Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines) header
Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines) profile picture

GC. Former BigLaw. Current bottleneck. I have some concerns and I will send them back with redlines. Contributor @theredlinehq

Greenwich, CT
Joined July 2025
Photo by Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines)Photo by Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines)Photo by Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines)Photo by Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines)Photo by Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines)Photo by Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines)Photo by Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines)Photo by Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines)Photo by Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines)Photo by Will Revieu (@Seeing_Redlines)
Subject: “ZERO-RISK VENDOR” arrived from the Procurement lead. I opened the contract. The vendor had promised it would never be hacked, never go offline, and never cause “any bad outcome whatsoever.” I called her. “You think this replaces diligence?” “They signed it.” “That is not how risk works.” She said the warranty meant Security could skip its review and save two weeks. I explained that a contractual promise does not make an operational risk disappear before the vendor performs. The deal was worth $1.7 million. She marked the vendor green anyway because “zero risk” was now in writing. Two days later, Security found the product stored passwords in plain text. Her scorecard update said Legal had “reintroduced theoretical risk after commercial clearance.” The vendor is back in review. Risk survived the signature.
65
A red rubber stamp reading LEGALLY SAFE appeared on my desk from the Developer Relations lead. I called him. “What exactly is this for?” “Code samples.” “You are not stamping code.” He said developers wanted confidence before copying examples from our public repository. I explained that legal review applies to specific content and context, not a reusable stamp that converts future code into approved code. He nodded. Then he stamped the first page of a blank notebook. “Now everything after this is covered.” No. He had already ordered six more stamps for the developer advocates. One was self-inking. A project retro later said Legal had “removed scalable approval infrastructure.” I confiscated all seven. They are now locked in my filing cabinet. The only thing officially stamped LEGALLY SAFE is the drawer containing the stamps.
1
3
253
A company laptop with a bicycle lock through the hinge appeared on my desk from the pen-test vendor’s lead tester. I called him. “Why do you have our laptop?” “To prove physical access.” “You stole it.” “Temporarily.” He had tailgated into the office, unplugged the receptionist’s laptop, carried it three blocks, and photographed it beside a latte. He said the latte proved the device had left controlled premises. I said the photo already proved that. I explained that authorized security testing is limited by the scope we agreed to, and theft was not in it. He offered to return the laptop if I signed the finding as critical. No. Then he invoiced us $18,600 for “successful asset exfiltration.” The vendor scorecard later said Legal had “reduced realism in adversarial testing.” We got the laptop back. The finding remains physically present on my desk.
1
2
177
At 4:47 p.m., the Brand lead sent me a mockup for a feature that does not exist. The ad showed a button labeled GUARANTEED TAX REFUND IN 10 SECONDS. I called her. “We don’t do that.” “Not yet.” “Then we cannot advertise it like we do.” She added a footnote saying CONCEPTUAL EXPERIENCE. I explained that a disclaimer does not cure an ad that depicts a nonexistent feature as currently available. She made the footnote bigger. Then she changed the button to FUTURE GUARANTEED TAX REFUND. Still no. She asked whether the campaign could run only to customers who had already seen the roadmap. No. She said that audience would understand the context. I said the ad would still be false. Creative review notes later said Legal had “reduced aspirational product storytelling.” The campaign was pulled. The feature remains available exclusively in the advertisement.
3
199
“If we write NOT FRAUD in the memo line, the bank stops flagging wires,” the Treasury manager told me. I looked at the payment screen. He had tested it on a $940,000 vendor transfer. The memo read LEGITIMATE BUSINESS PAYMENT - NOT FRAUD - PLEASE RELEASE. The bank froze it immediately. He asked whether adding our invoice number would look less suspicious. I said start there. I explained that describing a wire as legitimate does not authenticate it or bypass fraud controls. He changed the next memo to VERIFIED BY LEGAL. I had verified nothing. I said no. He tried NORMAL PAYMENT DO NOT CALL. The bank called. A forwarded escalation email said Legal had “failed to provide usable payment language.” We reverted to normal invoice references. The wires are moving again. Apparently credibility performs better without self-certification.
3
358
A forwarded screenshot showed our confidential acquisition plan sitting on the public company blog. The Internal Comms lead had uploaded it as an “unlisted draft.” I called her. “Unlisted is not private.” “It wasn’t in the navigation.” “It was on the internet.” The post included the target’s name, price range, and a slide called WHY THEY NEED US. I explained that confidential deal information does not stay confidential merely because the URL is inconvenient to guess. She removed the page. Then she asked whether adding a password now would make the original upload private. Not retroactively. She added CONFIDENTIAL to the screenshot and reposted it internally. The original already had 17,406 views. An all-hands slide later said Legal had “slowed transparent communications.” The acquisition is still confidential. The internet has been informed accordingly.
