STEM Education Excellence (@STEMExcelNYC) header
STEM Education Excellence (@STEMExcelNYC) profile picture

Life-long NYer advocating for excellence in STEM education! Reposts and Quotes are not necessarily endorsements. You can Direct-Message me.

New York, NY
Joined January 2019
Photo by STEM Education Excellence (@STEMExcelNYC)Photo by STEM Education Excellence (@STEMExcelNYC)Photo by STEM Education Excellence (@STEMExcelNYC)Photo by STEM Education Excellence (@STEMExcelNYC)Photo by STEM Education Excellence (@STEMExcelNYC)Photo by STEM Education Excellence (@STEMExcelNYC)Photo by STEM Education Excellence (@STEMExcelNYC)Photo by STEM Education Excellence (@STEMExcelNYC)Photo by STEM Education Excellence (@STEMExcelNYC)
An inequitable geographic distribution of students who are even trying to get into specialized high schools. Awareness of, and desire to attend these science and math-focused schools must be brought to the Bronx and central-eastern Brooklyn. @BPEricAdams @rubendiazjr
7
8
4
29
STEM Education Excellence retweeted
This is why there is a case to have a certain number of schools be test only which is relevant for HS admissions. Grades are now inflated. Essays can be faked or enhanced using AI. Mainly wealthy families can afford extracurriculars. Only the test has been reliable.
Rich parents have paid up to $25,000 to get their kid's college essay polished for years, and colleges were fine with it. Then poor kids started getting the same kind of help from ChatGPT for free. Now colleges are getting rid of the essay. And the essay was tilted toward rich kids long before AI. Back in 2021, Stanford researchers ran 240,000 University of California admissions essays from 60,000 applicants through text analysis. The word choices, the topics, even the punctuation predicted family income better than SAT scores did. Give them an essay and they could guess the kid's SAT score within about 120 points. Which is wild when you remember colleges spent years ditching the SAT for favoring rich kids, when the essay was favoring them even more. There's a whole industry built around that one page. AcceptU charges $12,500 for essays and a college list. Admitium charges $15,000 to $25,000. Former admissions officers sit down with a 17-year-old and work his 650 words over until they sound like what the readers want to hear. That's been going on for decades. Then ChatGPT showed up. Researchers at Cornell and Carnegie Mellon looked at 81,663 applications to one selective university from 2020 to 2024. AI use shot up in 2024 for everybody, and it shot up the most among kids who got application fee waivers, meaning the low-income kids who could never have paid for a consultant. Those kids paid for it anyway. The more AI showed up in an essay, the more it hurt the applicant's chances. It hurt low-income kids more than wealthy ones, even after the researchers controlled for grades and test scores. The free version makes a lot of kids sound like the same kid, and admissions readers are learning what that sounds like. Look at what colleges are doing now. Tulane paused its "Why Tulane?" essay and said AI was definitely a factor. Cornell, UVA and Georgia cut back their essay requirements. Duke quit giving essays a numerical score. Columbia became the last Ivy to bring back required test scores in June. And the UC system, the same one whose essays were in that Stanford study, is thinking about bringing back the SAT too. Virginia Tech went another way. It got 57,622 applications for about 7,000 freshman spots, so now an AI scores every essay alongside one human, and a second person only reads it if the two scores are two or more points apart. Funny how the essay only became a problem once everybody could afford the help.
2
2
19
705
We're not out of the woods. Many other schools, including colleges and K-12, are now, post SFFA, hiding their racial discrimination using criteria that are either subjective or are proxies for race. We need to win the pending lawsuits fighting discrimination by proxy.
Colleges like Johns Hopkins appear to be complying with the SCOTUS ruling, with the number of Asian students admitted nearly doubling since 2023. What is now clear is that thousands of Asian students were previously rejected on the basis of their race, an injustice that was finally addressed with the end of affirmative action. More good news: The class of 2030 has the highest percentage of low-income students in its history.
