For those who believe that muscle glycogen (the Large Glucose pool- LGP) is a more important determinant of exercise performance I invite you to look at this graph from the iconic study of Professor Ed Coyle in 1986. This was the study that helped drive the current belief that the the LGP not the Small Glucose Pool (SGP) that is the more important CHO source determining prolonged exercise performance. I have shown this slide frequently in the past 40 years without seeing what is obvious. Such is the power of intellectual blindness/conformity. The data are from their study entitled muscle glycogen utilization during prolonged strenuous exercise when fed carbohydrate (Journal of Applied Physiology, 1986). It is an iconic paper in the exercise sciences.
The top panel shows changes in blood glucose concentrations during 3-4 hour exercise when 100g CHO was ingested every hour. This reflects what happened in the SGP. Note that clinical hypoglycemia developed after 2 hours when subjects did not ingest CHO during exercise. It's not possible to continue exercising when the blood glucose concentration is falling. That is established fact.
The bottom panel shows changes in muscle glycogen content ie the LGP. Clearly there is no difference in metabolism in the LGP between trials so this cannot be the cause of the premature fatigue when CHO in not ingested. (Remember the story that CHO ingestion during exercise improves performance by slowing depletion of the LGP? Well that is clearly not the case in this example).
Thus my definitive conclusion: "It should be blatantly obvious that (in this iconic study - the world first to show that CHO ingestion significantly prolongs exercises performance) the ingestion of carbohydrate during exercise improves performance by preventing hypoglycemia (SGP), not by sparing glycogen use in the LGP".
I have stared at this figure and used it in lectures for more than 40 years. But it was only on Wednesday night this week when preparing a lecture for the @TheNoakesF annual World Nutrition Summit that I finally saw its real message. The key was to add the terms SGP and LGP to the top and bottom panels of the slide. When I did that the answer became obvious.
@PhilipPrins11 @AKoutnik @PaulBLaursen @sweatscience @Brady_H @Nyborger_Nybo @theplews1
Replying to @RunWithAmmo
The safety margin is usually quite large. Only exceptionally does it get overridden - Alberto Salazar in the Boston Marathon "Duel in the Sun" against Dick Beardsley youtube.com/watch?v=x-Ogazhm…; Ron Clarke in the 10 000m final in the 1968 Olympic Games in Mexico City when he ran himself into unconsciousness that reportedly lasted >10 minutes. In both cases environmental factors - heat or altitude - tipped the balance. In the recent example, @mathieuvdpoel went deeper but recovered fully. So the safety margin was still not breached even by his once-in-a-life time kind of performance. @LoreofRunning1
Confirmation that when Messi moved to eating real foods in 2015, he lost weight and started scoring more goals. High carbohydrate, high sugar, highly processed foods may work in some (endurance) sports, but not apparently in world-class football (for those with insulin resistance).
@LoreofRunning1
He keeps being sick on the pitch.
Not once. Regularly. Lionel Messi, the most gifted footballer anyone has ever watched, vomiting during matches, and for years nobody can tell him why. Barcelona run the tests. The tests come back with nothing.
In 2014 he stops asking the club doctors and goes to see an Italian nutritionist called Giuliano Poser.
Poser looks at what the best player alive is actually putting in his body and finds pizza, fizzy drinks and refined flour. A schoolboy's diet, carried into his mid-twenties, on top of a professional athlete's training load.
The fix was subtraction.
Out went the sugar. Out went the refined flour. Out went the processed food. Poser's line on it was blunt: sugar is the worst thing there is for a muscle.
In came olive oil, fish, whole food, water.
Messi drops around three kilos that were never meant to be there. The sickness stops. The following season he scores 58 goals and wins the treble.
The best footballer alive spent his early career quietly poisoned by the same processed, sugared, refined-flour diet a whole generation of children was raised to think was normal, and got well the week a man took it off his plate.
And this week he is in a World Cup semi-final, chasing another final, sponsored start to finish by the fizzy drink he had to quit to get there.
Replying to @simoncclark456 @theproof
Simon @simoncclark456, Messi clearly changed his diet after 18th October 2014. (The willpower overlay is for those who believe that weight loss is all about will power not about the nature of the foods that are eaten. I don't think Messi has ever, ever lacked will power.)
1
94
Here's what Grok has to say:
"Alan Turing ran two official marathons in his life. He began serious long-distance running in his mid-30s after the war (around 1946), joining Walton Athletic Club. His competitive marathon career was brief:
First marathon: 12 July 1947, in Rugby (a race promoted by British Thomson Houston). He finished 4th out of 61 runners in 3:01:23..
Second marathon (and personal best): 23 August 1947, AAA Championships at Loughborough (a key qualifying event for the 1948 Olympics). He placed 5th in 2:46:03. This 2:46:03 time was world-class for the era (only about 10–11 minutes behind the 1948 Olympic winner and strong enough that he was in contention for the British Olympic team). A leg injury (fibrositis) in early 1948 prevented him from racing any marathons that season or competing in the Olympics, effectively ending his serious marathon running. He continued occasional club running (including relays) after moving to Manchester, with his last recorded event being a road relay in April 1950, but no further marathons. He did some impressive non-race long runs, such as 40-mile commutes to London or ~50 km training routes, but these were not official marathons".
Perhaps his running helped him break the Enigma code and so help Britain avoid starvation during WW11.
Here's a picture of him finishing a race. Probably not the end of a marathon race however
Replying to @ProfTimNoakes
Never knew he was a marathon runner
In the days when it wasn't popular to be marathon runner
Hi Val @ValMThatcher. Do you know this guy? He's Tete Dijana. He has won the 88km Comrades Marathon three times and is the record holder for the down run in which he covered the distance in 5:15:38. That's a pace of 3:35 per km. Would you say that is quite fast and obviously can only be sustained on a high carb diet. But guess what: The picture shows what Tete ate the night before the race. This is the type of food he trains on. Strange isn't it
Dear Dave @realDaveFeldman and Nick @nicknorwitz. Do you guys refer to this "hidden" abstract. Suggests that Nick is not simply "an experiment of one". Instead ~40% of subjects with "Familial Hypercholesterolemia" have CAC scores of zero as reported in this difficult to trace abstract.
Replying to @stevemagness @Gonzalez_JT
I'm not at all dismissive of athletes and their coaches, Steve @stevemagness. (Why must there always be victims in these tweets?) I understand the biology and just don't agree with their approach - as is my democratic right. But why are you so dismissive of Joe Jogger who makes up 99.9% of all runners? Time will tell who is correct.
At least it looks like the American Journal of Physiology Cell Physiology at least understands why we say what we do.
1
4
783















