The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball) header
The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball) profile picture

#Youngstown style Italian #meatballsubs & pizza! Available at our first location in #OldHilliard @ the Center Street Market (inside crooked can brewery)

Columbus, Ohio
Joined October 2013
Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Pizza Madness Sausage Region
66%Classic's
34%Meatball Mafia
146 votes • Final results
1
1,341
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Due to popular demand… we opened the whole thing up. All FOUR Pizza Madness regions are officially LIVE. Vote now at pizzamadness.pizza/ Then share your picks and tag the pizza spot you’re riding with. The debates start now.
5
5
1
51
12,042
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Keep making those peppers!
3
1
6
622
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Pizza Madness 2025 Round One, Eggplant Region: Rubino's vs Meatball Mafia
64%Rubino's
36%Meatball Mafia
441 votes • Final results
1
1
3,384
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Replying to @MafiaMeatball
@MafiaMeatball What a great pie this was! Will be back!
2
2
157
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
FRIDAY FOOD: Meatball Mafia- 5354 Center St, Hilliard Timmy introduced me to this place. YTOWN style pizza. Thick, chewy & the perfect vessel for meat. Get a side of peppers to top the pie. If you crave a meatball sub, try the Nicky Santoro. GTH
11
8
263
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
And @TimHall971's Top pizza spots in central Ohio:🍕 5. Flyer's 4. Meatball Mafia 3. Adriatico's 2. Mikey's Late Night Slice 1. DiCarlo's Thoughts?
62
3
6
32
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Replying to @nbc4i
Best pizza by far is Meatball Mafia in Hilliard. @MafiaMeatball
1
2
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Replying to @NyerinOH09 @nbc4i
5000% agree. BUT Best pizza I've tasted in Columbus is at Meatball Mafia in Hilliard. Ytown style pizza! #best @MafiaMeatball
1
1
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Burger from Hot Mess. And a lil @MafiaMeatball 🍕too!
6
1
14