Munim (@Munimusing) header
Munim (@Munimusing) profile picture

“In our infinite ignorance we are all equal.” | Elec. Engr. | Power Systems | Legal Theory | OSINT

Joined December 2012
پانچویں کلاس میں ایک ہم جماعت تھا جو ہمیشہ علامہ اقبال اور قائد اعظم کو خلط کر دیتا تھا۔ اسکا مشہور لطیفہ جو سکول کے دوست آج بھی یاد رکھتے ہیں وہ کسی سوال کے جواب میں “علامہ اقبال محمد علی جناح” ایجاد کرنا تھا (کیونکہ قائدِ اعظم کو قیدِ اعظم کہنے پر استاد غصہ کرتا تھا)۔ اس مناسبت سے علامہ اقبال محمد علی جناح کا مشہور شعر ہے: کون کس کو دل میں جگہ دیتا ہے درخت بھی سوکھے پتوں کو گرا دیتا ہے واقف ہیں ہم اس دنیا کے رواجوں سے جب دل بھر جائے تو ہر کوئی بھلا دیتا ہے (زیرِ نظر تصویر والے بائیس سالہ اقبال نے یہ شعر کہہ کر قلم توڑ دیا تھا۔ اب یہ مت پوچھیں کہ کیسے اور کہاں!)
1
2
11
715
Replying to @bee_asks
The Quran marks the age of 40 as the point of full maturity. At that stage a person, reflecting on his own creation, comes to realisation, and the ideal response to that realisation is humility and to say: "My Lord! Inspire me to ˹always˺ be thankful for Your favours which You blessed me and my parents with, and to do good deeds that please You. And instil righteousness in my offspring. I truly repent to You, and I truly submit ˹to Your Will˺."
2
95
Dpt. Sec. Landau made one Pakistani Fulbright alumna the face of a policy. He counts $180,000 for her degree; Washington sends Israel $3.8 billion a year, about 21,000 such degrees. In 1919 Palestinians asked for an American mandate. The question is how that trust was spent. munimusing.substack.com/p/th…
1
3
9
668
کچھ احباب کا تقاضا تھا کہ اس معاملے کو مکمل کیا جائے۔ اس کتاب کا خیال ۲۰۱۰ء سے ہی ذاتی حوادث کے باعث ذہن میں کسی نا کسی حوالے سے موجود رہا۔ اللہ پاک نے حالیہ دہشتگردی کی لہر میں نظر آنے والے نئے رجحانات کے دیکھتے ہوئے یہ خیال دل میں ڈالا کہ اس کام کو کر گزرا جائے۔ کچھ دنوں سے فرصت کے باعث تمام وقت اسی پر صرف ہو رہا ہے۔ ان شاء اللہ اس کی مزید تفصیل عنقریب مشورے سے احباب کی خدمت میں پیش کی جائے گی۔
جو کتابچہ متشدد گروہوں کے افکار پر لکھا تھا اس پر کچھ پیغامات موصول ہوئے تھے، بالخصوص یہ کہ ان گروہوں کا نکتہ نظر ٹھیک بیان نہیں کیا گیا۔ چنانچہ جو اختصار مصلحتاً اُس وقت کیا تھا، اسے ختم کر کے تمام بنیادی مصادر کا ذکر بھی کر دیا گیا امید ہے اب نوجوانوں اور انکے بڑوں کو تشنگی نہیں رہے گی۔ ہور کوئی حکم ساڈے لائق!! ---- اگر احباب میں سے کوئی کبھی متشدد گروہوں کے افکار کا اسیر رہا ہے یا کبھی رغبت محسوس کی ہے تو یہ مختصر کتابچہ ان افکار سے بچاؤ اور اعتدال کی راہ کی پہچان کے لیے ان شاء اللہ مفید ثابت ہو گا۔ کئی دوستوں کا اصرار تھا کہ میں اپنے فکری ارتقاء کا بھی کبھی ذکر کروں۔ تو یہ تحریر اس تناظر میں بھی ایک طرح کی خود کلامی ہے۔ حالیہ کچھ ماہ میں اس فکر کا پرچار پھر شدومد سے کیا جا رہا ہے جیسے اب تک کے نتائج سے نوجوان آگاہ نہ ہوں۔ abdulmun.im/ur/posts/khajoor…
6
5
2
52
3,033
