ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest) header
ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest) profile picture

Occasional Poet || Among 5% || About Kashmir || کشمیر || History || Politics || آسمانی حقائق یہ ہیں کہ حق بہرحال غالب رہتا ہے

کشمیر
Joined April 2020
Photo by ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest)Photo by ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest)Photo by ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest)Photo by ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest)Photo by ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest)Photo by ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest)Photo by ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest)Photo by ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest)Photo by ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest)Photo by ضربِ کلیم (@KashmirInterest)
ضربِ کلیم retweeted
Factually untrue. Nehru himself came to see Iqbal at the latter's residence in Lahore in 1938 when Iqbal was unwell and close to his eventual demise. The ever-shrewd Nehru flattered him, hailed his poetry, and asked him to sideline Jinnah and be "the true leader of the Muslims" with whom "Congress could negotiate". Iqbal became furious and lashed out at Nehru, calling himself a "foot soldier of Jinnah, the real leader of Muslims". Nehru, insulted, left shortly thereafter - and years later, concocted this fake tale to cover up the refusal.
Nehru on Iqbal : A few months before his death ,he sent for me and I gladly obeyed the sommons. He was in reminiscent mood and wondered from one subject to another.. A little before I left,he said "What is ther common between you and Jinnah? He is a politician You are a patriot" (Excerpt from Jawaharlal Nehru's book The Discovery of India, where he recounts a meeting with the poet and philosopher Sir Muhammad Iqbal in Lahore in early 1938, a few months before Iqbal's passing) #Nehru #AllamaIqbal #India #Pakistan #Bharat
9
28
3
173
13,521
Well,these SS are just that,snippets. There is a bigger picture that,i am afraid, u are either missing or, worse still, choosing to ignore. There is ample evidence to conclude SMA's heart lay with Nehru's India over Pak. You can however,owing to your performative neutrality, 1/2
Setting aside the presentist agenda, this is quite a flawed inference. That the tribal invasion, undertaken with the active complicity of the League and the passive complicity of Jinnah, forced Abdullah's hand is beyond doubt. Here's a few relevant bytes from Noorani. (1/2)
2
3
10
1,048
choose to privilege his public posturing and speeches as his definitive stand, while bracketing out the private correspondence and political machinations afoot at that time. P.S: Attaching some snippets that present the complete picture. #historicism 2/2
3
147
When M.A Jinnah met SMA in 1944 in Kashmir, he advised him: "I am like your father & I have turned my hair grey in politics. My experience is that Hindus cannot be trusted; they can never be your friends. I have tried all my life to win their trust,but I have not succeeded. 1/2
You’re unable to view this Post because this account owner limits who can view their Posts. Learn more
4
3
1
42
10,586
The time will come when you will remember what I have said and regret it." Jinnah further said: "How can you trust a nation that considers drinking water from your hands a sin? Is there any place for you in their society? They consider you impure." 2/2
2
1
11
1,595
Nov 13, 1947 — Lal Chowk. SMA takes the mic beside Nehru & recites: "Mann Tu Shudam, Tu Mann Shudi.." To those pushing the "compelled accession" theory: does a man forced into joining India speak like this?Does he declare spiritual & ideological oneness with India's leader? 1/2
2
2
2
13
2,828
This was not the voice of a majboor leader, but of ideological fusion. A decade of grooming by Nehru, Congress socialists, and progressive writers had already shaped Kashmir’s fate long before 1947; Lal Chowk was its public culmination, not an act of compulsion. 2/2
1
5
354
From Pir Afzal's book: 32K arrests,12 martyrs,1st martyr Ghazi Ishaq - All Majlis-e-Ahrar. First Jatha-bandi against Maharaja - Ahrar. The war cry of Kashmir - Ahrar's. SMA was in jail waiting to apologise. It appears some ppl don't read the book even after getting it translated.
Here lies the contradiction: If Iqbal supported mobilisation from Punjab, why does Abdullah portray the very organisation that mobilised volunteers from Punjab in such a negative light?
