
ALT Tier 2 Reading Interventions: Reporting of Fidelity and Alignment Blog Post Multi-Tiered System of Supports in Reading (MTSS-R) is a framework for providing reading instruction and intervention in schools across instructional tiers. Tier 1 refers to core instruction that all students receive. Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Tier 2 refers to supplemental intervention provided to some students who require additional support. Researchers have evaluated Tier 2 reading interventions in many studies to examine how effective they are at supporting students experiencing reading difficulties. Still, in order to fully understand the effectiveness of a Tier 2 intervention, researchers must also understand the features of Tier 1 instruction and how Tier 2 intervention complements it.

ALT Thus, the researchers examined the extent to which published studies of Tier 2 interventions reported information about: (a) implementation fidelity of Tier 1 and Tier 2 instruction and (b) instructional alignment of content and approaches across tiers. Young et al. (2026) reviewed group design studies and single-case design studies. Group design studies typically have larger samples, offering a broad perspective on the efficacy of Tier 2 interventions across classrooms and schools in various Tier 1 contexts. On the other hand, single-case design studies generally have fewer participants, allowing researchers to evaluate fidelity and instructional alignment in a more nuanced manner.

ALT What Did the Researchers Find? Group Design Studies The researchers found that Tier 2 literacy intervention studies commonly reported on Tier 2 fidelity and researcher-manipulated Tier 1 fidelity, but school-implemented Tier 1 fidelity was reported less often. In over 80% of studies, researchers reported information about the features of Tier 1 instruction, but studies varied in the level of detail provided. In studies in which the research team manipulated both Tier 1 and Tier 2 instruction, greater detail was reported about instructional alignment, when reported. Overall, the authors found that reporting on implementation fidelity and instructional alignment has increased since a prior review conducted in 2012 (Hill et al., 2012).

ALT Tier 1 Tier 2 What Are the Implications of These Findings? Because it is challenging to assess the effectiveness of Tier 2 interventions without understanding how well Tier 1 instruction is implemented and how well it complements Tier 2 instruction, assessing implementation fidelity and instructional alignment serves an important purpose in both research and practice. Rather than evaluating instruction provided in each tier in isolation, the researchers recommend considering how instruction across Tiers 1 and 2 is intentionally coordinated to support students’ learning.




























