
Former Video & Web guy (ThisHereVancouver), Current Econ & Data guy advocating for better social infrastructure (CoFounder @VisThinkCo), Future Coureur des bois
Langley, Metro Vancouver ๐จ๐ฆ
Joined January 2010
- Tweets14.3K
- Following355
- Followers681
- Likes112K
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
We actually have historical precedent for this.
When guilds collapsed, so did apprenticeships. Young craftsmen defected to factories, and societies lost the slow, embodied skill transmission that produced things like the stonework of Notre Dame. Productivity roseโbut craftsmanship thinned.
When big-box retailers displaced local hardware stores, we didnโt just lose small businesses. We lost succession. The โheir apparentโ who learned inventory, customers, and judgment over decades was replaced by a store manager trained to follow a system.
AI is doing something structurally similar.
As noted, entry-level QA, junior analyst roles, and โgrunt workโ werenโt inefficiencies โ they were discovery mechanisms. They let firms observe curiosity, resilience, judgment, and learning velocity under real conditions. Automating them removes the lowest rung of the ladder, not just the cost center.
The danger isnโt that AI replaces junior work.
Itโs that we eliminate the environments where raw talent proves itself.
If we donโt deliberately rebuild new apprenticeship structures (rotations, shadow systems, paid learning tracks, scoped responsibility sandboxes) weโll get short-term efficiency and long-term talent collapse.
History suggests the market wonโt fix this automatically.
When the on-ramp disappears, so does the next generation of masters.
The real question isnโt โhow do people get in?โ
Itโs whether employers are willing to re-create intentional paths for becoming excellent, rather than assuming excellence simply arrives fully formed.
H/t @INArteCarloDoss
One of the best engineers I ever hired failed the technical interviews.
We told him he didn't make it. He was crushed.
But there was something about him that impressed us, so we called him back and offered him an entry-level QA analyst job.
To his credit, he swallowed his pride, took the job, and then rapidly proved himself, working his way up to engineer and then technical manager in short order.
He became a superstar in my company.
My concern is that with the AI we have available today for software QA, THAT JOB MIGHT NOT EXIST ANYMORE. As AI improves, these entry-level "grunt work" positions will become more and more rare.
So how will the next generation get a foot in the door?
A little more background:
Our process for developers was brutal: multiple rounds, live coding, advanced homework.
He didnโt make it. But heโd showed curiosity and promise, so we gave him a shot doing manual testing and bug reports in Quality Assurance.
He took it seriously, absorbed feedback, acquired skills.
Within 2 years was promoted to developer. Then senior developer. Eventually, he was leading on some of our hardest technical challenges.
That path used to exist. But itโs disappearing.
Today, those training grounds are automated by AI.
The whole bottom rung is being ripped out.
How do young people with entry-level skills prove themselves today?
Since AI is eating the entry-level job, whatโs the new way in?
How can employers bring in raw talent and evaluate them?
How can people new to the workforce gain skills and confidence?
Would love to hear what you are doing!
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
I think every premier should actually require higher density zoning laws to be implemented at the municipal level
And then tell every mayor and city councillor who disagrees to pound sand
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
Housing sector is broken because development causes a lot of externalities (where costs are concentrated and benefits are diffuse) that canโt be internalized due to a bargaining failure between developers and locals residents.
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
Replying to @TheChaosWeeber
One cut I would support is have OAS clawback start at 40-50k and phased out by 80K not current 150k. It should be to help seniors struggling not rich seniors. Raising eligibility age would save long term but that would be unfair to do without at least a decade's warning.
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
Six storey, single stair 12 plex with shared rear yard.
On a single residential lot.
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
My Grand Theory of 2020s Politics is that countries that had a bad response to the Great Recession (or other stagnations) have fascist movements and that these manifest in gender polarization if there's a labor market gap between skilled (female) and unskilled (male) labor
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
Iโll also add that classical NDPers and progressive conservatives are natural allies. Tommy Douglas once said that he and John Diefenbaker could โmake a very fine country together.โ
So, I think everyone needs to take a moment for deep reflection on how we want politics to look.
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
I am a centrist on this. I'm open to new flags but you shouldn't start with the decision to do a redesign and then go through a process to come up with a new design.
New designs should be adopted when they cross a certain threshold of use naturally in the wild.
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
Credit where credit is due she really wants to build a train โ at Toronto, Ontario
Today I had the opportunity to take the Hayabusa high speed train from Tokyo to Sapporo. Topping out at 320 km/h, Shinkansen trains like these allow both locals and tourists to cross the country in just hours.
If Alberta had one we could get between Calgary and Edmonton in less than an hour!
We are currently developing a Passenger Rail Master Plan for the province. More information on what it might look like is available at alberta.ca/passenger-rail
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
It may surprise you to learn that community meeting attendees oppose new multifamily housing even when it's low-income housing rather than "luxury apartments for white frat boys". Usually, what they really care about is minimizing density, not maximizing affordability.
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
Replying to @leehaber @iamkennethchan
Here is the correct link: dailyhive.com/vancouver/metrโฆ
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
You know, I really want to consider the Conservatives, but as a tory-type, this statement is just the polar opposite of my values.
You do well, you give back more. It's a reciprocal obligation, not a punishment for success.
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
One of the big insights of Abundance is progressives need to stop fetishizing "the process."
A lot of prog lawmakers seem more proud of how many stakeholders they include and how many special interests they pay off than, y'know, how expensive the project is and how long it took.
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
Replying to @besttrousers @bendreyfuss
Like I'm sure there's lots of people feeling financial stress generally, but you can just say "percent of Americans stressed about their finances". โ at Medford, MA
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
Iโm so sick of their weaselly Authoritarian โyou didnโt say thank youโ bullshit.
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
Damn JJ I wonder if any writers or YouTubers contributed to a public narrative in the United States that Canada should be assimilated! โ at Toronto, Ontario
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
I refuse to hear economic illiteracy arguments from an economically illiterate opponent of carbon pricing, the most economically efficient way to reduce GHG emissions.
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
ipads have no soul but desktop computer is like a nervous horse and has the capacity for love
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
Josh "Tax+Spend" Messmer ๐โ๏ธ๐จ๐ฆ retweeted
Are you a cafe owner thatโs thinking about changing your coffee supplier?
Why not choose a Canadian company who shares your values . . . and is likely on the same government watch lists you're on.
Know a cafe owner who might be interested? Tag โem here.
#canpoli









