The Mecca Pact moved from signature to action in Riyadh yesterday. The questions in front of Pakistani planners are delicate and historical. I argue history and possibilities in this piece here. munimusing.substack.com/p/th… Every durable settlement in Yemen since Taif in 1934 has followed the same pattern: limited gains on the coast, then negotiation. No outside army has won in the Zaydi highlands, and the Saudis have learned not to try. The campaign should therefore be bounded in space and time. It should retake the Bab al-Mandab and the coast up to the April 2022 line within about six weeks, stay out of Hodeidah city and the highlands, and then stop. Pakistan's greatest asset is not its rocket or air forces but its access to Tehran. An Islamabad Declaration on Yemen, trading Pakistani restraint for an end to IRGC backing of the coastal offensive, would turn a restored line into a lasting ceasefire. A pact that acts quickly, stops on schedule and then guarantees a settlement will deter its rivals far more than one that fights to exhaustion. Prudence, not heroics, is what the alliance must show in its first test
5
25
719
یعنی مساجد پر حملہ تو ہوا صرف "خطا" یا غلطی، مگر مسلم عوام، ان کے اعمال، ان کے املاک وغیرہ کو حلال کرنا ہو تو لمبی چوڑی قلابازیاں، موشگافیاں اور فقہ، اصولِ فقہ کا قیمہ کر کے کہیں سے ابن تیمیہؒ اور کہیں عرب اثری سلفی علماء کو لا کھڑا کیا جاتا ہے۔ کہیں کی اینٹ کہیں کا روڑا، بھان متی نے کنبہ جوڑا۔ لمبے لمبے فتوے تراشے جاتے ہیں، یا پرانے فتاویٰ سیاق و سباق کے بغیر جوشیلے نوجوانوں کے ذہنوں میں انڈیلے جاتے ہیں۔ آپ لہک کر کوئی نغمہ بھی گنگنا لیں تو ہر چیز کا حکم شریعت سے ثابت کرنے کی رٹ لگائی جاتی ہے۔ اب بتائیں شریعت میں ان اعمال کی کیا سزا ہے؟ تاریخ یہ تماشا پہلے بھی دیکھ چکی ہے۔ نہروان کے راستے میں خوارج کے ایک ساتھی نے گری ہوئی کھجور منہ میں ڈالی تو باقیوں نے ٹوکا کہ مالک کی اجازت کے بغیر؟ اس نے تھوک دی۔ ایک نے ذمی کا سؤر مار دیا تو اسے فساد فی الارض قرار دے کر مالک کو قیمت ادا کی گئی۔ اسی قافلے کو صحابیِ رسول ﷺ حضرت خبابؓ کے بیٹے عبداللہؓ ملے؛ ابوبکرؓ، عمرؓ، عثمانؓ اور علیؓ کے بارے میں پوچھا، انہوں نے خیر کہی، تو انہیں نہر کنارے ذبح کر دیا اور ان کی حاملہ اہلیہ کا پیٹ چاک کر دیا۔ کھجور پر ورع، مسلمان کے خون پر فتویٰ؛ یہ "خطا" اسی مکتب کی صدائے بازگشت ہے۔ یہ خوارج کا عمل نہیں تو کیا ہے؟ ستم ظریفی یہ ہے کہ "شریعت کے دشمنوں" کو مساجد میں نشانہ بنانا بس غلط ہے۔ یہ شریعت کے کیسے دشمن ہیں جو مساجد میں پائے جاتے ہیں؟ یہی عقیدے میں نقص سے تکفیر نکالنے والی لاجک تھی جو خوارج خود صحابہ کرامؓ پر چسپاں کرتے تھے۔ مسجد میں نمازی پر وار بھی کوئی نئی ایجاد نہیں۔ حضرت علیؓ کو ابن ملجم نے کوفہ کی مسجد میں فجر کے وقت زخمی کیا، تو نعرہ وہی تھا: "الحکم للہ"۔ یہی نعرہ جب پہلی بار لگا تو علیؓ نے فرمایا: "كَلِمَةُ حَقٍّ أُرِيدَ بِهَا بَاطِلٌ"۔ ابن عمرؓ نے اس ذہنیت کا نسخہ یوں بیان کیا کہ یہ لوگ کفار کے بارے میں نازل آیات اٹھا کر مؤمنین پر چسپاں کر دیتے ہیں۔ انکا ترتیب دیا الولاء والبراء کا پورا عقیدہ اپنی اصل میں یہی ہے۔ امت کے بہترین لوگ انہوں نے محض نعروں کے پیچھے مروا دیے۔ ان کے شر سے عامة المسلمین کا ہی نقصان ہوا۔ کفر کے آگے کسی نے بند باندھا تو وہی تھے جن کا خون انہوں نے اپنے لیے حلال کیا ہوا تھا۔ نبی کریم ﷺ نے یہ علامت پہلے ہی بتا دی تھی: "يَقْتُلُونَ أَهْلَ الْإِسْلَامِ وَيَدَعُونَ أَهْلَ الْأَوْثَانِ"؛ اہلِ اسلام کو قتل کریں گے اور بت پرستوں کو چھوڑ دیں گے۔ چودہ صدیوں بعد بھی نشانہ بدلا نہ ترتیب۔ اب یہ طالبان کی جنگ کے بعد پھر سر اٹھا رہے ہیں۔ وہ پہلے بھی بیوقوف تھے جنہیں اردنیوں، مصریوں نے آگے لگائے رکھا۔ اب پھر وہی حال ہے۔ لوگوں کی ذہن سازی کرنا، معاشروں کو بدلنا، ادارہ سازی کرنا، عوام میں انقلاب برپا کرنا لمبا، صبر آزما، مشکل کام ہے۔ بندوق اٹھا کر جلد بازی سے نتائج کے پیچھے بھاگنا آسان ہے۔ یہی وہ جلد بازی ہے جو سوادِ اعظم کو امت کے اکثر ادوار میں موجود اس گروہ سے ممتاز کرتی ہے۔ اور ایسے کسی بھی انقلاب کی وہی درگت بنتی ہے جو افغانستان و ایران سے لیبیا تک کئی دہائیوں سے بنتی آ رہی ہے۔
