Julie Batt retweeted
Replying to @Anosmic1
It's not draining the budget. The public school system is and it gives us <40% academic proficiency in return.
Julie Batt retweeted
I argued recently for a return to understanding Parent Responsibility when it comes to education decisions.
We should trust parents AND realize they are the ones who will be responsible for decisions regarding their children’s education. It’s not the governments job.
Julie Batt retweeted
I spent over an hour on the phone with @JenBerryHawes explaining that IDEA only gives access to a SWD's zoned district school (no open enrollment), that for decades families of SWD had often pulled a mistreated child out of their zoned public school to home-school them with zero assistance whatsoever out of pure desperation.
Oh and that the ESA program in AZ enrolls a higher percentage of SWD than the AZ public schools-19% vs. 14%. Also I think I explained that AZ public schools shamelessly discriminate against students with disabilities in open enrollment.
Oh also that ESAs give families options outside of attending private schools-that we have families in AZ for instance teaming up to hire their own teachers, that if they do do multivendor education that they would at least have resources to help them do it. ESAs are more than vouchers.
I mentioned that if what she wanted to do was to write a story of families complaining about not finding a spot in a private school, she could write that story, but it would be a huge oversimplification of a complex reality- ESAs are an incredibly useful innovation for many families of students with disabilities, but do not alone dry every tear or cure the world's pain.
They also don't harm anyone- districts have complained about not getting enough SPED $ for decades- so if a kid leaves with their share they can either spend more on the remaining kids, or do less of an xfer from gen ed to sped ed. Districts win either way, so long as the $ story they have been telling for 50 years is true.
Sometimes journalists seem to struggle with fitting a complex "this makes the world better but not perfect" narrative into a superhero versus supervillain comic book framework. I may have missed it, but none of the above information seemed to make it into the story, which instead went with the standard "GRRRRRR school choice STRONG BAD!!!!" predetermined narrative.
JBH did not ask me about the "toe hold" strategy also included in her story, but if she had, I would have noted that whether or not legislatures take any further action on choice is entirely up to the normal democratic process. Mississippi for instance passed an ESA for SWD about a decade ago but to date has taken no further action on private choice in the state. Others may choose to do the same in the future.
That's democracy for you, imo. ESAs for SWD stand on their own merits regardless.
propublica.org/article/schoo…
@HeritageOnEd @JasonBedrick @RobertEnlow @RonMatus1 @ClarkRimsza @jandrewclark @AdamPeshek @propublica @KathyVisser1 @LevesquePat @alexanderrusso @JebBush @rickhess99 @MrDanielBuck
Really?! Have you seen the hundreds of videos of lying signature gatherers? This wasn't luck. I realize you're new here, but ESAs ran well before Horne. The law already has what we need. With better leadership and technology, ESA would be amazing for both parents and taxpayers!
We Won … But We Also Got Lucky
This is the part I don’t want us to forget. We got lucky this time.
More than 420,000 signatures were submitted. For weeks, the future of one of America’s strongest school-choice programs depended on lawyers, signature challenges, county verification rates, and ultimately a decision from the Arizona Supreme Court.
That’s far too close for comfort.
We cannot repeatedly take a gamble this serious with our children’s education and simply hope everything works out in the end.
This is the second election cycle that they come attacking school choice.
We know that if we don't act in a solid and permanent manner, they will come back stronger, more organized and with more money.
Our next responsibility is to look beyond this victory and work strategically toward long-term protections for school choice in Arizona.
We need policies that strengthen the ESA program, preserve parental freedom, address legitimate concerns responsibly, and make it increasingly difficult for opponents to dismantle educational choice every election cycle.
Arizona families deserve that certainty.
1
51
Julie Batt retweeted
We love seeing headlines like this!
"Teachers unions suffered yet another deserved but embarrassing defeat this week. In Arizona, the state Supreme Court found that not only did unions fail to submit enough valid signatures to get their anti-school-choice proposition on the fall ballot, but they also broke the law by hiring felons to collect signatures."
Julie Batt retweeted
A HUGE win for parents and kids in Arizona! The anti-school choice ballot initiative is OFF the ballot after the anti-school choice union activists pushing the measure spent millions of out of state dollars and hired felons to gather a huge number of signatures. They ultimately fell short of the required number of signatures to qualify. The message is clear! Arizonans support school choice, and Arizona families will retain the freedom to educate their children in the environments that are right for them. Thank you to the Goldwater Institute, AZ Free Enterprise Club, plaintiff Jenny Clark and thousands of parents and supporters across Arizona for fighting in court to ensure that activists’ deceptive and unlawful attempts to make the ballot were rebuffed.
.
.
.
.
.
#AZLovesESAs
#ProtectESAs
#SchoolChoice
Julie Batt retweeted
What an honor to see this result after so many months of hard work from incredible school choice organizations in AZ !!! @GoldwaterInst and @azfec and our PAC - @AZlovesESAs !
🚨 BREAKING: “PROTECT EDUCATION ACT” FALLS SHORT
Based on the trial court’s ruling in Clark (@ClarkRimsza) v Fontes and county signature validity rates, the union-backed anti-ESA initiative does not have enough valid signatures to qualify for the November ballot.
The numbers:
➡️ Approx. 245,000 valid signatures
➡️ 255,949 required
➡️ More than 10,000 short
➡️ Nearly 70,000 signatures disqualified
➡️ More than $7 million spent by union backers
The @GoldwaterInst led the legal challenge, with the Arizona Free Enterprise Club and other school choice advocates working alongside them to review petitions and identify invalid signatures.
Many of the disqualified signatures were duplicates or were collected by legally ineligible circulators with serious criminal histories.
AZFEC President @ScotMussi said:
“This is a major victory for Arizona parents, students, and the integrity of our elections.”
The unions spent millions trying to dismantle school choice and still failed to collect enough lawful, valid signatures.
Arizona’s election laws apply to everyone.
#ProtectSchoolChoice #ProtectESAs #ArizonaParents #ElectionIntegrity
Julie Batt retweeted
BREAKING: Teachers unions FAILED to submit enough valid signatures to roll back school choice in Arizona.
They spent nearly $7 million to take away school choice and still failed.
The Arizona Supreme Court just issued a ruling that will knock the union's attack off the ballot.
Julie Batt retweeted
VICTORY! In a major victory for school choice, the Arizona Supreme Court has ruled that Proposition 212, the anti-school choice measure funded by out-of-state special interests, failed to turn in enough valid signatures to appear on this November’s ballot.
🤖 Made with AI
Julie Batt retweeted
VICTORY in Clark v. Fontes!!!
"Arizona’s universal school choice program is the most successful school choice effort in the country, serving over 100,000 kids across the state. Today’s court decision puts the final nail in the coffin..."
READ MORE: goldwaterinstitute.org/union…
YAY!! THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!
