The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver) header
The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver) profile picture

Dude

Israel
Joined July 2007
Photo by The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver)Photo by The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver)Photo by The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver)Photo by The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver)Photo by The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver)Photo by The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver)Photo by The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver)Photo by The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver)Photo by The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver)Photo by The Bagel People (@Onlineobserver)
The Bagel People retweeted
Egypt's peace with Israel has held since 1979. Jordan's since 1994. The UAE, Bahrain and Morocco since 2020. Every Arab government that tried peace with Israel got peace. Hamas tried rockets and Oct 7 and got exactly what that gets you. Cry harder.
61
727
17
4,275
41,740
What I see here: the art of bullshit- and something much, much more dangerous. Hasan Piker is a commentator and political activist who built his fame promoting a radical view of Israel while expressing sympathy for forces like Hezbollah, fundamentalist and reactionary movements abhorrent to any coherent progressivism. He knows very little about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict or its history. He stitches together fragments: scraps of history, anecdotal observations from different eras, pieces of unrelated circumstances. The result is bullshit dressed up as political insight. Example: At the beginning of the clip, Ezra Klein raises the question of Israeli security concerns, giving the impression that this is a substantive discussion. Piker responds by asking how Palestinians can be expected to live alongside “those who slaughtered them.” When wars and conflicts end, people routinely find themselves living alongside those they once fought. And Palestinians, of course, have slaughtered Israelis too. That's precisely why security concerns are a serious issue. Piker isn't interested in answering the question. He's interested in turning it into another opportunity to portray Israelis as monstrous, while evading the issue. It's just a shallow political performance. Klein knows well what Piker is doing. Yet he sits across from him with a straight face and treats him as an authority on the Middle East. He doesn't do it because Piker has anything illuminating to say. He does it because Piker commands an enormous young audience, and with it clicks. The performance rests on a bargain: Piker delivers his radical talking points, and everyone else pretends something intellectually serious is taking place => more hits. A legit onlyfans. Pornography simulates intimacy without providing any, and this kind of discourse simulates intellectual engagement without delivering any. It borrows the gestures of serious journalism, like measured questions, the thoughtful expressions and the look of open-minded inquiry, and empties them of substance. Why is this dangerous? Because hatred is one thing. People see the images from Gaza, believe passionately in Palestinian liberation, and come to hate Israel. That's an emotional response. But something fundamentally different happens when hatred masquerades as intellectualism. Hatred alone has limited political reach. Many people are reluctant to enlist in it. But dress it up as reasoned analysis, as a sophisticated debate that supposedly leads to the conclusion that Israel has no right to exist as a national home for Jews, and suddenly you can recruit people, institutions, justify policies, and legitimize violance. What started as the art of bullshit becomes the pornography of discourse, and ultimately something more dangerous: the transformation of prejudice into the shell of respectable thought.
190
366
61
2,940
443,252
The Bagel People retweeted
Morální džihád je silný módní trend. Neodolal ani pilot F1 Lewis Hamilton, který se nechal odvézt na egyptsko-gazánskou hranici. Vychrlil spoustu velkých slov o genocidním Izraeli a mohutných zdech vybudovaných jím kolem vězení pod širým nebem. Drobný problém je, že se nechal vyfotit u egyptské strany přechodu Rafah. Mohutné zdi a ostnaté dráty postavil… wait for it… Egypt! Aby zabránil pašování zbraní Hamásem, masovému exodu Palestinců před izraelskými bombami. Slepota morálních majáků vůči utlačování Palestinců arabskými státy, ale i vlastními extremisty, a především zneužívání jejich utrpení pro sebepropagaci neslouží Gazanům, ale výhradně autorům podobných výkřiků s nezbytnou fotografií jich samotných uprostřed dění.
57
174
18
1,819
54,267
The Bagel People retweeted
Palestinians were never given a state by the Ottomans or Jordanians because they never existed!
46
399
18
1,141
11,117
The Bagel People retweeted
This is the definition of insanity, and it shows how far the @UN has fallen.
SHAME: The U.N. General Assembly just elected the murderous Islamic Republic of Iran to its Committee for Program and Coordination, the main body shaping the world organization’s priorities on Women’s Rights, Human Rights, Disarmament and Counter-Terrorism. 144 voted for Iran. 🧵
1,108
5,305
187
27,188
458,111
The Bagel People retweeted
If Israel’s objective was genocide, why facilitate humanitarian aid, vaccination campaigns, civilian evacuations and the return of displaced Palestinians? These are legitimate questions that deserve serious answers. Accusations as grave as genocide demand evidence, not political slogans.