5
26
5
81
7,273
Replying to @arqaamm
Emotional nahi hona bss
1
36
9 — THE BROWNFIELD BLIND SPOT This is the thing he is closest to being right about, and still misses entirely. Let me bring this back to the projects I work on. At Gundremmingen, RWE is spending about €230 million on a 400 MW / 700 MWh battery sitting on the grid connection of a nuclear plant that has been demolished. Same site, plus 55 hectares of solar and a gas plant to follow. Groundbreaking in late 2025, commercial operation in early 2028 (if some of the reports I worked on get reviewed by RWE in time :D - sorry!). At Coalburn in Scotland, Zenobē reached financial close this year on 200 MW / 800 MWh on a former coal site, with a fifteen-year toll. Coalburn 2 has also almost reached commissioning stage. Neither project is a story about batteries being cheap. Both are stories about the CONNECTION POINT. In Europe a strong 400 kV connection takes eight to twelve years to obtain and is now the scarcest thing in the system. When a power station dies, the connection is the inheritance. That is the asset being monetised. Now look at what we are doing. GHCL has been auctioning defunct GENCO plants as scrap. Jamshoro 880 MW, Muzaffargarh 1,350 MW, Faisalabad 132 MW, a combined 2,362 MW at a reserve price of roughly Rs 26.6 billion, with barely a bidder turning up. Over thirty obsolete units went to Wah Industries for around Rs 38.25 billion. The first round put up nine sites at Kotri, Lakhra, Quetta, Sukkur, Multan, Faisalabad and Shahdara. Every one of those is a Gundremmingen. Land, a 220 or 500 kV switchyard, transmission easement, cooling water, road access, a colony and a trained workforce, all paid for decades ago by the taxpayer. We are selling the copper and giving away the connection for free. The fix costs nothing. Unbundle the auction. Sell the boiler, keep the substation and the transmission infrastructure. Then tender the site as "X MW of firm interconnection at an existing node" for solar and storage. That is the cheapest megawatt in the country and it needs no dam and no new transmission line. If you actually want fast, modular, cheap power, this is where it is, and most analysts never mention it. I have heard that Habibullah Khan and Hassan Mansha have interests in this. Lalpir and Pakgen sit right next to that GENCO corridor. Everyone is waiting for the energy market to liberalise under CTBCM. Many brownfield scenarios are already sitting in NGC system planning files in PLEXOS. SECOND BROWNFIELD PLAY: TURN DEAD GENERATORS INTO SYSTEM STRENGTH Go back to the NESO result I opened with. Regulators are paying for fault current and inertia. A retired steam turbine generator does not have to