Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg) header
Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg) profile picture

Owner/agronomist @ 4G Agronomy | Corn & soybeans | agronomy, plant physiology, soil fertility, precision ag, data management | 14 yrs in field | Jesus is King

Western Missouri
Joined September 2024
Photo by Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg)Photo by Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg)Photo by Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg)Photo by Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg)Photo by Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg)Photo by Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg)Photo by Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg)Photo by Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg)Photo by Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg)Photo by Matt Greenspan (@MGspanAg)
Deep-band K beat broadcast. P placement? Almost never moved the needle. Mallarino at Iowa State ran this on 100-plus trials: fall broadcast, a fall deep-band 5 to 7 inches down and 30 inches apart, and a planter band. P seldom changed yield at 28 to 120 lb P2O5/ac. It did green corn up a little earlier in no-till and ridge-till, but yield usually didn't follow. K was a different animal. Deep-band beat broadcast or planter-band by about 8 bu/ac in ridge-till, 4 to 5 in no-till, and about 2 in chisel-disk. In a lot of those ridge-till trials, even pouring on broadcast K didn't beat the check. Makes sense here. When that surface bakes in July, roots start shopping deeper than the high-K layer up top. Broadcast K likes to sit there in no-till and strip-till. A 5-7 inch band puts it where those roots can still find it. I know the fertilizer bill has been painful. Anhydrous is at $1,007 a ton and MAP is $987. Potash is still the reasonable one at $510 in that same DTN survey. I'd try a strip next to broadcast before I hung my hat on those exact Iowa numbers - especially on the droughty knobs. If you're going to test something, K is the cheaper lesson right now. Go Chiefs. Iowa State / Mallarino
2
3
38
4,765
This one’s getting more traction than usual, so I wanted to share the source work itself. Mallarino at Iowa State walked through those 100-plus trials here: crops.extension.iastate.edu/…
106
Soybean roots nearly disappear just above the claypan. That's not a figure of speech. On Centralia claypan ground, depth to that clay ran about 12 inches on the hilltops, 4 inches on the eroded hillsides, and up to 40 inches at the bottom of the slope. Roots were thick near the surface, then almost vanished right above the claypan - then showed up again 8 to 16 inches below the top of that clay, about 20 to 30% thinner. And the water story is even simpler: 6 inches of topsoil holds about half the water of 39 inches. Corn struggled where topsoil was under 6 inches. That same field had lost about 5 inches of topsoil over roughly 150 years - as much as 12 inches on the north end. So when a yield map stays stuck on those shoulders, it isn't always begging for more P and K. You can't fertilize a 4-inch topsoil shoulder into a 40-inch toeslope. Not every low zone needs more P and K. USDA-ARS / MU
1
9
679
That spring K test can look fine - until July shows up. Here's the part a lot of people miss: a regular soil-test K reading only sees what's in solution and hanging on exchange sites. It doesn't see the K stuck between 2:1 clay layers. On high-smectite ground, those layers can collapse when the soil dries and trap that K for a while. NDSU split their corn trials at a smectite-to-illite ratio of 3.5. Below that, the critical mark was 150 ppm. At 3.5 or higher, it jumped to 200 ppm. On those high-smectite sites, a dry July or August still threw K-deficiency symptoms and more than 20 bu/ac of response - even when spring tests were already above that old 150 ppm bar. Our Mexico and Adco claypans are Fine, smectitic, and that clay layer is usually more than 50% clay. So a grid that "looked fine" in a wet fall can still get cranky on those eroded shoulders when July dries out. Fertilizer as a whole is a gut punch right now. DTN's latest national retail survey had anhydrous at $1,007 a ton and MAP at $987. Potash is still the reasonable one in that lineup, at $510. If a dry July is leaving K bushels on the table, this isn't the year I'd skip it just to save a little money. Not a new Missouri critical. MU and Tri-State don't split K recs by clay type. Just a reason to keep an eye on those shoulders. NDSU / Franzen
10
995
Saturation Risks: why it matters. Warm soil + standing water = N gone fast. Above 60°F, full of water 2–5 days, 50%+ of N can be lost. At 55–60°F: ~1–2% of nitrate a day. At 65–70°F: ~4–5% a day. Only nitrate is at risk. Ammonium holds.
