Ser ikke spesielt renslig ut
Full text of article:
Jay Bhattacharya, head of the National Institutes of Health, has written to Nature Medicine journal demanding a “formal, independent investigation” into why a key scientific paper misled the world about the virus causing Covid, and concealed the contributions made by three senior scientists to commissioning, reviewing and editing the paper.
In a career as a science writer that spans more than four decades, I have never seen an alleged case of scientific malpractice as influential. Like many others I have called for the paper to be retracted. Twice, the editor of the journal, Joao Monteiro, has been sent letters from numerous leading scientists demanding an investigation or retraction of the misleading paper. He has ignored us.
I know the paper entitled “Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2” was misleading because I was among those misled. At the time I sat on the science and technology select committee of the House of Lords and we were conducting an inquiry to try to understand this new virus threatening all our lives. The possibility that it had been accidentally released from a laboratory, if true, would have significant implications for the public-health response: a virus marinaded in human tissues in a laboratory for weeks would be far more infectious than one newly arrived from bats.
Parliamentary colleagues were asking me what I thought. To my shame, I told them a lab leak could be ruled out. I did so based almost entirely on the authority of this one paper. That very phrase “ruled out” appeared in the press announcement of the paper from the institution where the lead author, Kristian Andersen, worked. The article itself left no room for doubt: “we do not believe that any type of laboratory based scenario is plausible… our analyses clearly show that SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct.”
That these words appeared in Nature Medicine gave them a stamp of authority, or so I believed. The paper was subsequently viewed millions of times and cited in thousands of academic papers. The journal and the authors of the paper therefore had a special responsibility not to allow themselves to be misled. Yet we now know that Proximal Origin’s arguments were flawed and released Slack messages and emails show several of its authors were expressing exactly the opposite opinion in private both before, during and after publication. They still thought a lab leak was “friggin likely”, in the words of Andersen.
Worse than all that, congressional investigations have uncovered records strongly indicating that three of the most senior medical scientists in the world, Francis Collins (Bhattacharya’s predecessor as head of the National Institutes of Health), Anthony Fauci (head of National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases) and Jeremy Farrar (head of the Wellcome Trust) had not only seen the paper before publication, but – according to a House Select Subcommittee report – had prompted its authors to write it in the first place, had reviewed it and even suggested alterations in wording. Fauci referred to the paper from the White House podium, giving no hint of his own role in it.
These men were heads of the bodies that funded the scientists’ work, yet they were not listed as co authors or acknowledged in the paper, despite the journal’s stated policy that authors disclose any funder’s “involvement in the conceptualisation, design, data collection, analysis, and preparation of the paper”. Farrar even suggested a change of wording to strengthen its conclusion: from “unlikely” to “improbable”. Why was he not acknowledged? Robert Garry, one of the authors, wrote to his colleagues: “Jeremy has been an amazing leader – should be author.”
Ed Holmes, another author, replied: “I agree, and I offered, but he wants to remain independent.” As we wrote to the journal editor in 2024: “This omission of a significant role played by the head of a funding agency, allegedly to maintain his ‘independence’, represents a serious breach of publishing ethics that completely undermines the credibility of the journal and calls into question the motivation behind the paper.” Answer came there none.
It should infuriate the journal’s editor that the paper appears to have been commissioned, designed and intended to shut down all debate about a possible laboratory origin of the most destructive pandemic in a century despite going directly against its authors’ own opinions. For the sake of science’s integrity the journal must act on Dr Bhattacharya’s letter.
24
Knipetang retweeted
University debate: "Beef is the most wasteful food on earth."
Vegan: "It takes 25 kilos of feed to make one kilo of beef. Any other machine that lost 96% of what went into it would be scrapped."
Farmer: "25 kilos of what?"
Vegan: "Feed."
Farmer: "Grass. How much of it can you eat?"
Vegan: "None. That isn't the point."
Farmer: "It's the whole sum. A gold mine shifts a tonne of rock for five grams of gold. Nobody stands at the gate complaining about the waste of rock."
Vegan: "Rock isn't food. That land could feed people directly."
Farmer: "Two thirds of Britain's farmland is grass. Most of it is too steep, too wet or too thin to be anything else. You're welcome to try it with a spoon."
Vegan: "They're fattened on grain at the end."
Farmer: "Mine finish on silage and what the brewery throws out. The barley made your pint first."
Vegan: "Even so, 25 to one is indefensible."
Farmer: "A wheat plant is roots, stalk, chaff and grain. You eat the grain. That's about half of it wasted before the miller starts. I don't see a motion about bread."
Moderator: "Closing lines, please."
Vegan: "A hungry world can't afford a food that takes 25 in to get one out."
Farmer: "25 kilos of something you can't eat, off land you can't plough, for one kilo of the best food there is. I'd call that the only free lunch in farming."
Knipetang retweeted
Amazing story in play here. Man vs AI in the rush to prove the Riemann Hypothesis
This is massive. A story I've been following for years. He thought he had more time but didn't. Alessandro Masullo announces a separate, purely human proof of the Riemann hypothesis. math216.wordpress.com/2026/1…
Knipetang retweeted
Oops
NEW - A devastating verdict on German climate and energy policy: An expert panel concludes that Germany's society and economy will "not survive" the self-proclaimed "energy transition."
disclose.tv/id/h216jz69v6/
Bra, skulle ønske norske politikere kunne sette en fot i bakken nå. Lite som tyder på at velgerne ønsker hard klimapolitikk når man ser krangelen om penger til grunnleggende velferdstjenester.
Min spalte i E24: Netto null er dårlig for Norge
2 500 milliarder kroner (262 milliarder dollar) for 0,000570 °C mindre oppvarming i 2100
4 øre tilbake for hver krone
NetZeroCostBenefit.com/Norwa…
2
10
195
Bra!
«Regjeringer som ønsker innstramninger, må forholde seg til ikke mindre enn 331retningsvisende dommer fra Strasbourg. Under slike omstendigheter blir innstramninger ofte ikke annet enn slag i luften.»
minerva.no/asylpolitikk-hoyr…
3
95
All verdens diktaturer mener sanksjoner mot deres land bryter med "menneskerettighetene", og de bruker FN-systemet for å stadfeste dette. Nå har altså denne absurde konklusjonen FN-logoen påstemplet.
Knipetang retweeted
Writing is a superpower. It is an exceedingly difficult skill to master. Winston Churchill has some notes to assist us. If you're like me, you didn't learn to write well in primary school. It's not an excuse. The greats show us the way.
Knipetang retweeted
Reply with your country and I'll reply with what its net zero costs, and what it buys
Take Norway. Net zero by 2050 costs kr 2,500 billion ($262 billion), for 0.000570°C less warming in 2100
4 kroner back per 100 kroner spent
NetZeroCostBenefit.com/Norwa…
Knipetang retweeted
Replying to @RogerPielkeJr
.@jrockstrom is a liar, fabulist, and fanatic. He is an embarrassment to Germany.
Forsøk fra regjeringen på å føre Stortinget på villstrå, dette her. Skal regjeringen snart slutte å lyve?
Enova er et supperåd. Dette er skandaløst.
dn.no/innlegg/havvind/teknol…
2
120
