be scrapped. Declutch it from the turbine and run the machine as a synchronous condenser: no fuel, no emissions, but real inertia, real short-circuit level and reactive support. RWE and Amprion did exactly this at Biblis (Germany). ESB (Ireland) did it at Moneypoint. South Australia did it after the 2016 blackout. Muzaffargarh, Jamshoro, Guddu and Lakhra sit precisely where solar is concentrating and where the grid is weakest for inverter penetration. Converting even a handful of those machines would be the cheapest system strength Pakistan can buy, and it would let us connect MORE solar, not less. That is a pro-solar argument, and it needs the carcass of a thermal plant to work. THIRD, AND THIS IS WHAT ENDS THE ARGUMENT: WAPDA'S OWN BROWNFIELD PIPELINE IS THE CHEAPEST HYDRO ON HIS OWN CHART His first chart shows Tarbela Extension 5 as the cheapest project on the board, around $1,500/kW. That is not by luck or accident. T5 adds 1,530 MW on Tunnel 5, taking Tarbela from 4,888 MW to 6,418 MW. No new dam, no new reservoir, no resettlement, no new 500 kV line. It is brownfield hydro, and it is cheap for exactly the same reason Gundremmingen is cheap. Mangla Refurbishment is the same logic: 1,000 MW rising to 1,310 MW, four units already refurbished and back in service, the rest scheduled to 2030, executed without shutting the station down, part funded by a USAID grant and AFD. And the one nobody in this argument seems to have noticed: WAPDA is building Pakistan's first floating solar, around 325 MW split between the Tarbela reservoir and the Ghazi Barotha head ponds, on substations that already exist. WAPDA conceived this back in 2015 under a World Bank technical assistance package tied to the Tarbela extension, and the site list has since grown to include Ghazi Barotha, Khanpur and Attock. That project is the answer to his entire thread. Floating solar on a hydro reservoir gives you cheap daytime energy on a connection that is already built and paid for, on water instead of farmland, running cooler and therefore more efficiently than panels baking at 50°C in Bahawalpur, on a dedicated 220 kV corridor that sits idle for most of the day, with evaporation losses reduced as a bonus. And the dam itself is the battery. Hold water back while the sun is up, release it at maghrib. No lithium, no rare-earth insecurity, no imports, and no replacement cycle every twelve years. You do not have to choose between the dam and the panel. Put the panel on the dam. (I would have called for a Nobel Prize or something, but this is a very old idea that has already gone crazy in China. Dammit, Chinese!!) There is more of this available than people realise: canal-top solar along tens of thousands of kilometres of the world's largest canal network, low-head units at the existing barrages, spare transformer capacity at DISCO 132 kV grid stations, and the retired IPP sites at Mehmood Kot and elsewhere whose PPAs have now lapsed. None of it requires a new right of way. All of it is faster than anything either side of this argument is proposing.