16
135
10
423
19,573
Israeli mother on live TV, asked about Western recognition of Palestine: “If you’re willing to have your daughters 30 meters away from terrorists who openly say they will massacre, rape and burn them… and your government does nothing… and even gives them food… …and you think that’s normal… …and you want to give them a state (which they already had since 2005)…” She continues: “They had independence. What did they do with it? They destroyed their own territory.” Then, looking straight into the camera: “I wish the British people a lot of luck. As one mother to the mothers of the United Kingdom… you are being overtaken by extremist Islamist forces.” No filter. No apology. Just reality. Am Yisrael Chai 🇮🇱
12
1,444
53
5,509
89,969
The Bagel People retweeted
Hey @VP Vance, this is how it's done. We shouldn't govern by polls. We should govern by principle and what is right. #MAGA
443
3,428
173
20,454
2,298,209
The Bagel People retweeted
the first 48 hours of Woke 2 has already produced more humor than the entire decade of Woke 1
the algo is out of control rn
228
1,699
276
15,670
1,066,924
The Bagel People retweeted
Joe Rogan just passes on any ol' lie he finds in the deepest holes of the internet, even when the lie is raw hate from beginning to end. Israel allows genetic testing. Almost all clinical tests and prenatal tests are actually covered under our national health insurance. And you absolutely can get ancestry testing in Israel. 23AndMe specifically, which Joe mentions as outlawed in Israel, ships to Israel. Go to their international website and try it before you spread this dumb, mean lie. Also FamilyTreeDNA and some others. And once you get your raw DNA information through 23AndMe and others, you can upload it to every other ancestry website for analysis. In fact, Ashkenazi Jews, including Israeli Ashkenazim, are some of the most genetically studied populations on the fucking planet, you racist dolts. (Oops, just realized I'm kinda pissed.) There are even Israeli studies by Israeli researchers of Israeli Jewish genetics. Nature has published studies using Israeli genetics databases. Here, for example: nature.com/articles/nature09… So what does Israel actually restrict, and why is it so severe about it? Two words: Parentage and obsessive privacy rules. Parentage tests are as tightly controlled as heroin. The reason is peculiar to our tradition and may be hard for outsiders to understand. In Jewish religious law, a "mamzer," someone born of the mother's adultery or from incest, lives a restricted life in some ways, including limits on who they can marry under traditional laws. And their religious status is heritable. These are ancient laws, but they matter in a basically conservative and religious society. To protect children from ever becoming saddled with this status, parentage tests require a family court order, even if both parents consent to the test. Because the child has to be protected. Rabbinical courts have often forbidden testing almost across the board, including in divorce cases. In one case I once read about, the rabbinical court quashed the father's genetic test and demanded that he adopt the child to avoid any doubt. This was to protect the child in that particular case. The court refused to release the father from responsibility for the child and refused to examine evidence into the child's actual parentage. Is this a weird cultural artifact born from a specific feature of the Jewish tradition? Yes. Feel free to make fun of it over in the secular West. I make fun of it myself over here. But inasmuch as old traditional rules are an unavoidable part of our big-family, tightly-knit society, I'll take this weirdness, and the never-ending effort to cleverly circumvent the damaging parts of the old traditions, over what's happening in your neck of the woods. Is it all an attempt to hide the 2000 years we spent in Europe? No, you dolt. What the hell is wrong with you? And then there's privacy. Pay attention to this one, because you'll wish you had some of our rules in your own country. This is the only real limit on ancestry kits. Your genetic information is totally, utterly private. Your employer and your insurance company can never discriminate against you based on your genetics. Even just attempting to get their hands on your genetic information is a felony. Labs and genetic counselors are closely regulated. In the age of AI, even just the leaking of a *relative's* genetic information can hurt your employability and your insurance premiums. And it's not some crazy fear. Ancestry kit companies are bought and sold by commercial investors all the time, and they're the owners of customers' data. A data breach of 23AndMe in 2023 put the genetic information of millions on the internet. You're telling me insurance companies didn't scoop it up? Israelis are more protected from that dystopian new reality than most of the rest of you. And importantly, the law's prohibitions are on the commercial companies, not on the customer. Giving someone your own genetic information isn't a crime. The company buying and selling it commercially within the jurisdiction of Israeli law is committing the crime. That's why the one company that's actually hampered in any meaningful way from testing Israelis is MyHeritage, which is Israeli. To bypass Israeli jurisdiction and that massive privacy regime, Israelis just order a kit from a company in Texas. So why do literally hundreds of millions of people believe the lie that Israel has a blanket restriction on genetic testing to avoid anyone ever finding out that Ashkenazi Jews come from Europe? At its core, at its most basic: because they want to create the permission structure to destroy Israel. They want to declare Israel a colonialist, imperialist interloper doomed to be felled by the noble indigenous Arab of the land. So they declare that Israel is hiding this great, terrible secret that nobody has ever hidden and nobody could ever hide -- that it doesn't actually belong here. Never mind the fact that every study of Ashkenazi Jews shows that they have origins in the Levant -- isn't it a bit odd that this argument never grapples with the millions of Israeli Jews who spent the past 1,800 years in places like Iraq and Yemen, Jews who were expelled and fled to the last man, woman and child to Israel, and who make up half of Israeli society today? You'd think if this was actually about Israeli "genetics," that would be part of this conversation. But it isn't about any kind of reality, it's a bigoted, genocidal fantasy. So the millions of Jews who don't even come from Europe magically disappear from this conversation. I don't think Joe Rogan dreams of our annihilation. I think Joe picks up garbage floating in the juices at the bottom of the internet's deepest garbage bins and launders it happily for clicks.