1
2
6
607
Early praise is not a lifetime endorsement. Allama's praise of Mirza Ghulam Qadiani between 1900 and 1910 does not make Qadiani a saint; Iqbal became Qadianism's most prominent opponent in the 1930s. The same applies to Kashmir. Iqbal praised Sheikh Abdullah in 1931–32 1/2
Iqbal, the poet, had become greatly disappointed about #Kashmir when he visited the place in 1921. کشمیری کہ با بندگی خو گرفتہ Kashmiri, he lamented, has become accustomed to slavery. Then a decade later, Iqbal saw hope - in one man.
2
3
39
2,251
as the leader of the Muslim Conference, fighting for Muslim rights,not as the man who later dissolved Muslim identity into the National Conference and aligned with Congress. Had Iqbal lived until 1947, he would have opposed Abdullah’s post-1939 politics just as fiercely. 2/2
1
14
359
This is how Sheikh Abdullah, then the prominent leader of Jammu and Kashmir, betrayed the suffering of #Jammu Muslims, mocking and laughing at a delegation that had come to him in December 1947, while the scars of the RSS-driven massacre were still fresh.
Replying to @KashmirInterest
how Hari Singh his wife & his administration were hand in glove in killing of innocent Muslims.Your heart breaks & your mind struggles to comprehend the suffering they endured.Yet SMA accepted to install his son as Sadre Riyasat.He showed little concern for Muslims of Jammu. 2/2
1
14
2
41
1,013
ضربِ کلیم retweeted
A heartbreaking scene of a Palestinian woman whose tent was flooded by heavy rains in the Gaza Strip.
176
2,729
123
4,522
167,195
Years later, when SMA returned to power in 1975,Mir approached him with documents seeking the property's release from Dharmarth Trust's "illegal occupation."On Sheikh Abdullah's assurance,Mir handed over the papers, but neither the promise was kept nor the documents returned. 1/2
Replying to @KashmirInterest
During late 1950s, Abdul Samad Mir and some residents of Dalgate, fought a long and ultimately unsuccessful battle for the restoration of the mosque. On one occasion, he even confronted Sadr-e-Riyasat Karan Singh and demanded the restoration of the land.
3
4
1
16
1,249
Mir died on 11 January 1981, and with him ended the fight for the disappeared mosque. P.S: Mir had resisted the construction of the Dharmarth Trust building, headed by Karan Singh, on the precipice overlooking the River Jhelum. 2/2
2
222
According to Afzal Beig on 26 Nov 1947 Sheikh Abdullah said that "whatever happened to the Muslims of Jammu was their own responsibility that they had never accepted him as their leader so he would not console them today." Carefully delving into the Jammu massacre reveals 1/2
PM pointing to Muslim bodies still lying at Ramnagar & saying "population ratio too can change" is explicit admission that #Jammu killings were seen at the highest level as a tool to alter demography for parity. Not a breakdown of order, but factored into power-sharing. #Massacre
2
10
34
1,562
how Hari Singh his wife & his administration were hand in glove in killing of innocent Muslims.Your heart breaks & your mind struggles to comprehend the suffering they endured.Yet SMA accepted to install his son as Sadre Riyasat.He showed little concern for Muslims of Jammu. 2/2
1
1
4
1,228
In early November 1947, thousands of Muslim residents from Jammu city & surrounding areas were gathered under the promise of safe escort to Sialkot across the border at Suchetgarh. Instead, the convoys of trucks and buses were diverted and ambushed near areas like Chattha, 1/2
3
10
1
38
1,803
Miran Sahib, and the Suchetgarh route, where large numbers of refugees were killed by armed communal mobs and state forces. This tragedy forms the core of what is remembered annually in the region as Jammu Martyrs' Day on November 6. 2/2
1
10
316
For those claiming the mosque was never there: the 1911 photograph(1st pic) clearly shows it beside the temple. Built in 14th century, when Kashmiris were converted to Islam en masse, it had mysteriously disappeared by 1935(2nd pic), while the temple, dating to 200 BCE, remained.
Pardon my late comment on this. It was not originally called Shankaracharya. Until the late 1930s, its official name was 'Takht-e-Sulaiman'. And a mosque once stood on the hill; it fell into disuse during Sikh rule and was later demolished during the Dogra administration.
6
16
3
85
5,932
During late 1950s, Abdul Samad Mir and some residents of Dalgate, fought a long and ultimately unsuccessful battle for the restoration of the mosque. On one occasion, he even confronted Sadr-e-Riyasat Karan Singh and demanded the restoration of the land.
1
1
15
1,911