1
1
241
5 — THE CURRENCY RUNS THE OTHER WAY The FX argument runs in the opposite direction to the one he claims. This matters to Pakistan as much as EVs do, and for the same reason: economic security. Most of a dam's cost is civil works. Cement, aggregate, local steel and local labour, all paid in rupees. The imported content is turbines, generators, gates and some components of the balance of plant. A solar+BESS plant is cells, modules, inverters and trackers. It is close to fully imported, including the part Pakistan has a whole industry capable of localising. So per rupee of capital cost it carries MORE dollar exposure, not less. And it carries that exposure again at every replacement cycle instead of once. The last I checked, the Power Division and other stakeholders were working hard to lift local content in DB's eBOP alone from 11 to 30%. The older generation did this exercise starting with Mangla. Go and check with PEL, who now export transformers to the very USA that jump-started the Mangla and Tarbela projects. Whole industries were propped up by that one initiative. Splitting a project into tranches does not hedge currency risk. It simply books each tranche at a worse rate than the last one.
1
79
3 — WHOSE BILL IS IT He charges the full cost of a water project to your electricity bill, then complains that the electricity is expensive. Bhasha is 8.1 MAF gross and 6.4 MAF of live storage. Pakistan's large reservoirs have already lost about a third of their design capacity to silt. Tarbela alone has gone from 9.679 MAF of live storage down to 6.434 MAF in 38 years, against a sediment inflow of roughly 200 million tonnes a year. Bhasha is credited with cutting the sediment reaching Tarbela by around 69 per cent and extending Tarbela's life by about 35 years. So the dam is simultaneously an irrigation asset, a flood asset, a sediment trap protecting an existing national asset, and a power plant. Allocate the capital properly across those four functions and the share attributable to electricity falls sharply. He concedes in the thread that "dams are important for water and flood management", and then prices them as if they were not. You cannot have it both ways. 4 — A WALLET IS NOT A BANK ACCOUNT A battery and a reservoir are not the same machine. This is the lesson from the 800 to 1,200 MWh projects being built across the world right now. A battery is a wallet. A reservoir is a bank account. You cannot pay a year's school fees out of a wallet, no matter how many wallets you buy. 6.4 MAF of live storage behind that head is something in the order of 3 to 4 TWh of stored, dispatchable energy, refilled free every year by snowmelt. Building that as lithium at $270/kWh gives you a number with twelve digits in it. Four hours of battery, which is about the most you can go right now, is a brilliant answer to the evening ramp in July. It is not an answer to a Rabi shortfall, to a two-week December fog event, or to a low-water year.
1
2
115
2 — THE TWENTY-YEAR WINDOW Judging a dam over twenty years is like judging a house purchase against renting by looking only at the first five years, while you are still paying the arrangement fees. A 272 m concrete gravity dam has a design life well past a century. Tarbela is 51 years old and its useful life now runs to around 2060. Over that period you replace the battery fleet six or seven times and the solar modules three or four times, each replacement at whatever the exchange rate happens to be on that day. But hear this part out loud, because most analysts skip it and Ammar has overlooked it as well: the capacity charge on a dam STOPS when the debt is repaid. After that the plant delivers power at almost zero cost for another sixty years. It is exactly why Tarbela and Mangla are the cheapest electricity on the Pakistani system today. One of his charts showed solar+BESS debt service going flat after year 10 and staying flat forever. That quietly assumes the batteries never need replacing. Draw both lines out to year 40 honestly and they cross.
