“Nobody ever runs and says… we’ll have to stop GDP maximizing”
I’m sure you know the compulsion to maximize growth is not one of will but rather structural a necessity placed on politicians by market forces. Nobody has the capacity to stop it.
The American system is designed to maximize GDP and sacrifice things the left wants like free healthcare and public transportation, and also things the right wants like traditional gender roles and immigration rates inflexibly fixed at the low, 1950s level. This produces perennial dissatisfaction from the masses, and so there’s always a political market for political entrepreneurs pretending to sell these things which the American system can’t actually deliver. Nobody ever runs and says “to get you your free healthcare / public transportation / traditional gender roles / permanently low immigration, we’ll have to stop GDP maximizing.” Or alternately: “to deliver any of those things, we’ll need to do a risky, developmentalist moonshot to keep GDP afloat, like fusion power.” They don’t say that either.
Even politicians fluent in revolutionary rhetoric (Bernie etc) won’t say that. They all proceed as if the American system can stay in place but “also” there can fully paid universal 6 month parental leave, or “also” there can be religiously motivated anti-AI limitations. Anyway, that’s why everyone feels betrayed every 2-4 years. What’s more, memories are poor: people always think “their” current wave is the one to break the cycle, the wave to end all waves. Instead, they’ll get into “power,” in their minor, symbolic, and circular way, do their stint of managerial paper-pushing on behalf of the American system, and not deliver anything they had promised which was in defiance of the American system.
194
The elite theory bandwagon people have been on lately has damaged modern understanding of politics.
Good elites matter sure, but good elites can only get you so far. Wise elites cannot overcome institutional degradation and the capacity of regular people to take political action
3
515
Your original statement about the role of politics is antidemocratic and elitist. You believe politics is something to be restricted and put back in the genie. What you’re attempting to do is depoliticize citizens and relegate the political to a special class of technocrats.
It is precisely in a society like America - which, from the founding, has contained dissident groups with different understandings of the good and an acute sense of the risks of civil war over which to impose - that it is most important to separate meaning from the state.
1
318
I don’t think this guy realizes those “traditional” ideals were taught for and brought forth by the leftists of their day!
Replying to @ChristianHeiens
Notice how each domino tries to tether one of their own platforms to a traditional one.
Gay agenda to free expression.
Sexual revolution to women's rights.
Anti-republic to free speech.
Cosmopolitanism to freedom of worship.
Yet in each case, transgenderism opposes the latter.
1
164
I expect burnham to last less than two years.
Andy Burnham’s allies expect the new prime minister to stress that female ministers will play a big role in his new cabinet, although Labour has yet to elect a female leader.
Read the latest here: ft.trib.al/orGQyle
1
374
If your movement is for everyone, then it’s for no one.
Abundance is an intellectual movement, not a mass movement. The one cannot substitute for the other. Establishment Dems, Socialist Dems, and even some Republicans will (and should!) take pieces of the Abundance Agenda and make it their own. It will not replace those movements.
1
286








