Delighted to say that our paper identifying a novel role for protrudin in endosomal fission has been published:
Protrudin acts at ER-endosome contacts to promote KIF5-mediated endoso... sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
@TheCIMR @juliakleniuk
Congratulations! @SerenaNikZainal
Congratulations to Professor Nik-Zainal for winning the 2024 ESMO Award for Translational Research | Oncology Awards: esmo.org/about-esmo/awards/e…
1
171
Excited to unveil our latest work:
Protrudin acts at ER-endosome contacts to promote KIF5-mediated endosomal fission and endosome-to-Golgi transport biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/…
This is mostly the work of @juliakleniuk, a wonderful student who has just finished her PhD in my lab, with a bit of help from Aish Nadadhur, Eliska Zlamalova, Emily Wolfenden (a medical student with a great future!) and Catherine Rodger.
1
127
It is well worth reading the paper that Cahir links to here. And stop using n= number of cells please.
Our latest thing:
Atlastin-1 regulates endosomal tubulation and lysosomal proteolysis in... sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
Worth a look if you're interested in how #ERshape can affect other cellular processes. Also gives some insights into the pathogenesis of #hereditaryspasticparaplegia #HSP in human neurons
Looking forward to seeing this blog site from @Lab_Coleman develop. Essential reading for all scientists, but especially useful for those pre-tenure:
Science Without Anguish - My Site sciencewithoutanguish.com/1/…
If you're interested in ER morphology and lysosome function in neurons then check our new BioRxiv paper out:
Atlastin-1 regulates endosomal tubulation and lysosomal proteolysis in human cortical neurons biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/…
Job alert!
Are you a cell biologist interested in studying the molecular pathology of rare genetic neurological diseases affecting children? Based in Cambridge, UK @TheCIMR. Then check this out
👇
jobs.cam.ac.uk/job/43303/
A very good point 👇
There’s this unfortunate myth in science that the head of the lab alone controls its culture. In reality, all the members do and so each person should realize that they bring their own values, attitudes, and spirit for how things should be and that this does matter quite a bit.
227
I thought this a very good explanation for the power of experimental data over observational data
Every Data Scientist needs to know these ideas.
They will blow your mind.
1. Correlation vs Causation
P(A | B) is the probability of A given B. It is the probability that we will observe A given that we have already observed B.
P(A | do(B)) is the probability of A given do(B). It is the probability that we will observe A given that we have intervened to cause B to happen.
In this context, an intervention simply means to take an action of some kind. Therefore do(B) means to take an action which causes B to happen.
The expressions P(A | B) and P(A | do(B)) might seem very similar but they represent very different situations.
2. We can only learn P(A|B) from the data alone.
Bob has an extremely accurate weather app and is always very good about bringing his umbrella when it rains. We observe Bob over several years and we find that whenever it rains, Bob always has his umbrella and he never brings his umbrellas on days when it doesn't rain.
In the language of probability, we say P(Umbrella | Rain) = 1 and P(Rain | Umbrella) = 1 as well.
What we can learn from this data alone is how to predict whether it rains with a 100% accuracy by checking whether Bob has an umbrella. We can also learn to predict with 100% accuracy whether Bob has an umbrella by checking if it's going to rain.
What we cannot learn is what will happen if we give Bob an umbrella on a random day of our choosing. The answer to this question is P(Rain | do(Umbrella) ) and it's unknowable from the data alone.
We need prior knowledge about how the world works to properly interpret the data we collected. We need to know that rain has an effect on Bob's behavior, but Bob's behavior has no effect on the rain.
Information about the effects of interventions are simply not available in raw data unless it is collected by controlled experimental manipulation.
3. Scientific Experiments work because they produce a very special kind of data.
You may have heard of what many people call a scientific experiment. Take a collection of objects, animals or people. Randomly split that collection into a control group and a treatment group. Apply your intervention to the treatment group while leaving the control group alone. If you observe any differences between the treatment group and the control group, it is logical to attribute these differences to the treatment. You can therefore say the differences were caused by the treatment.
In statistics, the procedure I just described is called a Randomized Controlled Trial. It is a procedure for generating a specific kind of data where:
P(Difference | Treatment) = P(Difference | do(Treatment) )
This is why traditional science experiments work. They are designed to capture causal information. This is not the case for vast majority of data that we collect in society.
Without human guidance or access to real world knowledge, statistical algorithms and artificial intelligences can only learn P(A | B) from the raw data. This is a fundamental mathematical limitation on the use of data alone.
That's it for now. This post is part of a series of posts about the concept of causal inference. They are based on the content of the Book of Why by Judea Pearl with lots of commentary from me.
Follow me (@kareem_carr) so you don't miss out on the next post.
Please show support by liking and retweeting the thread.
232
👇Good news! Could we get this sorted in England now? Pretty sure a similar deal - no sub-inflationary pay rise and commitment to pay restoration - would do it.
🚨🏴 CONSULTATIVE VOTE RESULT 🏴🚨
Scottish junior doctors have voted to ACCEPT the Scot Gov's pay offer.
✅ 81.64% voted in favour of the offer
✅ Turnout was 71.24%
Read SJDC chair @ChrisSmith2211's full message to members 👇
bmascotland.home.blog/2023/0…
212
Interesting! 👇
Spastin locally amplifies microtubule dynamics to pattern the axon for presynaptic cargo delivery biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/…
4
363
Handy to have them all in one place: An update on genetically encoded lipid biosensors | Molecular Biology of the Cell molbiolcell.org/doi/10.1091/…
Can we find better ways to integrate the latest genomic findings into cell biology experiments? We think we can. If you want to get involved look here 👇
Interested in rare genetic neurological disorders? Enjoy collaboration? NeuralNet Prog @TheCIMR is looking for a post-doc to work across several labs & pilot projects Reporting to @ReidLab_HSP, you’ll learn a wide range of skills in cell biology & biochem tinyurl.com/mr3d6vky
You need to read this 👇
I’m an oncologist and I love my job. But I’m striking because I know first-hand that the NHS is failing our patients with cancer and I’m striking because I know first-hand that the NHS is failing its workforce. lucygossage.com/my-reasons-f… #ConsultantsStrike
1
229
👇 In light of this I’m now seriously reflecting on whether I will continue providing the free 20% extra that I do for the NHS above my contracted job plan PAs. Enough is enough


