New: Joe Rogan reveals to comedian Sam Tallent that the real reason Israel restricts DNA ancestry testing is because most of the people over there aren’t Semites and are actually just European Jews: ROGAN: “The real Semites are the Palestinians. Benjamin Netanyahu’s family is from Poland.” CONTEXT: Israel does have restrictions on DNA testing. According to Israel's Ministry of Health, paternity and family-relationship DNA tests generally require a COURT ORDER, even when everyone involved consents. And there's an especially surprising detail. MyHeritage, an ancestry-testing company HEADQUARTERED IN ISRAEL that offers DNA kits internationally, explicitly lists ISRAEL among the countries where its consumer ancestry tests are unavailable. But that does NOT establish Rogan's allegation about WHY these restrictions exist. Israel's genetic-information laws address matters including consent, family relationships, privacy, and potential consequences for children. There is no substantiated evidence that the restrictions were created to conceal the ethnic origins of Israel's Jewish population. And when Rogan brings up Netanyahu's Polish family roots, he's referencing something with a documented historical basis. Netanyahu's father, Benzion Netanyahu, was born in WARSAW in 1910, before his family immigrated to what was then British Mandatory Palestine. But European family history doesn't automatically mean someone has no ancient Middle Eastern ancestry. In fact, scientific research reveals a much more complicated story. IMPORTANT NOTES: A major genetic study published in NATURE in 2010 found evidence connecting many Jewish diaspora communities to shared ancestral origins in the LEVANT. And a 2020 study published in CELL examined ancient DNA from Bronze Age populations in the region. Researchers found substantial genetic continuity between ancient Levantine populations and multiple populations living in the region today, including Jewish and Arab communities. In other words, the evidence points to a history of shared regional ancestry, migrations, and intermixing. It’s not a simple genetic division between two populations. Then Rogan takes the discussion even further. He questions whether the term ANTISEMITISM should instead be called “anti-Jewish,” arguing that Palestinians have a stronger claim to being called Semites. But there's another important historical distinction. “Semitic” originally refers to a LANGUAGE FAMILY that includes Hebrew and Arabic, not a scientifically defined genetic race. And the word “antisemitism,” despite its linguistic roots, has historically referred specifically to hostility or prejudice toward JEWISH PEOPLE.
178
679
65
3,784
125,643
The Bagel People retweeted
Saudis are providing a more responsible analysis of Israel’s war against Hamas than many members of Congress.
107
1,190
97
4,603
209,541
The Bagel People retweeted
👇👇👇
Thanks for all the feedback on my last tweet—here is my reply: last night Abdul El-Sayed doubled down on the claims that got him in hot water last week, mainly the idea that rising costs in America are because of US funding of “genocide,” as he put it last night. He made versions of this claim not once but 3 times.
5
11
116
17,988
The Bagel People retweeted
31
103
4
368
4,083
The Bagel People retweeted
Top Democrat strategist Van Jones, One of Obama’s former aides during his presidency Released this message to #Michigan on #AbdulElSayed #Midterms
484
2,985
276
13,328
2,183,848
The Bagel People retweeted
Jewish Democrats are hopeful today that with U.S. funding to Israel ending and AIPAC politically diminished and no longer funding candidates, the hatred will stop. Here in Canada we have no AIPAC equivalent, and our funding to Israel is insignificant. The hatred is worse.
581
1,294
132
9,094
354,491
The Bagel People retweeted
Dan Schueftan gives an honest defense of the Israeli conflict in Gaza.
