Stone Transparency retweeted
Eight months ago, an important study was out, with its results relevant for 200 million people, but went largerly unnoticed. How?😱 #Zheln finds out👇 Thread #1 threads.net/t/Cuo1-k_OJLn/?i… [This content is available exclusively via Instagram’s Threads] #WrittenInStone @WriteInStone

ALT Zhelnov P. Threads: #1 Neck Pain. A critical appraisal and evidence-dissemination assessment of ‘Hu T, Long Y, Wei L, Zheng Y, Tong Y, Yuan M, Liu C, Wang X, Lin Y, Guo Q, Huang J, Du L. The Underappreciated Placebo Effects and Responses in Randomized Controlled Trials on Neck Pain: A Systematic Review With Meta-analysis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2023 Jul;104(7):1124-1131. doi: 10.1016/j.apmr.2022.10.013. Epub 2022 Nov 20. PMID: 36417969’. Zheln. 2023 Jul 13;27(1):t1e1. URI: https://zheln.com/thread/2023/07/13/1/.
Stone Transparency retweeted
Doing a #systematicreview or another #evidencesynthesis and still considering ‘foreign language’ a valid exclusion criterion? Well, it’s not, and here is why: youtube.com/shorts/zzWneXcBK… @WriteInStone @rayyanapp @Google @GoogleAI #googletranslate #googlelens #academictwitter
Stone Transparency retweeted
It's here and free to download and use (currently only for PC, soz) writeinstone.com/
Stone Transparency retweeted
And, guess what, there's an app for that. I could explain how it works but it's best if you try for yourself
Trust me it is the work of moments and our (admittedly small) user base loves @WriteinStone's ability to organise and present their research, fast and for free
Stone Transparency retweeted
What's interesting is as podcasting and "the making of" shows keep growing, I hear more researchers wishing they could show more to their audiences than just the final article
They are PROUD of their processes and want people to see why their stories went the way they did
Stone Transparency retweeted
Many media organisations still balk at the idea of having their research uploaded, organised and shared with the reader/viewer.
As if they regard their research as untouchable, meritorious simply because it's done by Them, their own special sauce they want to sheild from view
Stone Transparency retweeted
This one was cultural. We at Stone believe the only way to restore trust in news is to follow the science, embrace full transparency and accept that journalists are no longer the gatekeepers of right and wrong, but rather that facts, data, and research are the builders of truth
Stone Transparency retweeted
Concerns such as privacy and proprietory content, we took to our engineers and they crafted elegant and effective workarounds
But when we returned to some newsrooms, including international wires heavily invested in factchecking, we encountered an additional barrier
Stone Transparency retweeted
When we tried to approach large media organisations (who had since resorted to embedding entirely subject-independent video content in order to claw back some revenue from their expensive production), they raised a host of concerns - some legit, some not
Stone Transparency retweeted
Whereas the research suggests that audiences trust most when they can see the journalist/researcher at work - like, literally see their face - and they can see the process unfold before them.
Stone does all of this, in a matter of seconds.
Stone Transparency retweeted
For fact check, newsrooms assumed (wrongly) that they will regain audience trust via meticulous, long debunks, and that trust and veracity will be restored simply because it's Journalists Telling People Facts so they must be trustworthy
Stone Transparency retweeted
The prevailing wisdom of newsroom management over the last 20 years has been:
- We need video content (mainly to raise ad money)
- We need fact checkers
They pivoted to these (which are both expensive and time consuming) when newsrooms were laying off people left and right
Stone Transparency retweeted
It is free and easy to use, integrates seamlessly into the workflow process, and allows real-time verification of journalistic decisionmaking while automatically creating free, subject relevant video content that can be embedded and monetised.
So of course big media hates it
Stone Transparency retweeted
Some thoughts here from @WriteInStone founder here.
Stone is a research transparency app that was conceived as a way to buttress journalism against disinformation by showing audiences the research and story-writing process, rather than telling them nitter.cf/WriteInStone/status/16…
Stone Transparency retweeted
Positively giddy about @aimos_inc next week looking at this all-killer-no-filler programme eventcreate.com/e/aimos2022
Stone Transparency retweeted
Having a great time zooming in to #AIMOS2022! Fantastic set of speakers discussing all things metaresearch and open science. So cool seeing many talks addressing those difficult doubts we whisper to ourselves about our research practices and norms. eventcreate.com/e/aimos2022
Stone Transparency retweeted
Such a great study by Aidan Tan our brilliant PhD student @TrialsCentre on #datasharing #OpenData policies across stakeholders @aimos_inc #Aimos2022
Stone Transparency retweeted
Published! "Many Analysts, One Dataset: Making transparent how variations in analytical choices affect results" 65 of us led by Raphael Silberzahn demonstrate the contingencies of analytic decisions on observed outcomes. doi.org/10.1177/251524591774… (OA: psyarxiv.com/qkwst/)
Stone Transparency retweeted
Lovely speaking with @WriteInStone today about the amazing work they do; maintaining transparency in research and journalism.
We look forward to supporting their endeavours
Stone Transparency retweeted
There are studies and polls that all point to the fact that enhanced transparency in the news gathering process, including open source material and visible journalist engagement all build audience trust
And there’s an app for that: @WriteInStone
"I go to quite a few journalism events where journalists seem reasonably fed up that we’re not all celebrated as being fantastic."
"I think we need to drop that and understand a lot of people don’t see the value in what we’re doing," says @BBCRosAtkins
pressgazette.co.uk/increase-…