1
6
295
Standardized Tests are not only more Objective, Truthful / Accurate, Transparent, Incorruptible, and Fair, they're also cheaper and easier to administer.
3
213
STEM Education Excellence retweeted
What a disaster. So Regents stay....but don't count....but count towards accountability....but not really because they don't count so kids won't care. yahoo.com/news/politics/arti…
8
19
6
95
11,215
Albany educrats are increasing NYS high school graduation rates without in any way improving education! They keep hiding the truth from families by getting rid of standardized tests, inflating grades and lowering diploma requirements to pass the buck onto colleges. The cost of remedial classes in college is effectively a tax on low-achieving students, because these courses don't earn credits towards a degree. This is the genius of ideologues like Regent Shino Tanikawa. tinyurl.com/bdh49rpt
1
6
20
621
STEM Education Excellence retweeted
Activists would have you believe that the 1% of funding that NYC PTAs raise has something to do with literacy outcomes. It’s simply not true, and while there might be some schools that are outliers, this appears to be yet another ham-fisted attempt to take away other people’s money.
New York: $31,918 per student. Reading score: 215. Mississippi: $12,324 per student. Reading score: 219. New York spends 2.6× more and gets worse readers. Good teaching is what can fix this.
2
24
1,237
There's a scandal fueling declining enrollment: Grade Fraud. Schools give passing grades to students who are objectively failing in math & English. Here are 15 schools where the math course passing rate is over 70 percentage points more than the math proficiency rate based on standardized tests. The map shows the extent of Grade Fraud for middle schools citywide. Lying to families prevents them from making timely interventions. This fraud must be stopped! @JumaaneWilliams @DoEcorruption
Today my office has released a major new report on student enrollment in NYC. We found that k-12 enrollment in our public schools has fallen by 187k since 2013, with a projected decline of an additional 128k students by 2034. As total enrollment declines, NYCPS is serving a student population with growing needs. The number of students with disabilities is increasing. In the most recent school year, approximately 73% of students were in poverty and 14% were homeless or living in temporary housing. Our report finds the drop in enrollment is driven by declining births and families with children leaving NYC, with a particularly notable drop in public-school enrollment as students transition from elementary to middle school. These trends have massive implications for our schools that we have only barely begin to grapple with. My hope is that this report will spur a long overdue conversation about what the era of falling student enrollment means for NYC, and what we can do to reverse or slow it. 🧵
8
1
13
1,385
By far the most critical school reform we need is the cheapest and easiest to implement! Stop Lying to Families! We can't fix problems we can't see. When grades are inflated, corrupted by external influence, pressures for social promotion, conflicts of interest to hide incompetence, then families can't make needed interventions on a timely basis. @MarkLevineNYC: stop this crime! Grade accuracy is needed to hold the system accountable. Grades should objectively measure knowledge and skill mastery. Grade fraud secured jobs for about 80,000 @NYCSchools teachers, but it robbed opportunities for over 1,200,000 children over the last 20 years.
And it’s not just her son. In all 32 NYC school districts, far more middle schoolers passed math class than were proficient on the state test.
2
5
13
512
The most critical school reform we need is also the cheapest and easiest to implement: Stop Lying! With Grade Fraud we can't see the problem until it's too late. @nhannahjones wonders if she betrayed her daughter. @nanalatinaAA knows @NYCSchools betrayed her son.
NYC public schools deceived me into thinking my son was a straight-A math student - but he can't do fractions, basic algebra trib.al/pWwmbHR
1
80
"At PS307 parent night, we were the only parents who showed up." Integration activists like @nhannahjones are fixated only on race to explain gaps in educational outcomes. They're blind to the effect of culture and values, such as parental involvement. At parent-teacher conference nights at many high-achieving schools, the line of parents waiting for the school to open is quite long. fordhaminstitute.org/nationa…
1
3
161
Same School, Different Attendance. Integration activists are so fixated on race that they ignore culture and values. Just showing up is half the battle. This chart uses available 2024–25 NYC public middle-school data, excluding charter and mixed-grade schools. Schools are grouped into four categories based on their Economic Need Index (ENI). Within each category, attendance rates are calculated separately for Black, Hispanic, Asian, and White students, using school-level averages weighted by each racial group's enrollment.
