sales candidates?
2
80
Knowing when to train a struggling salesperson versus when to let them go comes down to one clear line. Most day to day performance issues are completely coachable. If a rep misses target in their first month, review their ramp plan before labeling them a failed hire. If they dominate conversations or discount at the first sign of hesitation, get into call recordings and coach the behavior. Even when reps delay deals into next quarter, you should look at whether your compensation structure is driving that choice. Skills, processes, and habits can all be taught. The moment to let someone go is when trust is broken. If a salesperson logs calls they never made or knowingly overpromises product features after warnings, coaching will not solve it. You can train skill, but you cannot fix dishonesty. Where do you draw the line between a coachable sales rep and an immediate parting of ways?
57
Your best salesperson might make a terrible sales manager. Being exceptional at closing deals does not mean someone knows how to coach others. When a rep struggles, strong individual closers tend to jump in and close the deal themselves. That might save the deal today, but the rep still needs help on the next call. Slow sales also does not automatically mean you need more salespeople. If your team is having plenty of conversations and nobody is buying, you have a conversion problem to fix first. When you do recruit, clear alignment on candidate profiles allows you to move quickly. Empty territories and leaderless teams lose revenue every day they sit vacant. You can be highly selective without letting your hiring process drag out. Which transition is harder to navigate, turning a top rep into a manager or fixing a broken conversion funnel?
98
Imagine training for a mission to the moon, losing your seat days before launch, and then working around the clock from the ground to bring that crew home safely. That happened to astronaut Ken Mattingly on Apollo 13. He missed the flight, but he stepped up when it mattered most to help save the mission. In sales hiring, quota attainment will never tell you whether someone is actually a great teammate. If you want to evaluate real character, ask candidates to walk you through a deal they helped someone else win. Have them explain what was stalling the deal and how they helped resolve the issue. Top performers do not just hit their own numbers, they actively elevate the reps around them. How do you evaluate whether a sales candidate is genuinely collaborative during an interview?
1
70
It is frustrating being told that you do not have the right experience, especially when you have spent years getting good at what you do. In 1993, a struggling tech giant hired an outsider from a food and consumer goods company to lead them. He was not the obvious industry choice, but he understood what enterprise buyers actually needed. Instead of breaking the business apart, he unified it and turned the company around. That does not mean hiring an outsider works every time. It means you must be clear on the exact problem you need fixed. If you need a leader to build a team from scratch, verify they have actually built one. If you need someone to close complex enterprise contracts, test how they run that specific deal cycle. Ten years in your industry means very little if they cannot execute the specific job in front of them. How much weight do you place on industry background versus proven execution when evaluating sales leaders?
44
Passing on a candidate because they have not worked at a well known company is a massive mistake. It is the equivalent of a professional sports team scouting players based only on their height. You look at the resume and see unfamiliar employers. So you pass on them without a second thought. But having a recognizable logo on a resume does not guarantee they can close deals in your environment. You need to stop evaluating where they used to work and start looking at what they can actually do. The real test is whether they can effectively sell to your specific customers. When you stop scouting with a tape measure, you start finding the overlooked top performers. What is the most unconventional background you have seen from a top performing sales rep?
48
The candidate from the well known company might actually be your riskier hire. Not because they’re bad at sales. Because you’re assuming the logo means they can sell in your environment. Ask what they actually had around them. A brand everyone recognized. SDRs filling the calendar. Messaging that was already proven. A defined territory. A process that was already built. None of that takes away from what they’ve accomplished. But at an early stage startup, you might need someone who can test messaging, build the process and still sell without any of that. That’s a different job. So don’t automatically pick the biggest logo. Figure out what they personally built versus what the company built for them. Then ask if they can succeed in the environment you’re actually hiring them into.
69
Your number one salesperson did everything you asked. They hit the number. They earned the respect. Now everyone expects the next title. But the promotion everyone expects can still be the wrong reward. And saying “not yet” can feel like you’re punishing success. That’s how companies walk into the Peter Principle. Selling proves someone can produce. Management is a different job. Can they coach a struggling rep? Can they diagnose someone else’s pipeline? Can they give tough feedback to a former peer? Most importantly, do other salespeople get better around them? Don’t make management the reward for being great at selling. Evaluate them for the job they’re about to do. Managing, not just selling, which they’ve already proven.
30
Revenue is flat, so the next move feels obvious. Hire a VP of Sales. But first, diagnose what’s actually stopping growth. It usually comes down to three things. Demand, the sales motion or leadership. If demand isn’t there, sales leadership can’t manufacture customers. If demand is there but the sales motion isn’t working, the fix is the motion, not a new title. If you have a working sales motion and a team that needs recruiting, coaching and forecasting, now you may have a leadership problem. Different constraints need different solutions. A VP of Sales should solve a sales leadership problem. Not become the default answer to flat revenue. Before you hire, ask one question. What is actually stopping us? Then hire for that problem.
39
If you’re hiring your first salesperson because you’re sick of selling, you might be handing them an impossible job. You’ve been carrying everything. Prospecting, demos, follow-ups, closing. So you want someone to take it all off your plate, and hiring feels like relief. But relief is not the same as readiness. Before you hand sales off, ask yourself if you can clearly explain who buys, why they buy, what objections come up and what gets them to pay. If you can’t answer those yet, your salesperson isn’t just selling. They’re figuring it out for you. You don’t need a perfect playbook. You do need a validated, repeatable sales process they can execute. Being tired of selling isn’t the hiring signal. Having something proven to hand off is.
1
1
56