
#Author. Actress (back in the Jurassic period), lyricist, theatre teacher, occasional tour organiser.
London
Joined May 2012
- Tweets3.6K
- Following130
- Followers167
- Likes3.7K
Well said
The level of personal hostility directed at Keir Starmer over the last week deserves scrutiny in its own right. Not because he should be immune from criticism, but because the tone and intensity of the attacks tell us something unhealthy about the state of democratic politics.
1. Starmer is a conventional political figure. Cautious, legalistic, incremental. He frustrates people precisely because he is managerial rather than messianic. Yet the reaction to him often goes far beyond disagreement, tipping into visceral hatred more commonly reserved for authoritarians or demagogues.
2. Much of this hostility is disconnected from concrete policy. It is not about specific votes, proposals or outcomes, but about projection. A belief that Starmer embodies betrayal, bad faith or hidden malice. That kind of politics runs on suspicion rather than evidence.
3. This matters because democracy depends on the assumption of good faith among opponents. You can think a leader is wrong, timid, or misguided without believing they are fundamentally illegitimate. Once politics becomes moralised to the point of demonisation, compromise is reframed as treachery and pluralism as weakness.
4. The pattern is familiar. In fragmented, polarised systems, anger concentrates not on extremists, whose intentions are clear, but on moderates, who disappoint maximalists on all sides. The centre becomes the lightning rod precisely because it resists totalising narratives.
5. There is also a media and online dynamic at work. Incentives reward outrage, not proportionality. Algorithms favour contempt over analysis. Over time, this creates a political culture in which relentless personal attack feels normal, even virtuous, rather than disgusting.
6. None of this is a defence of Starmer’s decisions, instincts or record. Those should be argued over robustly as you do in a democracy. The problem is the substitution of critique with hostility and the quiet erosion of democratic norms that follows when political opponents are treated as enemies rather than rivals.
7. A democracy cannot function if every election is framed as an existential struggle against internal evil. At some point, the target may change, but the damage to trust, restraint and culture remains.
2
Patsy Trench retweeted
London crime: fear vs data.
It has big problems - like any city. But our nation's capital is cleaner, calmer and safer than perhaps any time in living memory.
Patsy Trench retweeted
A woman dubbed the ‘MAGA Granny’, who refused a pardon for her part in the January 6 insurrection, made an emotional apology during a hearing to mark the fifth anniversary of the Capitol riot.
Pamela Hemphill addressed Capitol Police officers who were serving during the 2021 attacks at the House January 6 panel which was reconvened by Democrats to hear from witnesses and lawmakers about the events of that day.
The original panel was disbanded in 2023 with recommendations Trump be prosecuted on four federal charges.
Upon starting his second term in 2025, Trump pardoned or commuted sentences for 1500 people charged over the attack. Hemphill refused her pardon.
RIP to one of the cleverest funny people ever.
American musical satirist Tom Lehrer dies at 97, US media report bbc.in/4ffPpMQ
33
Hooray!
Judi Dench, @David_Suchet and Sienna Miller are among high-profile performers backing a campaign to rename the West End’s Duchess Theatre after prolific playwright Terence Rattigan 👇 thestage.co.uk/news/judi-den…
20
Patsy Trench retweeted
PETITION 🚨 We are asking for a lift to the USAID freeze, or at least, an exemption for humanitarian aid.
Many of our aid operations have been forced to shut down, leaving thousands of our patients at grave risk.
We are fighting to reverse this & continue critical aid efforts.
Patsy Trench retweeted
Matthew Syed might also care to reflect why the home of "truly free speech" hasn't allowed journalists into Gaza, while slaughtering those already there.
Patsy Trench retweeted
When a young American Jewish woman raised to support Israel unconditionally witnesses the way her country treats Palestinians, it transforms her life.
Watch the film, @IsraelismFilm, for more: aje.me/Israelism
Tom on the far right election result in Germany. Eek.
You can hear me witter about the German state elections here, should that sound enticing shows.acast.com/theintellige…
1
51
A very interesting appointment. Someone who knows and understands how prisons work.
Watch this it’s fascinating - I asked James Timpson what he’d do about prisons and sentencing if he was in charge. He believes only a third of prisoners in jail should definitely be there. He’s now in charge of prisons (but not sentencing).
55
Patsy Trench retweeted
Israel’s government moved Sunday to shut down the Al Jazeera Media Network’s operations in Israel, clamping down on one of the few international broadcasters providing largely uninterrupted coverage of the Gaza war. wapo.st/4dpONTo
The Polish foreign minister. Quiet, considered, devastating. We could do with people like that in our parliament.
Bravo @radeksikorski. This is what debate in the Security Council on an issue of grave importance should be - but rarely is. Not a scripted speech but a devastating point by point demolition of the adversary.
1
99
Writing a book on Substack. patsytrench.com/2024/02/13/a…
51

