🚨 BREAKING: “PROTECT EDUCATION ACT” FALLS SHORT
Based on the trial court’s ruling in Clark (@ClarkRimsza) v Fontes and county signature validity rates, the union-backed anti-ESA initiative does not have enough valid signatures to qualify for the November ballot.
The numbers:
➡️ Approx. 245,000 valid signatures
➡️ 255,949 required
➡️ More than 10,000 short
➡️ Nearly 70,000 signatures disqualified
➡️ More than $7 million spent by union backers
The @GoldwaterInst led the legal challenge, with the Arizona Free Enterprise Club and other school choice advocates working alongside them to review petitions and identify invalid signatures.
Many of the disqualified signatures were duplicates or were collected by legally ineligible circulators with serious criminal histories.
AZFEC President @ScotMussi said:
“This is a major victory for Arizona parents, students, and the integrity of our elections.”
The unions spent millions trying to dismantle school choice and still failed to collect enough lawful, valid signatures.
Arizona’s election laws apply to everyone.
#ProtectSchoolChoice #ProtectESAs #ArizonaParents #ElectionIntegrity
Julie Batt retweeted
Out-of-state special interests are spending millions to buy their way onto Arizona's ballot.
Today, Goldwater filed suit challenging the invalid signatures submitted for this anti-school choice measure.
We will keep fighting to defend the rights of Arizona families and protect students from reckless attacks on their educational freedoms.
goldwaterinstitute.org/goldw…
Julie Batt retweeted
It gets worse. @SteveMontenegro @EslyMont @Tommy_USA @AZGovAffairs @azedschools @SchoolChoiceNow have a hired lobbyist who might be Gretchen Jacobs, keeping the FOIA hidden. This needs a legislative investigation. @CraigHarrisNews @GarretLewis @Rach_IC @ClarkRimsza @PamKirby
🚨🚨🚨🚨This is the best takedown I've ever seen of the bogus criticism directed towards Arizona's wonderful Empowerment Savings Accounts (ESAs) for education. Under RINO Superintendent of Schools Tom Horne, everything is amplified as if parents are supposedly engaging in fraud with their purchases - yet Horne WILL NOT RELEASE the internal rules on ESAs to the public, so parents don't know what are acceptable purchases and what are not! 🤬🤬🤬🤬Makes it easy to nab them and have the fake news embellish the stories. The fact is, the items a handful of rogue actors attempted to purchase were CAUGHT, and the fraud rate in the program is miniscule, far lower than other state agencies! This is a massive violation of law not to release the rules, it's a PUBLIC RECORD! Not doing so sets parents up for entrapment! This is why @KimberlyYeeAZ is going to defeat Horne in the election on Tuesday. Please spread far and wide so Arizonans know the TRUTH! This makes me so angry, my sister was homeschooled the entire way since she had dyslexia and ADHD. Arizona's expansive ESA program is the best in the country rivaling Florida's.🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
CC: @DeAngelisCorey @LIESofSOSaz @JakeHoffmanAZ
---
The Manufactured Crisis: Inside the ESA Compliance Trap
By David Thompson
Executive Summary: The Invisible Extortion of Arizona Families
This is not a debate about school choice; it is a clinical look at institutional greed. While the public is manipulated into endless, angry squabbling over sensationalized headlines, a quiet and predatory scheme is being executed inside our state apparatus. The Arizona Department of Education, under the direction of Superintendent Tom Horne, is running a deliberate compliance trap, withholding the very rules parents are required to follow, manufacturing administrative failures, and weaponizing the resulting confusion to extort the Legislature for larger budgets and more personnel. Our families are not failing the system; a protected bureaucratic cartel is intentionally forcing them to fail because parent mistakes have become the department's most lucrative cash cow.
I. The Illusion of Rampant Fraud
For months, Arizona headlines have blared a consistent, panicked refrain: the universal Empowerment Scholarship Account (ESA) program is a wild, unmonitored frontier leaking taxpayer dollars to luxury items and blatant fraud. Critics point to portfolios of flagged transactions, rejected receipts, and bizarre purchase attempts as absolute proof that parents cannot be trusted with educational autonomy.
It is a compelling narrative, but it relies entirely on a fundamental distortion of how accountability systems actually function.
In the world of auditing, there is a vast structural gulf between an unallowable expense, such as administrative paperwork errors, and criminal fraud. When a headline screams that a parent attempted to buy Disneyland tickets or an unauthorized electronic device, they routinely omit the most critical punchline of the story: the purchase was flagged, reviewed, and denied. No taxpayer money was spent.
To claim that a blocked, unapproved receipt represents a failure of the system is the height of logical absurdity. If a bank’s security filter flags and rejects an invalid check at the counter, the bank didn't just get robbed; the system worked exactly as designed. The paper trail exists precisely because the guardrails are functioning.
Independent data bears this out. Statistically, actual flagrant criminal abuse like deliberate forgery, double enrollment, or identity theft represents a fraction of one percent of ESA transactions. The overwhelming majority of what the state and media label "non-compliance" consists of administrative noise: a harried parent purchasing a standard, legitimate textbook or laptop but omitting a date on a receipt, or failing to upload an explicit curriculum sheet to justify the tool.
Yet, instead of refining the system to help families navigate these clerical technicalities, Superintendent Tom Horne's Arizona Department of Education (ADE) chose a different path for the 2025–2026 cycle. They weaponized the handbook.
II. The Invisible Rulebook
The latest ESA Parent Handbook reads less like an educational guide and more like a compliance trap. It is peppered with aggressive warnings, threatening families with immediate account suspension, retroactive repayment demands, and criminal prosecution. But the real trap isn't the severity of the penalties; it is the phantom standard by which they are enforced.
Throughout the text, the Department explicitly states that parents will be penalized for violating unlisted "program rules" and internal "program policies,” regulations that do not appear anywhere within the public document itself.
As a citizen and a systems analyst, this immediate red flag prompted a simple, necessary question: How can a parent be expected to maintain flawless compliance with a rulebook the state refuses to publish?
To find out, I submitted a formal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request demanding the release of these hidden, internal guidelines. If parents were going to face bureaucratic retribution and public shaming based on these shadow rules, they had a legal right to read them.
The department’s response to a transparent demand for the rules of engagement? Dead silence. Weeks of phone messages and emails went completely unanswered, disappearing into an administrative black hole.
III. The Watchdog’s Surrender
Refusing to accept being stonewalled, I escalated the matter to the Arizona State Ombudsman’s Office—the state’s official watchdog meant to ensure agency transparency. While polite, their office offered the standard institutional excuse of "overburdened workers" and tried to provide an outside interpretation rather than forcing the department to produce the actual rules.
