
Professor of Philosophy and Religion @CIIS_SF • Currently working on Contemplation and the Book of Nature • I mostly post what I’m reading
Sebastopol, CA
Joined June 2013
- Tweets6.2K
- Following1K
- Followers4.3K
- Likes12K
Jacob Sherman retweeted
Today, the promises of transhumanism and posthumanism are multiplying. These are ideological currents according to which, sooner or later, technology will eliminate all disease and pain, as well as aging and even death itself. Precisely because scientific progress is a supreme achievement of human intelligence, it must not be confused with a privilege reserved for millionaires seeking immortality, while entire peoples suffer from poverty and oppression. In the face of this mirage, which promotes the illusion of human beings perfected by cybernetics and biotechnology, Christian anthropology reminds us that a limitation is not a manufacturing defect, but rather the very condition of human grandeur. #ApostolicJourney #Peru #MagnificaHumanitas vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/e…
This can't be proved, because the claim is false.
Jacob Sherman retweeted
There are many stars in the heavens and their numbering is beyond all my power of calculation, and yet there is not one that I do not need in my praise of God." --Paul Claudel, Conversations dans le Loir-et-Cher
Jacob Sherman retweeted
The future of #ArtificialIntelligence is not pre-determined. As a technology developed by human beings, its future depends on the choices we make. We therefore have the responsibility to guide, change and, when necessary, reject its applications. A reliable system that serves the human person is of greater value than one that is exceptionally powerful but whose consequences cannot be adequately foreseen or controlled.
Jacob Sherman retweeted
Reality is a poem. The Fall was the occlusion of that reality. The Incarnation restores reality as a poem. When we let ourselves be written into this poem we are redeemed. (That is the essence of Augustine’s theology in one tweet.)
Jacob Sherman retweeted
Anyway, until we can meaningfully return to the teacher/scholar model and get serious about liberal gen ed reform, I think we will continue to crash out.
Jacob Sherman retweeted
remains one of the best tweets of the year
AI ppl loooove to pretend they hold tons secret knowledge. Everyone has Seen Things, and have been trusted with the Esoteric Knowledge. It's also cringe if you don't partake because it implies you're not in the Inner Circle. In reality most people are kinda confused, working it all out ad hoc, relying on the same rumours, and so on - but the status games are hard to resist!
Jacob Sherman retweeted
Intelligence must draw on memory. The mind must not simply compile data — as an algorithm now does more quickly than we can — but recall lived experiences, which contain depths of meaning that only the human soul can recognize, and connect more deeply with the goodness of these experiences. Everything that is good begins “with the Spirit” and thus possesses a breath, a dynamism and a sense of communion that, once experienced, are engraved upon the heart. vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/e…
Jacob Sherman retweeted
In this era of artificial intelligence, it is becoming urgent to distinguish human art from what machines produce. There is an ontological difference, even before an aesthetic one, between art and what a machine can generate through statistical calculation based on millions of images created by others. Algorithms lack the spark of humanity. For this reason, the Church wishes to renew an alliance with artists and cultural institutions to safeguard our humanity.
Jacob Sherman retweeted
it's also not a like for like argument.
You can deconstruct parts of the world view (as @ProfCalNewport did in NYT last week) without addressing the empirical force of a lot of the arguments about what this technology is or where it is going.
It may be possible to challenge those claims too but those are much more technical arguments and I'm not totally convinced that anyone knows the answers to those claims.
Briefly, on why I pay attention to the EA/rationalists:
Imagine you have an extremely nerdy friend who, in the mid-2000s, would not shut up about how Donald Trump was going to become president and reshape American politics. "Stop saying weird shit," you say. "He's a joke. He's a clown. The Apprentice isn't even good this season." But this guy won't stop. He's obsessive. Read McLuhan, he says. Read Postman, read Meyrowitz, read Ong, this is where everything is headed. God, he can be so incredibly annoying ... and then, ten years later, Trump becomes president and reshapes American politics.
This is the most relatable frame I can think of to explain my experience with EA/rationalist people in the AI space. I became friends with EA folks after my mom died and I found really profound meaning in donating to Against Malaria and GiveDirectly, which struck me as a way to honor a life by saving a life. Then, these peple started talking about AI. And talking, and talking. Constantly. They said AI would solve impossible math problems; that it would mimic PhD-level achievement in a variety of fields; that it would change parts of life like education in ways we couldn't imagine; that it would become the dominant sector in the economy; that it might teach itself to code itself and escape test environments; that it would, in a decade, be the only thing many people talked about in the news. My response then: Stop saying weird shit! You sound deranged. Go back to talking about malaria nets and direct cash aid to poor families.
