Ann Smarty (@seosmarty) header
Ann Smarty (@seosmarty) profile picture

Co-founder of @smartyMktg, SEO, GEO/AEO, Reddit Marketing 😎 20+ years of SEO experience. I've seen it all 💪 Newsletter: https://nitter.cf/t.co/zuHJw1yixd

New York
Joined December 2007
Photo by Ann Smarty (@seosmarty)Photo by Ann Smarty (@seosmarty)Photo by Ann Smarty (@seosmarty)Photo by Ann Smarty (@seosmarty)Photo by Ann Smarty (@seosmarty)Photo by Ann Smarty (@seosmarty)Photo by Ann Smarty (@seosmarty)Photo by Ann Smarty (@seosmarty)Photo by Ann Smarty (@seosmarty)Photo by Ann Smarty (@seosmarty)
Checking our clients' digital PR campaigns we did 6+ months ago, I am seeing them become the top cited sources for LLMs, even for pretty huge sites. There's, of course, a lot into that (apart from the fact that LLMs do love citing stats): ✅ Solid organic findability (direct correlation with citability. PR projects that didn't end up ranking well in Google are not cited that well) ✅ Strategic (and ethical) seeding on Reddit I've seen many studies that LLMs seem to "trust" sources that regularly publish authority-driving content (original research, whitepapers, etc). Whether it is because they are like people (original research makes people believe a site is kind of a big deal) or because of all other signals (mainly, organic search visibility), but it surely works! Bottom line: If you want to get cited by LLMs, invest in original research in your niche!
9
3
4
44
11,673
Heyyy! @NickLeRoy, an old SEO friend, is hosting an AMA on my subreddit on SEO/GEO careers!!! Definitely a topic with LOTS OF QUESTIONS! Go ahead and ask yours! reddit.com/r/SEO_for_AI/comm…
🤖 Made with AI
1
4
394
A better question is: WHY CHOOSE? I don't even get this part. SEO is key to GEO; so even if you prioritize GEO (which I may or may not agree with), SEO still remains fundamental... Who can explain this part to me, please?
here's a question for everyone pivoting their entire SEO strategy toward AI search if Google is still generating the overwhelming majority of your organic signups, why are you suddenly prioritizing ChatGPT visibility? genuinely curious where people draw the line between innovation and chasing shiny objects
4
1
5
2,055
This article by @YoungbloodJoe from 2023 explores the very faulty Google's Helpful Content update (which they soon after turned into part of the core algorithm, but also predicts the very sad future of AI-powered search, as we let AI define the overall consensus: "By using our latest AI model, Multitask Unified Model (MUM), our systems can now understand the notion of consensus" This whole algorithm also contradicts the "first-hand experience" and "hidden gems" concepts that Google promised to surface, and that are the direct opposite of the "consensus" and would make the web a so much more beautiful place 💔 joeyoungblood.com/seo/google…
Replying to @seosmarty
Correlation and causation of course, but anytime a publisher was hit and reached out to me they had those exact same 2 attributes in every case I reviewed: joeyoungblood.com/seo/google… The one case known to have rebounded above and beyond where they were prior (HouseFresh), saw their link-based values skyrocket over a 1.5 year period of doing every interview/podcast/etc... smashing Google's decision. Far from evidence, but very tantalizing.