When pressed for concrete answers, Ombudsman Frank Rutledge issued a written response that effectively gave away the entire game. He admitted to me in writing:
"A.R.S. 15-2402(4) lists the categories of approved/acceptable items in which ESA funds can be spent. I understand that not all items a student may need are identified on this list, so parents need to make a judgment call... ask yourself whether you can defend the validity of the purchase to the Arizona State Board of Education if questioned. If you can, then there shouldn’t be a problem with the purchase. Avoid questionable purchases."
Let that sink in. Restated, the state’s official stance is literally for parents to read the raw Arizona Revised Statutes, make a "judgment call," cross their fingers, and hope they can successfully defend themselves later before a hostile review process.
How, exactly, is a harried parent of several children at various stages of development supposed to "avoid questionable purchases" when the Department explicitly refuses to share its own internal interpretation of what is questionable? This is an administrative trap: parents are forced to guess, and if they guess wrong, then they face prosecution based on rules that have been hidden away.
IV. The Smoking Gun: Funding the Trap
When the Ombudsman’s office joined the ADE in dead silence (yes, I was stonewalled again), I escalated the matter to State Representative Way’s office. It was through this legislative inquiry that the final, cynical piece of the puzzle fell into place.
I was routed to a contracted lobbyist representing the Arizona Department of Education. In a series of candid conversations, the underlying business model of this entire crisis was laid bare.
First, she confirmed what my FOIA had been trying to establish: the internal, definitive rules defining what constitutes fraud absolutely exist. Second, she explained exactly why Tom Horne's department refuses to publish them for the families they govern: releasing them, she stated verbally, would "let the cat out of the bag."
When pushed further on why transparency was such a threat, she deployed a well-worn local political buzzword, claiming that publishing the exact guidelines would provide a tool for "bad actors" to use against the department.
Let's translate that out of political-speak. In our current local landscape, "bad actor" is a hollow label slammed onto any taxpaying citizen who dares to disagree with an agency or hold them to a legal standard. The department isn't hiding the rules to protect taxpayers from criminals; they are hiding the rules to protect themselves from accountability. If parents don't have a copy of the definitive regulations, they can never prove the department made a mistake.
Meanwhile, the lobbyist made her primary objective clear: she was actively using the resulting "compliance crisis" to lobby the Arizona Legislature to secure more money and more personnel for the Department.
And there it is: the closed-loop cycle of bureaucratic empire-building.
The Department deliberately keeps its compliance rules secret. Because the rules are kept secret, well-meaning parents inevitably make administrative mistakes. The Department and the media then point to those mistakes to manufacture a public panic over "widespread parent fraud." Finally, the Department hires a lobbyist to weaponize that exact manufactured panic, going to the Legislature to demand more taxpayer funding and more staff to police the very confusion they created.
V. Filling the Regulatory Vacuum
When a state agency deliberately creates a vacuum of clear, public regulations, it leaves a chaotic void. Nature abhors a vacuum, and so does politics. Because the Department of Education refuses to provide transparent, standardized guardrails, outside political factions stepped into the empty space to write their own rules. The direct result of this engineered confusion has been playing out right now on our street corners, where citizen initiatives were launched to aggressively circulate petitions for signatures to make the November ballot.
Both measures claimed they existed to bring "accountability" to the ESA program. In reality, both are deeply flawed overcorrections responding to a manufactured crisis.
The first initiative, the teacher's union-backed "Protect Education Act," attempts to fix the system with an axe. It reacts to the phantom media narrative by trying to structurally roll back the program entirely—introducing strict household income caps and permanently seizing any unspent funds at the end of the fiscal year. It ignores the reality that a child’s educational costs naturally scale as they grow and instead forces families into a classic, wasteful "use-it-or-lose-it" trap. This clawback of funds moves money into the state general fund and relieves stress on the conventional school budgets. It no longer serves individual learning at the family level; instead, itfeeds the monster that has caused the chaos.
The second initiative, the "Reform and Accountability Act" (promoted by Fortify AZ), took the opposite approach but introduced its own brand of bureaucratic bloat. To protect universal access, it sought to mandate a rigid, state-managed online marketplace where all purchases must be pre-cleared through a state checkout portal, while simultaneously slapping mandatory standardized testing onto homeschooled students who use the funds. This marketplace is a prime target for graft and corruption. By forcing parents to use one list of vendors, it creates a monopoly that can use kickbacks and coercion to inflate costs. Standardized testing has been a mantra for so long that we tend to accept it; however, independent data shows that such testing results in "teaching the test" instead of actual mastery of the subject matter. Our children suffer in later life as the actual education level of our country drops based on worldwide comparisons.
In a telling twist, the backers of Fortify AZ have just abruptly pulled their initiative from the race and called off their petition drive. The move exposes the cynical gamesmanship at play: the initiative was never meant to be a genuine solution, but rather a strategic piece of leverage in a high-stakes legislative poker game. When a backroom deal between legislative leaders and the teachers' union collapsed on the final night of budget negotiations, Fortify AZ's leverage evaporated. Realizing that running two competing, bloated measures would only fracture the base and confuse voters, the big-money donors abruptly pulled the plug.
Neither of these frantic measures would be necessary if Superintendent Horne simply opened his department's drawers and published the compliance guidelines they already possess. Instead, the state's calculated silence has thrown the public into a state of argumentative chaos, forcing voters to navigate a minefield of institutional clawbacks and collapsed political bluffs.
VI. Conclusion: Reclaiming the Narrative
The public is being taken for a ride. The loud, argumentative chaos dominating our news cycle isn't a reflection of parental dishonesty—it is the engineered output of a bureaucracy farming its own system for budget increases.
Real accountability is a two-way street. If the state expects parents to be flawless, transparent stewards of their children's education, then the state must be a flawless, transparent provider of the rules. Forcing parents into a "use it or lose it" model or demanding compliance with a shadow rulebook won't fix education. It just replaces parental autonomy with bureaucratic empire-building.
It is time to pull the cat out of the bag, publish the rules, and trust Arizona parents to manage their families' futures.