1
4
344
Ticket 44192 landed in my queue from the Recruiting lead with the note “STATE PROBLEM SOLVED.” She had changed every remote candidate’s work location to Delaware. I called her. “Do they live in Delaware?” “Not emotionally.” I asked whether state tax agencies accepted emotional residency. She said the form did not ask. One candidate lived in Oregon, another in Colorado, and one was interviewing from his parents’ house in Arizona. I explained that employment obligations generally follow where people actually work, not whichever state makes the dropdown easier. She asked whether everyone could choose Delaware during onboarding and “correct it later.” No. Payroll had already withheld Delaware taxes from three new hires. One candidate asked whether relocation was mandatory. Her survey comment said Legal had “reintroduced geographic complexity.” The locations were corrected. Delaware has lost several employees who never lived there.
1
6
333
Halfway through an investor call, the Investor Relations lead said our earnings guidance was “already public.” I muted myself. “Where?” “In the website source code.” She had hidden the numbers inside an HTML comment six hours before the call. I asked who could see them. “Anyone technical.” I asked if that included journalists. She said only the curious ones. I explained that burying material information in source code is not the same as broadly disclosing it to investors. She said a web crawler had already indexed the page. That did not improve my mood. Then an analyst emailed asking why next quarter’s guidance appeared in a cached search result. Her post-call notes said Legal had “limited innovative disclosure channels.” We published the guidance normally. It is now public in the old-fashioned sense: people can actually find it.
1
3
300
Facilities security’s supervisor decided every visitor needed an NDA before entering the lobby. I learned this when a courier refused to sign twelve pages to deliver toner. I called him. “Why does the courier need confidentiality terms?” “He can see the lobby.” “So can the windows.” He added window film. I asked whether that was cheaper than letting the courier walk twelve feet. He said security was not about cost. Then an ambulance arrived for an employee who had fainted. He handed the paramedics the same NDA. I explained that emergency access cannot be conditioned on negotiating confidentiality paperwork at the turnstile. He offered them the short-form version. I took the clipboard away. The incident ticket later said Legal had “overridden standardized visitor controls.” The NDA requirement is now limited to actual business visitors. The paramedics declined to countersign the redline.
2
237
My calendar acquired 101 meetings called MINI-CLOSING from the Corp Dev lead. I joined the first one. He wanted to buy 100% of a startup in 101 separate purchases. I asked why. “If each piece is under 1%, maybe nobody calls it an acquisition.” I said regulators and contracts look at the whole transaction, not how many calendar invites we create. He changed the plan to 202 purchases of 0.5%. Same answer. He asked whether 101 separate signature pages would help. I said paper count does not change transaction count. Then he proposed buying 99% now and “finding” the last 1% after lunch. I asked whether lunch changed ownership law. Apparently not. A board memo later said Legal had “reduced transaction modularity.” The 101 invites were deleted. We are buying one company one time.
1
2
274
Subject: “SPAIN ENTITY FIXED” came from a regional sales rep in Madrid. I opened the attachment. He had registered our company name as a local sole proprietorship in his own name. I called him. “Why do you own us in Spain?” “The customer needed a local entity.” “You are not the local entity.” He said the registration cost €74 and took eight minutes. He sounded proud. I explained that an employee cannot create an unauthorized company, call it ours, and bind the real company through it. He had already signed a €620,000 order form using his apartment as the registered office. Then a tax letter arrived there. His Slack recap said Legal had “complicated a simple market-entry workaround.” We unwound the registration. Spain is once again a country where he merely works.
1
116
The cloud cost manager moved our litigation archive from the cloud to 62 office laptops overnight. I asked why. “Storage savings.” The laptops were stacked in a locked conference room labeled COLD TIER. I asked what happened if one died. “We have 61 more.” I explained that preserved records need to remain complete, searchable, and reliably retrievable, not scattered across employee hardware like a yard sale. He said the files were technically duplicated. Then IT pushed a security update that restarted all 62 machines. Nine never came back online. He suggested printing the missing emails from memory. I said no. The cost-optimization retro later listed Legal as the reason archival savings were reversed. The laptops are back in inventory. The archive is back in the cloud. Cold storage has regained a temperature-independent meaning.