2
2
5
1,216
This is sad to see 😔 I used to be a contributor to this site many years ago, and we were a great team! There were ~10 of us, managing to compete with giants like Mashable... I am not sure how they operate these days, but I couldn't see any signs of AI content or anything... Likely just eaten by AI (their major content focus was how-to and top-tool lists) 💔 This is an illustration of #adaptordie reality of SEO
9
5
50
11,621
Ann Smarty retweeted
I'm hosting an AMA on @seosmarty r/seo-for-ai subreddit. Questions about search careers or AI's impact on SEO skill sets? Let's talk more! reddit.com/r/SEO_for_AI/comm…
1
7
371
"Track ChatGPT Product Referrals in GA4" | @seosmarty shows how to configure Google Analytics to track ChatGPT-referred traffic. Shoppers increasingly ask ChatGPT for product recommendations/comparisons. practicalecommerce.com/track… #ecommerce @googleanalytics @ChatGPT
3
2
4
339
I am back on my oldest blog ☺️ Thoughts? "Should Businesses Still Have In-House SEO Teams, or Can They Just Use AI for SEO?" seosmarty.com/should-busines…
6
3
13
1,347
Somehow, never gave it a thorough thought... How AI Training can impact politics... Scary
AI Optimization at scale: China is producing the equivalent of TRILLIONS of docs across 120k+ training datasets, largely to train + influence LLMs When folks debate if GEO is different than SEO, this is what I think of (and also, influencing training data is hard!)
1
1
5
695
My weekly SEO/GEO roundup! OMG what a week, especially for the AI side of things! 💡 David Konitzny, the GEO researcher, hosted an outstanding AMA answering questions about video GEO, image GEO, Reddit, and more: 🔗 reddit.com/r/AISearchAnalyti… 💡 I wrote about YouTube SEO and GEO, and how that channel is not to be missed! 🔗 annsmarty.com/p/youtube-one-… OUR SUBREDDIT HIGHLIGHTS: I am so proud of our community! 🔥 It really shapes itself as a great source of GEO/AEO insights. I love the quality of comments in there! 👉 ChatGPT fetched my pages 1,120 times in 27 days. ~87 people clicked. Here’s how I made the clicks visible. GREAT TIPS on how to see more of ChatGPT clicks in your analytics by Edy Werder reddit.com/r/SEO_for_AI/comm… 👉 GREAT reminder and tips here: Outdated PDFs on your website are still answering questions about you reddit.com/r/SEO_for_AI/comm… 👉 Here's how to track your product performance in ChatGPT using Google Analytics (my SEO/GEO tip of the week): reddit.com/r/SEO_for_AI/comm… *IN OTHER NEWS* 😱 Reddit launches Reddit reviews! Now you can search Reddit for any product or keyword, and it will show you the sentiment of the relevant products and a discussion summary. 😱 ChatGPT launches "Business Hub", its version of Google's "Search Console" to report on verified business visibility in ChatGPT 😱 The biggest AI advocate in the world, Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia’s chief executive... This is going to impact the whole global AI market.
2
4
365
This whole timeline is pretty unbelievable 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯
7
984
I CANNOT EVEN!!! When you don't even know where to start :))) Ughhhh this post is the definition of the sad state of our industry these days Let's tackle this one by one: 😡 This has NEVER worked like this!!! “get mentioned in a Reddit thread, get cited by AI” 😡 We DON'T EVEN know how Reddit's login-only experience will work. Reddit doesn't know either! How can we discuss what it means if we don't know how it will work? 😡 CITATIONS MEAN NOTHING!!!! Reddit may not be cited as much but it still plays its role in AI Answers and training data 😡 The Q4 test may tell us NOTHING! LLMs have their own "back" door into Reddit's data. User experience has nothing to do with AI agent experience or LLM visibility...
7
7
697
Thursday's quick SEO/GEO tip! Track which products of yours ChatGPT recommends in Google Analytics! ChatGPT Answers often include product carousels, in which product links have utm_source=chatgpt.com&utm_medium=feed parameters, so you can track and compare their performance! In Google Analytics, go to the Traffic Acquisition report, 1️⃣ choose "source/medium" and type "chatgpt.com / feed" in the search filter, 2️⃣ add a comparison to see each page path, and... Here you go: You see your most successful products that are cited in ChatGPT answers. 3️⃣ For the fun of it, also add more comparisons to compare mobile and desktop traffic. Now you can see how ChatGPT traffic performs, based on the product page and the device being used. Your task is now to figure out why some pages drive more engagements, and what to improve.
7
2
12
553
No service-based business support yet in ChatGPT's brand-new "Business Hub" 💔
3
1
11
1,118