Julie Batt retweeted
Release the FOIA documents. Stop withholding the internal ESA guidance parents are expected to follow. What are you hiding, @RealTomHorne? Arizona families deserve transparency. @Tommy_USA is this is your lobbyist? @Rach_IC @DeAngelisCorey @JasonBedrick @JakeHoffmanAZ @Jellenne
🚨🚨🚨🚨This is the best takedown I've ever seen of the bogus criticism directed towards Arizona's wonderful Empowerment Savings Accounts (ESAs) for education. Under RINO Superintendent of Schools Tom Horne, everything is amplified as if parents are supposedly engaging in fraud with their purchases - yet Horne WILL NOT RELEASE the internal rules on ESAs to the public, so parents don't know what are acceptable purchases and what are not! 🤬🤬🤬🤬Makes it easy to nab them and have the fake news embellish the stories. The fact is, the items a handful of rogue actors attempted to purchase were CAUGHT, and the fraud rate in the program is miniscule, far lower than other state agencies! This is a massive violation of law not to release the rules, it's a PUBLIC RECORD! Not doing so sets parents up for entrapment! This is why @KimberlyYeeAZ is going to defeat Horne in the election on Tuesday. Please spread far and wide so Arizonans know the TRUTH! This makes me so angry, my sister was homeschooled the entire way since she had dyslexia and ADHD. Arizona's expansive ESA program is the best in the country rivaling Florida's.🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
CC: @DeAngelisCorey @LIESofSOSaz @JakeHoffmanAZ
---
The Manufactured Crisis: Inside the ESA Compliance Trap
By David Thompson
Executive Summary: The Invisible Extortion of Arizona Families
This is not a debate about school choice; it is a clinical look at institutional greed. While the public is manipulated into endless, angry squabbling over sensationalized headlines, a quiet and predatory scheme is being executed inside our state apparatus. The Arizona Department of Education, under the direction of Superintendent Tom Horne, is running a deliberate compliance trap, withholding the very rules parents are required to follow, manufacturing administrative failures, and weaponizing the resulting confusion to extort the Legislature for larger budgets and more personnel. Our families are not failing the system; a protected bureaucratic cartel is intentionally forcing them to fail because parent mistakes have become the department's most lucrative cash cow.
I. The Illusion of Rampant Fraud
For months, Arizona headlines have blared a consistent, panicked refrain: the universal Empowerment Scholarship Account (ESA) program is a wild, unmonitored frontier leaking taxpayer dollars to luxury items and blatant fraud. Critics point to portfolios of flagged transactions, rejected receipts, and bizarre purchase attempts as absolute proof that parents cannot be trusted with educational autonomy.
It is a compelling narrative, but it relies entirely on a fundamental distortion of how accountability systems actually function.
In the world of auditing, there is a vast structural gulf between an unallowable expense, such as administrative paperwork errors, and criminal fraud. When a headline screams that a parent attempted to buy Disneyland tickets or an unauthorized electronic device, they routinely omit the most critical punchline of the story: the purchase was flagged, reviewed, and denied. No taxpayer money was spent.
To claim that a blocked, unapproved receipt represents a failure of the system is the height of logical absurdity. If a bank’s security filter flags and rejects an invalid check at the counter, the bank didn't just get robbed; the system worked exactly as designed. The paper trail exists precisely because the guardrails are functioning.
Independent data bears this out. Statistically, actual flagrant criminal abuse like deliberate forgery, double enrollment, or identity theft represents a fraction of one percent of ESA transactions. The overwhelming majority of what the state and media label "non-compliance" consists of administrative noise: a harried parent purchasing a standard, legitimate textbook or laptop but omitting a date on a receipt, or failing to upload an explicit curriculum sheet to justify the tool.
Yet, instead of refining the system to help families navigate these clerical technicalities, Superintendent Tom Horne's Arizona Department of Education (ADE) chose a different path for the 2025–2026 cycle. They weaponized the handbook.
II. The Invisible Rulebook
The latest ESA Parent Handbook reads less like an educational guide and more like a compliance trap. It is peppered with aggressive warnings, threatening families with immediate account suspension, retroactive repayment demands, and criminal prosecution. But the real trap isn't the severity of the penalties; it is the phantom standard by which they are enforced.
Throughout the text, the Department explicitly states that parents will be penalized for violating unlisted "program rules" and internal "program policies,” regulations that do not appear anywhere within the public document itself.
As a citizen and a systems analyst, this immediate red flag prompted a simple, necessary question: How can a parent be expected to maintain flawless compliance with a rulebook the state refuses to publish?
To find out, I submitted a formal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request demanding the release of these hidden, internal guidelines. If parents were going to face bureaucratic retribution and public shaming based on these shadow rules, they had a legal right to read them.
The department’s response to a transparent demand for the rules of engagement? Dead silence. Weeks of phone messages and emails went completely unanswered, disappearing into an administrative black hole.
III. The Watchdog’s Surrender
Refusing to accept being stonewalled, I escalated the matter to the Arizona State Ombudsman’s Office—the state’s official watchdog meant to ensure agency transparency. While polite, their office offered the standard institutional excuse of "overburdened workers" and tried to provide an outside interpretation rather than forcing the department to produce the actual rules.
When pressed for concrete answers, Ombudsman Frank Rutledge issued a written response that effectively gave away the entire game. He admitted to me in writing:
"A.R.S. 15-2402(4) lists the categories of approved/acceptable items in which ESA funds can be spent. I understand that not all items a student may need are identified on this list, so parents need to make a judgment call... ask yourself whether you can defend the validity of the purchase to the Arizona State Board of Education if questioned. If you can, then there shouldn’t be a problem with the purchase. Avoid questionable purchases."
Let that sink in. Restated, the state’s official stance is literally for parents to read the raw Arizona Revised Statutes, make a "judgment call," cross their fingers, and hope they can successfully defend themselves later before a hostile review process.
How, exactly, is a harried parent of several children at various stages of development supposed to "avoid questionable purchases" when the Department explicitly refuses to share its own internal interpretation of what is questionable? This is an administrative trap: parents are forced to guess, and if they guess wrong, then they face prosecution based on rules that have been hidden away.
IV. The Smoking Gun: Funding the Trap
When the Ombudsman’s office joined the ADE in dead silence (yes, I was stonewalled again), I escalated the matter to State Representative Way’s office. It was through this legislative inquiry that the final, cynical piece of the puzzle fell into place.
I was routed to a contracted lobbyist representing the Arizona Department of Education. In a series of candid conversations, the underlying business model of this entire crisis was laid bare.
First, she confirmed what my FOIA had been trying to establish: the internal, definitive rules defining what constitutes fraud absolutely exist. Second, she explained exactly why Tom Horne's department refuses to publish them for the families they govern: releasing them, she stated verbally, would "let the cat out of the bag."
When pushed further on why transparency was such a threat, she deployed a well-worn local political buzzword, claiming that publishing the exact guidelines would provide a tool for "bad actors" to use against the department.
Let's translate that out of political-speak. In our current local landscape, "bad actor" is a hollow label slammed onto any taxpaying citizen who dares to disagree with an agency or hold them to a legal standard. The department isn't hiding the rules to protect taxpayers from criminals; they are hiding the rules to protect themselves from accountability. If parents don't have a copy of the definitive regulations, they can never prove the department made a mistake.
Meanwhile, the lobbyist made her primary objective clear: she was actively using the resulting "compliance crisis" to lobby the Arizona Legislature to secure more money and more personnel for the Department.
And there it is: the closed-loop cycle of bureaucratic empire-building.