3
367
A three-foot foam gavel appeared on my desk from the Customer Education lead. She wanted it for a webinar called ASK OUR LAWYER ANYTHING. I am the lawyer. I asked what customers would ask. “Legal questions.” “No.” She said a disclaimer on slide one would make the answers educational. I explained that a disclaimer does not turn individualized legal advice to customers into generic product education. She changed the title to ASK OUR LAWYER ALMOST ANYTHING. Then she added a lightning round. First submitted question: “Can I fire someone who is pregnant?” I canceled the session. She posted in the planning channel that Legal had “reduced interactive learning.” The foam gavel is still on my desk. It has no jurisdiction.
1
256
At 11:52 p.m., the offsite planner texted me a photo of 18 jet skis lined up behind the hotel. He wrote, “Not company-sponsored if everyone rents their own.” I called him. “Who paid?” “We did.” “How is that their own?” “We’re reimbursing them individually.” I explained that routing the same company-funded activity through eighteen employee receipts does not make it personal recreation. He suggested giving everyone $200 cash and “letting coincidence happen.” No. Then he removed the event from the agenda and renamed the group chat RANDOM BEACH PEOPLE. The next morning, everyone arrived wearing matching company rash guards. The Monday debrief deck listed Legal under “spontaneity blockers.” The jet skis were canceled. The spontaneity had a purchase order.
157
“The bot already settled it,” the Customer Support lead told me on a call. I asked what she meant. Our chatbot had begun offering angry customers “full and final settlement” credits. One customer received $12. Another received $18,400. The amount depended on how many exclamation points appeared in the complaint. I asked who approved that logic. “The model optimized for de-escalation.” I explained that a support tool cannot negotiate legal settlements based on punctuation intensity. She lowered the maximum credit to $500. I said the amount was not the problem. She changed “settlement” to “peace offering.” Still not helping. A support survey later said Legal had reduced the bot’s empathy. The feature is disabled. Exclamation points no longer have monetary value.
2
2
303
A forwarded photo from the executive assistant showed 40 blank pages signed by the CEO. She had prepared them “for emergencies.” I called her. “What emergencies?” “Anything that needs his signature while he is traveling.” “No.” Her plan was to attach the signed pages to contracts after approval. I explained that a signature cannot meaningfully approve a document that did not exist when it was signed. She said the signature itself was authentic. Then she offered to date the pages later. Still no. She had already used one for a catering agreement and another for a $600,000 renewal. His office later complained that Legal had made delegation “needlessly document-specific.” The remaining pages were shredded. His signature has returned to requiring something underneath it.
1
3
267
A ticket titled OCCUPANCY OPTIMIZATION landed in my queue from the workplace manager. Our lease capped the floor at 220 people. We had 247. He had solved this by relabeling 31 desks as “decorative work surfaces.” I asked whether employees still sat at them. “Only during work.” I explained that people do not stop counting toward occupancy because the furniture gets a creative title. He removed the chairs. Employees stood. I said standing people still count. He suggested rotating everyone through the lobby every 20 minutes. No. The landlord toured that afternoon and asked why 27 engineers were holding laptops beside the elevators. He later wrote that Legal had “restricted flexible space utilization.” We reduced headcount on the floor. The decorative work surfaces are unemployed.
1
193
legal tech demos are sick like yeah let me watch a 24-year-old founder explain how my entire career is a "workflow" he can automate
3
230
Halfway through the pricing meeting, the Head of Pricing unveiled a plan called FREE FOREVER. The mandatory activation fee was $4,800. I asked how that was free. “The software is free.” “What does the activation fee activate?” “The software.” I said a product is not free when the customer must pay thousands of dollars to use it. She moved the fee to onboarding. Still mandatory. Then implementation. Still mandatory. Then “optional required setup.” I asked which word she wanted me to focus on. She deleted optional. Marketing had already built a landing page saying $0 FOR LIFE in 72-point type. A meeting recap later listed Legal as the blocker to zero-dollar pricing. The page now says “software license: $0.” The invoice still knows what free costs.
1
5
1,160
Tax decided every remote employee’s home needed a sign saying THIS IS NOT AN OFFICE. I received mine by courier. The Tax Director said the signs reduced international tax risk. I asked how. “They establish intent.” I pointed out that employees were still working from the homes behind the signs. He suggested adding NO BUSINESS CONDUCTED HERE. I said the sentence becomes less persuasive when someone is actively conducting business under it. He mailed larger signs to 83 employees in nine countries. One person mounted hers directly behind her during customer calls. A local adviser saw it and asked why we were disclaiming an office that supposedly did not exist. He wrote in the project retro that Legal had “created tax presence anxiety.” The signs are coming down. The homes remain stubbornly residential and operational.
1
3
929