Sabih (@Nazaratives) header
Sabih (@Nazaratives) profile picture

☪️ Muslim · Sunni · (Just a) Student of Knowledge, Khaṭīb 🔥 My Interests — Theology ⚙️ My Bread/Butter— AI, Computer Science ▶️ https://nitter.cf/t.co/gn0pvxgXEC

Germany
Joined March 2026
Photo by Sabih (@Nazaratives)Photo by Sabih (@Nazaratives)Photo by Sabih (@Nazaratives)Photo by Sabih (@Nazaratives)Photo by Sabih (@Nazaratives)Photo by Sabih (@Nazaratives)Photo by Sabih (@Nazaratives)Photo by Sabih (@Nazaratives)Photo by Sabih (@Nazaratives)Photo by Sabih (@Nazaratives)
God being separate from creations entails Him having a spatial measure (miqdar), according to Ibn Taymiyya in his second phase, not his first phase and it's certainly not an Athari belief, that's just a label Mujassima of our times adopt. Separation does not entail having miqdar (spatial measure), according to us, which is what @hashimiyy_ wrote. Heck, it's not even separation, their literal belief is that something transcending spatial measure cannot possibly exist and the source of this way of thinking is using Wahm (imagination) to dictate nature of God.
1
2
49
The funny thing is that a lot of them still try to hide their beliefs in ambiguous words as if they know their guilt internally, so what's with hiding behind "separate", cut to the chase, you believe in separation by Miqdar (spatial measure), a size having God (that too finite from all sides) being separate from Universe. You believe that Ash'aris and Maturidis and standard Atharis (even if you don't admit) worship nothing because a being not spatially spread is nothing. That's the belief, state it proudly and unambiguously and without shame. Many of them actually fought tooth and nail, accusing us of lying upon Ibn Taymiyya, before realising: 'oops, he said it', only to start parrotting the non-sense while others hide behind saying, no it's not the 3D extension, it's this or that, but that's exactly what IT meant..
3
28
Initially, I had the impression that Mufti Taqi said something absurd to the effect that selling something that benefits Palantir or is used for genocidal purposes, is okay ( I guess many laymen who retweeted the post might not have watched the video or if they did, they didn't get it). However, upon watching the video, he is actually saying something pretty normal that if someone is sure of such a usage then the transaction is not Halal. I am not really sure what is the issue here. The remarks on the post are simply misleading. If may try to find faults myself, it could be the following: 1- Why does Mufti say that the transaction takes place nevertheless? 2- Why does he condition forbidding sale upon certainty and lets it go when you are unsure? As for 1, it appears that the objector may not know the very difference between بيع فاسد and بيع باطل. Furthermore, this doesnt look like fasid even, it is Haram due to an extrinsic reason which is aiding in sin and transgression. The transaction itself is valid. A close analog I can provide from Ilm ul-Kalam is the position of many Deobandi scholars that a lie in Kalam Nafsi is intrinsically impossible, however, a deception or so by God is extrinsically impossible due to Hikmah, while it remains within the Qudrah. Some people made a mountain out of that also. If someone knows that beneficiary is using the sold item for genocide, quite clearly, the transaction would be HARAM (albeit, due to an external factor) and Mufti Taqi explicitly said it that if one is sure that him selling weapons or contributing to it shall be used by the enemies or in the civil war, this is *prohibited*. So, I am not sure what's the noise about and why it warrants insinuating that he has gone insane, while he is still the president of Wifaq. I myself don't agree with some of his takes, but I don't get the issue here. As for the second issue, the Fuqaha have mentioned that many times very highly likely is treated as certain. In that case it would be forbidden. Third issue is to also assess if the relative benefit for the Muslims is higher. And fourth one is to also look at the nature of the product, for e.g., direct sale of weapons or something directly convertible to harm is clear as compared to any thing which may end up by many steps being used in a certain way. If someone claims that the later is Haram then there is no limit to such an argument because the very letters and words that I type on internet may contribute to training of AI which may contribute to genocide! That is why classical scholars differentiated between various cases of selling to Ahl ul-Harb, is it a weapon bi-'aynihi, is it iron, is it some commodity? How essential is a commodity? Etc, etc. All these above mentioned factors are to be seen. Mufti Taqi gave a correct principled short answer, completely fine. So once again, the idea that he must go against the fundamentals of fiqh and say that the transaction itself is non-existent (while he is calling it haram) , otherwise, we will call him senile Palantir loving Mufti, is very immature behavior.