The Department deliberately keeps its compliance rules secret. Because the rules are kept secret, well-meaning parents inevitably make administrative mistakes. The Department and the media then point to those mistakes to manufacture a public panic over "widespread parent fraud." Finally, the Department hires a lobbyist to weaponize that exact manufactured panic, going to the Legislature to demand more taxpayer funding and more staff to police the very confusion they created.
V. Filling the Regulatory Vacuum
When a state agency deliberately creates a vacuum of clear, public regulations, it leaves a chaotic void. Nature abhors a vacuum, and so does politics. Because the Department of Education refuses to provide transparent, standardized guardrails, outside political factions stepped into the empty space to write their own rules. The direct result of this engineered confusion has been playing out right now on our street corners, where citizen initiatives were launched to aggressively circulate petitions for signatures to make the November ballot.
Both measures claimed they existed to bring "accountability" to the ESA program. In reality, both are deeply flawed overcorrections responding to a manufactured crisis.
The first initiative, the teacher's union-backed "Protect Education Act," attempts to fix the system with an axe. It reacts to the phantom media narrative by trying to structurally roll back the program entirely—introducing strict household income caps and permanently seizing any unspent funds at the end of the fiscal year. It ignores the reality that a child’s educational costs naturally scale as they grow and instead forces families into a classic, wasteful "use-it-or-lose-it" trap. This clawback of funds moves money into the state general fund and relieves stress on the conventional school budgets. It no longer serves individual learning at the family level; instead, itfeeds the monster that has caused the chaos.
The second initiative, the "Reform and Accountability Act" (promoted by Fortify AZ), took the opposite approach but introduced its own brand of bureaucratic bloat. To protect universal access, it sought to mandate a rigid, state-managed online marketplace where all purchases must be pre-cleared through a state checkout portal, while simultaneously slapping mandatory standardized testing onto homeschooled students who use the funds. This marketplace is a prime target for graft and corruption. By forcing parents to use one list of vendors, it creates a monopoly that can use kickbacks and coercion to inflate costs. Standardized testing has been a mantra for so long that we tend to accept it; however, independent data shows that such testing results in "teaching the test" instead of actual mastery of the subject matter. Our children suffer in later life as the actual education level of our country drops based on worldwide comparisons.
In a telling twist, the backers of Fortify AZ have just abruptly pulled their initiative from the race and called off their petition drive. The move exposes the cynical gamesmanship at play: the initiative was never meant to be a genuine solution, but rather a strategic piece of leverage in a high-stakes legislative poker game. When a backroom deal between legislative leaders and the teachers' union collapsed on the final night of budget negotiations, Fortify AZ's leverage evaporated. Realizing that running two competing, bloated measures would only fracture the base and confuse voters, the big-money donors abruptly pulled the plug.
Neither of these frantic measures would be necessary if Superintendent Horne simply opened his department's drawers and published the compliance guidelines they already possess. Instead, the state's calculated silence has thrown the public into a state of argumentative chaos, forcing voters to navigate a minefield of institutional clawbacks and collapsed political bluffs.
VI. Conclusion: Reclaiming the Narrative
The public is being taken for a ride. The loud, argumentative chaos dominating our news cycle isn't a reflection of parental dishonesty—it is the engineered output of a bureaucracy farming its own system for budget increases.
Real accountability is a two-way street. If the state expects parents to be flawless, transparent stewards of their children's education, then the state must be a flawless, transparent provider of the rules. Forcing parents into a "use it or lose it" model or demanding compliance with a shadow rulebook won't fix education. It just replaces parental autonomy with bureaucratic empire-building.
It is time to pull the cat out of the bag, publish the rules, and trust Arizona parents to manage their families' futures.
Julie Batt retweeted
And while you're at it, please find out why ESA families are being locked out of their student accounts for 12+ months for "audit" with zero communication from ADE. This is a huge barrier to education for those students! Audits need to be completed quickly with communication at all steps with the account holders.
Replying to @LIESofSOSaz
@CraigHarrisNews you’re so worried about ESA fraud you should investigate why @RealTomHorne isn’t releasing the rules. The @azedschools refuses to release the FOIA request. @MatthewGress @AZAGMayes @AzCapitolTimes @OmbudsmanAZ @MichaelWayAZ @LisaFink4AZ @RealMarkFinchem @AZGOP
Julie Batt retweeted
🚨 ESA parents, this should outrage you.
@RealTomHorne and @azedschools expect families to follow rules they refuse to make public.
Why are they hiding them? Read this. Share it. Demand answers.
@DeAngelisCorey @JasonBedrick @CraigHarrisNews @votewarren @KimberlyYeeAZ @abc15
🚨🚨🚨🚨This is the best takedown I've ever seen of the bogus criticism directed towards Arizona's wonderful Empowerment Savings Accounts (ESAs) for education. Under RINO Superintendent of Schools Tom Horne, everything is amplified as if parents are supposedly engaging in fraud with their purchases - yet Horne WILL NOT RELEASE the internal rules on ESAs to the public, so parents don't know what are acceptable purchases and what are not! 🤬🤬🤬🤬Makes it easy to nab them and have the fake news embellish the stories. The fact is, the items a handful of rogue actors attempted to purchase were CAUGHT, and the fraud rate in the program is miniscule, far lower than other state agencies! This is a massive violation of law not to release the rules, it's a PUBLIC RECORD! Not doing so sets parents up for entrapment! This is why @KimberlyYeeAZ is going to defeat Horne in the election on Tuesday. Please spread far and wide so Arizonans know the TRUTH! This makes me so angry, my sister was homeschooled the entire way since she had dyslexia and ADHD. Arizona's expansive ESA program is the best in the country rivaling Florida's.🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
CC: @DeAngelisCorey @LIESofSOSaz @JakeHoffmanAZ
---
The Manufactured Crisis: Inside the ESA Compliance Trap
By David Thompson
Executive Summary: The Invisible Extortion of Arizona Families
This is not a debate about school choice; it is a clinical look at institutional greed. While the public is manipulated into endless, angry squabbling over sensationalized headlines, a quiet and predatory scheme is being executed inside our state apparatus. The Arizona Department of Education, under the direction of Superintendent Tom Horne, is running a deliberate compliance trap, withholding the very rules parents are required to follow, manufacturing administrative failures, and weaponizing the resulting confusion to extort the Legislature for larger budgets and more personnel. Our families are not failing the system; a protected bureaucratic cartel is intentionally forcing them to fail because parent mistakes have become the department's most lucrative cash cow.
I. The Illusion of Rampant Fraud
For months, Arizona headlines have blared a consistent, panicked refrain: the universal Empowerment Scholarship Account (ESA) program is a wild, unmonitored frontier leaking taxpayer dollars to luxury items and blatant fraud. Critics point to portfolios of flagged transactions, rejected receipts, and bizarre purchase attempts as absolute proof that parents cannot be trusted with educational autonomy.
It is a compelling narrative, but it relies entirely on a fundamental distortion of how accountability systems actually function.