5
300
Fall burndown sets up a clean start in spring. Henbit comes up mostly in fall and is a strong SCN host. Fall control of emerged marestail is more effective and consistent than spring burndown. Spray on a 50°F+ day. Still scout before planting.
2
186
Wet soil doesn't just rut. It compacts, and soil remembers. Combines, carts, tillage, NH3 rigs, lime trucks: one heavy pass crushes pore space. MN trials: wet-subsoil compaction still there 4 yrs later, through freezing. Dry subsoil didn't. Let it dry. If you must go, one lane.
1
6
469
Sources: Voorhees, Nelson & Randall 1986, SSSAJ 50:428 doi.org/10.2136/sssaj1986.03… | Håkansson & Reeder 1994, Soil Tillage Res doi.org/10.1016/0167-1987(94… | UMN Extension extension.umn.edu/natural-re… MN: ~10 & 20 ton axle loads, applied once. Wet subsoil: density up ~5 lb/ft³ at 12-20 in., still detectable at 4 yrs despite freezing to ~3 ft. Dry subsoil: no significant change below ~8-12 in.
1
76
SATURATION RISKS, Part 3: Flat-rate N protection ignores the map. MU claypan trial, 4 yrs: nitrapyrin netted ~$81/ac on footslopes, ~$51/ac more than on shoulders. Wet low ground has the most N to lose. Zone protection by loss risk, within label rates. @agrilytics
1
4
351
Saturation Risks, Part 2: harvest is early, your anhydrous can wait. MU: wait for 6-in soil <40°F (Novelty, MO: ~Nov 24 typical). MN tile study, 6-yr corn, fall NH3: 161 bu. + N-Serve: 171. Spring NH3: 172.
2
1
5
647
Sources: MU Extension, J. Lory extension.missouri.edu/news/… Randall & Vetsch 2005, Agron J 97:472-478 doi.org/10.2134/agronj2005.0… MN Mollisol, 120 lb N/ac, fall NH3 Oct 20-Nov 1. Novelty dates = typical year.
50
New series, Saturation Risks: managing soil-applied N and drainage. Part 1: on claypan, tile pays through stand. MU Bethel soy: drained planted up to 17 days earlier, undrained lost 29–52% of plants, 20 vs 40 ft yield similar. Wet 2009 corn: 74% more plants at 20 ft than 40 ft.
1
5
418
Your N bill comes with a lime bill. MU Extension: every 100 lb of N from NH3, urea or UAN takes 72 lb ENM of lime to neutralize. Ammonium sulfate? 220. So 180 lb N/ac as NH3 ≈ 130 lb ENM/ac. Compare lime quotes by ENM, not by the ton. extension.missouri.edu/publi…
3
3
1
24
5,774
Your K soil test can change with the weather. Iowa State's 2023 update: on moderately poor to poorly drained soils, the moist K test was much more reliable than the dry test. Prime suspect: wet/dry swings. Drying can collapse clay sheets and trap K. agronext.iastate.edu/soilfer…
1
5
307
Claypan K isn't one number. In MU plots near Columbia, soil-test K ran 4.4 kg/ha lower per extra cm of topsoil, and raising soil-test K took 4x more fertilizer K at 44 cm topsoil than at 0 cm. Map depth to claypan before you build K. doi.org/10.2134/agronj2017.0…
2
153
Fall anhydrous in Missouri: is your soil actually cold enough? The 50°F rule came from Iowa/MN. MU says wait for 6-in soil <40°F. Typical year at Novelty: 50°F ~Oct 27, 40°F ~Nov 24. That's a month. Worth the wait, or are you running anyway? extension.missouri.edu/news/…
1
2
167
Worth adding: DCD protectants show solid results, as well as nitrapyrin. The real edge isn't the product. It's knowing where N loss risk lives in a field. Map it (wet holes, wetness index, drainage) and vary protectant rate by zone. That's how you protect fall NH3. @agrilytics
72
A full 1,200-bu grain cart can put 35–40 tons on one axle. On wet soil that packs 2–3 ft down, below any tillage, and it can still cost yield in a drought or wet year a decade later. Unload on headlands, stay in combine tracks, and drop tire pressure.
1
3
241