Shaykh Taqi Usmani has done his job. Has written excellent books. It’s time for him to retire from this kind of interactions. He is on the road to senility. His English is not that good. His generation does not understand Palantir and its trans humanist agenda. It’s not a stock or a company. It’s Evil incarnate. Example of “halal meat and haram meat” from medieval texts are not going to cut it, most respectfully. I see elderly scholars undoing their great legacies by not retiring on time. Time for his students to come forward and communicate what they have learned with impeccable language skills, and transcending the “contract is valid” trap and see the forest for the trees, and save fiqh before it becomes too late.
6
15
101
8,233
Ibn Taymiyya affirming that God has a limit in the precise meaning of miqdar (spatial measure, i.e., three dimensional spatial extention). Ascribes it to the Salaf and claims that God's existence cannot be comprehended without miqdar. This is his own hand writing, published in jami' al-masa'il vol:8, pg:70, Uzayr Shams' edition. The manuscript is in Zahiriyya Library, said to be written in 706 Hijri by IT himself. This is precisely the time when I estimate the change in his views took place, prior to which, he did not affirm spatial measure or God becoming a locus of temporal occurrences.
14
15
3
76
12,017
Welcome to the clilub---takfired by Barelvis, wear it like badge of honor.
The cultists of Abū al-Ḥasan who deemed my blood lawful to shed will uncritically swallow any response, no matter how intellectually bankrupt, so long as one is offered. When Imām Ibn Fūrak uses the expression مِنْ نَوْعِ (“of the same kind”), does this not necessarily presuppose that the prophets themselves belong to that same category for his analogy to hold? Any sincere reader would understand this. However, it is entirely possible that @ridawipress is simply an ignorant liar who lacks even the rudimentary competence required to read and comprehend works of kalām. He cannot even grasp how the doctrine of kasb pertains to the question of istighāthah, yet has the audacity to lecture others on matters of manṭiq. Jāhil murakkab in the fullest sense: ignorant of the subject, ignorant of his own ignorance, and arrogant enough to mistake that ignorance for knowledge.
1
6
299
This book needs to be translated in Arabic, Turkish, and a number of non-Subcon Muslim languages. I feel as if the threat of India isn't properly understood.
My new book, The Architecture of Complicity: How India Helped Israel Conduct a Genocide in Gaza, will be published by @PlutoPress in January 2027. The book shows how India, which presents itself as a leader of the Global South, helped enable Israel’s genocide in Gaza alongside its Western allies. It traces media complicity, diplomatic shielding at international forums and the replacement of Palestinian workers with Indian labour. It also examines how and why Palestine failed to become a national political issue in India. Drawing on previously unpublished military trade data, the book reveals the scale of Indian military exports to Israel during the genocide. It will be available in the US, UK, South Africa and, hopefully, India.
2
5
1
12
629
I principle, this is the strongest proof against shias that if Ali(ra) was divinely appointed, he would not agree to serving under Shaykhayn.
