Future of Christendom retweeted
Doug Wilson says purity is a luxury and “politics is the art of the possible,” but that’s Bismarck’s standard, not God’s. In this episode @ChrisHume1658 explains why you can’t build Christendom with man-made law.
Future of Christendom retweeted
"It's not a death of a thousand cuts. It's a death of a thousand seatbelts." — Luke Saint of @ThinkandReform on what it means to live in a nation where the laws protect the wicked and punish the righteous. Ep. 241 ↓
Future of Christendom retweeted
Luke Saint's core question from the @ThinkandReform immigration debate: Is the magistrate, according to God's law, authorized to punish someone for crossing a national border? Poll:
Ep. 241 ↓
38%Yes, clearly
50%No, just criminals
12%Not sure
0%Terrible question
8 votes • Final results Future of Christendom retweeted
Ep. 241: Luke Saint of @ThinkandReform returns to debrief his immigration debate with William Wolfe at the Future of Christendom Conference — the magistrate's actual job, the biblical immigrant/invader distinction, and why we're dying from a thousand seatbelts. #CarpeFide
Future of Christendom retweeted
Gospel AND law, not gospel OR law. @ChrisHume1658 responds to a CREC pastor’s sermon against Lancastrian theonomy.
Future of Christendom retweeted
Replying to @_jon99 @ThinkandReform
The magistrate’s job is not to “create the conditions” in which fathers can do their work. That language is the open door to the nanny state.Scripture assigns the civil magistrate a narrow task: to be a terror to those who do evil and a praise to those who do good (Romans 13:3–4; 1 Peter 2:14). He is to establish justice by punishing actual crimes defined by God’s Law. He is not commissioned to order society so that fathers can more easily feed, clothe, educate, or protect their children.
Peace, order, and the conditions that allow fathers to fulfill their responsibilities are the byproducts of justice, not the magistrate’s assigned task. When he punishes actual evil according to God’s standard, those good conditions follow. When he instead tries to engineer the conditions themselves, he steps outside his God-given role and begins to play father.
Once you say the magistrate’s role is to create the right conditions for family life, you have given him a blank check. He can then claim authority over immigration, education, employment, housing, health, and nearly every other area of life under the banner of “protecting and ordering.”
Future of Christendom retweeted
Is modern Christian education teaching God’s law—or syncretizing Christianity with statism? Chris Hume takes a critical look at institutions like New Saint Andrews College and how they approach justice.
Future of Christendom retweeted
Replying to @ChrisHume1658
@ChrisHume1658 discusses Morocco, the Netherlands, and the Two Faces of Apostasy
Future of Christendom retweeted
We are drowning in debates between the R2K/Two-Kingdoms camp and the Christian Nationalists, yet both sides have a massive blind spot. They fight endlessly over who gets political "power," while completely ignoring the true purpose of authority. Listen closely to almost any presentation on this topic—from VanDrunen to Wilson to Webbon—justice is barely even a footnote.
Future of Christendom retweeted
Doug Wilson is wrong about Sunday worship, and Dan Horn is wrong about speed limits.
Future of Christendom retweeted
I Asked Claude to Grade My 3-Hour Theonomy Debate with Nolan Corcoran. futureofchristendom.org/i-as…
Future of Christendom retweeted
Replying to @BonifaceOption
@BonifaceOption: are you and/or C. Jay Engel willing to represent the natural law side in an in-person debate at @ThinkandReform’s 2026 October conference in Pennsylvania?
Future of Christendom retweeted
After a months-long hiatus, @ChrisHume1658 returns to The Lancaster Patriot Podcast to (finally) wrap up his analysis of Dr. Chris Walker’s Sunday School series on civil government.
Future of Christendom retweeted
Are you a Christian man willing to go beyond the keyboard and stand behind your convictions in public? @ThinkandReform is looking for qualified opponents to debate any of the following affirmations:
- Civil magistrates are biblically authorized to create new laws
- Forced taxation is biblically authorized and necessary
- Imprisonment is a legitimate replacement for biblical restitution
- The magistrate may punish “pre-crime” and regulatory violations with coercive force
- The Christian Western legislative tradition improves on God’s judicial law
- Immigration legislation is required
Bring Scripture. Bring arguments. Leave the keyboard at home.
Email [email protected] to accept the challenge.
Future of Christendom retweeted
@ralphcochran @TravisSchmals @ThinkandReform
Travis, thank you for your statement. The disagreement is not merely over historical precedent; it is over whether the civil magistrate is bound to the revealed judicial law of God or whether he may supplement it with positive legislation.