In the world of auditing, there is a vast structural gulf between an unallowable expense, such as administrative paperwork errors, and criminal fraud. When a headline screams that a parent attempted to buy Disneyland tickets or an unauthorized electronic device, they routinely omit the most critical punchline of the story: the purchase was flagged, reviewed, and denied. No taxpayer money was spent.
To claim that a blocked, unapproved receipt represents a failure of the system is the height of logical absurdity. If a bank’s security filter flags and rejects an invalid check at the counter, the bank didn't just get robbed; the system worked exactly as designed. The paper trail exists precisely because the guardrails are functioning.
Independent data bears this out. Statistically, actual flagrant criminal abuse like deliberate forgery, double enrollment, or identity theft represents a fraction of one percent of ESA transactions. The overwhelming majority of what the state and media label "non-compliance" consists of administrative noise: a harried parent purchasing a standard, legitimate textbook or laptop but omitting a date on a receipt, or failing to upload an explicit curriculum sheet to justify the tool.
Yet, instead of refining the system to help families navigate these clerical technicalities, Superintendent Tom Horne's Arizona Department of Education (ADE) chose a different path for the 2025–2026 cycle. They weaponized the handbook.
II. The Invisible Rulebook
The latest ESA Parent Handbook reads less like an educational guide and more like a compliance trap. It is peppered with aggressive warnings, threatening families with immediate account suspension, retroactive repayment demands, and criminal prosecution. But the real trap isn't the severity of the penalties; it is the phantom standard by which they are enforced.
Throughout the text, the Department explicitly states that parents will be penalized for violating unlisted "program rules" and internal "program policies,” regulations that do not appear anywhere within the public document itself.
As a citizen and a systems analyst, this immediate red flag prompted a simple, necessary question: How can a parent be expected to maintain flawless compliance with a rulebook the state refuses to publish?
To find out, I submitted a formal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request demanding the release of these hidden, internal guidelines. If parents were going to face bureaucratic retribution and public shaming based on these shadow rules, they had a legal right to read them.
The department’s response to a transparent demand for the rules of engagement? Dead silence. Weeks of phone messages and emails went completely unanswered, disappearing into an administrative black hole.
III. The Watchdog’s Surrender
Refusing to accept being stonewalled, I escalated the matter to the Arizona State Ombudsman’s Office—the state’s official watchdog meant to ensure agency transparency. While polite, their office offered the standard institutional excuse of "overburdened workers" and tried to provide an outside interpretation rather than forcing the department to produce the actual rules.
When pressed for concrete answers, Ombudsman Frank Rutledge issued a written response that effectively gave away the entire game. He admitted to me in writing:
"A.R.S. 15-2402(4) lists the categories of approved/acceptable items in which ESA funds can be spent. I understand that not all items a student may need are identified on this list, so parents need to make a judgment call... ask yourself whether you can defend the validity of the purchase to the Arizona State Board of Education if questioned. If you can, then there shouldn’t be a problem with the purchase. Avoid questionable purchases."
Let that sink in. Restated, the state’s official stance is literally for parents to read the raw Arizona Revised Statutes, make a "judgment call," cross their fingers, and hope they can successfully defend themselves later before a hostile review process.
How, exactly, is a harried parent of several children at various stages of development supposed to "avoid questionable purchases" when the Department explicitly refuses to share its own internal interpretation of what is questionable? This is an administrative trap: parents are forced to guess, and if they guess wrong, then they face prosecution based on rules that have been hidden away.
IV. The Smoking Gun: Funding the Trap
When the Ombudsman’s office joined the ADE in dead silence (yes, I was stonewalled again), I escalated the matter to State Representative Way’s office. It was through this legislative inquiry that the final, cynical piece of the puzzle fell into place.
I was routed to a contracted lobbyist representing the Arizona Department of Education. In a series of candid conversations, the underlying business model of this entire crisis was laid bare.
First, she confirmed what my FOIA had been trying to establish: the internal, definitive rules defining what constitutes fraud absolutely exist. Second, she explained exactly why Tom Horne's department refuses to publish them for the families they govern: releasing them, she stated verbally, would "let the cat out of the bag."
When pushed further on why transparency was such a threat, she deployed a well-worn local political buzzword, claiming that publishing the exact guidelines would provide a tool for "bad actors" to use against the department.
Let's translate that out of political-speak. In our current local landscape, "bad actor" is a hollow label slammed onto any taxpaying citizen who dares to disagree with an agency or hold them to a legal standard. The department isn't hiding the rules to protect taxpayers from criminals; they are hiding the rules to protect themselves from accountability. If parents don't have a copy of the definitive regulations, they can never prove the department made a mistake.
Meanwhile, the lobbyist made her primary objective clear: she was actively using the resulting "compliance crisis" to lobby the Arizona Legislature to secure more money and more personnel for the Department.
And there it is: the closed-loop cycle of bureaucratic empire-building.
The Department deliberately keeps its compliance rules secret. Because the rules are kept secret, well-meaning parents inevitably make administrative mistakes. The Department and the media then point to those mistakes to manufacture a public panic over "widespread parent fraud." Finally, the Department hires a lobbyist to weaponize that exact manufactured panic, going to the Legislature to demand more taxpayer funding and more staff to police the very confusion they created.
V. Filling the Regulatory Vacuum
When a state agency deliberately creates a vacuum of clear, public regulations, it leaves a chaotic void. Nature abhors a vacuum, and so does politics. Because the Department of Education refuses to provide transparent, standardized guardrails, outside political factions stepped into the empty space to write their own rules. The direct result of this engineered confusion has been playing out right now on our street corners, where citizen initiatives were launched to aggressively circulate petitions for signatures to make the November ballot.
Both measures claimed they existed to bring "accountability" to the ESA program. In reality, both are deeply flawed overcorrections responding to a manufactured crisis.
The first initiative, the teacher's union-backed "Protect Education Act," attempts to fix the system with an axe. It reacts to the phantom media narrative by trying to structurally roll back the program entirely—introducing strict household income caps and permanently seizing any unspent funds at the end of the fiscal year. It ignores the reality that a child’s educational costs naturally scale as they grow and instead forces families into a classic, wasteful "use-it-or-lose-it" trap. This clawback of funds moves money into the state general fund and relieves stress on the conventional school budgets. It no longer serves individual learning at the family level; instead, itfeeds the monster that has caused the chaos.
The second initiative, the "Reform and Accountability Act" (promoted by Fortify AZ), took the opposite approach but introduced its own brand of bureaucratic bloat. To protect universal access, it sought to mandate a rigid, state-managed online marketplace where all purchases must be pre-cleared through a state checkout portal, while simultaneously slapping mandatory standardized testing onto homeschooled students who use the funds. This marketplace is a prime target for graft and corruption. By forcing parents to use one list of vendors, it creates a monopoly that can use kickbacks and coercion to inflate costs. Standardized testing has been a mantra for so long that we tend to accept it; however, independent data shows that such testing results in "teaching the test" instead of actual mastery of the subject matter. Our children suffer in later life as the actual education level of our country drops based on worldwide comparisons.
