BadLegalTakesplainer (@LegalTakesplain) profile picture

Trying to explain what's wrong with the worst legal takes on Twitter.

Joined December 2020
Photo by BadLegalTakesplainer (@LegalTakesplain)Photo by BadLegalTakesplainer (@LegalTakesplain)Photo by BadLegalTakesplainer (@LegalTakesplain)Photo by BadLegalTakesplainer (@LegalTakesplain)Photo by BadLegalTakesplainer (@LegalTakesplain)Photo by BadLegalTakesplainer (@LegalTakesplain)Photo by BadLegalTakesplainer (@LegalTakesplain)Photo by BadLegalTakesplainer (@LegalTakesplain)Photo by BadLegalTakesplainer (@LegalTakesplain)Photo by BadLegalTakesplainer (@LegalTakesplain)
Notice: I am not actually a lawyer. I have a Master's in economics that focused on Law & Econ. Most bad legal takes do not require a law degree to explain. Even if I were a lawyer, I would still be fallible. I'm happy to admit if I'm wrong, & I'm not the last word in arguments.
13
2
1
233
(A rare off-topic thread. Absolutely nothing law-related here.) Hideki Yoshimura (吉村 秀樹), the singer/songwriter/guitarist for bloodthirsty butchers, died 10 years ago. I've thought about him almost every day since. youtube.com/watch?v=E6RQJi7z…
1
7
3,008
Yoshimura: I miss you. But you shared so much. Thank you.
1
4
1,821
(Geez his handwriting was cursed, though. Trying to decipher this as a non-native is so much work.)
1
7
1,781
Clarification on 611 (since some members of the GOP): Non-Citizens can't vote on Federal Candidates or Issues. Some localities permit non-citizens who are legal long-term residents to vote on local issues and candidates. Just not federal ones.
1
6
If "fire in a crowded theater" were a propositional argument: α = The alphabet. φ = "The cute brown fox jumped over the lazy dog". Q,K,I ∈ α. Q,K,I ∉ φ R ∈ α. But I don't like the letter R. And also R has a K-ish look to it. ∴ R ∉ φ.
2
1
27
Replying to @BadLegalTakes
Context: 1) In the US, in almost all states, truth is an absolute defense against defamation. 2) Only provably false statements of fact that hurt your reputation can be defamation. Opinion and hyperbole can't. Nor can technically false statements that are close to the truth.
4
2
2
59
Replying to @BadLegalTakes
Context: docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/sta… It doesn't say "whoever has the bigger weapon is the bad". It says you can defend yourself from someone trying to kill you or cause permanent bodily harm even if you started the altercation, as long as you tried to tried to escape first.
1
25
Replying to @BadLegalTakes
Context: I mean, if it's not meant as a legal take, I guess you could believe that. But Wisconsin's self defense law doesn't have a carve-out for "unless you're doing something stupid, dangerous, or threatening but technically legal".
1
18