The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin) header
The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin) profile picture

An independent advisory firm that works with investment firms, banks, and technology companies.

Manhattan, NY
Joined January 2017
Photo by The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin)Photo by The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin)Photo by The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin)Photo by The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin)Photo by The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin)Photo by The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin)Photo by The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin)Photo by The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin)Photo by The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin)Photo by The Gallatin Group (@TheGallatin)
America was born in revolution and also in debt. Jeff Sikkenga and former Fed and FDIC official John Popeo on the national bank, the Federal Reserve, and why an independent central bank is always political. rss.com/podcasts/amideapodca…
1
6
84
The Gallatin Group retweeted
Worthwhile article given market action. “Popeo says while he has noticed ‘notable increase in chatter about bank failures,’ the ones that have emerged in recent months are more attributable to broader economic stress than any specific risk. Liquidity constraints and credit deterioration are especially hard for small firms, which are less aptly positioned to weather economic stress.” @JWPopeo @TheGallatin americanbanker.com/news/fdic…
1
5
413
/14 A lower cap could widen the advantage of qualifying three-party structures under current treatment, such as @CapitalOne, @Discover. This difference is likely to draw scrutiny during the Fed's rule rewrite. Greater economic value may come with greater regulatory risk.
1
1
31
/END If the ruling stands, we expect lower permissible fees for most covered issuers, but an uneven impact across banks and processors. Watch rehearing, mandate orders, the Sixth Circuit and Fed action. This is a framework rewrite, not just a fee cut.
1
2
48
TLDR: Fee cap stays for now, but if Eighth Cir. ruling stands, we expect lower fees for most covered banks, significant upside for processors, and closer scrutiny of three-party networks (TBD via a Fed rule). The appeals process and Fed rulemaking will determine timing.
1
44
/12 The Court's analysis contrasts a bank’s fixed software expense with another bank paying an outside provider per transaction. This distinction may encourage outsourcing and benefit companies processing debit transactions for banks.
1
1
18
/13 For merchants, routing remains relevant, including PINless online debit over alternative networks. We expect continued demand for cheaper routes. But a lower interchange cap does not, by itself, make one network cheaper than another.
1
16
/10 What about the Fed’s 2023 proposal? Its proposed 14.4 cent base retained fixed processing costs. Our take is that if this ruling stands, the Fed needs a substantially different methodology, not simply to finalize the 2023 proposal as written.
1
14
/11 Our base case proceeds as follows: proposal in 2027. Final rule in 2028. Permanent framework effective in 2028 or 2029. An interim rule could change fees sooner. A court stay is not a promise that today’s economics last until 2029.
1
14
/9 We expect that a processing component below .05 cents is plausible for the largest issuers under a standard excluding fixed costs. A separate fraud prevention allowance must be assessed independently.
1
10
/5 In such scenario, we would expect urgent Fed action toward a temporary rule. Skipping advance public comment requires a legal justification. Neither timing nor legal durability is assured.
1
14
/8 The Court rejected the existing uniform cap but did not prescribe specific tiers. We expect for the Fed to develop standards reflecting different cost structures, with greater revenue pressure on efficient, high-volume covered issuers.
1
11
/7 Core to the Court's holding is the focus on the cost of processing one additional transaction, not fixed expenses that do not rise with each transaction. The Fed may use a reasonable estimate rather than price every transaction individually.
1
12
/6 We are watching the Sixth Circuit closely, which heard Linney’s Pizza on October 22. If that Court upholds the existing rule, this would create conflicting appellate decisions. Such a split would strengthen the case for Supreme Court review and grant of cert.
1
19
/3 That said, we expect the Fed to seek rehearing and, if needed, a stay while pursuing Supreme Court review. A continued stay remains our base case. Such stay, however, is discretionary and would not automatically protect the current cap through replacement rulemaking.
1
17
/4 If the cap falls away before a replacement, banks do not have to stop collecting interchange. Covered fees would still have to be reasonable relative to transaction costs (as stated in the law), but no numerical cap would remain. Fees could even rise temporarily.
1
13
/1 It's worth highlighting uprfront that the focus is on debit interchange, not credit-card fees. Issuers with less than $10 billion in total assets (including affiliates), generally are exempt from the fee cap.
1
1
93
/2 A key takeaway is that current fee cap remains in place. There is no immediate fee cut. The ruling takes effect when the appeals court issues its mandate (~Dec. 17, 2026), unless a timely rehearing petition or court order changes the schedule.
1
47
On October 26, the Eighth Circuit affirmed the ruling striking down Regulation II’s debit interchange standard and sent it back to the Fed. The implications reach beyond fees and will affect processing and network strategy. Brief take: 🧵
1
2
171