In a telling twist, the backers of Fortify AZ have just abruptly pulled their initiative from the race and called off their petition drive. The move exposes the cynical gamesmanship at play: the initiative was never meant to be a genuine solution, but rather a strategic piece of leverage in a high-stakes legislative poker game. When a backroom deal between legislative leaders and the teachers' union collapsed on the final night of budget negotiations, Fortify AZ's leverage evaporated. Realizing that running two competing, bloated measures would only fracture the base and confuse voters, the big-money donors abruptly pulled the plug.
Neither of these frantic measures would be necessary if Superintendent Horne simply opened his department's drawers and published the compliance guidelines they already possess. Instead, the state's calculated silence has thrown the public into a state of argumentative chaos, forcing voters to navigate a minefield of institutional clawbacks and collapsed political bluffs.
VI. Conclusion: Reclaiming the Narrative
The public is being taken for a ride. The loud, argumentative chaos dominating our news cycle isn't a reflection of parental dishonesty—it is the engineered output of a bureaucracy farming its own system for budget increases.
Real accountability is a two-way street. If the state expects parents to be flawless, transparent stewards of their children's education, then the state must be a flawless, transparent provider of the rules. Forcing parents into a "use it or lose it" model or demanding compliance with a shadow rulebook won't fix education. It just replaces parental autonomy with bureaucratic empire-building.
It is time to pull the cat out of the bag, publish the rules, and trust Arizona parents to manage their families' futures.
YES! YES! YES! In my 15 years of ESA, it has NEVER been as chaotic as it has been under Horne! Parents want to do the right thing. It doesn't need to be this hard!
🚨🚨🚨🚨This is the best takedown I've ever seen of the bogus criticism directed towards Arizona's wonderful Empowerment Savings Accounts (ESAs) for education. Under RINO Superintendent of Schools Tom Horne, everything is amplified as if parents are supposedly engaging in fraud with their purchases - yet Horne WILL NOT RELEASE the internal rules on ESAs to the public, so parents don't know what are acceptable purchases and what are not! 🤬🤬🤬🤬Makes it easy to nab them and have the fake news embellish the stories. The fact is, the items a handful of rogue actors attempted to purchase were CAUGHT, and the fraud rate in the program is miniscule, far lower than other state agencies! This is a massive violation of law not to release the rules, it's a PUBLIC RECORD! Not doing so sets parents up for entrapment! This is why @KimberlyYeeAZ is going to defeat Horne in the election on Tuesday. Please spread far and wide so Arizonans know the TRUTH! This makes me so angry, my sister was homeschooled the entire way since she had dyslexia and ADHD. Arizona's expansive ESA program is the best in the country rivaling Florida's.🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
CC: @DeAngelisCorey @LIESofSOSaz @JakeHoffmanAZ
---
The Manufactured Crisis: Inside the ESA Compliance Trap
By David Thompson
Executive Summary: The Invisible Extortion of Arizona Families
This is not a debate about school choice; it is a clinical look at institutional greed. While the public is manipulated into endless, angry squabbling over sensationalized headlines, a quiet and predatory scheme is being executed inside our state apparatus. The Arizona Department of Education, under the direction of Superintendent Tom Horne, is running a deliberate compliance trap, withholding the very rules parents are required to follow, manufacturing administrative failures, and weaponizing the resulting confusion to extort the Legislature for larger budgets and more personnel. Our families are not failing the system; a protected bureaucratic cartel is intentionally forcing them to fail because parent mistakes have become the department's most lucrative cash cow.
I. The Illusion of Rampant Fraud
For months, Arizona headlines have blared a consistent, panicked refrain: the universal Empowerment Scholarship Account (ESA) program is a wild, unmonitored frontier leaking taxpayer dollars to luxury items and blatant fraud. Critics point to portfolios of flagged transactions, rejected receipts, and bizarre purchase attempts as absolute proof that parents cannot be trusted with educational autonomy.
It is a compelling narrative, but it relies entirely on a fundamental distortion of how accountability systems actually function.
In the world of auditing, there is a vast structural gulf between an unallowable expense, such as administrative paperwork errors, and criminal fraud. When a headline screams that a parent attempted to buy Disneyland tickets or an unauthorized electronic device, they routinely omit the most critical punchline of the story: the purchase was flagged, reviewed, and denied. No taxpayer money was spent.
To claim that a blocked, unapproved receipt represents a failure of the system is the height of logical absurdity. If a bank’s security filter flags and rejects an invalid check at the counter, the bank didn't just get robbed; the system worked exactly as designed. The paper trail exists precisely because the guardrails are functioning.
Independent data bears this out. Statistically, actual flagrant criminal abuse like deliberate forgery, double enrollment, or identity theft represents a fraction of one percent of ESA transactions. The overwhelming majority of what the state and media label "non-compliance" consists of administrative noise: a harried parent purchasing a standard, legitimate textbook or laptop but omitting a date on a receipt, or failing to upload an explicit curriculum sheet to justify the tool.
Yet, instead of refining the system to help families navigate these clerical technicalities, Superintendent Tom Horne's Arizona Department of Education (ADE) chose a different path for the 2025–2026 cycle. They weaponized the handbook.
II. The Invisible Rulebook
The latest ESA Parent Handbook reads less like an educational guide and more like a compliance trap. It is peppered with aggressive warnings, threatening families with immediate account suspension, retroactive repayment demands, and criminal prosecution. But the real trap isn't the severity of the penalties; it is the phantom standard by which they are enforced.
Throughout the text, the Department explicitly states that parents will be penalized for violating unlisted "program rules" and internal "program policies,” regulations that do not appear anywhere within the public document itself.
As a citizen and a systems analyst, this immediate red flag prompted a simple, necessary question: How can a parent be expected to maintain flawless compliance with a rulebook the state refuses to publish?
To find out, I submitted a formal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request demanding the release of these hidden, internal guidelines. If parents were going to face bureaucratic retribution and public shaming based on these shadow rules, they had a legal right to read them.
The department’s response to a transparent demand for the rules of engagement? Dead silence. Weeks of phone messages and emails went completely unanswered, disappearing into an administrative black hole.
III. The Watchdog’s Surrender
Refusing to accept being stonewalled, I escalated the matter to the Arizona State Ombudsman’s Office—the state’s official watchdog meant to ensure agency transparency. While polite, their office offered the standard institutional excuse of "overburdened workers" and tried to provide an outside interpretation rather than forcing the department to produce the actual rules.