1
3
232
This is a good effort, but it falls short due to the technical limitations of the author. I am lucky to work closely on some flagship EU projects, Gundremmingen and Coalburn, although in a very different and highly technical domain. I must begin by saying: people do not understand the complexity involved, and investment bankers plus politicians have put the whole of the EU and the USA in a tailspin compared to China. In the UK, in NESO's Stability Market Round 2, every grid-forming BESS submission failed technical assessment while synchronous condensers and OCGTs took 7.3 GVA of contracts. This was after £323 million had already been spent proving BESS could do the job. The market is still paying for real inertia and real fault current, not the synthetic proxy. And Pakistan's own January 2021 and January 2023 nationwide blackouts were restored on hydro black start. No inverter fleet black-starts a 25 GW system. Now let me address the claims to the best of my ability, which I must say is minuscule compared to the giants I have seen in this field, even in Pakistan. 1 — THE DENOMINATOR PROBLEM Ammar is a learned person and I think he has used this metric before, but here his whole thread rests on comparing US$/kW of nameplate capacity. That is the size of the motor, not the amount of water it pumps. This is, unfortunately, the very McKinsey and Lazard style that rookie analysts use. The comparison must account for plant capacity factor, which means US$ per kWh actually delivered. Bhasha is designed for 4,500 MW producing roughly 18.1 TWh a year. That is a capacity factor of about 46 per cent. Utility solar in Pakistan runs at 18 to 20 per cent in its early years. Do the division on his own numbers: Solar+BESS at $705/kW ÷ 19% = about $3,711 per average kW actually delivered Hydro at $1,798/kW ÷ 46% = about $3,909 per average kW actually delivered That is a 5% difference, not 61%. And that is the wrong comparison anyway, because a 30 per cent battery attach is not a dispatchable plant. The correct comparator against a reservoir is his own "100% firmed" tier at $1,200/kW, which works out at roughly $6,316 per average kW delivered. That is about 62% MORE capital-intensive than the hydro he is arguing against. His own chart contained the refutation. I just did the division. Now,
On why delaying power generation from Diamor Bhasha (or any dam) is a great idea. A Solar+BESS combo has 61% lower capital intensity than hydro, cam he rolled out in 6-18 months, while hydro takes a minimum of 8 years and remain susceptible to delays and cost overruns 1/
2
2
10
915
Pakistan's bet on the House of Saud is unlike anything else available in this century. To my working, Aal-e-Saud is the only remaining functional great house in the world showing no sign of stopping -- and they are not slowing down. They are entering their next hundred-year stage. Zooming out to see that organic structure is essential before any of the rest makes sense. I say this coming from a background critical of monarchies. I spent most of my youth as the off-the-shelf romantic you find by the dozen in the post-colonial Muslim world. But manoeuvring idealism -- not moralism -- in a world of brick and mortar is entirely doable, if you know how things actually work. For the fifty to hundred years ahead, Pakistan's commitment to Saudi Arabia yields multiples over any commitment to Türkiye or China. Jordan, Egypt, Kuwait -- they are not the main players. That hemisphere is controlled by Riyadh. The Saudis are the only apex player in the region, and I have been saying this for years. Everything Pakistan has done on the Abraham Accords, Libya, Sudan -- it was built on a working arrangement with the Saudis, and to a lesser extent the Turks. That framework is yielding results. It should be deepened and committed to. The rest is just noise.
3
2
23
1,679
Erdoğan didn't so much out-plan the plotters as invert, in real time, every condition a coup needs to succeed. Read against Luttwak's (a guy is a douchebag, but!!) classic checklist -- decapitate the leadership, seize the information organs, present a fait accompli before loyalists can coordinate, and keep the population a passive spectator -- the Yurtta Sulh Konseyi ("Peace at Home Council") faction failed on all four, and each failure maps onto a specific counter-move on his side.
🤖 Made with AI
3
8
474