And then, so much of what they said would happen actually happened. And, even crazier, they made it happen. Many of the ppl who contributed to, or were influenced by, all that EA/rationalist stuff ten years ago literally built the damn thing in the labs.
Like every group, the EA/rationalist world seems uniform to outsiders, but it has a ton of internal divisions. I still think some of their predictions are nuts. I don't think AI will kill us all. I don't foresee Dyson Spheres in the 2030s or millions of robots making millions of robots in the next few years. These are crazy predictions, and I hope most of them are wrong.
But when I see people shitting on the EA/Rationalist worldview, all I can think of is me, 10 years ago, thinking a lot of these folks were crazy for predicting that AI would by the mid-2020s be the center of the the news cycle, the engine of the economy, the hinge-point of geopolitics. That was an insane call. They got many of the details wrong. But they got the big picture right. They said: Pay attention. And they were right about that. The EA/Rationalists deserve skepticism, criticism, and doubt, like any other ideology. But I think it's wise to pay attention to the people who have been saying to pay attention.
Jacob Sherman retweeted
I’m not picking on Armand but this is the problem: a lot of smart and informed people are completely unaware that, yes, many tech billionaires are transhumanists who believe in things like merging men with machines and that AI is about designing our own digital successor species.
Replying to @Tyler_A_Harper
Which CEOs think this? It’s certainly not a view I’ve ever seen expressed by Amodei, Altman, Musk, Pichai…
Jacob Sherman retweeted
And yet we have higher ed leaders telling us that their students need to have AI everywhere all the time. It's absurd.
MIT published a brutally honest report on what AI is doing to students.
A committee of professors and students spent five months studying how AI changed learning on campus, and the findings read like a warning to every university on the planet.
Study groups are disappearing. Office hours are emptying out. Problem sets and take-home exams no longer prove anything, because AI can produce credible solutions to almost any written assignment in the undergraduate curriculum. Students who lean on chatbots lose mastery and confidence, and some slip into what the report calls cognitive surrender, reaching for AI at the first hint of struggle.
The numbers are rough. 46 percent of surveyed MIT undergrads use LLMs daily. 90 percent worry about their own overreliance. Undergrads who feel AI makes them replaceable now outnumber those who feel it makes them capable.
The committee's answer surprised me. They refused to fight AI with surveillance. The report calls AI detectors unreliable, says lockdown browsers feel like spying, and warns that policing students builds a classroom atmosphere of mutual distrust.
Instead, MIT wants to rebuild education around the things AI can't replace. That means oral exams, semester portfolios, in-person project work, and a required social component in every subject. The report even floats the idea of rethinking grades entirely, since without a GPA to optimize, much of the incentive to cheat with AI evaporates.
The committee warns professors against replacing undergrad research assistants with AI agents just because they're cheaper, because a university exists to grow people, not output.
The most famous tech school on earth admitted the machines broke its way of teaching. Its answer is more humans, not more software.
Jacob Sherman retweeted
Here at Galadriel, we are building a different kind of AI.
Instead of a Dark Lord, it will be a queen. Not dark but beautiful and terrible as the dawn! Tempestuous as the sea, and stronger than the foundations of the earth! All shall love it and despair!
Jacob Sherman retweeted
“What you see and what you hear depends a great deal on where you are standing. It also depends on what sort of person you are.”
- C.S Lewis, The Magician's Nephew
Jacob Sherman retweeted
Philosopher Anthony Kenny has died. dailynous.com/2026/08/06/ant…
Jacob Sherman retweeted
Kant said that ‘being is not a predicate’. But Coleridge said ‘being is its own predicate’. The latter view is far more profound: there is no existential without copulative existence and therefore being can analogically differ and is not just univocally ‘either there or not’.
Jacob Sherman retweeted
This is incredible because the top rows look to me recognizably like “elementary school teacher handwriting”
Jacob Sherman retweeted
1995: oh cool you can buy books online now
2026: the company that owns Whole Foods and Lord of the Rings is experiencing setbacks with its space program
Jacob Sherman retweeted
Lots of people telling me The Odyssey is a terrible film on the basis of not having seen it…
FWIW, I’ve now watched it twice, and it is by some way the best cinematic adaptation of a Greek myth I have ever seen.
It honours Homer while simultaneously making something new of him
Replying to @Casey88428138
Christopher Nolan’s fascination with time, homecomings, narrative complexity and the moral ambiguities of heroism make him the perfect director for The Odyssey

