When pressed for concrete answers, Ombudsman Frank Rutledge issued a written response that effectively gave away the entire game. He admitted to me in writing:
"A.R.S. 15-2402(4) lists the categories of approved/acceptable items in which ESA funds can be spent. I understand that not all items a student may need are identified on this list, so parents need to make a judgment call... ask yourself whether you can defend the validity of the purchase to the Arizona State Board of Education if questioned. If you can, then there shouldn’t be a problem with the purchase. Avoid questionable purchases."
Let that sink in. Restated, the state’s official stance is literally for parents to read the raw Arizona Revised Statutes, make a "judgment call," cross their fingers, and hope they can successfully defend themselves later before a hostile review process.
How, exactly, is a harried parent of several children at various stages of development supposed to "avoid questionable purchases" when the Department explicitly refuses to share its own internal interpretation of what is questionable? This is an administrative trap: parents are forced to guess, and if they guess wrong, then they face prosecution based on rules that have been hidden away.
IV. The Smoking Gun: Funding the Trap
When the Ombudsman’s office joined the ADE in dead silence (yes, I was stonewalled again), I escalated the matter to State Representative Way’s office. It was through this legislative inquiry that the final, cynical piece of the puzzle fell into place.
I was routed to a contracted lobbyist representing the Arizona Department of Education. In a series of candid conversations, the underlying business model of this entire crisis was laid bare.
First, she confirmed what my FOIA had been trying to establish: the internal, definitive rules defining what constitutes fraud absolutely exist. Second, she explained exactly why Tom Horne's department refuses to publish them for the families they govern: releasing them, she stated verbally, would "let the cat out of the bag."
When pushed further on why transparency was such a threat, she deployed a well-worn local political buzzword, claiming that publishing the exact guidelines would provide a tool for "bad actors" to use against the department.
Let's translate that out of political-speak. In our current local landscape, "bad actor" is a hollow label slammed onto any taxpaying citizen who dares to disagree with an agency or hold them to a legal standard. The department isn't hiding the rules to protect taxpayers from criminals; they are hiding the rules to protect themselves from accountability. If parents don't have a copy of the definitive regulations, they can never prove the department made a mistake.
Meanwhile, the lobbyist made her primary objective clear: she was actively using the resulting "compliance crisis" to lobby the Arizona Legislature to secure more money and more personnel for the Department.
And there it is: the closed-loop cycle of bureaucratic empire-building.
The Department deliberately keeps its compliance rules secret. Because the rules are kept secret, well-meaning parents inevitably make administrative mistakes. The Department and the media then point to those mistakes to manufacture a public panic over "widespread parent fraud." Finally, the Department hires a lobbyist to weaponize that exact manufactured panic, going to the Legislature to demand more taxpayer funding and more staff to police the very confusion they created.
V. Filling the Regulatory Vacuum
When a state agency deliberately creates a vacuum of clear, public regulations, it leaves a chaotic void. Nature abhors a vacuum, and so does politics. Because the Department of Education refuses to provide transparent, standardized guardrails, outside political factions stepped into the empty space to write their own rules. The direct result of this engineered confusion has been playing out right now on our street corners, where citizen initiatives were launched to aggressively circulate petitions for signatures to make the November ballot.
Both measures claimed they existed to bring "accountability" to the ESA program. In reality, both are deeply flawed overcorrections responding to a manufactured crisis.
The first initiative, the teacher's union-backed "Protect Education Act," attempts to fix the system with an axe. It reacts to the phantom media narrative by trying to structurally roll back the program entirely—introducing strict household income caps and permanently seizing any unspent funds at the end of the fiscal year. It ignores the reality that a child’s educational costs naturally scale as they grow and instead forces families into a classic, wasteful "use-it-or-lose-it" trap. This clawback of funds moves money into the state general fund and relieves stress on the conventional school budgets. It no longer serves individual learning at the family level; instead, itfeeds the monster that has caused the chaos.
The second initiative, the "Reform and Accountability Act" (promoted by Fortify AZ), took the opposite approach but introduced its own brand of bureaucratic bloat. To protect universal access, it sought to mandate a rigid, state-managed online marketplace where all purchases must be pre-cleared through a state checkout portal, while simultaneously slapping mandatory standardized testing onto homeschooled students who use the funds. This marketplace is a prime target for graft and corruption. By forcing parents to use one list of vendors, it creates a monopoly that can use kickbacks and coercion to inflate costs. Standardized testing has been a mantra for so long that we tend to accept it; however, independent data shows that such testing results in "teaching the test" instead of actual mastery of the subject matter. Our children suffer in later life as the actual education level of our country drops based on worldwide comparisons.
In a telling twist, the backers of Fortify AZ have just abruptly pulled their initiative from the race and called off their petition drive. The move exposes the cynical gamesmanship at play: the initiative was never meant to be a genuine solution, but rather a strategic piece of leverage in a high-stakes legislative poker game. When a backroom deal between legislative leaders and the teachers' union collapsed on the final night of budget negotiations, Fortify AZ's leverage evaporated. Realizing that running two competing, bloated measures would only fracture the base and confuse voters, the big-money donors abruptly pulled the plug.
Neither of these frantic measures would be necessary if Superintendent Horne simply opened his department's drawers and published the compliance guidelines they already possess. Instead, the state's calculated silence has thrown the public into a state of argumentative chaos, forcing voters to navigate a minefield of institutional clawbacks and collapsed political bluffs.
VI. Conclusion: Reclaiming the Narrative
The public is being taken for a ride. The loud, argumentative chaos dominating our news cycle isn't a reflection of parental dishonesty—it is the engineered output of a bureaucracy farming its own system for budget increases.
Real accountability is a two-way street. If the state expects parents to be flawless, transparent stewards of their children's education, then the state must be a flawless, transparent provider of the rules. Forcing parents into a "use it or lose it" model or demanding compliance with a shadow rulebook won't fix education. It just replaces parental autonomy with bureaucratic empire-building.
It is time to pull the cat out of the bag, publish the rules, and trust Arizona parents to manage their families' futures.
Julie Batt retweeted
Every American, whether Republican, Democrat, Independent, or otherwise, should be able to agree that we deserve the most secure, honest, and fair election system anywhere in the world.
Secure elections should not be a partisan issue that divides Americans.
Julie Batt retweeted
.@POTUS: Addressing this crisis of election security demands that Congress MUST pass the SAVE America Act. The only reason you wouldn't want to do it is that you want to cheat.
This landmark bill requires that all voters must show proof of voter ID, all voters must provide proof of citizenship, and hopefully there will be NO corrupt mail-in ballots except for illness, disability, military deployment, or travel.
These reforms are urgently needed to stop the vulnerabilities I have outlined.
To all Americans, I ask you to pick up the phone tomorrow, call your representatives in the House and Senate, and demand they PASS THE SAVE AMERICA ACT without delay.






























