Barmazid (@Pashz7) header
Barmazid (@Pashz7) profile picture

Tarikh-i-Pakhtunkhwa

Joined September 2014
Photo by Barmazid (@Pashz7)Photo by Barmazid (@Pashz7)Photo by Barmazid (@Pashz7)Photo by Barmazid (@Pashz7)Photo by Barmazid (@Pashz7)Photo by Barmazid (@Pashz7)Photo by Barmazid (@Pashz7)Photo by Barmazid (@Pashz7)Photo by Barmazid (@Pashz7)Photo by Barmazid (@Pashz7)
Did you create this map with AI, or what? It's all wrong and bizarre. Check the distance between Peshawar city and Attock, and Hazara is lying somewhere near Chitral or whatever. The Khalsa's Peshawar province is all ballooned up in this AI map, but it was very tiny and narrow.
سکھ ایمپائر (خالصہ سرکار) کے صوبے اور ہمسایہ ریاستیں۔
5
7
50
1,787
Check the rivers on the map he shared. Indus River is flowing out of what looks like Kurram and flows closer to Kandahar city. A river passing through Peshawar city and Attock turns into the Jhelum River and then becomes Chenab River. The Indus River does not join the Chenab.
10
170
This is slop generated with the help of ChatGPT. That mid-17th-century Rajasthani bardic poem was written at a time when Mughal emperors were taking Rajput wives; the claim that Sher Shah's mother was a Rajput seems to have been inspired by that. 15th-century Afghans did 1/7
Was Sher Shah Suri Really an Ethnic Afghan or a Rajput? Based on D. H. A. Kolff’s Naukar, Rajput, and Sepoy: The Ethnohistory of the Military Labour Market in Hindustan, 1450–1850 (1990), pp. 57–70. Sher Shah Suri, founder of the Sur Empire, is traditionally described as an Afghan ruler. However, historian D. H. A. Kolff challenges the assumption that Afghan identity in medieval India necessarily represented a fixed ethnic ancestry. Kolff presents several important observations: 1. Possible Rajput ancestry: Sher Shah's mother reportedly belonged to the Qaimkhani Rajput family, while Kolff also considers the possibility that his paternal grandfather was a Rajput. 2. Afghan identity could be acquired: Kolff explains that members of Hindu military communities could adopt Afghan or Pathan identity through conversion to Islam, military service, and incorporation into Afghan clans. 3. Strong Rajput connections: Sher Shah's father, Hasan Sur, served Rajput patrons. Sher Shah himself developed important military alliances with the Ujjainiya Rajputs of Bihar. 4. Rajput participation in his army: During the Battle of Surajgarh, approximately 2,000 Ujjainiya Rajputs fought alongside 3,000 selected Pathans in Sher Shah's forces, according to the account discussed by Kolff. 5. Military identity over ethnicity: Kolff argues that Sher Shah built his political authority through military recruitment, merit, alliances, and the distribution of wealth rather than exclusively through Afghan clan solidarity. On page 57, Kolff raises a particularly significant question: «"Afghans and Rajputs were not really exclusive or even distinct ethnic groups at all."» He further explains that even if Sher Shah's grandfather was a Rajput, this would not necessarily prevent him from being recognized as an Afghan. Conclusion Kolff's research challenges the conventional portrayal of Sher Shah Suri as an unquestionably ethnic Afghan. His family's possible Rajput ancestry and the fluid nature of Afghan identity in medieval Hindustan suggest that being called Afghan did not necessarily establish Afghan ancestry. Source: D. H. A. Kolff, Naukar, Rajput, and Sepoy (1990), pp. 57–70. A free copy of the book is available through the following Telegram link: t.me/bokharkhoda/3
7
27
2
91
6,081
gives his precise sub-tribe; Shera-Khel. This "identity was fluid" bullshit is not going to fly here. 7/7
1
27
454
He vigorously uses ChatGPT to find anything he thinks can be used to malign Pashtuns, increase hostility against them, or muddy the waters. A paid account along the lines of Jan Achakzai.