You rightly note that Deuteronomy 17:14–20 anticipates monarchy. Yet the same passage simultaneously places the king under the most stringent limitation imaginable: he must make a personal copy of “this law” (the Torah) and “shall not turn aside from the commandment, either to the right hand or to the left” (v. 20). The king is not granted a new legislative charter; he is placed under the existing one. The judicial law of Moses is repeatedly presented as complete, exhaustive, and unalterable (Deut 4:2; 12:32; Prov 30:6). To add new crimes or new sanctions is not royal prerogative; it is rebellion.
Church confessions, business policies, and even HOA covenants can be prudent and useful at times. No one disputes this. The disagreement arises only when such standards are given the coercive force of the sword in the civil sphere. Private associations bind by consent. The magistrate binds by divine command. His statute book is already written (Exod 21–23; Deut 19–25). He has no warrant to add to it.
You mentioned that you will defend “the Christian Western legislative tradition, as far as it is consistent with God’s Word.” This is the sentence that sounds weighty but, upon examination, evaporates into vapor. It supplies no standard of justice. It names no crime that deserves death, no restitution owed for theft, no penalty for adultery, no remedy for disputes. It offers no mechanism for adjudication. It never identifies a single judicial law from Scripture that must still be enforced today. In practice it functions as a rhetorical escape hatch: salute a tradition in the abstract while remaining free from any concrete obligation to apply it. It is the civil-polity equivalent of saying, “I love the Bible, as far as it is correctly interpreted.” It commits to nothing, changes nothing, and requires no repentance.
The Western legal tradition—from Justinian’s Corpus Juris Civilis through the glossators, Gratian, Aquinas, Blackstone, and the American constitutional order—is a mixture of Roman law, Germanic custom, canon law, feudal law, and Enlightenment theory. It is not the Law of God. Where it departs from Scripture (imprisonment instead of restitution, forced taxation, licensing of dominion activities, legislative supremacy), it must be rejected, not reverently preserved.
Most telling is what is never provided in opposition to Lancastrian theonomy: a single example of how this “Christian Western legislative tradition” would actually establish justice in 2025. What is the penalty for theft? What is the remedy for fraud? How are land disputes settled? What sanctions fall on the adulterer, the false witness, the rapist? We are given none of these. We are simply told to trust a tradition that has produced the modern regulatory state, the prison-industrial complex, and the administrative tyranny we all lament. That is not reformation.
Those who speak most warmly of the “Christian Western legislative tradition” are often the first to ignore its actual statutes—speed limits, zoning ordinances, licensing requirements, and countless other positive laws. They treat the tradition as binding in theory and optional in practice, exactly the opposite of how God’s Law is to be treated.
We do not seek a utopian return to the book of Judges. We seek simple obedience: that magistrates would confine themselves to the sanctions God has revealed, and that the Church would cease baptizing human statutes as though they carried divine authority. The period of the judges is instructive precisely because Israel was governed for centuries without a human legislature, without a standing army, and without a royal treasury. Justice was administered case-by-case according to the written law of God. The chaos of Judges 21:25 was the result of covenant unfaithfulness, not the absence of a legislature.
The issue is not personal, but theological and practical: whether the magistrate’s sword is bound exclusively by the written Word, or whether he may wield it according to man-made law or centuries of accumulated “tradition.” (See Jesus’ comments to the Pharisees on tradition.)
I invite you—and anyone willing—to continue this conversation by coming onto our podcast, or at the very least attending the second annual Lancastrian Theonomy Symposium, March 14, 2026, in Ephrata, PA.
Future of Christendom retweeted
Michael Foster is working on "saving" the PCA (savethepca.com/about), but the CREC should receive salvation as well!
Future of Christendom retweeted
A couple weeks after their public debate at @ThinkandReform's 2025 conference, @ChrisHume1658 (Christian) and Wilson Whiting (atheist) sit down to continue their conversation.
youtu.be/A1t5tPlJhqo?si=WrEl…
Future of Christendom retweeted
I am prepping for a follow-up to my recent episode on biblical slavery (youtu.be/yFBKcCdlPJI). Did you know the American system praised by statists (atheists or otherwise) allows for the buying and selling of people? From Harvard Law Review: "[P]rison officials may trade prisoners — either for money or for other prisoners" (E. Kaufman). For the statists, buying and selling people is fine, so long as they violated some man-made law. The objection then is not against the concept, but the conditions. The atheists want man to create laws and lock people up for violating them. The Christians embrace God's system as just and recognize that someone could be sold for his theft (Ex. 22:3) or could be brought into the position of a bondservant due to financial straits (Lev. 25:39; cf. Neh. 5).