Although I do not hold to the creed of Maturidis, just a simple fact check can prove that this person is probably misrepresenting the Maturidi position. I might post more evidence if I find it, so please check the comments for a possible thread 🧵; In his tafsir of the Qur'an, specifically of Surah al-Maidah, Abu Mansur al-Maturidi states; “And that was at the time when Ali—may Allah be pleased with him—sought the caliphate and fought for it. For it is inconceivable that he would know that he had the caliphate during the time of Abu Bakr—may Allah be pleased with him—and regard the right as belonging to himself, and then abandon seeking it, thereby neglecting his own right. Thus, his silence and abandonment of seeking it indicate that the right was not his, but rather belonged to Abu Bakr—may Allah be pleased with him. And Allah knows best.” Tawilat Ahl al-Sunna, vol. 3 OR 4 (not sure), p. 543 He also states; “And in this is evidence establishing the imamate of Abu Bakr—may Allah be pleased with him—for Allah, Mighty and Majestic, praised them for going forth in the path of Allah and striving against His enemies...” Tawilat Ahl al-Sunna, vol. 3 OR 4 (not sure), p. 542
1
5
381
Although I do not hold to the creed of Maturidis, just a simple fact check can prove that this person is probably misrepresenting the Maturidi position. I might post more evidence if I find it, so please check the comments for a possible thread 🧵; In his tafsir of the Qur'an, specifically of Surah al-Maidah, Abu Mansur al-Maturidi states; “And that was at the time when Ali—may Allah be pleased with him—sought the caliphate and fought for it. For it is inconceivable that he would know that he had the caliphate during the time of Abu Bakr—may Allah be pleased with him—and regard the right as belonging to himself, and then abandon seeking it, thereby neglecting his own right. Thus, his silence and abandonment of seeking it indicate that the right was not his, but rather belonged to Abu Bakr—may Allah be pleased with him. And Allah knows best.” Tawilat Ahl al-Sunna, vol. 3 OR 4 (not sure), p. 543 He also states; “And in this is evidence establishing the imamate of Abu Bakr—may Allah be pleased with him—for Allah, Mighty and Majestic, praised them for going forth in the path of Allah and striving against His enemies...” Tawilat Ahl al-Sunna, vol. 3 OR 4 (not sure), p. 542
Imam Ali was the rightful leader according to Sunnis This is according to Imam Māturīdī the founder of the Māturīdī school which is followed by Hanafis, the biggest group of Muslims. No one was equal to Ali in his entitlement [to the leadership]. This is indicated by the Prophetic report concerning the reign of Abu Bakr, where the Prophet relayed; “If you are entrusted to Abu Bakr, you will find him weak in body but strong in religion if you are entrusted to Umar you will find him strong in body and strong in religion; and if you are entrusted to you will find that he is guided by God and will lead you on the right path.” Based on what [the Prophet] said Umar included [Ali] into the Shura and the Sahabah agreed on his [leadership].” (Kitaab at-Tawheed)
2
4
3
28
9,541
Abu Ismail al-Harawi has some content that is distasteful to everyone. Even Ibn Taymiyya calls him a Jahmi on matters of Jabr and among the worst. Objectively looking, does he believe in Hulul? I am not convinced because such statements were known to be from the shatahaat or wahdat ul Shuhud. Most importantly, people should have consistent methodology, it shouldn't be the case that their side of Sufis with similar statements are given a charitable reading, while others are not. Ibn Rajab mentions about al-Harawi that he had such an unstable temperament of boycotting on smallest of issues: فإن الأنصاري والتيمي وأمثالهما يقدحون بأدنى شيء ينكرونه من مواضع النزاع There is more to Ansari on issues of tanzih, like did he really believe in spatial measure and Hulul of Hawadith as Ibn Taymiyya does?
This quoted post is unavailable.
3
466
L'encouragement puis l'accompagnement au retour des kurdes d'Afrin a été un énorme symbole et un geste concret. Près de 90 % des kurdes chassés d'Afrin par la Turquie et ses milices en 2018 sont rentrés chez eux. De l'aveu même de l'ex-AANES. 8/
1
4
1
71
4,401
And so can say the person who wants the dome over the blessed grave blown up that he simply wants the fiqhi rulings enacted upon? Whereas, the prophecy does not even carry with it a legal ruling.