35
410
34
1,451
33,839
The Bagel People retweeted
If you’re under 30, the most important thing you need to understand about Stevens’ endorsement is that, just 10 years ago, a candidate who (a) signed a letter urging the Muslim Brotherhood to eliminate pro democracy dissidents in Egypt, or (b) refused to disavow a surrogate who claimed America deserved 9/11 or an ad that claimed you can’t afford groceries because bloodthirsty Israelis love to kill children, or (c) said “hurt people hurt people” about a terrorist who tried to murder dozens of children, would not have polled above 2% in a Democratic primary, and that today a Democrat who says that supporting a candidate like the above is a bridge too far in the name of party loyalty is being called a traitor by the Democrat Senate Minority Leader. Haley Stevens is a patriot who put country over party.
233
1,286
81
9,375
337,992
The Bagel People retweeted
I ran into an Israeli protest! #democracy #israelelection
19
64
1
414
16,782
The Bagel People retweeted
Truth is stranger than fiction…
1,359
12,658
741
54,775
882,695
The Bagel People retweeted
Idag var jag med om en av de märkligare ögonblicken i min karriär. Jag var inbjuden att diskutera Israel/”Palestina” (vad annars?) i studio 3s soffprogram på YouTube. Både Kasselstrand och en kolla från Palestinarörelsen vid namn Fayad var med och på något sätt, i hård konkurrens med dessa herrar lyckades en ung man vid namn Magnus Sturm (vad annat än Sturm?) från den så kallade tankesmedjan Katalys leverera ett av de mest absurda situationer jag varit med om i sådana här sammanhang. Mitt i en rant om att Israel mördar barn (vad annars?) vänder han sig till mig och frågar varför jag överhuvudtaget är engagerad i den här frågan. ”Jag ser dig alltid ute och veva men varför är du ens engagerad i det här?” eller något i den stilen. Jag blev faktiskt ställd. För förutom att jag är jude, barnbarn till förintelseöverlevare i alla led vars släkt mördades i Förintelsen, har bott i Israel som barn, har släktingar och vänner i Israel och ser Israel som garanten för att jag ska kunna leva säkert som svensk jude så är det självklart för mig eftersom det är en fråga som handlar om västerländsk civilisation, om liberal demokrati mot barbari, om rätt och fel, sanning och lögn och alla dessa ting är mig mycket kära. Det absurda består i att han, etnisk svensk så vitt jag kan bedöma eller med något tyskt ursprung om jag ska drista mig att gissa med anledning av hans efternamn, är så engagerad i den här konflikten. Varför bryr han sig? Hans expertområde enligt katalys hemsida är kriminalpolitik, psykisk ohälsa och unga män. Inte geopolitik. Jag har inte sett några demonstrationer av den svenska vänstern för de hundratusentals som dödats i Jemen, Syrien, Sudan, eller de miljontals som dött i Kongo. Men den här skitkonflikten med relativt få döda i jämförelse får hans blod att koka. Den engagerar varenda fiber i hans kropp. Men så är det. En analys av nästan 14,7 miljoner nyhetsartiklar (på 65 språk) visade att Israel får oproportionerligt hög och ihållande täckning: • Även under relativt lugna år (t.ex. 2019) var 1 av 112 internationella artiklar primärt om Israel. Israel rankades högst i världen i täckning per capita. • 2024 nämndes Israel i 1 av 26 artiklar globalt – mer än dubbelt så många artiklar som alla 48 länder i Afrika söder om Sahara tillsammans. • Efter 7 oktober 2023 låg Israel på i genomsnitt 5,65 % av amerikansk kabel-TV-tid under ett helt år – högre än Ukraina året efter Rysslands invasion. Tigray-kriget i Etiopien (uppskattningsvis ~600 000 döda) nådde aldrig ens 0,03 %. Det är oproportionerligt. Jag skulle säga patologiskt. Och enda anledningen är att ena sidan består av judar. Han skulle aldrig tillstå det själv såklart men jag har inte heller sett vänstern eller palestinierna själva protestera när de massmördas av Hamas, torteras av Fatah eller skjuts i drösar av Libanon. Denna patologi är ett symptom på ett samhälle i förfall. Som hellre fokuserar på judar 3 325 km bort än sina egna problem hemma i Sverige. Eller för den delen vårt närområde. Hans frågar avslöjar en okunskap om historien, om vilka vårt samhälles fiender är, ja, om det mesta faktiskt. Och han är produkten av den svenska skolan, den svenska pressen och svensk kultur. Så bra jobbat allihopa! Jag hoppas att ni är nöjda med er själva.
166
456
17
4,322
128,152