8
171
Barmazid retweeted
This is slop generated with the help of ChatGPT. That mid-17th-century Rajasthani bardic poem was written at a time when Mughal emperors were taking Rajput wives; the claim that Sher Shah's mother was a Rajput seems to have been inspired by that. 15th-century Afghans did 1/7
Was Sher Shah Suri Really an Ethnic Afghan or a Rajput? Based on D. H. A. Kolff’s Naukar, Rajput, and Sepoy: The Ethnohistory of the Military Labour Market in Hindustan, 1450–1850 (1990), pp. 57–70. Sher Shah Suri, founder of the Sur Empire, is traditionally described as an Afghan ruler. However, historian D. H. A. Kolff challenges the assumption that Afghan identity in medieval India necessarily represented a fixed ethnic ancestry. Kolff presents several important observations: 1. Possible Rajput ancestry: Sher Shah's mother reportedly belonged to the Qaimkhani Rajput family, while Kolff also considers the possibility that his paternal grandfather was a Rajput. 2. Afghan identity could be acquired: Kolff explains that members of Hindu military communities could adopt Afghan or Pathan identity through conversion to Islam, military service, and incorporation into Afghan clans. 3. Strong Rajput connections: Sher Shah's father, Hasan Sur, served Rajput patrons. Sher Shah himself developed important military alliances with the Ujjainiya Rajputs of Bihar. 4. Rajput participation in his army: During the Battle of Surajgarh, approximately 2,000 Ujjainiya Rajputs fought alongside 3,000 selected Pathans in Sher Shah's forces, according to the account discussed by Kolff. 5. Military identity over ethnicity: Kolff argues that Sher Shah built his political authority through military recruitment, merit, alliances, and the distribution of wealth rather than exclusively through Afghan clan solidarity. On page 57, Kolff raises a particularly significant question: «"Afghans and Rajputs were not really exclusive or even distinct ethnic groups at all."» He further explains that even if Sher Shah's grandfather was a Rajput, this would not necessarily prevent him from being recognized as an Afghan. Conclusion Kolff's research challenges the conventional portrayal of Sher Shah Suri as an unquestionably ethnic Afghan. His family's possible Rajput ancestry and the fluid nature of Afghan identity in medieval Hindustan suggest that being called Afghan did not necessarily establish Afghan ancestry. Source: D. H. A. Kolff, Naukar, Rajput, and Sepoy (1990), pp. 57–70. A free copy of the book is available through the following Telegram link: t.me/bokharkhoda/3
7
27
2
91
6,081
Vicroye Wavell meeting with Pashtun Tribal Masharan. 📍Peshawar —1944
📍Waziristan — 1957 🇵🇰 A glimpse of PM Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy addresses a tribal jirga in Wana, Waziristan, a rare moment of civilian leadership dominance. Seated nearby were Gen Ayub Khan & Brig Sadiqullah Khan. Just an year later, Ayub imposed Martial Law.
3
21
1
80
3,961
Barmazid retweeted
The real historical Najib-ud-Dawla (a Yousafzai Pashtun) was held in high regards by his contemporaries. Harry Verelst (an administrator with EIC) in 1768 describes Najib-ud-Dawla as follow: "He is the only example in Hindustan of, at once, a great and a good character. He
Funny scene from Bollwyood historical fiction movie "Panipat". Najib-ud-Dalwa is shown getting disrespected by Ahmad Shah Abdali. The former is depicted as a pathetic villainous creature with a forked tongue while the latter is depicted as a ruthless antagonist.
3
20
2
107
Nah, there was a relation. Both the Sur & the Shahu Khel (the ruling clan) belonged to the same Lodi tribe. The relative insignificance of the Sur tribe was due to its small numbers. Anyway, in India, his family initially settled in Bajwara (Punjab) and then in Narnaul (Haryana)
Replying to @Pashz7
Sher Shahs' father was a horse merchant. According to Richard Eaton, Suris were a marginal clan, unrelated to the ruling Lodi dynasty.
3
4
35
1,631
All people, including Pashtuns, continue to repeat the erroneous claim that Sher Shah was born in Bihar. He was not. The Lodis had not yet conquered Bihar when Sher Shah was born, either in present-day Haryana (most likely) or Punjab (less likely), according to historical sources
Babar became Afghan just by conquering Kabul before Delhi but Mughals did not became Indians in four hundred years. Ghaznavi became Afghan because his father conquered the region that is not part of Afghanistan. However, Sher Shah remained Afghan despite being born in Bihar. Can have your cigarette please?
3
9
47
2,926
Barmazid retweeted
Stamp paper of the Yousafzai state of Swat, December 28, 1960.
3
53
4
262
24,618
Portrait of Nawab Najib al-Dawla (a Yousafzai Pashtun), made in circa 1760. It has been suggested that the sitter in the painting is the Najib ud-Daula. Although there is no identifying inscription on the present painting, comparison can be made with the features and dress 1/3
1
7
36
1,697
of the sitter and his attendant with an 18th-century equestrian portrait of Najib ud-Daula, attributed to Mola Ram (1743–1833), in the Balak Ram collection, Srinagar (the great-grandson of the artist), published in Roopa Lekha, vol. XXII, no. 2 (1951). 2/3
1
4
435