Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse) header
Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse) profile picture

'oppressing the TVS fans' pfp by @EchoesAyThGlen

Joined April 2020
Photo by Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse)Photo by Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse)Photo by Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse)Photo by Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse)Photo by Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse)Photo by Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse)Photo by Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse)Photo by Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse)Photo by Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse)Photo by Luke (not Ryan) (@SortaScouse)
plus when you actually look outside the locos its much less a "copy"
22
Replying to @MilkConqueror
that's mainly due to being inspired by (and being a bit of an advertisement to) the TR, you cant really get around that bit. You could create an entirely fictional roster but that'd defeat the original purpose the SR was introduced to the books
1
46
Replying to @JDogg073
the SR is single tracked like the TR, but outside of that yea much bigger and higher
2
48
Replying to @LightAndCoal
ig it depends on the design, some could work whilst others would have a massive butterfly effect (like the Hughes or Fowler pacific having a big effect on the history of the LMS)
46
its not ignoring anything, just doing its own thing. Yes Sir Haydn is an amalgamation of 3 engines from Corris days, but that doesn't mean the same should be same as Sir Handel on the MSR or SR. If it followed every detail it would be a 'carbon copy'
3
20
Replying to @Mikah_64000
I still wouldn't call it that, its rather different to the TR (more complex in a number of areas). Definitely not simplified
1
12
203
the Skarloey Railway isn't a ""carbon copy"" of the Talyllyn Railway If you genuinely believe this it just shows you don't know much about either railway
Whats yall’s BIGGEST Thomas hot take? I’m not just talking lame shit like “Erm Hit Era is good actually!” I wanna hear opinions you have that no one else has! I’ll start: I genuinely think Edward should’ve become Alice it would’ve been better for the tvs THERE I SAID IT
6
18
116
1,698
god how a loath all of them baring D261
1
13
Replying to @HobbesTank
Edward getting the double windowed cab in 1923 and rebuilt in 1952, also getting the Brendam branch in 1948
9
People still calling GWR and BR green Brunswick in the big 2026 smh
1
1
14
434
Replying to @Toonzy_01
Life sentence for something that he had no control over??
12
Luke (not Ryan) retweeted
Day one of the National Festival of Railway Modelling is going well! #HeartofGold
3
15
98
1,747
Luke (not Ryan) retweeted
2
6
1
58
1,665
Replying to @modrail
not really, the LNER just wouldn't do the rebuild. Railway companies don't usually do work for other railway companies
84
Replying to @modrail
he couldn't have been rebuilt 'at any LNER workshop'. Stanier owed Topham a favour hence why he went to Crewe, otherwise the NWR would've had to do it themselves or go to a loco manufacturer to get it done
2
6
177
Luke (not Ryan) retweeted
admittedly. the T1 and Mallard debate does not matter that much, I think if you take it that seriously one way or the other you're a tiny bit silly lol have a color photo of Mallard on her record run
7
47
1
332
3,585
the NER did similar with the Shildon - Newport electrification. Only electrifying that section and not the whole system (tho they did have plans for at least York - Newcastle, but sadly these fell through with the decline of the coal industry)
21
even if you were electrifying the mainline you'd still electrify the branch, no point in not doing it. Makes sense not doing the full mainline as it just fully undermines the books and in lore it would be rather expensive
1
26
as for the electric railway, for Wilbert at least he didn't find electric locos interesting so would probably have struggled to personify them for a book (plus not that many story influences regarding electric locos)
18