I again deleted this post because it was being deliberately misconstrued as a call for bombing the Haram. In reality, I believe that these tall buildings in Saudi and the Gulf are the ones prophesied in the Sahih hadith: "When will the Hour be? [...] When you see barefoot, naked, destitute shepherds competing in constructing tall buildings." Keep in mind, this clock tower is part of a luxury McHotel complex that the Saudi regime wants to continuously expand as part of their secularizing Vision 2030 agenda. They want to continuously change the face of Mecca and orient it towards more luxury consumerism. I believe that many of Saudi's longstanding policies have been a unique evil in Muslim history, and have caused and continue to cause the death and destruction of countless Muslims. They have opened Mecca, Madina and all of Arabia for the West and Israel to occupy and infiltrate, to secularize our religion. One day, corruption and tyranny will be removed by Allah, including their symbols of clock towers, etc. So that is my message. Hopefully this is a better expression than my previous post. Ultimately Brother Mohammed Hijab advised deleting the original post, as did other brothers. Out of respect for them, I've done so.
1
2
643
It’s genuinely mind-boggling to see people actually defending the ṭāghūt Bashshār al-ʾAsad.
1
2
9
454
The wajh of tashbih is that all mentioned in the categories are not fought for their e'teqad, this obviously, doesn't mean that he considered companions at the battle of Jamal morally equivalent to khawarij or other groups. Why would someone offer such an egregious reading of the text as if Jassas saw our mother 'Ayesha(ra) equivalent in the moral sense to other categories, which would be Kufr. The wajh of Tashbih is explicitly mentioned as Ahl al-Qiblah fought not for e' teqad of Kufr. As for the objection of seeing the blood spillable, once again, a deliberately bad choice of words as if the blood was just deemed Halal for no reason, the predominant Hanafi-Maturidi (though Jassas is only a Hanafi, not Maturidi) view is that Ali(ra) was legally the Khalifa and the ones opposing him from the Sahaba(ra) at Jamal did the rebellion, for which, the legal ruling is fighting those who rebel. This was obviously the Ijtihad of 'Ali(ra). It's a different situation altogether morally speaking, from perspective of Aqidah, respect, love, etc, but that does not change the base legal ruling.
The jurist al-Jaṣṣāṣ, in his discussion on fighting rebels, argues that the people of al-Jamal were not to have their women and children enslaved. He mentions that many in the army requested to enslave their women, until ʿAlī رضي الله عنه stopped them by saying, in meaning: “Who among you will take ʿĀʾishah?” From this, al-Jaṣṣāṣ derives that their women and children were not to be enslaved. However, while discussing them, he explicitly treats their blood as permissible to spill due to rebellion, and then uses deeply offensive analogies, comparing them to adulterers deserving stoning, highway robbers, and Khārijites, all in the context of speaking about the army that included the Mother of the Believers ʿĀʾishah, along with Ṭalḥah and al-Zubayr رضي الله عنهم. The framing is reprehensible and grossly inappropriate when speaking about some of the greatest Companions of the Prophet ﷺ.
2
191
UAE was never a backer of Syrian revolution, in fact, it opposed it from the get go and is still opposed, though for diplomatic reasons, it has toned its criticisms down.
Simple question for the Syrian nationalists. You claim that the ousting of Assad was justified because of Assad's record of injustice. Do you feel the same about UAE, which has allied with Israel, backed the genocide in Sudan, jailed and tortured many dissidents? Should MBZ be ousted? Don't be shy. Or are you not allowed to be consistent on this question, since Jolani will throw you in jail for criticizing one of his main backers?
1
140
Sabih retweeted
Assad is obviously worse than Netanyahu. The Syrian civil war killed an estimated 500,000+ people, with the regime responsible for the large majority of documented civilian deaths through barrel bombs on residential areas, chemical weapons attacks (Ghouta, 2013), and systematic torture and killing in facilities like Sednaya prison, which UN investigators and Amnesty International have both documented in detail. Millions of Syrians were displaced internally or forced into exile Streamers sitting in the US, thousands of miles from any of this, talking like they’ve got the moral high ground on a war they’ve never lived through or if anyone cares about their opinions
SNEAKO is left COMPLETELY BAMBOOZLED after his lawyer HASAN SHIBLY claims BASHAR AL-ASSAD is worse than BENJAMIN NETANYAHU — and says he hopes they BOTH END UP IN HELL 😳💀 “Assad is worse than Benjamin Netanyahu. If not, they are equal.”