2
4
356
STEM Education Excellence retweeted
This is my yearbook picture. A diverse student body, reflecting a diverse city. Stop making excuses for these folks and fix the damn schools. Almost 60% of the Black kids in NYC can’t read at grade and you all are worried about the SHSAT?!?
1
1
26
The Hecht-Calandra Act is a NYS law that waves a magic wand to stop race discrimination. Hecht-Calandra mandates a specific algorithm that must be used to determine admissions for NYC's specialized high schools, based solely on a multiple-choice standardized test (no essays) of mathematics and verbal reasoning that is scored by machines, not humans. This ties the hands of admissions officers, who have no choice and are forced to admit high scoring students. For 55 years Hecht-Calandra has promulgated a specific admissions process that is an objective, transparent single standard of merit that prevents the possibility of discrimination by race, gender and other protected classes and minimizes the possibility of corruption. Is there anything like Hecht-Calandra in the USA, if not the world? We must keep the Hecht-Calandra Act!
Replying to @strawsinanapple
The Supreme Court can't waive a magic wand and stop admissions officers intent on discriminating from doing so. Having been through the application process with a new college student recently, the obvious way of doing it is to have leading essay questions about your background, and give implicit preference to those who talk about their experiences as a ____ person. And you can also look at extracurriculars and favor those who were involved in minority student organizations. IOW, even if admissions officials aren't able to see which box students checked, and don't have explicit "goals" for admission the way they used to, they can still discriminate if they choose to.
3
8
425
I guess @mattyglesias' point is that Harvard's personality score is plummeting.
26
Experts Are Confused by Harvard’s Race Data. Here’s Why. The number of students not reporting their race has been growing. thecrimson.com/article/2024/…
Replying to @rawsalerts
Why is race even listed on the college application? What happened to merit as the deciding factor for college?
1
11
541
STEM Education Excellence retweeted
Replying to @STEMExcelNYC
Blacks are 19% of @NYCSchools enrollment yet make up 80% of the failing kids who can't read or do math on a proficient level. Most of state prison inmates attended failing city schools and are themselves barely literate. Yet Banks & Co. won't blame black & Latino leaders at DOE.
1
3
59
STEM Education Excellence retweeted
Replying to @STEMExcelNYC
You can’t buy your way into NYC’s Specialized High Schools. Can’t say the same for Dalton and Ivy League Schools. And the Nobel Prizes and Fields Medals too. Which are more prestigious?
1
1
9
491
NO! It has been stopping anti-black discrimination for almost a century!!! Learn SHSAT's true history in this testimony: nitter.cf/STEMExcelNYC/status/20…
"It was explicitly to stop white flight. It was trying to advantage white students." The SHSAT's origin story, in David R. Jones's own words. Full ep: youtu.be/tHJZq9JEYIU?is=m1f3…
3
2
6
862
STEM Education Excellence retweeted
This is literally what every model showed would be the result of admissions without racial discrimination against Asian Americans. Except Harvard is now discriminating against white students more because it thinks that is more acceptable. It isn't. Either everyone is equal, or everyone is vulnerable to racism. Americans should not support racial discrimination against anyone, for any reason. There are no good reasons.
Asians are now 43% of Harvard’s incoming class. Not even counting the 15% of students who are international admits. White numbers not reported, they seem to have stayed constant or gone down. Merit is back. Nativists will have to start a new movement to bring back DEI.
33
5
67
10,765
How many Dalton alumni are Nobel laureates, Fields Medal winners, scientists and technology innovators?
I do wonder if the Ivy League will become less socially and culturally prestigious as it becomes more Stuyvesant than Dalton.
8
4
51
3,908