22
4
132
7,779
The Royal Imagery of Istiwaʾ The linguistic beauty of the verse: الرَّحْمٰنُ عَلَى الْعَرْشِ اسْتَوَى is in the majesty of the image it evokes: sovereignty, mastery, kingship, and perfect governance. In Arabic, استوى على can be used figuratively from the image of iʿtilāʾ (rising over / being above), rising over or being established above something, to convey tamakkun (complete mastery and established authority): authority firmly established in rule. This is why Arabic can say: استوى على سرير الملك، أو على العرش: تولّى الملك “He istawā upon the royal throne,” meaning: he assumed kingship. The image of a king established upon his throne naturally conveys far more than the throne itself. It signifies the fullness of his authority, the reach of his command, and his governance of the realm. This understanding also appears very early in tafsīr. Al-Māwardī preserves an attribution to al-Ḥasan al-Baṣrī: معناه استوى أمره على العرش، قاله الحسن “Its meaning is: His command became established with respect to the Throne; al-Ḥasan said this.” Al-Qaffāl likewise explains: ثم أخبر بعده أنه استوى على العرش أي حصل له تدبير المخلوقات على ما شاء وأراد “Then He informed that He istawā upon the Throne, meaning that the governance of created things proceeded according to what He willed and desired.” Even more striking is his reading of the wording in Sūrat Yūnus: ثُمَّ اسْتَوَى عَلَى الْعَرْشِ يُدَبِّرُ الْأَمْرَ “Then He istawā upon the Throne, governing the affair.” Al-Qaffāl says: فقوله: يدبر الأمر جرى مجرى التفسير لقوله: استوى على العرش “His saying, ‘He governs the affair,’ functions as an explanation of His saying, ‘He istawā upon the Throne.’” This makes the Qurʾānic imagery especially powerful. The Throne evokes the highest image of sovereignty familiar to human language, while يُدَبِّرُ الْأَمْرَ makes explicit what that sovereignty means: command, governance, and the ordering of creation according to the Divine Will. So when Allah says: الرَّحْمٰنُ عَلَى الْعَرْشِ اسْتَوَى the image points toward tamakkun (complete mastery and established authority) and tadbīr (governance and ordering): There is something especially beautiful in the choice of the Divine Name al-Raḥmān (the All-Merciful). The One whose sovereignty encompasses all creation is the All-Merciful. Majesty and mercy, kingship and care, dominion and governance are gathered into one magnificent expression.
5
4
31
1,535
Tafwid ul-Ma'na of Ibn Kathir Somehow, the content of the ignoramus Jake has been showing more on my youtube. In most recent video, he attempts to show Imam Ibn Kathir was an anti-Ash'ari figure, however, the quotation he uses, is going against his own position squarely. For example, the claim from our side is not that Ibn Kathir was sympathetic to Kalam or that he was sympathetic to ta'wil in general, or that he was fully Ash'ari, the claim is specifically that Ibn Kathir was doing Tafwid ul-Ma'na and definitely not affirming spatial measure or concrete attributes, because of the relevant passages in his tafsir. However, Taymites dispute the meaning of إمرار (passing ambigious texts) and related passages, which brings us to find other instances to clarify the understanding of Ibn Kathir. This happens in Ibn Kathir's Tabaqat al-Shafi'iyya where Ibn Kathir explicitly says that the second opinion of Al-Juwayni is exactly the Madhab of the Salaf. This is obviously very problematic citation for Taymites because the Taymites never accept that Juwayni's second understanding on Sifat Khabariyya is the Aqidah of Salaf. For Taymites, both Tafwidh and Ta'wil are equally deviant position, if one is Tahrif, other is Tajhil. For some reason, this does not register in the mind of the ignoramus; he assumes that the quote he is citing is against Ash'aris, while it is not.
6
313